| Show LIVELY DEBATE IN M THE TOE SENATE Presentation of Text of Philippine tariff Bill VIII Caused It IAN AUtUN JlE ORr RE REthe cla claI Ok R it I lorma 1 I falcH all l ar rC Ju the cho Fob Feb spirit a with the tho th Philippine tariff bill bU bUbe dr waS ed lt lii In the Sm t b be e text tet aI the or oE borne II I II aE I today loday od y II fl 14 Ir r Oom In 18 couIe ot f Tinn T fl h on the tM th general Philippine l h thO 1110 eo I 0 HOIL on lt li II I WOH sva m la tho Semite and 1111 ha wan wu lira jit t good rood attention on oU both bolh IVra numbly Camber Wo spoke with wil ij dIl of or Q tho 11 with u manuscript J ot mi sed nd eloquence ju U the ot of his Ills hud hut bo n listened J to by ii y many ot of ofus othI otLIS In the ti of ot us LIS ormi r II j hI Mr MI M of ot ll llan an hal some oine of jf Ills hIs The he e debate which ensued WiH W very ery u fy for tor a low tv minutes taking on 01 u a ut at I t t jitt a Plia which moved tho who M jI Int re to 11 he the floor loor as na 11 well wel tin UR u tho the gal galOP gal ciL OF OP The measure re providing tor for nn 11 In Mie ame in rn wo I Ihl th of United d Status j I es was under n for tor or mi mit III t i ir In th lif of ot debate the tho w Judge Jud H 11 1 of ut the dl O MCI court aUtt of or Alaska ln lm was WUI drawn upon pOI wh should not no not t io 10 o suino somo Judges l li II t m Biven E n fl increase TakIng of if tIm tho latitude of oter 1 by bf the tho tl Mr Mi MiT I T Tilman linan nn ir dire tol attention to an I in n lite tle Washington Post l st published d I lay JY relate to 10 the Iho cuso of ot Judo JutO nur ncr It if I Noye Noys MI of at the district court courtl COUt l lukl Iska ika who w wal vai as fined recent i tin thi I eli rii cl nit ul court at nt Han ati Francis to mi in tu oi or I a It HOI HO of ot Judge NOel PP p In oT with sIth wih him bitu Mr hr lr film n 1 rend tho which r ui 01 a d I that thaI Ind itu his hl as tta aslaM iS iSa laM a s nr nY drawing salaries the I tnt nl Ml ii States Slates the ease cao m Is ts pending In tho tito courts courtn courtne couts it e if lit the men according to tho t r n nio I Yb o it I t his con to lit draw salary Mr hr Tinman running comments u in t the in hi II the tho article ill U nt ng fl alt all al nn hI ridicule nn lt l oIO i Judge Noyes Noye finally i ring ringI 1 I f the Ibe way whoso business 1st In II It Iti i 1 no Ioe iO man manIll f fI Ill I I Farak r of or Ohio Olto believed helleved b It might foment proceedings to re reif reIl if Il Ju Julge Noyes NAye but Mr 1 r Teller roller con that tha the th President hal had ample ma to remove a ft territorial Judge lie le liet t vf iki tl there Iho was lifts no 10 about t l gI He declared tho the ot of Judge u bad been bett eel n a 1 crying shame me and atut 1111 t that a recital of o blu outrages i Ho the tha American people TARIFF DILL VILL DILLA DIL DILA A i J tho tariff bill T S I III b rou the and Mr bi nl of ot n a member of or Ie I p delivered a am I m nt OVll to tl tho the pending t ur lie le contended that 1 nol flot to 10 understand iy h lle the l PhIlIppine situation in my IDT ot of Ita lt 1 thaes causo it I was WaN not flot lot ill Ihl th fai mets ts Tho W III bill he lie Wi ai had hit ha been framed by the Philip l ine C lon on an autocratic body bol boI I o MUM mIln rl 1 away I cnn and Illi not n tt ehu t been n made In ln I It u b 1 Congress m MM iatI Mr lv 11 all Jh earmark 18 II t LI I 1 Iho n theory them ham the thc ph phit l r it ar r n a 1 deadly menace mCce to out our ourn 10 n that Ul the tho lc less ICH wo Ut II thu fl tho 1110 l sl wo We havo t lu ILO do Fit Ihm m the Ih better lh It will bo eter I wi s us The oily u l that will flout Ilour Ih unI It Is lit that of ot o the e U le i and 1111 nl It is proposed to I rn thi Ih t o them It IB la 1 I i Use Ir th b hi r tit It of ot the tho I j v I fm 01 tn hI l of the o American jh rl Vi I flu I II ar of ut criminal n d II being S AU w waged get foa ln in 11 th le th bill of the Ih minority cannot support 01 o t ma 1 raf policy of which It U IB It 1 a 1 Ht briefly the ct I in p nH hlll ot o ress JISI I e aOla UP that It I waH Wil not ot but butti ti Ih ei n b by tit frt r n I At if th 1 1 1 o n party t d nt hll been beon pup the by tb Ih he declared nied and k O I r f Country ton luid hul been Icen b 1 of ot the lie matters to a ae 1 It 1 dg Ot r 1111 entitled I e II ring ng tho tt support tr 1 1 Sel Philippine poloy policy Yo mi u ua It t sour our I In holy horror a t L q n h og R or of n a itt man I In 1 pI L you u are nrc engaged In iner g ppl who recently 1 er our ur li lih your In II Ihy havo l no ro cr rn lt Upon which n 1 W ni Ih ho he declared ta t hi ot the n ri t t t O ant end his a cn e ia aft 11 blood ar i h th Admiral Dewoy DIcy Ind nt ose f Iho Who n hn s ura help heiti har of i COUld ruhl not escare th hP d 1 Violating tho tim lit the ch h n warfare IIII he hOlch oU b A Dewey From I rol the beginning said Mr tr ear Car Carmack ar armoCk moCk mack wo we 10 know 1101 that A wan nan lighting not bot for fOI n II change of ut masters out but u for tor absolute freedom and Gen Oen Anderson Antersol had assured I suret that tha time thc American people never had hall Ishol colonies und tind 1111 that ho Ito could caul trUst trus In the tho honor of the American people heO farm t I he said suhl constitute a ft binding obligation upon im to give gle them them their Independence Ho would ho said haul down tho the American liaR It waved 11 1 nn nil nn an emblem of or force unit and despotism H lIe charged that tile the United had hafl been heon holding a n nine false am attil delusive hope out to the tho Filipinos we wo were killing these theRe people for tor or tho of or their and build buildIng Ing ini In up Ut tho chuich of ot Clod out nut ot of hu Im man milan bones bOllos I Ih IMi Mr Mi h maintained that by IJ tot fol following lowing out the tha of ot conquest for tor mutated by time the majority In power the th United States wn n pressing Itself Into Inlo nil all the tho quarrels of the Iho world Under such Hueh n I policy no liD peace wan Wall In VIII tote for this government A 1 OY ny At tho the conclusion of Mr speech Mr n ft member Iut of tho the Philippine committee commItteD sharply challenged a 1 statement by the tho Tennessee senator that tho the Philippine Philippi no tariff burt had not Leon been well or considered con As An n it matter of ot fact hu said tho ho muff ernie eulo wag wa after of ot and 1111 after con COI suiting every Interest In the time Philip Philippines pines Did timo tho Philippine committee make maIm maIman an nn Investigation of ot the Philippine tar tariff lIT iff sonic onie Inquired Mr Carmack No replied Mr MI Beveridge but tim the Philippine committee has bait been consul eying that scale for tor two years yearL Mr declared 1 that If It time the Democratic party varty had given gon to Its 18 ta last losi tariff bill the tue same care which had imad been given Rhen the tho Philippine tariff scale thin prosperity would not riot have hn a withered as tin It had under tinder the time tar off lilT It had enacted Further l along Mr r declarer that the tho reason why I Cleveland Harrison and ami 1 ELI nil all of oC whom had hadnot I not 1101 ti t been J n In sympathy with the Philip Philippine PhilipI I pine limo I no policy f th administration le Ie dined to jo follow the he Democratic party i was vas because that party would not no ac accept the tho decision o of tho the Supreme Court and the verdict ot o tho the American peo pea people I pie piC aa its final He lie asserted that lInt time tho reasons why wh the time model moderate ate thoughtful antI and con people of ot tiu th not nol followed the tho Democratic party In Its Ita opposition to the proPer control of ot the timo und In other matters of ot notional national policy was that they feared that party would sow tin the dragons teeth from which would spring a 11 liar har harvest vest ost of anarchy Another reason he saId paid was waa that that party pari was sounding a 0 note of re roo retreat retreat treat trent and never neer In the thc history of ot the country had nIl the American people re retreated reo treated from tram ally proposition fairly presented to them and they tile noel never would TILLMAN TILL tAN INTERRUPTS As Aa he hp was proceeding tot to discuss dl some Mme of or the tho conditions in the tho Philip Philippine pine Islands Mr of ot South Houth Car Interrupted with wRit the lie Inquiry Will tho the senator be explicit und and give HIl UH its the benefit bell of or his personal ob oh observation or ot any uny fly of or the Information ho holies linK lies In mi regard to the dispatch Il tont Boll olI that ho imo proposes to make would want war BO so hut they ther peace IleaC Is s that true or Is III It not That was wu ot done white while I was theio replied Mr iti 1 I will Vill III ask n l the tho senator tie nil tor continued f whether whet h r When he Is l monk mak making ing Int war Wit ho iio would not make war BO so terrible t that the tho enemy would want peace That would depend said Mr Ir Till man whether I 1 honestly hone honc tl liy was wall engaged In III ri a war Will that t f 1 thought was decent and or 01 one ono of ot subjugation anil Infamy And the senator charge de do demanded demanded mantled Mr that General Bell doc not believe bellec he Is la engaged in inan an nn honest war warI wai I know i tint timit there arc plenty Illan of ot of at officers fleets there thelo who feet feel that they th y are do doIng dolog Ing log work ork shouted Mr Mt and nn they thc tho have tol told me they are ashamed of ot It II Hns Gen loin nell Hell told you so 80 Insisted Mt MI I 1 dont know about Gen den Hell said Mr I have not seen him ilm Then why wh do you OU drag drug In Germ Gen Hell lieU Oen Gm and others sharply In Inquired Inquired Mr Mr Ir will drag trag Into this die cushion cuss Ion nn an Associated A Prose representative tlc tive from rem Manila Mr Now It la le on an Asso cited Press Mr Ir you U either have hare haven n ft thorn them or me you have hae not You swear you Ol have not and amid then when the tins reports come cOlne you 01 say Those no not nol ours our Mr Is III hopeless When hen theY begin ln 1 to 10 discuss the constitution mid nud We e take them thel up III on ott that they thoy come cOIRe to censorship When we wo nay a that none exists then th they go to to war bloodshed pillage and murder A DUnNING INCIDENT After some JOme sharp colloquy in which the Indiana und amid South Carolina SOIl lien senators Ut bt rs ridiculed other Mr Bev ne proceeded to relate an on Incident of the tb burning of f R a i village and 1111 said that upon Investigation It proved that It was na the tile net act of the thu insurgents hl lilt hili purpose being to disprove d some reports against Ita the thO Ito American soldiers Mr lr Tiliman Was waR on his hili h feet again and antl asked Mr From I whom hom do we 0 get the thc state meats menta that the tho Insurgents Insurgent or rebels Or whatever or they are arc did all nl this burning The American authorities replied Mr Ir i f SAnd Is It 11 Inquired Mr Mn t 11 f determine n U rose case from MC cx X part statements Why Wh does I time senator always In d Mr Mt H lull any II which t from m on umi American source o urcel Is a l falsehood while Cory that thai comes cOm from tho the Is the truth 7 For Poe the same rn l reason nOon on rolled 1 1111 the South Carolina senator that In my own state when ltd lt ll wits burned In itt ISia there wai tn HH I Itoh that we WI iv l II ft t when overy body Jolty know we 0 11 hI tl L u so I sm n Now Mr tr ald saimi Mr Ilov back again MIllin on huary hl welt I decline t I to Mr rr Allison of TOn a ml tit of ot time the Philippine I ii II I tm hi I him t lU flu fur fat furan an am ho its ho lie had 1111 I ll given tIme the Philippine I uI Ii tariff I ut lIT f input t I U consideration con l I of lie wilt tn capable IJ 1 lit I it h hud tot I nono lIono u ks care carefully fully tull mind was ivan lIe th t time the us mM good 10 II as ItS be IH do tie V isel iselA After Att A Itt In by Mr Mt of or n Onto Iilo Mr 11 I r Teller r ller of mit Colo oio rudo tulo nod and Mr Ow hit lit at 1 I went Into It e slim n a afon few fon rC iii I mitt tim Inter laur In I |
