| Show INVESTIGATION Of WILliS BROWN BRONI Commission 1 Hears Evidence ot of Shameful and Outrageous Actions of Judge HIS STATEMENT SUBMITTED But it Does Not Agree With tha thu th Testimony of Numerous Wit Witnesses Witnesses Witnesses nesses Who Gave Evidence lo to Show limit n It m lri 11 Vac n lf reIT in lu Inno Her The h Of 0 tim Iho of ot Willis Brown of ot the court COUII In Inn ordering a 1 gini taken laken from rota h hili court room to II t tha the of ot a io to Lu undergo f po physical ph examination of o a n delicate was concluded In III Mayor In or Thompsons omen oO today The Time doors dooms nero thrown open in tm inday day do and aind macit were to the time Severs Several I newspaper newspapermen nef per men ell who were In tIme the courtroom at tt the tha th time time the caSe caso imas hoard h were Irene called ns nil witnesses e today ns 1111 fl ivita 1 also a ml 1 number of or court couri attaches There Them was ivan practically lI no ito difference between betle time thu witnesses us liB to tl the lough nought vulgar and us by liy bytho tho tue Judge In inn his hili examination of ot tim iho young girl neither was wait there thele any ony tilt dif difference ference at as In tm the time amount of ot force fore mod IIII to Rot get the girl 1111 from time the lo to Iho Ih I ims WAS AS 8 IAN The Time only exception to tIme the general line of ot evidence wan tIRS M lie He WRit wins evidently asleep at nt the untie time time the ex ax ex exI I 1 1111 lion was mimma being conducted mind and notwithstanding time tho fact that all nil thin XV other stated the time exact lan laim language guage III used by II Lime court which h cannot be bl put hilt In mm print owing to 10 its character S the time police did not lot hear anything ot of that nature mature at mit all although h lie hI to tho the Juvenile court commission lon today that he heard about everything that WIlli said In time the th courtroom on that oc ot occasion casion The officers testimony did not therefore with the time other othel eye wit IltneR neR es on vim that point He lie was OK also nl rath rather er mixed as IK to the time trouble eau caused d by b bythe b the Hie girl and the resistance remittance re nh sime put up HUH SCRATCHED HB He lie nt sit first said that ho lie used no force to III take tak time the girl gill from time the Ih room but lat hat later er Cr In his examination he lie admitted Iliac she mime hung unto unite to tine till doors and anti refused in to ingo go gt a several times sat ant down don ant and 01 bad to he be lifted to her feet and limit Hut dm dating Ing all unit that tIme lima she Ih titus nas UK yelling and protesting ns nit strongly mis IH HI WON waK In III lii hI power time The exhibited a mm ed Id hand hit nul which mulch he ii e said ald Hie t im e girl gave him himIn in I on In III her imer h I efforts tT to In r sitting final ly Iy 1 admitted 11 that he ime waft turns sorry forry parr ho hum mix 1 In lit the affair at all 1111 but that lie Inc was 1155 net act adIng acting Ing under Instructions from the tInt court N AlLf D The rime other tailed called tin time 1011 today were vere thieo newspaper f per tl it I men le Arl Choate Cimos Choo te Ie und amid rOil Probation F I J 1 Lucas MrM of or the Davis Deacon Deaconess Dla oll ess Home Mis ln IJ Young probation I ocr c r They The nil agreed In Iii an as anto anto asto to the time language uell by hy tile the court and amid nil all agreed upon time till form torce l upon the time girl As 8 to time the order artIer of at the time court to have havo the tIme girl examined timers there wax VaN a i difference of or opinion SonIc Some that time the Judge got thu the of or thi girl girls t mother before lie inc h ordered tine the Irl ex examined x while others stated that the th mother did 1 not give g her consent until l lifter litter she arrived at III the lime physicians of ot lice Mrs sm rim Knox time Iho mother of If time the th girl dj was imis not lIot called before th time thA commission It muns stated by hI at lit least t ono coma witness pi that she denied III In the tine presence of or Judge Brown that sims die consented to examination while In the court courtroom room it SEEKS TO SHIFT BLAME P The rime statement of tho of lb time i court which wits was tiled filed with time the com commission mission several days ngo wn given n nto to the public today nail and Is published herewith To that time the written statement ot of the ilia court doe doo not with tine the evidence of time the numerous witnesses before th time to today today day Is putting it very vary mildly In Iii fact 1 It would have teen been much tf It time tho L Judge of til the court lied had consulted hh his before ho inn submitted thus s then th there r would not liars han been b en the very marked he lie the statement and time the V Tho lito only thought of this the of time tho court apparently ID Is to nail and wander away from th the real Issues in the saul and make It appear that time only emily rca rea reason I son Eon for or the examination wa was to tt prove provi time iho girls innocence The lImo rule rulo of law IRV IRVin i in It that a person is presumed to be In Inno no ament until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt ind further than that thin tho girl should not mint haY been compelled to prove her innocence hut but butt it t should mate have developed Upon tIm per SOUR calms making the tho her herf if f i tImers lion trims any charge to prove hem guilt SHAW IN Time Tho statement of ot time tho court which In Its and signed by Ur Dr time man wIno who left tine tho state anti and could not net noti F Fhe he i secured ns a mu In tim this thin Ui tn I i amid several others diners aa well nil the tho follows In imi full Ia f I Court Com SOIL Salt City ns n r been mario by b certain daily pu pa f mere of cIty elty to a of at l la a girl which t l ill th lb i Court t I desire lo to acquaint J you in v ith a athe the ho real facts faits of the case j The Tho first Intimation w lied hud of f tik case aso wipe whon an officer of o n i court ourt brought the girl from this thu mity Jail jat Jailo jatto to o the loom r by i her mother another The by 13 both the mother anti than provo promo Hila girt UM tInt papers had quite an aim Article In th the morn morning ing edition acre t to i time effect that tut th ti girl gin ran away from non a omen man manof PI of bid record and arul was dUrot w l II J i with him In a it m n 1 nn till of tIme Iho mother the nr n I t was arrested and amid wan nt ih mho In Ibn city jail anti that the gill had AIM b n nIn In Jail that night Th The had with ci tim him hIm time that had lud been mado I Iby b by before time county at attorney mm I I torney charging the man wIth a I tory fat sm rui at her tf fl il 1 f ter ler ir The mad to Mm Young oIn the probation n Wo r hO o positive mid ind tho ho mother at tory rr cub pul 1 thorn them Hint the complaint was aa made charging chavn the t being IS chall nr A delinquent tho the being heln that Ihl mi lu lut t was WM wn beyond tile tho con control control trot ot of her er parents DI T I E t Tho rho o facia stated above aloo v were o not notI I known to to mo me 10 r to tn tho Iho examination I Of ot t the girl which occurred after nil ni 1 i ether ther ca had hotl been hl n el of ot a ii ie IC e eI I cess ces Ct ordered and arni all 11 person eron not wit witnesses wi I nesses or yr in n the tilt ITt l to leave the tW lurt room n 11 AR It itt t not our CI lol to tu tl hear cne of ot this kind In open court Three riveo re report r port er remained In lit th Iho ho court room a and d owIng osIng to 10 o the thc oct fact Unit that these thue re ra reporters porters and tho thEy hAt they i I rented relented re have hav hl been r fl o kind ant and con COI 1 I of cit o the children who ha hava liefer feor tort me nit even to t th sIO oC tir and not hot Imagining for tor one mo Inc moment moment ment that can develop In lii luch nn on unprecedented manner 1 i did Ij rot nt uk ak them thel to te retire The Tue le probation rohl ton I and r I co made mude the te I outlined above The girl 11 s failed I in il IC the th stand and al I profit In my m 1 1 ull to 10 thin case cl and atit questioned the th lh girl gir Ir to l Ir r con coil conduct conduct duct with wih this Ihl n fl with lh whom Iho tho thova ho was va a staying Hh ly 1 defant Ignored the tho order of ot the coUrt urt upbraided her mother and aM her with wi I cruelty erl and other ether of ot offence otIn ofus fence In ep us in Ing that the she wal woi ni a It lady and that the r and In fact fac every everyone cry one was WU lying about her hr ir she iho Iho e c would obey no n older ot of tho court no 10 not t commands of at her hel mother would go o no nu nowhere nuI where hel that fhe he dill did not nat want to 10 go 10 goi I i I would answer AnSler no Ito 10 that I did riot not fat went want to tl Arler onil would to no nn ono coo who talked d to her 1 that sho Iho he ran from homo hOlM with this with I moo man and ond wan 11 A staying him she hc n vehemence I m n to 10 her that thul 1 I wa 1 1 having iio In lb other r native to Inform t the girl that If It cho sho Mould not the tho i I court In her hr i In tho rare fare of nil all the damaging testimony 1011 mony 11 01 Y there ther o wai WAO wa but one ole way WiY for tho g court to tc ascertain the tho real and that was van Wil to In have hoo thc tho court C physician make an All tn examination It if her hel mother mol her was WOI j IS JS THIB THE Tm The mother mOlher being agreeable In to this thiM th Ih court coUr wa WAH Mt adjourned to 10 the the mother molher and tho the girt girl an Oil op lp ort I ni to Visit tIIt tho the physicians they Ih went out nut In charge ot of Pro ballon Officer Clark accompanied at by bythe y the who cIto Iho volunteered r wih them as lS n he had lomo of ot the tho gIrlis of Qt the law In lit n 0 similar J at nl the t city Lit I Jail Jai Th Tilo girt left lett lettI my I courtroom giving no tie 10 evidence Ildene that sho hn iti would offer any al and the c only display IIII on oil Oi her an in In noticed el by y ma me mawn meA wn A na ni fl Kill was waH s nhi IR e the tha Ih door loor th tha his iii hand on un her arm and nil he ho 11 ai ity Dont you dIre touch rn An Ui 1 to 10 4 she he left I the courtroom I t know not until on Oil looking out of ot tho window wildow I ow a w on the lawn In II ai iii of ot defiance Being opposed in to toI I fm my vcr and not wish I Ins In the Iho OI cl to tl It I J t I ly wiit n a dork on 01 the tho run rim out mit ot or ort lo ih courtroom to 11 tell t 1 them nut not nl to hu humiliate II lit t the tho girl by b tailing her through the he KII etH li to order a which vIi Wid done donl and the th KIll gI ri a lie tho t mother were t taken to 10 Dr of ot orI nCI flee whore hero idie he talked In lii the Mime de do delimit II I 4 limit MIte nhe tutu hud In th the Court Courtroom t manlier Iller It r ri ti hl I room Thit Thil wao WOH ON el lu to mil milby t by h phone by Ir nr who In n I kind 1 kindsaY way saY tIll to 10 convince the Hie girl RIll that hut U l 4 was I fur tM her lie own nt ii Rood Tho mother 1111 o t I I te d thu ilin doctor to examine e Ii KIll and pleaded with wih the girl to I sub submit lh i mit t Ii Ih hh he to 10 do Ii The gin 01 nd her mother then returned to my lilY lY i i CIP p the til girl Irl tout told 1011 Mr ii I rs rK ti Youna Youn lin Hint hilt ho would not have ob oh objected ohL l to 10 tuft the Ih examination to tn prove PIO Wf L I hail had It not lint bon been for to the fol follow ft ii low fact viz 1 that her hr mother unit Hod 1 about her her ulster Mister abided her herI I that hoi her 1111 clothing wa U UH unclean 1 and Mint 1 no one Oi could her do ro hilt but but hiltA A flint he WJ wa to condition that to nn examination under I she hc bo ho JO congenial u Tl WIT MONY IO Mrs r accompanied tho the girl RIll rr to tho home where after IUN i lr hu fuLl If it not hOt hOtI I anxiously I lot let tr make mal o tho tue ex oC examination 1 which a 1 nt condition and thu not hot mali nial It I tt t for tor the tho flor to tn bo ho trio trim trl i t Ir 1111 then took tho the girl to 10 her II J the ll that night I Ij I the tie outcome established l I tho the heon I question of nt doubt ci I tho saved ad the girl 1111 foin Commitment to Ogden and enabled our probation t 1 to PUI Us lit ls saving power I tt to a n misunderstood f 1111 girl ii i I I J would tint It itI I u u would tin 10 Ino IIlo for tor mn me or rl rite he c to have unfed u d milder language of ct to II 1111 put my toy 1 In lit II ft ii 1 moro maIo manner Jann r In a I cafe where n 1 r girl ot at o 16 Ki Wl vu ui In II a n hell bed room with H K man flail of 42 U away ivi from Crum q him hinI anti and lied had been breit known to lu luhlo ri have hlo been bron with wih him on In occa occasion OC sion sionI I will wi til MJ 11 th it till this 1118 cu r rite e f jy of ft having no Jomo sumo mo place of ot de tie detention Ie lot for gina other than Ih the deity el ami Ind county I 1 t Jail lail jai for fOI nn nii I our Is Ia Islo t lo tD 1 spend pelt some fon ilay Ia lu lit II all ni kI ii of ot hoyn by li II tension on of ot our Morris i j wn we 11 can al detain boys 1038 who Vl ii cHy tho the authority of tho lie murt urt hut but HI I In lii II w tho cai case cao o of lt gina we mi tnt place I I they the can cal ire In put pilL pil In tn a I normal condition where our cur laity lady proba probation I bit tion lon officer can un befriend them anil give I tho the saving of ot our proba probation tion lon nl I t uI au hint t I ii lUtON Inow The lu l Is Ia practically con concluded l ii I eu 11 although al ou gil the COmm wi nu HI In the morning and further con on rider tho the matter malN and may mal examine other i |
