| Show BUTLER TOLD HIS 1113 STORY He Related How He Had Served The Wife With Cocktails in All Sorts of Shapes ALSO DECLARED SHE SMOKED Justice Testified an as to Happy Relations Between Hus Husband Husband band and amI Wife ICe New Now York Dec Dee 20 Cocktails and cigarettes which have hae figured prominently prominently u In the suit of ot separation brought by b Mrs Mary Blair Brokaw against her husband W V Gould Bro Brokaw Brokaw kaw again assumed importance to today day duy du In tho the trial at Mineola L I 1 Sidney Sidne Woods the tho Brokaw butler testified t for the tho defense that he had served d cocktails to Mrs Brokaw In a teacup in n tumblers In a u soaker whon when she was up Uv and dressed and when she sho was in bed Ho He was positive that he had seen Been Mrs Brokaw puffing cigarettes and that he ho had served nor her horwith with them In her room During her butlers testimony Mrs 19 Brokaw who In her own testimony would only own to on an experience of four cocktails and an occasional cigarette sat open openmouthed mouthed I parried a cocktail to Mrs Brokaw In the sun parlor continued the tho butler and she mentioned to me that she had discharged lire ho nurse Miss lIss See I told her that Miss See had asked me for liniment to apply to bruises which sho she said had been caus caused caused caused ed by kicks and lashings from a whip Was Vas the tho name une of the person mention mentioned ed e asked counsel who applied the tho whip Or did tho the kicking Mrs Brokaw knew who did it il replied re replied replied plied the thc butler Was Vas anything an said to Indicate that sho hud had knowledge of the tho cuts on Miss Sees Secs limbs 7 Us Mra Brokaw was very vel cross and an nobody asked her Justice Henry Henr H Gildersleeve a friend of Mr Brokaw testified that h lid had spent somo time at High Point N K C the Brokaw winter country countr home homo and hint had always sways found tho husband hus husband husband band kind and affectionate toward towar Ma his wife Quarrels with her husband which Mrs Brokaw said were brought about by b Mr unreasonable jealousy had and nd ill III temper havo been as asserted asserted 1 by b guests of the at High point N C and elsewhere to have been trivial for tho the most part and as much the tho fault of Mrs Bro Brokaw kaw as of her husband Mrs ors constantly tl reiterated tales tale of trouble so annoyed anno ed Mrs H B Gilbert Mrs lr sister that tint Mr forbade her com coming comIng coming ing to their home Mr Gil Gilbert Gilbert bert bort testified These hese tales In their Inception at least were Imaginary ary a largely Mr Gilbert thought So far as actual barring of Mrs Bro Brokaw kaw taw from his home was concerned Mr Ir Gilbert said on he could not recall an instance when she sho he was refused admission Asked If Mrs had not asked his hili protection the witness did not re remember remember remember member the Incident nor did he ho re recall recall recall call Mrs sending her maid home for Cor her personal belongings Mr Brokaw was excited very ex ox excited excited cited that night Mr Gilbert remembered remembered remembered Mr Brokaw might have havo been lIeen drinking and certainly certain I was very much He Hc thought Mr Brokaw Brola might have been laboring under what the finally downed do fined for him after aCtor a close analysis anal of ot othis his views as exhilaration He did not think It strange that Mrs Brokaw should have havo come to his home homo that night when she sho kno had a homo home lime of nor her own She did not no s know v her hus husband band bund was at the Gilbert house when so came tore tere to te witness said Atty Baldwin wanted to know If It Mr Mfr Brokaw had not made Mr Gilbert and his wife the tho medium thorough which to obtain Information about Mrs MOl Brokaw Mr Brokaw was vas a highly solicitous man Mr 11 Gilbert admitted and would not state positively that Mr Brokaw had never wired the witness to find If It Mrs Brokaw had gone Sono to town |
