| Show i Of t i Verdict Returned Aft After r Eighty Eig ty Minutes s of J t I It t FOREMAN MAKES M K STATEMENT ST I s I r s lie Old I Xu Gut I I Deal That Vance 1 lih hI Ifo tho th oC I ls was i the thu ver let of o a jur that timE foi fI a cl hail hilll l t ne to the for roi the thene el The pi If tio te Jur oS s wa 11 court 3 10 jO oclo I on bom l m 20 the Ilie luil ip their and with tho th f t of 1 i 1 on ell tilI to tl judgment nt It r was n the nn In the loom l that the thu Jui Jury not Ill out oC the bc h 11 1 that thu n tI oC lt w oulU b foi the 01 that tho th 1 IVL H of I C tho b h Ju fo eight In lio ho ed On tho other hand hanel this th i and tint It Ions fo the Jury to at n a conclusion th it Vanto ance Aas wit g of In III t list ice a all Ni Nearly lily j oUe ohl who wh w Ir re n h n tho th Jub retired rein lined they made thell ic Ie ce i 1 JHN riom Froni tho moment that the jury en the tho boK thero wa In III the U e loom jou on al aln a l n ft decision tle lu kell Armstrong Iol i n Han hett Wo lune Ie and ale pitted pu n It slip of oC to In Judge rudge ni Tho he scan scanned ned nM it l and tind It tu Cieri who lio r ad us as follows Wu We the JUI IS In III the tho entitled Hurt the th numbed iel guilty of oC miu leI In the Hist nr t The no ono olle In III th ho Court rouin le s than I aico ulCe olf at lell t HO o far ns out appe nances oio Tie lIe is much lc le i by hy the oida that his hi doom than lie ho was In the cillY when his weak physical phy con was a i described Il resulting from a i 8 confinement in a i as us poi I by h Judo m In his to tho hc jul julA A CASE CAfeK CASEI I Perhaps neel before in the o or Criminal in this has public opinion IK ben en at such HUch yarl ns UH that occasioned b IW the t In this ao Tho ft Is and has been that Vance Is a nun man manof of oC vicious and am au time has d little doubt that I his hili was MIS the tho object of oC inhuman 1 at his hands Y t theio In tho of oC inJUn as aH asto aHto to hother hu I poisoned his wife wiCe Tim he was aH d Gf f socie ius conceded b by tin oC or i 1 I who hao followed the thu case Judge l In an all impassioned plea foi clients life saW Mild hf II hall had no liD sym foi a tt wife at any time Ho H said hild ul n that t Vante rance is a II man of oC Ii I and of oC but little 1 Seldom alto alo has hns a felt called upon to tl then theil Addict or lct almost as f toon oon as a ah a was the ca caHO o In this H Instance In tance I had tho loll left the and while they wore were in III f UK III they the welo bv h hiJ iJ CI of oC Van Ino co fut foi the rem remt K t IO 11 i A B D Vance nt oC Og en a 1 to ask d the UI bo how It was wa that th rould ld lne sU a bin thov to c cx c utu an nUll arid and tint that the mm would l when they th would see sec thell 1101 enOl Tho Jmj jul felt f to male make a and an HPe peaking lot fOl told Jlii Vance In III effect that Vanco Yanco had hanged hang l himself t Hanchett tt he was waH In hi doubt d tho was of oC in tho Hist until Vanco t the it stand hl In Iii Oln hut but lie I w waH is 1 that the tho man was 1 10 minutes af nf tei tN he hI began to testify This name Ic sud Mi 11 was waH bj b the othel jurors and 1 the bl SIJ In tho loom was ai tal i up 1111 not in Vances 1 but In III I the exact degree degreef f NO Ot I A DUAL hall had hilt but little to fri say concern concerning ing III the further th m that he was disappointed and that he hc wa was In Innocent of his wife Ife di clai ed that hy IW hud had not nor h id a fait deal and jury but said his hull had clone as nR foi Ol him af wi they could coul 1 ell en tenee would be upon I De 1 at 10 o clock i he would tale take an all appel and 1111 action in inthis I this Is likely to bo be laki n i when Bailee appeals lI peals for foi n OK db j One bile yea eai I the th day lIa AUs 1111 lur Vance was 11 taken tuk to St ft In a L al I condition from the effect of a beating from hei II husband Thomas and I Irom i alleged to t huo havo been ad utI i bj b him pin pie Ans wa found 1 uI of 01 1 hoi 1111 TIll The 1 healing took place on Oil Nov Jb 6 1107 1 0 and amI no Iaus thin than tha J Ils VU Sc o pinned ton tuu I Into luto the th cu of or liei hel at ut the mil mid milday midi i 1 day meil 1 Icat knocking lioi hel and kicking her Into ness finished his hi meal Ineal r hit Jils pipe Ill e and 1 i The rho r of or the Vance V U ill Jit ho Iho treatment lui and I Vy cay wan Mulu 1 ln don on n the dav last ast Van the room loom In a t l nt thu thI Od that thit thi sh ho put i a IL tJ ll stood b hei hel hc l Sli thank of M fhe he and oon lert tho loom arid el Ill She Sh continued to grow t wJ e until Dee DeC S 8 hen jho ho at St hospital ho l l SISI m lI Amanda Vance Yance a If f the thi woman wo ll i and a u J by b ot r Thomas Tho 1 I Vance was one le of or tho prill in tho th CI of Thomas If i Vance from rr rn start sturt to Ii A w lines testimony went perhaps s sto to C thu act aCl used man wali as hia h j n n I cna aged I ar who ho howa w wa is called to tl take the thc stand against hei hel ruthel at tho Iw tolling like stories of ur tho their mother mothe florn rom th 11 Tho rho two to younger hO CI not lIot In the trial ol ot the cae ea e and it was with reluctance that the tate slate put UHf tho eldest child upon tin stand An n aged S woman mun who ho called at the tho Vance Yance home as a II p l alco als ed tin the of oC Vance Vanco and it I stifled against him 1111 1 Keir win pet formed an on the tho h ll 01 oC Ml Vance ed that hero f of and that bruises found on the I The TIl contention of IC the defense was tin thal I If IC Mi Ind hei hon n poisoned tho fatal dose dORe was red b hy her own hand with suicidal Intent Vince Vance d that his wC Ife luc t e hut but when It was known to him Unit she was WIlS from HUIlIO supposed cd cdon on on Oil No Nfl i 2 he Slid saI l noth nothing nothIng ing of I mule bv h hoi hll and made nut attempt to help sa sao lICe lite |
