| Show CHEMISTRY IN INU U S 8 COURT ROOM I Counsel Go Back to Their College Laboratory Days in the te Smelter Case BAG HOUSE INTEREST CENTER Attorneys and Witnesses Revert To Class Room Memories To Uphold Theory Th ory Interesting Session Iol Cutler Way AVny ny In 11 Connection With the Modification Of Or tIme the lre Decree As 5 Interesting as a day n back In the tho chemistry laboratory Is UI Urn discussion discussion going on today toda before U S Judge Jab Jno A AMarshall Marshall Two eminent attorneys back backed ed by b Managing Director Holden of ot the United States States Smelting Kenning Si s jj Mining company compan are aro matched against two more moro attorneys equally eminent and backed baciel by Prof l me W T C Ebaugh bead of o tho the chemistry department nt ot of j the University ot or Utah The l two groups are aro asking each oth other ot othor er or the lie law ot of gases tho the nature ot of at atmospheric atmospheric composition the tho manner of ot diffusion ot of gases cases In the time the tho chemical composition COi of ot various gases under consideration and a nd a I a thou thousand thousand sand san other questions that belong b longto to tho secrets ot of the tho laboratory Not all the wise words ot of the thela law lawyers lawyers are te furnished them by b tho the scientists at a their elbows The Tho lawyers are ara ar college men So aro IO their witnesses anti and In ill 11 tho the effort eort to t prove that sulphur di dl dioxide dioxide oxide gas gl In such qualities as tho U S 8 smelter will I send It oft off of If It a modi modification of or time the present decree Is allow allowed alow ed memories all al parties partes revert to class room OLD O MEMORIES nS Dont Dolt you IU remember In the h e labor laboratory j jatO story atory atO asked Atty AU Joseph of oC a witness that the thue professor pour poured four poured 1 l fr froC ed cd a I pitcher picher of ot Invisible carbon dl 1 oxide upon a set et ot or scales anti and that the tho scales lowered BO so 1 that the gas J could bo be weighed and that It Il was wai a hours before tho the scales righted t 1 j I themselves thus thul showing that Ion Mon of the heavier gas gai very slowly slowlY The TIlO question was waa wa addressed Id to a mu t i Witness for the other side sl which J i I woks to o prove that tho law of sion Ilon makes sulphur gaa gas harmless anti ami the tho tho answer was nan w rained framed C IW accordingly No Indeed my I memory ob Is he Ii j ll Ehe contrary The 11 l oel o poured 1 the tile lIDS gas out omit on 0 tile imo 10 yea lew and amid they dipped down showing thai It If vas 1 heavier than titan tho tue air al hut but they ther righted themselves before the lecture was wu va fin finished tn finished Judge Jude Marshall was nas a I keen JH en listener In itt the time expert testimony on affairs of chemistry tr this hits morning HP Be 10 ite witnesses much more 1110 closely tutu thin i Is his custom and his taco facet betrayed f hits his Interest Instead of o the thu th usual pla placidity ot or countenance with which ho Ito h 4 conducts most of oC th lot cases C es before him JUDGE TAlES TAKES A HAND JA I when whon ci sora with wih lawyers In n the hue most tech technical kind of or questions he lie put ll In tp ono one on of Ills hula hi own oln to bring out tin t r i that to be he the Ito one that Jol they the wore ware seeking to arrUe arrhe ut tit tt Tho rho application of tC the United Stat Stats i smelter to get Jet a 1 1 lease on UI life an Oil 01 account of ut the construction of or f a 1 hag 11 at its plant was Wl carried through another alother day Iny of ot severe fighting and andU It U Is evident that tho regard time tho application as lS ono one that IhaL will unit m undo ullo all nil of ot their previous u work lo to have Ille the tH Wit Wil William Witham smoke moko problem solved Judge WI liam lal ham H 11 King ICing led In 11 the time examination of ot witnesses today tod for the tile farmer I while County Commissioner John C chairman ot of the tenneco tunel com cent committee i was at his hil side side and amid uld took a I keen Interest In tho the testimony i im Mil MIt m SIDE SIE 1 When hun asked for tor his bin view ot or time tho pres NilS present ent case Cf and Id to stale t why wimy the tho com corn committee mite was opposing tho the move no so 1 de do decidedly d Mr Maca declared that tha tile tho I bag 1 house hos was tas wa IL a n mere 1016 delusion In that 1 It was wan tho sulphur gai as a 0 I Ihlo ide hlo which did dimi most moat mot g of or the Iho damage especially at itt It some seine distance front from the tho smelters und and nd that tul the bag bl house did I Inot not In tho least lol prevent the tl th escape ICA C ot of or 1 this thin gas KOI but increased It It since it wn constructed wih with tho the now nOI roosters roasters to prevent tho the formation of or tho sulphur sulphuric I ic 10 acid Mid within th the plant plat leaving It tu to t tobe IM be 1 later made In the th trees and ul vegetation ion tion ton of ot tho the outlying farms farm MU MR U lOUDa 18 TS Director folden Holden of ot the tho tn United smelter wag al naked or ar hil his opinion on this thin point and ho M h do da that that the tho smelter had imail h rankly frankly admitted In Ua Us Is petition Its 11 Inability t to control the tho sulphur dioxIde through tIm bag house houS and all that It wn ol Ad Admitted fd that this gas EOS 11 would escape un unrestricted UI restricted Wo Ve V do claim however r added Mr mtr lr Holden to tako tao out alt all al form tonna urine of ut except the tho dioxide e and ammil all ul arsenic lead nail and copper comar cl pr dust This Is makes the tho point of ot time th ease aee on oil the possibilIties of sulphur lox de Ido to 10 do damage an as II limo thoc limb IN lit no contest content over oer the tho that It Ii is I otT ot Into th atmosphere This hIli morning tim tho tei tu li mony was wan to show how Aha the tho or 01 K according the ihn lends 1 In followed ved by th I the he two tO sides side respectively of oC one ono part 1311 of ot eui ul dIO In lii 1000 OO 0 parts of ot all air to Kettle on a IL plant p tnt and destroy detro It II lh winds prevailing preva 11 I around the tile ell II l figured upon and In l deuce del e ono one on thus thull hoping to holY that hat wert l too frequent lo tl permit hermIt from time tho th oil I gas guk and the tha to 10 show In tim ot or would still result l lI J F ES i The lIle first witness ot or the tho tIny day w WI urtus u B whom milt r its 1111 in the n whose who 1 t worK vork science clene had haul ten isen to tu ud 1 lIn and whose whoa and tIle had 1111 1 been tIme the t mil t hl t hl smelter could 1 now conui cOunts lit In litto i to ii court fourt su that yv were re known to 10 o 1 and lud fum that hat went Wem I Inot not lot known when tivi th decree at Judge 1 was waa entered J Jh Mr lilt h outlined the nature nf of h In with time tho bag 11 anti and id of or fact tad that lost It Il t I l could l nun not t o solved It II wan Cl 01 led II lit lie 11 won o In lit stating Mating tIme he tile American 11 used use 1 no 10 spelt mici di 11 diio I io 10 on HB its smoke ana told of new nr IV un an Datura tUNA of or tha tIa Ly house Judge tw fill ot the tho timelier ansi Judie J tn QI U Uw thy rot p r took this tJ |
