Show II i 11 SPENCER CASE p UP fOR HEARING t 1 i Testimony T of oi Dr Calderwood i r jl i Does Docs Not Establish sh That lJ Crime Was Committed L 11 T 1 JV f ti r h i r J Wj i OTHER MOTHER TELLS SUSPICIONS fir w wL L r Jj r V i ii L i f Sonio so Conflict I III Two l St rIc Told by II t Ihu tIie t tin iLl II f Girl I III hi t Case Cne Cn c cm m V r If ff Jr p Tho Ii eEls caso of or Samuel G Spencer WILH offense statutory th j charged chafed with a 1 t t up for hearing between Judge C H n criminal division of the tho thel th thy Q 0 In the tha l felly y court today During the forenoon i sion of Ut court three witnesses se for tho ho thov hos thoN N v v s wore wrO examined namely Dr hr 7 iJ Vf It Hannah Wal Vat V luce ll the girl gIr upon Ullon whom the tho attempt at atiAt i f f ls Is alleged to have havo b en com c orn n Si remitted EJ and nd Ann Alln Elizabeth Wallace tho thoA A mother At it tho the conclusion of tho thu i ri l girl s er v 14 direct examination court 4 took f i I o IL rc m recess ess until 2 30 0 dock o 0 C I oc this Bite after fl r V n on n V j J County Atty Aaron Meyers Moyer had hadS hadj hadL L S ji charge harge of tho case calle for tor tho the state assisted i liy y Atty H A Smith tho the latter having i boon been by tho the family of ot tho thu thur fJ r girl rl Atty Adam A t Duncan Dun an Is IM chief chieft I i t J counsel nol 1 for tor tho the defense and AllY Atty E F Ei i ii l joA appears as nl t b late atc counsel Instead of ot Judge S II U nI I 1 Thurman i FOUGHT i case In Is I being b stubbornly sought fought V M i on both sides Tho Th lh first clash between V 11 h c j opposing counsel came camo when whon Mr Ir Dun 1 ran n n asked that nil nit witnesses except tho tio tj I i ono one 0 o on ui the stand bo ho excluded from tho the iT i V courtroom Tho Thu other side requested re j V j li that hint Hannah Iva i a Wallace bo ho permitted i t l to to ho he conferred with from tron tf 1 ii time to time The ruling ot of the tho court 7 I iv as that nil all witnesses should hould I bo be ox ex ext t I i eluded i t TESTIMONY OF DOCTOn a t Dr th od was wai the first witness l V called Ho testified that on Aug 20 2 lt 1307 9 ho had by b request re eal of her W I I J 3 ido an examination of ot Hannah Iva I Th Wallace While conditions were not i J found to be b normal they were not auch duch ns n to to show conclusively ClY that a crime u 1 had ad been committed Upon tc the thu witness H Maid that the tho 1 name Hame situation might havo have oven lJ en an 0 f brought about by oUter oilier causes than i the ones OliO alleged 1 f V THIS THE rH GIRLS STORY STOn s1 11 t Hannah Hn Iva Ivl Wallace was then call catl calls s ed ad d to 10 the stand In answer to y Smiths question sue me said that sue ITh iv I would be 15 16 1 years old on March darch 8 next f i and that she ulic lived with her widowed mother at Granger She then told that tw t f oLn Jan Jam 7 to 10 Aug 26 G 1907 she sho work worl worked jI V ed id at the tho knitting works of ot Samuel Hamuel G O Spencer lencer her mothers lit nl was wall the tho manager For I or tour four mouths months fH 4 V beginning In April sho she stayed ut at the tha IIi Spencer home on Canyon Bond Komi part tHi f of the time In III n it t house and 1 part of ut the time In a LL one 21 next door both bath belonging to Mr Spen Spencer Tho The crime with the defend defendant V d ant Is l charged she sho testified was WIlS as com corn committed H on the tho nights of Aug 13 and und II H Ht t Y 1007 1907 she Him occupied the bed of ot lf l Mr dr r Spencer and ore one of oe his daughters iff t V L i The guis story was in pint purt the tho sumo same sumoas samer n r as told by bet hel when the tho defendant had hada hadi i a n hearing on all a n similar but butmore butmore more serious charge chargo In September lust last In t td d 4 In Mr Ir Duncan en endeavored endeavored to bring out that tho the story tory iii told tola t ld by b the tho girl today conflicted with her statements at tha the former hearing I St At the examination In September sho she Eft f I jl ho he reminded her hOI from tram thu tha tran Iran transcript IranI transcript I I Iii I script that sho he was sas entirely alone with 1 V h the th defendant In the thu room when Whon tho the offence Is alleged to have been be n com coin committed iN i today she swore that one ono of ut 1 Mr Spencers daughters daughter occupied the thu thoN theLi N Li I mime bed betl at nt the tho time lime and ana that In an another anG G other hII two or feet away alny nn on fl i daughter was sleeping steeping On tho 1 q former occasion sho sh Bin stilted stilled ted counsel re fl reminded h minded her ber that next morning Mr c Spencer SIlencer hail had spoken of ut his hIli annoying c her riming during the tho Today aim shu sl suid suld t that i the he conversation next morning was 1 of oe nn nil entirely character Con Can us liS to 10 the tho th alleged acts of at f defendant at nt the thu time the thc th s 8 iiI I alleged to Lu have hae been committed also 11 0 out to c r i jr Y YlI Mrs Mra lI 15 Ann nn f pf of pt Hannah Eva iva I vl W then i 1001 the f tand and Iho V I Ut trig up to III the employment ot of her ht hero o itt at the tho Knitting works and or r the It III cit l Mr tr Ir l 3 IOIe Mia Mi s W thon stated mated that I kiel Iel I 3 on tho ho hoI I morning of or AuG Aup 0 G hut upon uton lay laying ur V l clothes Intended Intend J tl oi 01 r tho tim N came cume hy to the tho thoin tt ty r in letI by hoi her j K in lIel haj bai asked the tha gIrl I silo Him had hall been leen subjected to zo V 1 fly anti alII had hlll received nn an 1 l reply 2 hearing ot or the tilt cage ense vu wet i 9 Pd late lato this tarn ion A t Y |