| Show W TALKS ON TEMPLES PLAN Noted doted Chicago Authority High in His Praise of Famous Buildings Design ESCAPED MANY TEMPTATIONS I lone nc St le When 1011 It gOpin fl W r anti 1111 MoM alo t of or Its It 1 Were Conspicuous CuIl pit Plea I All Ae rr n of the e Salt Lake tem temI made In III a method I S ar who said Bald flippant 1 MUo g 8 K pling it 1 the building long before It ItI pings i et I Dieted tt was wall published In the Archi iral Recant this summer Bummer over I 1 de dot 1 ire of or Franz K IC Winkler Lo i anxious to repeat anything esi 1 pap to the tho builders of or the tho i rk and 4 the of or the com cons reprinted tho the article He Re winds a I rda js from n a 1 higher authority ar world and one who d h the aI I nUon with tho the tract wait or Its Ite o l 1 1 tIn heen said bald ns Re much In ra ta rai taIt r It In i lecture as All the former i imposed t d to It Itis Lat Wt tk is rail fall William J of or orI I bICA m 11 architect who received hl hta training training under the great e whose ho e plans plane for city haH made mad many localities fam sea WI A s a In Salt Lake He Hei 11 vas II er i in w tend Nd by a n 1 News New II reporter re orter r i i l p ned to and him looking over dbr bf be t D I I grounds and Inspecting the tell 11 K g front frimi the I he distances or of the sur aur p it i ays Th Hii iI thing thIns that impresses me mo mel l gout out y ut III on this block ft Ii that n it i is genuine he declared The i r f ti neety IY rune runs through It It and MI n I si nty L that I aay say a great greet deal for I Ight Might Ight n mk make comparisons with wry rory buildings within sight eight or ot th the tho thoI temple that violate every rule or of I tur end and are aro botches batches In stone stono and nick Ilk j Th tf Is la tar far from a failure allure he hel heid l id II heu i told Mia of ot the criticism Tak for matches Instance this thle lower water blo bk ih we p rail call the design at the Less base bit bitI It t I li I higher than my head and on onn n 1 buildings you will find and It tt only a afoot acot foot cot or nr 1 11 off aft the ground level To lid It II high here was the and end corro t i thing and U le an architectural architecture n Now Nov 0 0 take Uk the tall columns that go gott got goI tt t I regular trull Interval Intervals and they are sm Im ImI Ir I done It Is 18 true but honestly done Ilone doneThey donehey They hey bt are an of or read HI ac are ar so eo 8 many of ot their kind tr of ot U f false IA f delI Uon They y suggest he h everlasting of or the eon con and nd the thi towers lors shooting up TO o o emphatically lI n lIy and a 11 solidly from the theto th to f with 1 their t tapering tops placed r J b ml red unquestionably In III position t th lI seine same thing If It the builders granted meal th Ir work to 10 state stale as IT Ir pro proClaiming Claiming dalming aloud In words Lyons that It was wa bUilt t to nand nind torf Co fr they could not urr ed their design The taper I II I big M t H r i ps ore i gracefully built buill and In good food rn 11 non n When I think or of dec orations that could hive have been attempt attempted ed td In Nat cast Iron lust Jut ju t then having 11 a 1 run runor of or great Enill popularity popularly I am specially Im Impressed Impressed pressed with what temptations have ha been avoided mid and how lion faithfully and nd sincerely the work wo k has hRS bm been executed DESIGNS Turning to buildings In general Mr Brinkman declared that no architect has haa a I right to judge Judie whether a building Is I successful or not until II he fully tully com corn comprehends the purpose for tor which It Is i I Postal Petal buildings building should l declare decla their festal purpose he be said Bust Busi Business Bu ness blocks block also a o should hould express them theme e d Ives R according to tn their purposes and so 10 also It Is 1 with places of ot worship Be Being BeIng Belag ing lag Ignorant of or the ritual service con conducted cond ducted within and with the needful ar arrangement arrangement arrangement of or rooms mains I have no right r ht to speak of or the window indo arrangement or orthe orthe orthe the IU of ot the building except tx pt iu its interior However from what I t know of ot the Winkler Inkler criticism It Is I flippantly done lone and end with a consciousness for tor say ing lug something III of ot a thing constructed by people whom he thought It unpopular tar lar to admire Here Mr Brinkman left lett the discus discussion Mon sion on long Ion I enough to speak of ot hl his hiM ud lul for tor the Salt Lake IAk theater built long ago aRG and yet more mor service nice serviceable able after this test teat of or years year than Ihan any building In America erected for tor the Iho th purposes no so many man years year ago 0 for the tabernacle with Its It wonderful arrangement of ot entrances e and nd exits and for tor the main portions portion of ot the As Ae Assembly hell hall all of ot which h he declared showed a masterful conception of or practical practical practical problems problem TEMPTATIONS TEAl PTA APED Not every architect lie he said can cando cando an do 10 justice to big Here lie complot com om complete ompie plot pie justice has hA been beat bt en done I 1 can ran make my In meaning most plain to my myself m mb self salt by b thinking of nf a thousand things thing that the architect might have attempt attempted ed Id but which are a sr not attempted In Inthe inthe the temple In every v ry move moe tr ty t end IM nd honesty of purpose ate apparent enl ant Kf every ry In I is In proportion In Is I shown The buttresses and nd towers s II are well 11 placed pieced and arhl correct Altogether th the building Is I M to per rr cent t better than many of ot the Ih ml of ot tha th that east at dons done at a tin ti h AO n period I 1 run ran count the hur h on my anger that 1 I would call so 8 well done A Mr lr before returning mum In I to his hl hi work In looked over or the Ih buildings in III n general and he h that the Ih stale Mat should hould be es U proud prud of the state tt fair strut tru turn lure since Ine It U an so 0 fully carried out nut Its It fetal festal Ideal and had In addition a personal Individual touch which Is II I the rarest thing thine In American architecture and nel which the W of ot really Indigenous styles styled Instead Insl of or successful copies cople of ot European models IA K a single city street finding R a splendid example developed tot fot countries with much snow mow ano and n It tendencies in art arl right alongside of ot a Classical example whose whole who art was as a de developed d tor for sn an 11 entirely different rises IBM of or civilisation OIK and to express ex pre an all en tn entirely entirely tI l different art feeling tUne ANNE FADS ADI l At the time or ot the th temples build buildIng teL Ing Mr Brinkman said Id In tn conclude concluding ing In our 0 eastern i tern architects al were giving lag ing I u us Queen Anno Anne tad fads and Instead of criticising the It temple for tor departing from the prevailing vogue vague I we should feel eel Joyful that out nut here hero hereIn In hr th the west wet there thre was an architect who h thought out his hla own models instead nt Ad of fir using those provided by b the fashion of or the time times Not one or of the Queen Quo n Anne structures of ot that period Is I classed a as a success today Most MOlt of them have been torn down special reel work at pres present present ent nt I is II In churches and school P hool houses hous of or which he ht hOB has designed more than thana a hundred I for tor prominent eastern cities He lie II Is t now at It work erecting f K a I great Catholic cathedral In Chicago std and d his hi visit I to Salt Rait Lake Lako was ae u to get n a 1 afew few lOW weeks week c k of nf rent Mt while the basement or of this building r went nt In In order to tu prepare himself lt for an arduous winter overseeing the tha th superstructure |
