Show ft f or 01 0 TIlE An atheistic writer u 11 known knoon hosed of ot Ms his fa attack on nn lel tl In m the th Bourse 0 of a 1 nor hr eom owe proof of the of 01 r th Ih Ihor h or soul IOUI t r spirit ot OIl mn man 5 11 distinct and different from th Ih TIt The skewer to the Ph he dm demand of or If th ath th dat lIt was that IbM Ita given by psychology tIM generally It n Is II t with db e rn moss In Roan Noab Porters Th Thc Human In Intellect Intel tel It ft Is I to this thle effect Mow III shut there titer I Ib How lIow ow do 0 we w ow IW such b a thIns thing as a S matter manes III l ty ly lythe y th the manifestation to our r W We ton lion of its Ita power r and pro know that there Is I a tree le or it stone yonder Onder simply because of Ma 9 them namely tb the thi perceive as we color hardness hard weight Ilat smoothness etc pie which th the object present pent to our 01 understanding in other emcee n and words ortIa we know the things by b bof meds which they t produce on oa onus of ot the tb lb effect us and we know knoN them tIMm In no other way Berkeley ventured the th conjecture the tile con oon contrary Oft that for tor aught we know to tear the existence of objectS object mar mf marbe since inee It hi is M in aU all Illusion be ho a am mire mere eases cases a matter of ot Inference front from the ba on us produce erects effects ecta which they tb bard bardae through their color weight of sure ae ess etc eto We W are practically course 00 that tbt objects do 40 exist eat because experienced their we wo have so long Ion from th the tIIa ota that the Inference and ead i Im Immediately to what we mediately 1 Infer IDler to be their a to amount natural as am to be lie so 10 0 appears appear of the b almost to a direct perception objects themselves That Tbt it Lt ta Is not exactly a perception of 4 the tIIa object o elect produced l by bythorn but bt only of an aft thorn them upon our or mind through the tM media of our senses ini Is i fully lUll proved One Oase mod iod of 01 proof proM In various ways way a In tn Is a given direct perhaps the Ut most moat considering the ease cue of Illusion I When Whan the nerves of sight ht ave are tul i i we the head bead ed ad eI as by b a blow on oa I though tho there are areno areno re reno see e e stars really reaD hoar hear tto 10 o we a to be hi seen INn W no tan stars tak of 01 f bulL bells after as ringing ot of quIn or cerium hV dose ins mO In i yet the th billS bells Ita we wa till ium th ther r siE Th The mere e re Ta report 1 1 I 11 1 INI pet ur t la not direct if f nur u a port Vort that bat b object II HW sQ nor ll t 01 experiences nr ee ott n t Hut LUt uch corroborated by b thAt thi repealed and the c n of nt 15 th I h re leads 1 to I t Union that th Ih n d In re resIl nII ll oI n nUN or fit rc pt phi own pi i ut uI IiI of o f mi U of ot thin thon So 14 do 10 c UN It of r matt r th Ih I ho i world work world of nr I t the In whit wy But BUl Not XI he henl perceived n Ind nd just a 8 but hut bo b suro ui to t nl quail do dothe or r t I Ly What prop w r In Infer Infer W th the mind Infer he h lust lUet t a it we w fer reI It I its IU proper properties of ot matti r from tru thi th ties tine or or oror i 1 The Th all 1111 the Hie tr for tta tb 11 ni ie e C or properties bv h the tte i allt same thing H HIt mint mind or r un on unIt onIta knowledge ar Itally self lf It to our but bt ar are rt Jut just an a area It Ita those ot of matter mattec of 0 mind wr w r If It th lb the properties real ml rea might con conclude ot of matter auel we Wi w those thO like Uke form of mai mit md to la a n mind elude clude that th property of matt att a pro tt ur toT r or a new D kind indicate But the tact facts f unlike Uk the really reality enU entirely of reality matter matt The phenomena known kao aa a under such inch mind are dearth 4 rt of fit Joy sorrow tear fit names nam ease as sa hope bope pleasure pain pan Imagination knows known o by bi b the bit etc atc Now How real 1 If terms are r these tUM known Down to us U II as AI than those tb anything and d the like Ithe U W color sine at hardi that at object t whether ther tnt tide or stay may doubt duo dus to the Ul Illusion only oat an a be real or nerve or cw to W the th of 01 t our disturbance cannot doubt bl t we WI but play pI of ot ot of wonder wom r about bont alto It at I Ireal that our feeling Joy JV or o sorrow over that daal our reel real or 0 What Whatever Whatever to Is a fact or 01 bad bed tidings tIdbit good t Porter Parter re reo as a be unreal areal else 1 luis may ever elIr U Is Ua I salt iel snarls marks this IbIs act acting and of joy Ju sor tor sorrow reality nUl Its Ita It phenomena a 5 Judgment nl etc et tt ve e the th ril row MW of ot otHorn manifestations of some reality Uty not nonentity These IMae Tb phenomena are Horn of ot th the body bod since place ace toy jo not pro unlike not only hope sad and fear ear are hardness color r weight t and the UMI other tit or matter properties but are Incomparable with them tam As AI tb the lite phil anil 11 say 57 la the phenomena of mind and of 01 matter are In These Thes Tb phenomena prove ProvI not only the tM of the realities that cause can cant t them but that these thea realities realiSts u are pr differ different 1 lint ent la Is kind from trO thou those t of 01 matter since Ini th the phenomena ar art a different 18 In kind lit One OM kind of reality Is Ia Salt since ace It U Itcan Itcan can be timed weighed measured u and all s sit Its It behavior vr under any gives lilY condition foretold That reality ream Is mIttiS Tn other kind bind of or reality altay seam coi lo to be of an eel nature sinus Ins ws We w cannot lift esti estimate mate m UI ounces dine the motive tl that t eaten der 4 what we c ClaU caU u ambition nor n the u uI b Idea I that thai causes au fear r nor ass the 14 project that aroue hop lao We W mar ma measure wr re tb the amount ut 1 4 brain thai u to these u l and a IA IAn Ideas n bet t Ik ea Mt not be hefted ft smelt melt or ur urr lilS r cu vise their u be pew ted dieted You nu an sn alway predict ct what w i a stool stone will in III 01 do If It yes WI f t It rt at gC i lal isi It Ku go It U will UI fall IU at u II rat You can 1111 1 lI what hat bal hydrogen n will du 4 if It you flU apply to au It It lt will burn Ma and r Watt will alwa always set t lb arne the tb pae 11 do bet r Iu l n II II III H will 10 Under any given phy hr iI d I II lii may all allS 11 I S I I luiis iii 1 l 1111 hll aLI aLIu I I 0 I N t u wild W ii II inui III LI I II It 1 l lI I j II I Io mm l I nl I I III It ItI I II I 11 41 j II Mon man ft or Of la ii I son l 1 n by b sn en bother hether world worl of circumstances I unknown M as a Mr racIer falor tor In I the Ute realm Im Nan Nn I by bl a world wrId of ot mental tOll lInn n hopes hope fears tn pains IM eon I It Is I by no mean man that lust h he doe d not control even von event th t as and arn nd bend them to t hi will on n the tile centres the he I b beet t and say m that he ha actually chooses choose elt among amen these t hett various v rlou mental r and 4 motive us to 0 which he h n will III fol tol follow tollow low Ma N la is I free f m III tills till maim and anC I is by b consideration that snake make maken n H i appeal to t SI apart t from mind The mere m rs object IW art act el th ho same mil no matter mallet ho hon often oltan H k has baa a d In tn thet tit I war or Oh la t 5 any a other way Not m with wish man nuin K Kach ch sot lot change him himMl Ml Nil future hi lion I Is determined tiet hy his It hI p I t sr ap rl and tint by b the Ih fact eOl r t tl lat ut 1 the Ih condition are te teI the I h same AS ui r th Ihn n wi w have hare hll a 5 world 14 of or reality lIt 0 souse all of man an action the tM phenomena na an of ot the mind or 0 soul which are ut utterly t terly trl unlike the th of 01 mutter matter sod nd d art aN not d by b the same me metin tin TheM phenomena of ot the th spirit lanot I d b bf seen n or touched but buit they th ran can he ht known and w we know them th much mouth than thin w we know die dis distance lance tance weight ir o rotor color They Th are rush real al the moat most rent rots 1 of or nil 1111 11 the things thing thin we w know They Th Sri are not no properties of ot mutter matter thoy Ihy are an tot ill unlike ill 11 the thu th of 0 mutter They ire arc n properties proper or of o the th ho soW mul Itself that which I is titter all au the Ih most moat real of ot the realities the human They Th prove the existence of ot the th soul nul Inee Ince w know that realities must mut originate from reality that tbt coon com CO from nothing That which h thinks think sure lIre surely ly I exists l i then her he bl 1 no nfl thinking A AM Ac D Descartes it itI Itt Itt t I think therefore I J sm am m or 0 an as the theler later ler thought would probably formulate the tile doctrine I am therefore I 1 think |