Show o 11 N Stem 1 of esi o Case CAM CAMA eR eRA A has hai hal been by Marshall Manhal In the t federal court curt in Sn hia lb b ae ease of a R H H 0 against A AI I I Hyde Hd and nd Jam J James Cunningham the th lb being bh In II favor of plaintiff Th Tb Th acts fl In lii I the th Ih matter mater at t 1 Issue lUll as a brought out In the tit Investigation are about as a fol An option plo was ass obtained by Mr Wr hyde un oil u a Nevada Hea mining property h Id b bin Ly by oil in lb purchase M price of which was w ws mutually placed by I owner and nd purchaser at al 10 while hll hl In 11 reality 11 JI t was wa lo tO Or be b to W a Mt li J Into the Ih dual dai lIr d in I Ia i M half I of 31 fur for fo fora a iii bat t In the Ih i rl Aft Af A ft fter Ir er r x or nr umi Petit PeltI gie m siw I Idu and 11 ux II i lusell 11 r Ui 11 h luie Ill ii u III of tC o affairs md aid ut u U d I Vui ui tb II return muni tuN of hi h his nu nl ny c t onn I with 11 h Mr Ir Hyde Ny in th u tm CS a Mi Mr M Cunningham I hough It a a not I shown shiw that h hI he SK I 1 mi I to 10 it the th Ih KIM rt n t I ll H ti I J hll lii tin lb I Ii I Ion 1 on of JLII 1 UtI ll i liil lt I i c Ml Wf I Cunningham loss loses 10 In the caw case c by reason of o the fraud Mud held Id by the court our to In have entered enter Into the th deal The Th plaintiff was 1 given ln a it ll len lien n upon an undivided of the mine In lt regard l rd to t Hydes action ato in the Judge Marshall said d In part pr With Wih respect It to the Ute fraud on glow the tl evidence ll the strong set I at MM kind of a case and warrants warrant want th the o N Unsung a that tt Hyde expressly assured aured Pet pt Pettier tier t that Ut both bh were to pay py of or 0 th lb t purchase price It I I said that tt 1 wa was simply silent client and ad under no n to disclose the fact t of or th th the agreement with wih Johnston had M procured pur a at false t a appearance to 1 th t the contract t an a ap sp appearance a Intended to deceive the per pur pr chasers ha aa us to t the price It I 1 I is Idle Idl to t say that Hyde ld made mae pee no false fl representations tUon H II He planned a device to deceive and purpose by b hi I his silence en accomplished hi h his |