| Show i MORE LIGHT ON STANDARD OIL GO GOI I Indiana Concern in DOe 1006 1 on i a I t Capital of a n Defers Earned Over 1 PACTS FACTS ARE FAST COMINO COMING OUT of foi t toi i on n IH Is I Suit It In nt i X ew w Ir York Sitt L i 1 Mow Mort H lIht ht wa WR waUpon hed Upon fIon pon the Ihl rm ca I IJ oIt aT lit the rn tUlln of the tb nt oil 1111 4 II Nfl n t U when Frank Frnk H II K I 1 U 1101 who wh tin i h the th II I lid fit lii placing upon uon the Ih the Ihl pr rt rn Jil lita Of 17 i of nr the II th firl in l nl In th Ih y yal an and 1 4 t I Th Thi abatements r f of ot Ih I h hj j I Oil on company of at Which WM recently fined I I y J of nt for forI linK I I thekia hek d d that In sti 1 thC tb company wm me d on of ot n 1 WOW or over 1000 per irni nl a t Mr nr The IM Th India in 1906 I t In than any ny nf r the tha Iti lAg big combine Mr Hello KUn de H th t that day while Mr U o 1 e tant nt comptroller of or thi Ui stand standard ard OH Oil company wan wa w un on tin fit tan S problem of book bk k klit lit k or or of account Aft p r tailed failed tf It t explain Irom It II wo wu that t t llio UIO oil of or iT erk rk ID l MM J ii made a profit prot of 7 II flINt noo tl dividend to the th Oil oh CO C OTRY of or N w 0 In M JIB Of OC 1311 TIIt tr lb Ih net nat aset II or of the th N Y YIk rk c Mur bJ from 40 6 o to o tIt tile tha leaped Ie from frum 47 4 7 J Ml 1 to 1146 In IteM an antu tu of or nearly n Th Tit mm Ir III of ot the tb lb If York company how Met w d from In 18 IP h i 14 the th ar at III or of the th tand III Oil ill of or New Nw Jnet Jeray grew rew w tim Soll I iii la t to Ie Mr r Vay Iy y WM wa cI aI n a to the tb nu nit tM JM tui of t Itle rn h of th Hew rw Tork York company and the th III I li h ha nta of th Ih the tand nl Id il OH OK of Mew Jray but H K Kt Mid isM t Il Ii be not tell until he hr h hail d th the look book of both i IM I h told toj Mr r he would 40 4 it 11 l Pratt II of f ih lt Oil ot company r In the thi 1 Mr told t ld h how bow w M i had held tor tore e Oil company pan the th ato tok k g the oe Oil company Itt at t t tp 1 lh e It K witti ft not permitted t I tIn Io tu o j In UM tha stat tote Ie of ot rexa He U paid aid it tie lioW h tile flu stack Mock a aa a of ot orl otc c l tM mid not to io avoid tb tbt anti antl t t laws Iwa I at or LaL hu tit J Ir latt threw nome pome Interesting t on an t W ler Pl Te oil vI the toek of or which was waa w held rr s Jell I by bV Mr Vaa Va BUD Burea is p not t with the stand t Oil OD Mr II Van Vaa V Bun Buren pur 1 lf Ui Mack from Mr Pratt and ancl thin huM your ir the Standard Oil tm om omI m I iI tt It back TIlt ma nature nf ot i tion abow d that Mr III r Van In IJ r t va 1 frOtH float the tHa Standard Oil Cb U cU wi al l t hb ks pad for or the th rl MI that the tb time tUne bo be 11 jJ wet w PaW paid Id to 10 the tb IL II JI lii H ii I l 11 ur at ot U tand anT rn il I wan Wa called to th tho l II RW and od Mr lr math mad mathIll Ill effort eOrt to 0 nave have hay d on the re rea rella a copy eoJ of Df f the truE agreement of ot lla but John Joha O G coun coune e Iff tI l the Itis Ih defendant object ed I oa nt tw the U thai rk h an agre ara ilL WM wap prior to 10 July Jul 1 I 1 I 9 whan wit wb i U the e t 1 law went Into ef if r Oil nil company or of Ne NW New r rv Je v i 1110 ha of or the lb Indiana 08 11 JI Muck The Tb Indiana com eom om J Y t CApita at The ri U paid by b the Standard OH Oil OHof 11 of hr Indiana tildian lat year H aie re I or a little mor mr m than I a le 11 I On I iolli The Th fuu cirt rt If today Iday In hn iii h teral 1 tit tin 0 Rid Arti ro Oil of or r New N JI J Th lid mid and lid i mm if cor if II 16 1 tIr r pub nub corporal km n w Wr WI r 1 n Th nt of and 11 or ot 17 U f r the th nf r th the Standard Oil 01 of if ifa N NII M a pre enl d If Ir thi t h nn 1 now III lu pro h In III thU Ihl c ii t fol fl Iea Atlantic Refining in l ou oa l I I J 7 O In IMM IiO ad j i ILU MU pro ta luckey Line Une lII Wn In i In lit IW 1114 fM Oil company compan III in WOl pUal I 7 HO in ill lIMit dividend 4 u i Oo Wit m DIS 13 ur Pipe liu tAt tl c in capital l fM In dividend fl 11 t profit lui t In f I i iON ON III c Si l to M In ItI i 1 OO Indiana India nit Pipe I 11 hr rom pit an ii In III 13 rap P al 1 I I r IH In lii fI t I 17 National Fr I III In n 1113 capital II 11 M UT 3 r r SW In III Ii I 15 5 II New N Y ik Trill i iti lill arty In capital 7 MimMi tI hi nd j profIt prot 1 I 3 In ti III dl 12 MI U S 2 Northern r l e I In In c 1 n Ill lii 1111 i lot ml HK lk l I i i i I n ll 11 Ill tI 1 n II li Ii I 12 s Z IIO OM flAO I ni hi II i 1 Mil ihl III tia i i lir ml In Ml iapi I I 1 I esIo prof 1 i I In 1 I W dividend Ih II oIn 1 IM INt IMI 10 I MI hi 11 t I I Bout 14 hern hii Pipe Ilp Une fm in III 1901 I j ii nS 8 I In m I 1110 dividend M 4 Wm proal ft oil ill of Iowa In III IIII I lH ifill 1111 tWO I 00 M In III I ISO 19 dividend 3 t ST W I Oil bI com ml puny ll of I In Ini i 1901 II II tl I II 1 i C 7 in Ih 10 I 0 2 I oil t Ill i t all of Kentucky In I 1 If capital i profit In l 1 0 I 1 OH of New Nv In Kt H dividend I 4 n I 14 In till tit n I 1 1 f bit I P M X 11 in I iril OH ft company II of nf Ohio ohm In I 1911 i Ial IS dividend II en 1111 hr lIt 1114 4 In st I Wt 1 dividend lId I II 74 i nIH IMS capital mini oil nil In oi noi nl III in 1 lin fOIl not a 1 7 AS ot TO IN Mr r k Mr Ir hi to 10 ii r o duci dl a Nhi vinK the thi Ih i S nf it t 1411 II h hi In h the th tb Oil hI WIH tt Ia Mr Pay Fay raid eald 11 hi Pu h u ul I if ir M H It ItaC va aC reed red that Mr Kay Fity mid an ac a e tot for the th l 11 ami hk I k up the Income ac a from th Ih i nIs 10 rh J part lal lint hat d 1 the th tb nain of 17 Ii i I i M s Mr K Fa 11 cud ld that prAt prAtI I all it II I I th lb of r f the th original on nal 1 I 19 uh U hel ii y I iii ii WIM W IN H obtained by hy Hi tk Oil lil of jf New NIr Jer Jerm m p y between WI n 1 If and anS 1940 1910 M Mi th ikid Mr Pay Pu Fa Fat If t hr h hal ha foi fi f th Ih records record of ll II u iLi tirig the rIm I lb II I n ii 1 J and I l i Mr Fay IV ay mild eald li II I iut n l found se seI e I II I I ih oil I I trust rU bt extern I NI the then th thI had not Dot xam which hh he ht n ht I of n I 11 t 1 did Iid ii nm 1 II It what wh t they hey th I con on He H said IJ 1 1 the th man only I hi k nt tt Ui Ut u bal ni h of recent dat date tind he h had hall made no h for tor forthe torI this the I h alam h to ISO IS Ml Mr that hi h hail cern M no tin ah hi t of ot the Water oil company Why Wh I hi jt It thaI your sour office which ha h has Information of f other companion the Waters has hai no n h formation of JIo oil III com comi an Y PRATT IRA A M Pratt Prall secretary ecret ry of th the Oil company took wok the wit i FH tid thIt fl H He Ht td i ni ia that re r v of 1 th h government were mIlle over oer th the I Id lid idere d nm of the truet a antl AM AMI j jI i hat Information th the shelton of lr the th truit wan a being prepared prepare i for or presentation In Mr was waa lIB chow n a statement 1111 the U Income of ot Ute Oe I c Ml fil 1 company of ot New N Jemey from C CM CM CM M Pratt and baked If the th Income wai we wa the total amount or of dividends dividend received from rote Ute tile Wit I company U He I La ret 11 hint I It wa We Mr Pratt Mill III Id the he held 1 In the Ier oil were In III hl by II H CIT Pierce of ot m 4 1011 the I h Prior Print to 10 O 1900 1108 the Hu Oil company of ot had a of or and thO th owned 1717 1117 h ts Mi Pratt ald eaid he lie Paid out cM of hi hip hili 1475 noo for tor the and it II In III the thi Ih of the Standard OH till In itt Mii May At Ii I 1 the Hit thi new Water Vt Ph oil lii WhIP wan formed and Mr Mu the nu old fi f OJ thy the t h certIficate of tho the new Why Wh did to u hold t thu ock for fortin tin till oil I 4 III ticked linked Ur Jon fl AM Ac A n it mutt T of f waa we weI I th he hi reply Niu Sw Nb ix C n Ii m I of tacit feat did you ou out ViOl not t hold tItle too to evade nde the antl anU law of Te e ePA PRATT PA KNOW I to t not net know wan waa Mr III r Pratt a c r Mr 1 r l Pratt Hid auld thai I In March lOC HOC lOCh 10 Ii h sold id the tho Wati tr ri Pierce PIrce ck to t M W MM Nan M 1 Van an Run Burtn n who wh tho Iho wUn 1 hut had i I i Ith the th till Ill I II toy Mr MI Van VID Buren Buton paid for fir the Ih tock stock giving ving S I i AI in ii and the th reat r t In note not The lb Ih h and note not Mr Pratt Aid asid uin 11 iI uruti I r by him to the aan n oil 1111 nip ny Mr MI fruit mid Id he did not lIot know why th tb tuk 1 aa wild sold to 10 Mr WI Van V Buran rhu Th dividend the year yar ear be Ita beheld held ht tuck amoRt to 1 oO mid tutu I you cold Id the clock t Hk for tor 4 1141 you 11 think that thai a good i irI ri w for forth forI th Ih I h Block tk V Yen va 1 l considered It u a fair price t Mr Mi M 1 Pratte IrU reply pl I ll tl you YOli lb Ih sue aale Ie bests Ill 1 Y alt lr Ir Mr 11 Mid Id Mr Nr Van an Purest itt the lb dividend to the Ih aX 1 Ill II company and acid the hi Ut Wat dock back to the Man tasi rei Oil nil of New Kew J racy and nd thi and notes note with which he h paid for fOI were war returned rn Mr Pr itt r rut Ad a resolution adopted bt at I a meet I uc of 4 f the tile board of or d of the tilt Oil company on nil June Jun J in III I hit which provided a hail hul of nf if I te of the alock of the Ih puti u 11 for fer the tho tb harM char of th tb OH 01 HI company of New Nw Jet Jer IM Ni y There were t at thu th meet mit Inn III H If M t li ii Ir r John D P H H It 11 i II H anti nd Paul Thor There were iii hr irr re f Ih new II com company om patty pany ud l to tb I taki tahi in ti the lb Ih I i n 1111 it I 1 the thi k tit ii Die II v umi m Ila II I Mr Ir te that thi th I h 1 1 rd Oil on company voted It hut M I in the th nub flUb bv by M 8 The Th did not nut IV ua wh ho h h Ii il II the pros pro iou lew Attn After the 01 0 i t Ihl lb IMd of the Ih board of cg director dl tors or if t f the Mua dard Oil company Mr II MUM eald Id In 1 a committee of tu fOUl out waS waa al Ap AI Appointed 5 pointed to act iii a sa as a com ml tie t John D n 1 ld Jahn C l M I Pratt and end Mi M J were the th member of the th which acted m a custodian of the I h Mill sleek dock ha having vine a book of I Mr 1 amid that U the OH OIl of if t New N York ell eli from the Standard Oil of N New w Jersey J II r C i r I export and find andl l linot Ml all lot of thi tb th spott bual buil flee nena n Mr air r Pratt MId laid that he h Willi nea a boy boyhen hen the trim truet agreement w we a In III tAU and mI at t that time Un only knew II H HM H M cad and Me ils father T Pratt a aa among mong th who the Ih I I nD Mr Pratt wa we x and H ft Tilford t of ot th the OH oil of New Jer J y WA wa At celled cabled to tu the aland Mr Tilford waa Wa a ft vo vice WI president of the th Oil oom of ot New York ork He it H had acted tad M aa a II dating of or the Ih Oil trust he 11 Mild Id John n 1 for fo the de di defendant at title this point made objection to an any testimony being taken the tn Involved pre p v loua to July JuI 2 t IBM when II the law la went into effect affect Mr ald 14 the original In i t run tee were w John D I Rockefeller John D 11 In 11 1 ter o 0 I J 3 and II H M N i Mr tr 11 ni Id that tbt before be he went wt lIt Into the tI dard Oil he wai WI Iden idU 1111 with the Cite CIMo Charte Tharle Mr I r KellocK at thi thu vouch t to 10 have h pd upon ouch the th record a Py of the lb original entered Into in inINI INI to which Mr dr Ir Milburn objected on the tb round that the th agreement a wag we made mAd prior to ISM 0 and therefore Imma Immaterial tenal a Ra na evidence with It to any aay y matter at ue In thi thie hearing Adjournment w wee taken taMn till tomor tomorrow row roe ro SUIT TO ro ANUI CHARTER FInd O 0 Sept wa wac 11 filet died In the common pleas plea court today by I W WD WD WD D David county count pro to deprive the Manhattan Oil company ny of ot Its char charter chartr tar ter and to It from flout paying a R high higher er r prk for tor oil oU than la Is paid by the th Buckeye Bucky Pipe Pine PI Lint Lilt company In ito inc stunt ml territory The Th petition alien that the Manhat Manhattan tan an wa wee w an in Independent com om company panT any but wt was waa a eight Ight year ago 1100 and wd ii I Inow Inow by the l Oil on company now flow owned by b the Industrial Develop Development I London Ibur ns mint ment company O land lanil and only lIve five hare of ot the tb tock valued at each fb ire are owned by the th director who ho manage the Ih atTain of the company The Th petition charge further that aft At after Ater at t ter er the a the Solar z company a c m tuu nt af or the Oil on companY took over lie Ita I refinery the l e Ohio Oil company took look It production the In tun Tank line Ita iii It tank cars CArl leav leaving lea ing lug the lbs ry only Ita I It II line linea nee which are lined to light fight the co 10 o called lIt M MIt 4 It H I Is Ia alleged aJl ged that for or the bLat luat ven venY the company comy use hall done nothing yearn yeara but hut Y nerve 1 a IL medium m for fur forthe forthe the Buckeye PIPe line line hue II companies Slay nay pa InK lag S f cent a barrel ba mom inure for fur the oil uti than It received for It when lii the corn com commodity west pieced on to the th Buckeye Pipe Linc company coni pa yet the tb Manhattan lu itC dividend annually to 0 ha hat he paid |
