OCR Text |
Show I 1 ' ft'l ftl ' , r ' { ' : . 1 t 1 1c c rt it itt t , 'ti1 ti1 ' If l1Nt l1Nti l1Nterr ' 1/I1 1 I1 / J"r.b Jr.b Jrb . " . err errY errt errd ? Y i d kvd7p , t 'b b t ' 'bJ J . ; ! ' i I IWQ } w n v : " ! Mjf J JP P { , . ? .J J . } t 1 1Si ' ! ' ' . } ' ? , , H ) Ml t ' " N Nd 'j\'ln 'j j 'ln ln ' \ d , ' Id t ? ) " , 'tii tii ' , . : W Wv ft.t ftt : . . Si t'j s stftr tts . } 4 B er t ' : ' " . , > . /'j 'j j / ' 'f f ' " .1.t-r 1.tr .1.t 1t r . - , " 1 " . ( v l } n < . i 1 Il ecru . "rr rr . " ; i ' ( i A i\ i \ y ( , ; f ( E El iOfl It Ite.tnalt R e.tnalt etnalt : . " r IJ.t IJt . mfm Ofl " , "fitewe ewe nmm , ffW nmmffW . jl.vis- jl.vis jl.viswriiiui 4 4Nirltr . Nirltr I , 1I "fit fit - " wriiiui 1 t t ' nt yf r " " ' ( ( ' 71 P 1Y r r f'i"i fii f'i"iJj , < ; , 1Yi " . \i i ' \ 1 It { . w ' " " Jj ' yi t L J . Jlase r \lase lase lasea \ J ) , Jmi lase1lt4 lase1lt4I iiM.Th iiMTh a . mi . . .UfQ UfQ . ' : \ , I pu QU QUf QUOr jx f , ) , u of Or j , r \ i il ' . l ( i/XiBdeyal i XiBdeyal a a"ederal . / ; fedora : "ederal ederal " ) . " ! ' Oowt Oourt Court " ' i t irlIi Kf - . tt t4 t4'On f t ; 'On On ' On n Juriidlction Jur1 Jtuioliiction dtction J11&wy FIawa Iliw J11&w J11w & y ; ; ; t ' f1 I - " > 1 ( $ c cf f i T 1't 1t . ' 1'tl ' ( ( -l l - tM ( ! j < " . * f 1 fXwo rj . ? < . > I 1 ' lt ltTWO t ) , . -Xwo Xwo TWo - h1t bcl hItch.httan hItchhttan ) .b1teff'r .b1teffr b1teffr . iikefdtelesedfry iikefdtelesedfryt ) ! : ' wIeMeff n1 ec trMH ( t \ tbetmere U ti ur < . a s B . federal cowi cOUit court , "whew whew "Wbt Wbt " where4 J.lJ JlJ . : ttttw tbet mere were con'flcted conflcted conv1etedt ' 011 tit ' ' q , i m ddrde ) ' . ? chargerwpreebc charse charge harga'wiire'backi-ln harga'wiire'backi hargawiirebacki ln . + . rwpreebc ' ' re ' b'ackl- b'ackl backl b'acklIn ' - > tr - In Vernal Vema.1 Vema1 . ( fat Eat- Eat 8'e.toi 8e.toi 8etoi ' . , - .r r . , } : ' Urday tu'c111.V tuc111.V tuc111V ttrday . , . when where theyJwere theywere thyj * , fr * 1o icdrted Iong ce4rW ce4rWj ( l lpi farth j th the * - county ' jaU iail . , " ' aWa1t1nr- aWa1t1nr aWaiting aWa1t1nrj'aUtlD awaltlnriJt - + j'aUtlD\ j'aUtlD jaUtlD j'aUtlDJ ; ' aaitai alltlat alltlatthe \ \J J \ Jtho ' 1th tho the * diatrict d1atdct district . court . Th The * tw two tw + a ljie1ai tf ljie1aiw > Et Etwar tfwire w wire war J'e Je ' * brought brQQht totVemal to vemat Vernal by bYr tarjBhecUB tarjBhecUB'K 1eir1.felJ 1eir1felJ 1eir1.felJIt . , 1terlt ! ! " ) I I1f 'K K ' It 1f , ! U M . , Qnyderlli ilnydergand anyd rrt , uct l ct \ OOUnty OO\U1ty OO U1ty gtyt tMfAJtw/'y tMfAJtw 'y y AttOC lttor.t lttort : ( . / , ' ' , , , tMfAJtw'yne nir ne aey , Widlap WaUago W e * + Chldet Oa1det Calderawbd ' . 'Wnoto1r ' who 'Wno Wno ! \to1r\ to1r \ to1rt totlgthem fcooic/ fcooic totlg ( ) ; fcooicthem ( . , / ' \ wenote1eMeIl terTtheyiwerteleated them t em Into cua cmtody custo1y after.th afterth a att terTtheyiwer r.th rth . Y yiwwt weno ! , te1eMeIl teleated < iatei , by TS y Jvw Juct Judge ; L 'Ithinm Ithinm ' Taima 0 R . la . .jolnnaon jolnnaon . tb.e'tted .r r . J'ohtisot Johtisot RJ'ohtisot ' ; whca 'When When ' be h . , he heI4 hdd , tthet \ s.that.ar sthat.ar sthatar . t . tb.e't tb.et tbet ti . ' * I dliuin ted 1edera , c c0trr court $ Mve.tjJ1ad MvetjJ1ad ttevet ttemT.hftdrjundl ttemThftdrjundl . r rddt . bttd jzz 1 icftc dliu- dliu tloain ttoia tloa - , in mth ddtMonday the * ! first kat ) > DiMif picas . ddt : ! 'i i ' f ' MQnd Monday y , _ . jtnorntay mom1ntl cloning 1 bptowWte tOf fore forer foreJ'tt r ! , J'tt Jtt * ' Host < , e , . eof lhof of the th * ileacqas ileacqas'glr peac * l lyr yr 'glr glr ' w , .Eh Eh . a & . . . aehdapffl UehdelzCetr Uend ? t tJames Janaea James rtlJlUtchey ecU Reedt R B6dr'aii4 B6draii4 * ' aruJ alto ; Lfcroy J.oetoy Joetoy Lroy . J,11nmt J11nmt HttwtfCl J,11nmt1 HttwtfClWtctey ) , tMw ( rtlJ . : > \1 1 \ ' " JU lUtchey Wtctey ) waived pnllmlnaly JeUm1nat7 pxellmhtaxy : fix ex , . 'aminatlon aminatlon ' .m1Ii.tton m1Ii.tton m1Iitton minaUon . . and M toad $ MVeTe \VeTe VeTe were w \ r bcNn bound O o1C oyer ttVthe f W ttV , , , , the th tb . dfatricr cUattk dlstriet i * . court eo\tftt eo tftt eotftti \ , ; i Thff 'W W ' wet , : . uf ; : t t { \ comntltUd comm1tt committed d U ui'the uithe tthe courtThey .th th ' . et & adsty adstyt adstyoil Cuitody f oil * t ! Hhwi . " ; , Iff Ut 1ff Bnyd Snyd Snyder r . . wlt wlthout wl9ioitt"bondrwt wl9ioittbondrwt l ) t " bond . 1 Wit Witpected 1U ( . jtac- jtac jtac'pected .l-Jr .lJr .l l Jr . - ' - 'pected pected ' ( pecte4 pected that tbat the they th , ' y wul 1V111 Wlll bq b * a TaI e4 arraigned . e4.t arraigned'r arralg d .t t 'r r . ' t-befor t befor ? ( - betotO before * a\ a aIP a \ + ' IP special cl 1 aeSS1 session n of Qf dh d1s cUsJoo v vtract 1 ' 1trtct > ? trict trtct tract court coun Gourt : aometiro som.et.tme somet.tme somettme somettmetthe . . * i < lth th * ifonM"lH ifonMlH ifonM"lHof * < for forepart"of forepartof park , ' ? " ' " of June tune , yun . , a aoconUng aocordtng to t Oounty OountT CounW .A A . At ) .iIar iIar . W w wtomey { ( ' " tomey torney Calder Oald.er Oalder . . Jr fi r t c 4 11 o < r - r-h r h r " , d m f4 . s . 't t ' f , rf rfThe The Th * first ( Int trial tttal trialof -of of .oti oti .otia ofya . - a first ' flr 11'4\ 11'4 114 11'4de ' t \ ; de deli delimutter d icre * ( . iunlflr murder mutter eotn cooiplalntr complatlltI la1ntr jit ) ilft/'th'i ilft 'th'i thi / 'tbe tbe . ' ' * United ltlnitod 'it11Ute4i.ttt it11Ute4i.ttt it11Ute4ittt 'it11Ute4i.tttStat ltlnitodStatea ' ' . rtStates Stat Statea S District p1trtct $ Oourtitpp Oourtitppmah ORurt3tpr-U ORurt3tpr U td 1-pt'O 1 pt'O ptO " - ' ; -mah mah bl ' blSatUfday - eh1 eh1Saturday , Saturday SatUfday asthe had bad ba a . a cUmactlq l1mactiq dlimacUt finlxh flhb # . as . * . the th * two convicted col\v1ete4 col v1ete4 \ men a 1Ooc1 tood ood , b 1 > * q - > ) ro fora qfora for * the th * courf pours In Salt talt ; lt Ijak9 Lade 1t9 , ; , , > - ease easeschedi1ed - r cheduled schedi1ed schec1 theptluefor } ed t fofr fot death deat1 deattt pn X11 aad fT theptlue the ft , ptiiex.for ptiiexfor . . tor for aunts a.l1f al1f , . llte ; jsen kehteoc tellenc0 , n * . < I > / fJ ! ! ( Continued bn on pttetlveJ pttetlveJi pageflvl pa $ ) ( 1 < ' , ftv * ) i " f ' , ) , t , It Hammer Murder Suspects SuspectsBrought SuspectsBrought Brought Here for Tnal Trial TrialCctstutied TnalC Cctstutied C < ( ntl ntllf'd i > tii , ! \ ued \lf'd lf'd lfd ' trTn from fre ( m rape I1RliCf paae ' one oneRofdl ) ) HoPdl ltoPdl 26 and Ritchey 24 con convlL convieted convicled vlL vieted IRd by the no jurisdiction j lry sry lryof sryof iryof of the hammer murder of Mr Mrs MrsAblgale MrsAblgale ' > Abigail Ablgale ' Agnes ' . Williams W'l.lI1amB Wl.lI1amB WllI1amB C Calif Callforina al1f or ornla orusa the theUII theUlt theUli nla usa W we ( man while traversing UII Ult tali tah Ouray Indian ReservaUnafter Reservatlinat Reservatinafh Reservatin ReservaUn ) afh after ( < r Mr Mrs . Williiuns Wlillam Williams " had jllvLn given jllvLnther giventier ; Riventher ther tier i 1 s a Iide i t Ide In her automob\1e automob 1e automobile automob1ewe automobilewestaarl automobilewestwari \ we westaarl tv\ tv tvar \ ar 1 from Colorado ColoradoTl ColoradoTI Tl TI d ( I 11 II n L.S.SBI LS.SBI LSSBI rssal I . . . . ' > al came Lamt ' following a alonb alon6 rlonfc lonb lon6 I i Ht n iv ( tigatloi Ilgallol tigatiot by U ' " Dis Distract DI Uistrict " trkt tract Att AI Attti-ney Attti ney I ( rnt'y rnty rney - ' Dan B Shields and andhis andhis amhis his I-hltalt I hltalt . ISM tint ' - bait ( nil John S C , Ikydt'n Ikydtn Ikydt'n1 B < yden ' \\1 1 al alrev \ v.1revewtd v1revewtd . 1rev rev eWI ewtcl d I a it t gnat great length It'ngth Itngth lengths ' I ) rav rovl rovllions rovlsions ! sion lions , > .f f > > . f the Ihe federal ft'deral ftderal ' law upremp supreme , > supremeco uprempco co rt Tt I r i I 11 II I g KS gs . Ind uu1 nd the tlw uta Utal Utah } E Et EI Ibl tbl Ibl1ng tbling iblIng 1ng ing Act aid ai ar ci d Utah lav.sM lassM laws lav.s lavs lass lawsM . M B 13 11 Bdtii \dtii dtii .dln dln vdur \ . loll toll JudKe Judge John Jolins 54 . < tl t1 ti it tt , on the li I it ' structlons 'itrucUons itrucUons structions from fromIll fromhe fromhe Ill he IllI ' n \I I tt \ fhtl P\ P f\ f ev ' \ Pht'eial \ htl II ht'eial hteial , ( ' es PIal al 11 U ti I ( ( J j I 1 i L'idlL LidlL lad Lsdictloi ' it . 1101 ilor f f U t1 I ( < ft federd feder " er il II couit court COUI t c lid ild lidn ildn ild11 n t t di dl cle fendedIx fendedIk fended fendedIkth Ix Ik Ikth til iii met nWI were wert ' Immediately Immedlatel hnmedlately : , ar or arre.ttl orresnl nrrested re.ttl rettl resnl . ( " ( 1 s i ' statt 'Itatl Itatl stall murder chargts chargf chargs ( s by bySheriff bySheriff bySheriff Sheriff qndt'r qndtr Sn\der Sn der " - , \ der ' of Ulntah Utntah CountyStripped CountyStripped County CountyStripped Stripped of It Its , > long legal hL his hist hist " t ry rv the j j irlsdicllon Irhdlctlon irisdiction hinged on ontwe ontwo ontwc twe two dat.f datf BattsIn dates Batts datesIn . ' ' In 1896 the United States St.ates . Su Supremt Suprenie Supreme premt prenie ' Court In the thf ' Draper case casea casea casea a m irder IrdeT srder trial trtal and a manslaughter man'ilaughtf'r manslaughterr man'ilaught manilaught manslaught ' f'r fr err ' ( ' ( mirti Inktl nvictl n ruled rulM . tliat t.hat that the ' Unit Unitt'd United United t'd td ed ' " St "It It ltt ites ties ' ' > does rtC ) { " ; not 1 I ive lVE eve ' jurlsdic11 jurisdicti jurL'5dlC jurL5dlC jurisdic ' ' ti t I I r i f f criminal offenses offenp . ' ; , > In In Indlan Indian Indian dlan dian ( 11 II tt tr\ tr tn trs trui \ ui us Ie less " . an all au Indian Is isit is11 11 it n olied nI'll nittvh ! \I'll I'll Ill \ ' oliedTl nittvhTie 11I Tie ' Tl 11 e I " sc ' > < s < - 1 ( < I s i e P of this crime cTtme howeveT however howeveTwa howeverwa howeverwa IsI I wa pt fit et 11 tl ii e P a tune tll11e time under fME'r fMEr federal ' .I I . Jur Jurisdictl jurIsdirti 1 isdictl < ; dlrt 1 n ibs It rbsl > < ; > ) Ilt-ely Ilt ely 1 ilely dely - lw because ixraase 'allse allse < ' of oftl ofU oftt tl U e I " Ft Duchesne Dudw.nt Dudwnt . ' military mllllRry reer reser resertatiw reser\atioi reser atioi reseratioiBy , ; tatiw . \ a tiOl reerI I tatiwBy tiOlBv By Bv executive order the lhE ' mfftnryreservation mUftaty mfftnry mUftatyrft'ratlon mlll'tB.ryrespr\ation mllltB.ryrespration mlll'tB.ryrespr mllltBryrespr ation ' . rft'r\atlon rft'r rftr atlon reservation ' ' ; \ \ VIR was aas . " abandoned In 1921 1925 1925Now 1&21Now 121Now & Now In CRe cases . , ; ' ! where when ' Indians Indian , > art are arepot arenot ' pot ( ot Invorved Invo1'vM Invo1vM involved ' the broad area ; . Is IsIm Istrader Isunder Im trader eT the state UHlf unless ' 's s < ; ' for build build1ng buildIngs buildhugs IsI I the stale state stalegTar stategrar stategrar 1ng hugs < ! of . , specific pectric purposes gTar grar I ts is , ; the government jurl\d1c jurl d1c jurisdic jurld1cUon jurisdiclion ) uri.sdlctlon urisdlctlon uri.sdlctlonJudge . . ' \ Uon lion UonJUdge lionJudge Judge Johnson JohnOn . ' ! waa VIas aas informed Infonned by byMr byMr byMr Mr Boyden lloyden that thal the Draper CllSewas Casewas Case CllSe Casewas was an absolute ab60lute bar to federal federaljurisdiction federaljurisdiction federaljurisdiction jurisdiction of a non nan Indian IndianCR"f Indianfare Indiancase IndiancaseAt CR"f CRf fare " ' fareAt At the courts court s request reque3t Calvin W WRawlings WRawlings WRawllnps Rawlings appointed to defend defendRoedl defendRoedl defendRoedl Roedl who has been convicted convictedwithout convictedwithout convictedwithout without recommendation recommendatian moved movedto movedto movedto to arrest judgement and dlsm1ss dismiss dlsm1ssthe dismissthe dismissthe the case Mr Rawlings Rawll.ngs Rawllngs . had pre- pre previoUJlly previously pre previously - viously vioUJlly raised the tile jurisdiction jurisdictionquesl10n jurisdictionquestion jurisdictionquestion jurisdictionquestionHowever quesl10n question quesl10nHowE'ver questionHowever However HowE'ver ' Kncrx Knox Pattcrson Patterson coun coon cooneel counsel counsel sel eel for far Ritchey c convicted d with ttr- ttr ttrommendatlon reo.onunendatloo reoonunendatloo - . ornmendation ommendatlon lor for Ion a life Ufe sente sentep sentencerefused , rPfWlt"d rPfWltd refused " to consent to the moUon motion moUonThe motionThe motionThe The motion moUon was made then on thecat the cat o i 1 1sad Jhaa 1sed sed sad "JE JE " flat 1t ' t rfsi fr s * fSS ) Patter-son Patter son Patterson - or BOrne some BOrneother someother Borneother other attof4 8tt.ante.Y 8ttante.Y 8ttanteY attonlcymtty . inay ma , . appeal tt it wu was wuwd wassaid wacsaid wd said 1mtn from.ibinojurtsdlctlon Ii-om-'W Ii om from.ibi fromibi - - . ' no-lurtsdictlon no lurtsdictlon no-jurtsdlctlon jurtsdlctlon no-jurlsdicUon jurlsdicUon - - rul- rul rulIng ruling rul ruling - ing and ' file lfUe 'f11e f11e motions tenons of former formerjeopardy formerjeopardy formerjeopardy jeopardy to 10 bar trial tt1al of Ritchey Ritcheyby Ritcheyby by the state of Ptah Utah _ ) I | |