| Show CLOSES fOB W o HAYWOOD Asks Mercy Meroy and Justice for De Defendant and for the Poor Weak and Weary I SENATOR BORAH FOLLOWS Millers No o on n hut hUI There Th ro In III Inter Interest est ft of Law and Justice Boise July Tul 25 Tho case of ot at ot Idaho M im William D Hay Uny Haywood wood charged with the murder of of ot former governor goor of ot tho will rest with judge and jury tomorrow night Clarence Darrow after for tal 11 hours concluded tto final pica plen for lito at p m and at 7 this United States Senator Borah opened closing 1 argument ment for or the prosecution Ho He will penk for tor session lon or about seven Reven Fremont Wood will In Instruct and charge the Jury on Satur Saturday day morning At leaRl 1000 lo were lo to find In hi the courtroom tonight THO Tl o hours before the tho hour net for r the third session se slon of the day crowds began to 10 arrive and mi within halt half an CUI hour tho doors were closed to nil all but court and newspaper men It was an all audience composed almost entirely of Holse gathered to Mar hear the tho speech of jf tho young man who recently r elected 1 11 y the of ot Idaho to rep represent represent resent them In tho United States sen senate Ito ate has been tho tM assistant counsel counRel for tor the prosecution In tho case against Aside from tho 1 crowd In the tho courtroom and the largo num number ber bel of women present tho scene was much as It has hns been at each of ot the ses sessions during tho lost last 11 weeks Mrs the widow of I t the mur governor appeared in the court courtroom courtroom room for tho first since tho Iho trial opened She occupied a seat scat Inside the tha railing beside her youngest son f Cn Julian Gov Gooding with a number of ho tho executive exe staff starr and a n largo laro representation tion of the state Judiciary ju and bar were the tho audience Haywood was surrounded 1 by b seven of at his hIli cOlin coun counsel sel and his Ita In her Invalid chair ns liS by his hili side Ride At the prosecutions table ta when Mn Seiji Borah Dorah rose roso to speak spank were u to twO assistant counsel but James Jamell H II Hawley leading counsel for tho state tato was not In hIs bis place to serious Illness Senator speech was a n From time to time limo ho turned on counsel for the defense denunciation ton tion pouring from his hili lips and at nl times limes brought protest from Richardson and Darrow but with blazing eyes and hot retorts ho silenced every effort to break the rush of at words Tha Tho climax was reached when In behalf of the state of ot Idaho Its people Its gover governor nor and himself ho disclaimed nil all In Intention or desire to Immunity to Orchard Finally his faco pole pale and every muscle quivering with emotion tho senator raised his arm and If It I i should over ever Join In or ap approval to Immunity to this man I hope the nio groat God may inti wither my 11 right arm to 10 tho socket DA FINAL ARGUMENT Clarence Darrow continued his final argument at 2 Ho no took up the alleged attempts to tn assassinate Pea hod Goddard and In Denver Denler and announced 1 that ho would devote most of ot tho afternoon to the tho assassination of i Before passing tram from tho Colorado troubles In which the tho federation was Atty Darrow accused Gov of ot trying to murder murler Moyer Sherman Bell of at having tried to as liS him and tho Minn Owners association of ot having had him arrest arrested t ed Pel on false charges As opportunity offered tho attorney continued to In Inveigh veigh against tho newspapers and the tho capitalistic class Leaving Denver with Orchard Dar Darrow Darrow row followed him through Idaho up to Portland and Seattle and back to lo the dImos In It re at al Mallace Darrow again argued tho thain In of ot tho motive for tor tile the killing of In tho finding of nil all his old 01 1 partners In the Hercules Hrh while Orchard himself lt was poor Ignoring entirely the argument of ot tint Orchard was In thc tho employ of ot the tho at nl tho time ho II killed Burrow Darrow assort assorted as ert ed d that tho position of ot the tho defonso as aa that Orchards solo motive for tho murder of ot was WIS to pay pa ort off tho old and revon o for tor hav ing beon driven ou of ef the Coeur Coeur and tho loss lOBS of tho opportunity to got rich like his old Running rapidly lIy through tho list of at witnesses 80 who have testified to threats by II Orchard against Darrow hat had n good fo d word to say for tor each cach and argued credibility as M t Orchard Q Om n of ot Colorado a former afforded an nn opportunity for nn of t tho former Gov Walto who Dr row wild would bo revered hv 11 tons ds of ot thousands thOU of peo people plo throughout this country for tor tho stand ho took In tho cause of ot Jabor lb r And BO 80 this man filled nUo l with ha hn tred 1111 Darrow continued went down to to kill whom he hated and ho borrowed from hit hili old Paulson on In or dor that ho might be he to do 0 tho was at tM and ho went from thero thoI to HIo and then thon to Ho trav traveled on 1 ticket I promised to provo thin to you OU tint hili I t Iono ono fo to I am 1111 not permitted to tell von why wh hut but I r mav 1111 n ono IO nf ot our ur tell WM killed In tho limo nt ot when ho wan Willi for tor Bolso to 10 testify on Oil this Darrow tlc tho written bv hv to Orchard ind by hv Orchard 1111 h In which Mid that tOO MOO had been hee sent to by b fill a but not nol Incriminating In any event ho lid 1 that of ot Orchard no direct to Pf t cont tho letter 1110 inner from Haywood to tn Mrs chard tho 1 of ot monay hy to Orchard In finn J narrow Darrow aM perfectly le tIll 1111 ii ho o nil 1111 tho other brought II th utterly l to client At the five after I altogether a or for tor llo ton Darrow tho I t lack tha voice and no ho discuss Ill you the Ih many i lIke ilka to 10 call to 10 your our at lit atHo Ho Hu pid a 11 to Borah n ni u i Ihu HO able would follow and d for law and oidor BIK 1111 peale of lie Iho luJ and thu country COli II I f NOTHING IN cAlm HUT D Dili nUl r I tell you that thoro thore l It in III 1111 but Orchard I J mn confident that you will this jn III thin I 1 leave I With Mth you fou mill lII J iray bo you Iff ay ho Q In this case euse 1 I In It as I 1 believe bellove In my 11 life Ive 10 given 30 years yeara of r my Ufo to the poor pOOl I have pleaded for tor them but never before have havo I pleaded a 1 cause In which I felt such an interest and never did I 1 hope fora tor II ver verdict verdIct dict In favor of my InY client as I 1 for tor this Eloquently Darrow appealed for tor mer mercy mercy cy and justice Ho said suld he ho had known Haywood for tor years and thal the day da of or his conviction would bo bl a n sad sud day for him Tho sun suri would not shine and the birds would not sing But Dut It Is not fur for Bill Haywood Hawood I plead ho cried or for tor his widow or his orphans If It he men who work In the mines will III send their mil milto to support the widow and the ones and imd a 1 million people send their message of sympathy I dont plead for Hay lIay Haywood wood Dont think for tor a II moment that if It you kill Haywood you ou will kill 1111 the tho labor lubor movement of a tho world or tho thu hopes and aspirations of ot tho poor Hay Haywood Haywood wood can die If dla dlo he must but thero ther are lue others who will live If It he dies Illes ond they the will como come to tako his pIneo and carry the tho banner which ho lets fall Call I 1 plead for tor the tho poor and tho weak ami the weary Tho of ottha the world worl on jou 12 men of ot Idaho tonight wherever the tho English tongue la Is spoken and throughout tho civilized world they aro 1110 wondering about your our verdict If It you decree e hla hl death the spiders and the Vultures of Wall street Will send 1 up leans of ot arid wherever men live who Haywood because I ho bo works for tho poor you will receive YOW your meed of praise Bui nul If It you acquit this mm min ore are millions of at men menoU out t on tho broad prairies on the wide ocean in the tho fac tac factories tories and an 1 mills and down deop In the tho earth there are aro women children who will pray for tor you ou These men and women children stand hero with me tonight stretching out their lianas and Imploring God Oo to guide gul o your Judgment and imploring you ou to sao Haywood Mr III Darrow finished abruptly and as ns ho walked to his plainly showed his emotion and many women In tho audience were in tears Court imme immediately adjourned until 7 p m Senator Borah commences his final ar argument argument for the tho state BOKAH BEGINS ARGUMENT Senator Borah Berah began his argument to the jury shortly after J 7 p m Ho said ho appreciated that the were fa tn fatigued from their long Ions ordeal and promised he would bo as brief as pos pas possible sible under all circumstances Much of ot his declared would bo an nn answer to tho argument of ot the opposing opposIng ing counsel I 1 am aware said Senator Borah that I 1 am In tho case caso as nil a special prosecutor The Iha learned counsel ait olf tho other side has haa Impressed this tact fact upon you But J t let mo say lIa that tho state which does not protect Its citizens or punish wrongdoers would soon loso 1090 tho respect of ot Its 1 and alii have no standing In our civilization But counsel has gone further with my associate Why they the should at nt attack tack Mr who went fearlessly Into tho investigation of ot this matter why wh they should assail In a n personal way a man who ho has practised law In Inthis Inthis this community for 40 years and honesty has before been ques questioned I Ido do nol know It Is usually thought to attack a n mans argument to do away with his logic 1011 but running through this case casols ta nn on at attack tack upon every oV ry ono one bo be he high or low who has had anything to do with or been beon In any way associated with tho Investigation Q tho crime erlmo of ot Dee Dec 30 1005 1905 Senator Borah Dorah declared the state did not want convicted of at any crime for tor which Orchard or or loer or SImpkins or 01 anybody else eho woe IIa responsible and desired a u verdict ot oC guilty only If It tho evidence deemed to warrant such u n conclusion Tho senator denounced need Dar Darrows Darrows rows statement that the Jurors minds had been poisoned against the tho defend defendants defendant ants ant In 11 thin caso Nowhere ha ht de dc declared could a I fairer trial have havo been be n held than In Boise no defendant ever sat Rat In a courtroom where thero was wa a II greater for Cor nn absolutely Hal lIal and just trial Havo you men m heard anybody on tho streets Of t asking for the blood of ur William D Hay wood los of ot hili guilt 1 No and It Is to the tho ever everlasting lasting credit of ot the of ot Idaho that despite the fact that ono of our most distinguished dl citizens was foully murdered nowhere has ha there ben nu all outcry for anything but Justice and justice after an nn absolutely fair and Impartial You men know U It by h now I 1 think th world knows know It You 11 know It you lifted your hands hand to high heaven and took your oath Mth Of ot service and U It IB III till all that tho j asks of you OU In this Its It closing hour NOT NOI FIGHTING LA DOll Wo aro not here fighting organized d labor We Wo aro not hero here lighting thu tho weak or Of the th poor Neither we hero here hereto to consent that organized labor shall be a II shield to This Is not nol nn In Industrial war as 11 my eloquent friend of o otho tho defonso would have you believe bellevo We Vc are not arraying class ChIs against class or nr one phase of society against another This Is not a battle bf Of tho rich against the th poor r or tho poor against the rich Wo Yo aro hero In the th Interest of ot law III of ot Justice of at fairness That Is I all ull Senator Borah herc plunged directly Into the tho assassination aRR of Gov He lIe declared Orchard had planted n bomb as ri ho had donn mon times before Ho was wall an old and ex ox experienced criminal and that Inti he hc was as not In the commission of ot If H ho cried you ou stand nt tho gato of Frank broken and stained with hi IM own blood and It If from thelo you YOli follow tho devious del ways WIlYs of ot Harry Orchard you will find that thu trail of ot blood passes up the stairway In Denver up which Orchard ran that the curb below day da the darkey held his horse nt Tho defense would have you OU believe that notwithstanding what Moyer Moer mav mn have hav done what may have lone done what mn have done or what Orchard may have done Hay Haywood wood Is not guilty Iut tho law gen gentlemen tI n of ot the jury that when men I len knowingly Join together to commit a 0 crime tho act of otono ono Is the act of at the theother theother other no no matter whelo that other ma maDO bo DO at al the time of the commission of t the crime erline It 1 Is not an answer to our charge charlO for the attorneys for tor the thc do to tn pay Wo caro ro nothing for Jack lot him go overboard W care nothing for what may ma hae done wo will talk of him later Inter laterI InterI I tell you OU and I think the tho court wilt wll Instruct you yo that In a case of this character c tho acts of ot tha I nets acts ot tIle the unexplained let tern terl and telegrams grams of Petti Pettibone hone bone and 1111 Jack SimpkIns are arc tho tin un Explained letters l and telegrams of William D Haywood Tho only question here Is ni nR to tn whether or not tile the evidence has been heen adduced to satisfy you oU was wasa a u conspiracy Counsel for the defense has hns bald we wc havn not liol shown an nn In Inner ner circle or or ar organized ll ed bureau for Well ell I 1 could pretty nearly rest the proof of that proposition on the thear ar argument of ot Mr Ir Darrow Darrol himself AV F MS POWER The evidence In this case calle shows that thai somewhere In tho Western Federation of Miners there Is a n which con COli controlled trolled 11 power which commits crime it is proved OB as clearly as nil the fact that Frank is dead Take tho of ot April 1899 when the Iho members of at the Western Federation of at walked badly from their work organ organized with military precision went to and there blew ble up the tho Bunker Hill HIli Sullivan mill Mr Darrow tells you himself that tho miners went back next day to their work In III the mines Why did they Because they believed there thero was no such as ns law In and order In tho state of Idaho Oh no rio gentlemen of the jury this was waa not a n criminal act ad this was not the Western Federation of ot Miners What was U It Was Vas It an nn accident Jim Sh was killed Oh yes but ho was n a scab Darrow D tells teUs you The Tho Bunker Dunker Hill Hili mill was blown up lip Oh yes but It em employed 1 nonunion men Darrow says bay that whenever you OU get a thousand mon men to go an and 1 to do a n thing that ought to bo done That may bo the tho rule rulo In Chicago but It dORent go In Idaho DARROWS DOCTRINE Darrow has painted Harry Orchard to you ua M a veritable devil and I agree with him Senator Borah Dorah declared that Atty Darrow In his address to the jury had offered subtle Justification for even eel thing charged against the defense He set himself up Ul In defiance of at all 1111 the theIn laws In ws ot oc public decency If It tho doctrine that Darrow I preached to you OU bo be true I nm not n t surprised that these men committed 1 murder said Sen Senator ator Borah who then turned upon Atty Att Richardson and declared that If It Harry Orchard Is crazy it 11 Will was no compliment to one of ot tho greatest lawyers ra In the tho west we t that the manioc dill did not disclose any of his Insanity in a weeks cross crolls examination Tho counsel of at tho defense Bald I Senator Borah orah tell you that was caught fc In the act of at killing that ho confessed to 10 t at hiM own neck and that If It confessed the |
