| Show l r I THE CONSTITUTION j I I jilt alt It is Only Hero Here Hereto to Destroy the thet t Laws Made for the Benefit I Of the Poor I 1 A ROUNDLY ABUSED HAWLEY Declared Gor Go oi Sowed tho Seeds of or Store Strife Than AVns J Ever er Sown by b Any n Governor Boise Dolse July 24 Tho career cari of ot Frank Prank the th murdered I of ot Idaho was discussed at soma somo length I 1 bY y Clarence Darrow narrow this evening In Inthe n behalf ot or Wil WilHam the courso cours cOUt of ot O his plea In lam Ham D liny wood Justifying the ar at articles attickS tickS published In tho the Miners Maga tIne ZIne tha tM th organ of ot the Western I r ot Miners ilIa Ut Chicago law Iw lawyer Iyer yer said the action of In tt InI I asking for United States troops to riot and the establishment ot oe martial law In n 1889 was unjustifiable land anti nn had properly stirred up liP Intense Int ns feeling te lIng In labor circles against n tho tito thoI I governor I narrows argument unfinished to toI tonight I night developed Into Int nn an appeal for or la Ia laII Ibor br II as US against capital and a II d nuli l atlon of f all opposed ed to the unions He Hc held beld an audience startled and open openmouthed I mouthed ns nt ono OM after another the tho sen son poured from his hl lips Ills His at ut attack 9 tack on Ott Orchard was expected and the he limit of ot sensation Three Thrle hours I were given to Orchard and It Il was wa only when vituperation physical mice rOlee and anil anilI J I words worda were spent that Darrow turned Sir tr IC H U hawley ey the leading coun sel for tho the state and the tho Pinkerton for Cor or something on which to toI I pour the lesser volume of at abuse I The Tha state of ot Idaho came In tn for or n nI I large huga share or oi Mr Darrows tion for the part It has bar played In the ho hoI I prosecution Culture education and wealth each In their the I turn were vere da de e na ns constituting a II combination I against which the workingman the un unI uneducated uneducated I educated and the poor must janet bo ho op opI I posed DOSed j Darrow sneered at tho universities Ins as purveyors of culture I And what Is a cultured man ho 8 cried but a I cruel always e Headline the tho climax of ot his den un I elation ot of sympathy for fOl tho the working i classes and hatred for tar the rich rici he as us f sailed the tho Constitution of the country i and cried The Tho Constitution The Constitution f It Is Js hero here only to destroy the laws made mada f tor for the benefit of or the tho noor poor t Darrows defense efen e of ot labor unions 1 I and of union men was passionate and his eulogy of ot the tho Western Fedora redora Fedoration tion eloquent Lovingly he h touched on this the b of found In Ini inthe i the tha for humanity when only I tho the man Is II found and ana then with the bitterest his hill voice pitched Ilche to 10 Its highest note and arms F upraised ed he ho heaped upon the rich and upon tha the i tion of ot o the state of or o Idaho DARROWS S PLEA i When Clarence larence Darrow continued his hb I plea pica In defense defeno of or Hay Haywood wood at the eve ove ovet t fling session of the th court which opened at 6 p m in he resumed his arraign mont ment of ot and I The attorney begged the tho pardon of ot Jury for dwelling so long ong upon too tbd toor r character of ot Orchard but he said It U was wn necessary In order to point out Just what tort sort of ot man ama It was who was con can coni i Moyer Haywood and Petti Pettibone Pettibone bone hone so that the Jury ry might determine i whether It would bo be sate safe even oven to whip i a dog on such testimony as ns he hl gave much less Jess to hang a human being i Mr 11 Darrow described McFarland 1 as ns asla asa la n a lying deceitful scoundrel tho very life lito ot of a t detective he ho declared was wasI I living lie lieI I This man ama who has Ms spent his bitt life In hounding down his fellow man mAil lIu dell dellI lly I ly turns evangelist and would have havo you believe that Orchard Is miraculously I transformed Into a now new man Orchard tells Hells you ou how ho talked to lo him about CIng David St Paul and Kelly tt Bum Ilum quoted tho the Scrip Scriptures tur tures 8 In one breath and lied In the th I next Passing finally from his tirade upon Orchard and Mr Darrow Darrol began to discuss some of or the evidence In the tho case taking up tip the troubles In III Inthe Ithe the dAlene of at Idaho In InIS IS I when ho he declared that Go Steu f sowed cowed tho the needs of ot moro more strife land nn anti l struggle than was aver sown by b the tho governor ot any tiny state down pros pres ont eat time CONDEMNS COURSE COUnSE I There Thoro was no tOn Tor for It exclaimed the attorney When such sucha In a course Is he taken by b a 11 chief executive Of of n a state It U lit It high time that all nil should be submersed submerged and th only law nw be the tha law Ian ot of might There Thoro is no man living who can defend It 11 00 felt that What ho did was var the th only ho he could do I run am not hero horo to discuss dIscus him or his hh motives but I 1 know that both In Ins inside side s e and nd outside of ot labor unions In all 1111 walks ot of lire life there wore thosa thio who do dc and und always will denounce the tho acts l pf Vt t so long ns as we wo pro pre tend to have Ilave a n government by b law In In these United States Slates Defending the tho articles printed minted In tho the Minors Miners Magazine denouncing berg helg Darrow said they the were written by bv Kd Id Royce the first president ot thin tho Western Federation of or Miners lIners a i grad graduate tints ot of tho the smelters and not of or the tho col colleges colleges leges legos but an honest man an with tilt nil that and a r man who had a aright right to express his hili onest views of ot tho the unwarranted herding of or men In a n bull von pen sur surrounded surrounded rounded by lice Pinkerton 1 detectives and other vermin With flaring words the attorney pic pie pictured pIctured to the Jury the difference between the tho owners of the tho mines nn who toiled rolled up their wealth and bought their way WilY Ihlo the tho United States senate In Jr the blood of oC the tho men who worked for Or them nOd and tho the miners and ond smelter men who when their lays days ot of useful usefulness ness through ago age injury Injun or o disability vero over oer Were thrown out on the scrap heap to polish perish and die I would that thiat more honest smelter men Boyco Boyce that honest black blacksmiths smiths with nil all their crude crudo command of ot language were writing for the tho news newspapers newspapers newspapers papers today and that more newspaper newspapermen men mon of ot o the time lime were working as fiB black blacksmiths smiths DENOUNCED STATES STArES ATTORNEY Darrow denounced the states slates at attorneys attorneys t torne 8 for tor allowing William Dewey Dewe who testified for or the prosecution that he h b l took tolk part In the thin mob mel attack upon the Bunker Hill Hili and Sullivan mill to return reLur to Colorado unhindered after confessing to murder on n the witness stand Were Wro you asleep he ho demanded dem of ot orthe the attorneys turning to the counsel table where they were seated or was your witness lying hying Are Arc you honestly In III this prosecution or Is there here some damnable conspiracy to pick up the th president ot of the Western Fedora Federa Federation Fe ern tion of at Miners Minors and the tho secretary and treasurer of gf the Western Federation of Miners ners and hang han them by b the neck for tor the pleasure and benefit benent of ot the Mine Own Owners rs association There Thore gentle genUe gentlemen men inca of tho the jury you ou have hae the real strong Iron hand behind this prosecution tion thon The mine owners of Colorado are pulling the tho witcH to make flake you dance like puppets They The gathered these of officers of the Western Federation of at Miners up and sent them here to be tried and with Idaho to hold holli the tho hag bag Idaho has haa a line privilege in III this trial to pay for It And you men of or this Jury Jur will have hove the pleas pleasure ure uro of working to lo pay Jip up the dell deficiency clency warrants which have been Is Issued issued sued by the state to meet the expenses of ot tho the prosecution I Back of this prosecution 1 too you rOll will whit find Gen Wells the ad nd of ot o who ho brought these men here There he Is with his epaulets and his Harvard ac nc accent accent cent a n cruel cmel tyrant with nil all his cul cuI culture ture for that Is what culture Is for forto forto forto to get rid of all an the humanity there s B sIn BIn sIn In a II man Hero again Darrow reverted to Or Orchard Orchard Orchard chard and anel renewed the versatile de do denunciation which was wile ever at his hI tongues command Among other things he termed Orchard scornfully a II cherub and a it paragon of ot vir virtue virtue tue lue since his conversion When Mr Danow lato hate In the tho even evening evenIng ing big reached tho the Colorado o labor troubles he grew eloquent In his hh do de denunciation of capital and his defense of tho the He lie told of the tho law passed bv by b the tho th Cobra Colora Colorado do legislature In ip and the light against that law by the owners of ot tho the mines and the smelters WHAT WHAr ARE LAWS FOR FORThe They The took It to the supreme court ourt t and of course that court declared d It unconstitutional ho lIe exclaimed Of Ot course it fl I is unconstitutional to pass a II law taking away awny from train the helms the right to take tako 12 hours work workout workout workout out of or the hide ot of their workingmen Instead of eight What are constitutions constitutions constitutions for tor except to be bo used use for the tho rich and to destro laws made mado for tor tho the poor poet Gold is in stronger titan than the lie pen iten stronger titan than law What are laws for or If It the rich have havo to lo obey obe them themI I 1 am nm not here hero to lo say Imy to toOl you men that labor organizations do no wrong I 1 know kno them bent too loo well for Cot that They have hMO often done dOlle wrong they have dt of often ten tou been unjust and cor car corrupt rupt but hUl bu the tho labor Ibor hits baa always stood for the ItO lh noor toe for the tho weak sonk for Cor laws and for tor hu human satin man life and liberty Tho The men struck In Colorado for tor forthe tho the tiny day they got It Arc you men nien of or tho the Jury going to 10 hake It away from front them Mr Air hawley asks you to destroy the Iho ho Western Ted Fed l Fedoration ed oration of Miners Minns by hanging Un its load loaders loader ers er r Aro Are you to do It Doubt lost leeR they tho haVe haYo dupe done sonic some brutal things some BoUie criminal things and attil seine that Were ern not no wise willa anil und sonic some that thaI were not Just Lets admit It I know It and 1 I am not going to lie to in you about It II for tor 1 think too loo much of ot you rou Hut nUI admitting nil nfl this thIll would you destroy the Western Federation l of ot Miners and aUll hang Its H men or force fore bent to with the tho Mine Owners association with tho the if I 1 you destroy tho the la III labor hot bor unions of ot this country you ou destroy liberty when you ou strike the tho blow anti and will leave lelo tho the poor to do th v bidding of the tho rich Ilch richI I tell you men that so 80 long a nf athe as the employers of ot labor lab r have tho the spirit of In their hearts thor theN theNIs thoris Is U going to bo be trouble trobIe says the t o Western Federation Fed of ot Miners MinOrs has made trouble It I has and I am glad Of t It U for when wo vo Cease Censo to cause causo trou trouble ble wp ve become slaves The troops were vere called Into Cripple Creek because old man Stuart was beaten b ten up I X am inn sorry Jorry for the old man but ho admits he was working eight hours a it day living ore oft the fruits of ot what the tho union had worked for tor and was working when the tho union vas mS not aoL If U sonic some Western Federation man had hal been beaten benten up It U they had all nil been slugged and beaten Gov by Peabody would never nover have called out any un an troops OLD OID MAN STUART And when you ou men ot of this Jury think of ot old man Stuart think you ou also of tho the Darling of Colorado Wells fooling fOol hI If around the tho B Back k Buy Bay ot of Boston Doston anti and spending his hi golden plen plea plenty ty l Think of ot Wells the man anna who tied a CI worker to a at 11 telegraph pole poll In iii zero weather because he was not wringing ringing out of the tho victims carcasses all nih the tho golden guineas he ito would like to tu spend In Boston or In England Think you ot of Bulkeley Wells Vello and the others ethers o ot of his other Idlers whoso fatuIties families tam Illes arc are clothed In la silk sponged Ill with the lifes sacrifice of workingmen think of them 1 tell lell you and give Civil them some somo responsibility rosl In thu the events of Colo Cole rador radoY Continuing to the tha very close of his remarks for the tho day lay to berate and nud de tie denounce denounce tho the prosecution t Mr Darrow of the tho time when they the would be h loading lending forth their lh lr next victim vl to tho the sacrifice He Ite ever coupled the tho prosecution with tho the Mine Uno Owners as association association anti and spoke of ot the tho car carnival of ot crime crimI and auth destruction The Tho driven from flom Colorado to tho the four corners of ot the tho world had nil alt returned to Boise to give the tho lie to Orchard despite the fact tact that t they were well taking their lives liven In III their hands by coming coining within reach rench of ot tho the Iron man of ot tho the prosecution Darrow had begun a 11 detailed review of the tho evidence In the case as court adjourned at nt 9 I p m an until 9 3 a n m in to tomorrow tomorrow tomorrow morrow |
