Show STRONG ii oNO EfFORT 10 I L HAYWOOD Orchard Again on Stand and Hi His Evidence lC Admitted ed Against ja Defenses Protest 1 STORY TOFY VIGOROUSLY ATTACKS ATTACKED iI i 1 1 lr u i lor Ir III riT I i l of ut III JO O J j Iiii or flu U 1 u t its ji h lo h MM If Orpa J nine I Ida June in Tim pK llon I t he n murd r 1 flOI i off rr fI ml 11 in Jill of or It t most Important Iet r T t 0 t D H H y iwI Or 01 O fri J lor tor ur redirect eeL ct It Intro P lie 1 ami secured u ed tit tI ot of n i I rl letter to tn hn tInt that ITI j 1 d during the Ihl fall tull nf f when wn Vh n Or 01 o l 81 Yn he ill was win n ruse 1 on j crime for COI the federation n hull J PR tI m III I U a it 1 plan to Y rs Orchard the tb hc second I of ofU as to tI U tho Lb whereabouts of ot her 1111 l cr 1 u tI Iet of Qt proU tn tH from the thed IheI I d 1 IUie l en ll i was tR u Honed to t t Ul t eurl In the tho or of Hay fy HayS bl old lod him that Mrs Ir Orchard was WUI wi S viI L tn him hi n fol or I I tim ax III to lu Or h swore p a t he Ii Il proposed ITO that he lie should write vrUe Ills his a o ot of t letters Unit that were ere til to be Lie h fal cl dated 1111 delivered J In to toMm Mm Irl Orchard liy II of ut the f 1 Clr fr r rn n hili JJ Ho He JI vald that ho lid two let Itt tt he lie dated ut n II t ian 1 1 I r and il miLl Intel tJI QI h lalIh i who tIle tut feder feiler lillon IJ C Creek Orchard Men lil Id n l the two Iv w letters leHen and n II rill n d It aI H II of tho Iho defense Judge Wood tI them 1 swore that he hc It d third letter purporting In til t come COlli from frame Alaska and that lIt under tins that he hc had with Ih II II the tho federation teI erat Ion om iIa Marlon carried d the Ihl I iI letter l Ic U tt r to hi Nome t I o he ho wont went n OS r of C o the te fed rell ration fl I loll and posted ed It I t i letter id I ter bear the late data of Nome AUK f r l OZ va produced IU and anI admitted In 10 evidence AUA TO 10 WS then luau Identified a II which wood wrote ruLe to lu Ir Orchard end and that thai too waH admitted In III evidence and nn end endri J ri if handed 1 to In the thu Jury Jun it is I us follows i Denver Nov Nn IS lB 11 H Or Dear Madame null and Sister I f fI have I not lIot hoard a n word vord since silica J I sew saw yon t Wio hJ last 1 I t Information i sill gut was we liS from 1011 Alaska kil 1 I think Fairfield was wall we the l ot of the place I sew seu that awful prevail ninon the law lit IU and nd order artier lI r element yours oure very vary truly WILLIAM WILLI D HAYWOOD The three letters 1 written by b w ure re commonplace and contained COli tallied prue lively tl nl bearing on oil the tins ease all or Orchards testimony CI inference rence to 11 the tho arrangement which Orchard y he 1111 made With the tho federation aPI for ur the care can of his wife while ho he absent Tho Th e tho the letter tin Orchard story them I II when h It tb tha Wit wil sot lIt ut a Il L to but Orchard held h ld lo to thu story ho lie hoI 0 I M them The Thu witness s sI Ively I I denied that he hl unit had made an at IU for Cor the thu delivery of ot tin Un let letters letter ter to asmUs that ilia Ihu let lel letL tem lt L IH bi had hu only made e their thai r appearance it he oCt eft tin th stand last Ilist wiek lIc ot nt had Invented the story tiLary hl hIs hIli wife bad IlIo letter In her herlIs herI lIs He lie I Ia positively thu I i had rc 1 to write the thc Alun AItH hit 11 letter huer l and lind that and IorI know I of oZ the till H It wan WIlM a II day of and documentary ry evidence hl He K th I four San letters lillI the tho jt le the admission of ot a II ceru nl ot of the unsigned 11 letter which 0 got ot at lit Caldwell Jail J ll and Orchard was wa in lit the Ilia th hand I ug of rf c Li The rh letter lett in inae was ae as its follows I E I Dec CC av Tom ton Your letter lettel That waa V tC s to Jack Doc I ce ceI e eI Jl I for rOI fa r you rOil He lit I I a should hould se iii It II I t so cu hat I hato l lJ J ou o a III to lu I ii have hu It II by h this lihi time I In ic Wilt V Ill IllS S not hUt rUe any more this tine time Write me lilly 1 8 sane as ta you net get t to lu your OUI new III s Held It Tho rho letter was 1 it t Den Denver i ver tr 11 on all One lee SO tO tins the day duy till that I hell un tte h and it ad it in jj claimed cia l by bythe h bythe the that the Jack mentioned m J was n ii lid that the that re lu to 10 which he h tu 10 rut fur huh whim when he ite h AMI WILli V I a i Caldwell Calil w The he Klute developed J Its III ht to tu show a conspiracy and of lIt tins th wu without any 1111 is I ro IC r him hi III furnished urn is with a I lii oln o in inel Vel tI el Within u a few kw after hili It Ti first that Orchard U Ill after his bin sent I Jin iIi communication ci Jail and ii iii ami 1111 1 the Iho of oC the ho oC at o the lie I following foil ital hg U number phone a time I I ate 31 p I 1 m III 11 nine paid charge Hob Itoh Millet Miller tIC SaHli lull Inn S 3 1 ToT t a 1 Ho I I age an a iBi tiie 8 C ii ld Id IdI II I Ida 1 ii iA Ally t I P i hid will viI I marl for ir in III the thu M 5 6 59 Tim Ihn It Ii a 1 f II H ICil ii iti on tOI 11 thin subject t and it Iii Igei toil II I to 10 I 0 sItu t I g t hat ha tin I 1 hi It Ii liOn of lit f I Ii I a i w I h fl uni I ii et sd el tar for MX 1111 I I III is vI eve ei I mid a iii Whenever they jut got ot imo a to I I ni 1111 I IJ jc J tin I h Iti lent I I 1 I ii killed III m I P IC fur fI ui thiN liln 10 loss r fn of Ut a II iiii iI r t in III ii tin hin 1 tin III 1111 mi iI I h 11 I f fi ni I 11 d I u It d hut I In hi I s ui hi In lii III in Hie Un In Iii isi 1 i 1 i 1111 tIN l Hie JIb ti ii If The ihu de tie It iii tu I i i ii r by hy QI till tini lu iii Ihal li III hud hd Hot Hold Hol III tui I lii I in lh Hull l 4 1111 lieu hull it II n nd i aid uld lIn It liu 1 l Ii 1 n i linn iii up in ti I bus III tit I hi h hrCo me t I ii 1 bin I II ha i d I In to the statement that he hf had sold out otiL Th re was sliM a it long Ion contest over liver tIll Oil effort by hy the state Hall lo lu ii show how tint that the th confession lon ot of Steve dums had been voluntary It R man aged ged 10 to u bring brine out nut that Adams had once Hie tue th mutter matter freely tr I with Atty AU lawley and hilt but that thit was as about IlK ts s far fr ns os It tot gist the ourt sustaining u It series ot or objections from the tue do sic fells nile At A t the opening ot of the tue Ih ws lies I IS lon sion SIO the tile defense asked 1 Orchard a II ser Kero seres h es s or of Impeaching ii il They rhy hey all dill dealt with conversations In lu which It II recited his hili as tin Frank Vie Ilk heig and vowed sawed that he III ie would 1 kill killIm Im It Ir lie III Im hit need for tor l i II de tie III led J every I ery query both bolh specifically anti and V VEtt Ed Ett Hoyce Boyce onel president ot of the ot or Miners and anU now one 1 of ur O the tho th owners of CC the rich Her JIri rules 1111 after Orchard and WI still on ml the stand wll the th court tc e tor t or l the day ll He lie was called to 10 Identify hi en I I ry the lIl Miners ii Magazine us II ii the Iho lit a organ of cit It the federation and to It the tho nay WU for tor the use tIC ns evi evidence dence delict dell of ot a Ct great I number r fit Jt articles from rain tins the Ih The Tue he defense o was given Riven articles for tt examination tonight mid ii the I III It ii tow over Wel their admission will i II CIU tomorrow morning moral ATm OON SESSION S Orchard Ol was ns brought back hack tu to t tint tho wit wll witness it ness chair chIllI at ut IMS I 48 8 and the redirect Ic ex cx examination continued by J 1 H II He lie wa WIlS It l he hi h over OVel hUll hind Instructions from rout Moyer or tetti italiC lione us to what he Ite should do it IC ho lie gut ot laIn Into trouble Yes vs 1 5 J had replied Orchard They hll toU tolt me ml any lIW time Iliac I ot t Into Imo trouble nut 1111 lo to write writ rite or tHo U wire them Ih that they I he would send some blue one cue to Q look losik after mo lilt Mr Mi II next asked If It he lIe used n IJ ipa p pa it of oC the t samy lI h line d for or the tiit r bomb on the I or a r rd bomb bombI I h UNO liS the lilt lids line on this tho If i ml Icy but hm I 1 did ill J ui liS i n U p pull it ot SIC tilt ill lilt NII me line 1111 I I iii on Oil ill the tile id bomb I tiara from these details to toI Ihu ho Ih I penitentiary pen I after a ft I the Thu fhi fh a It C brought h up tI the IIII t iii Adams A siC lu lIlen In III IIII thu hg th I I ti Ut III IY ii lid asked Olt hard If I C CI It I I WitH was nut 1101 I IU ui u that t A taw saw some someone one clue before lie It saw sa w I cl ami be Iii before fore fill she Ad d inn IllS e any a lit C It to Iii tomate mate III Li Ic brought i I up U p the 1 hL Adams Adm mM Incident I t In I it him ii liti thai Ihal t I ho lit had 1151 cen an till attorney B torney named MistiLy tOIl The 11 is ii il Ill of nr n the I t of ot the he t stale lale ii ta Ic to 10 It n git 11 lilt ill tO any uny II flY statement St I mail made by lJ Adams to Orchard was by ty h both sides and tutu an 1111 objection by b the Willi alis overruled Orchard 11 4 ii it tOM saw SI un a t to some days N before hi I saw It Mcl arland lint and alter after lit hll hasit saw sit ii M ii b iii ho iii to tu mo 1113 titian about kIng a II COIl 35 fill fillI Here 1111 I i iri th I lie OLIg lit hard hall II 1 lii lo to I o pio plU vent I this til Ihl is I 1 I from Crom rain I ng out mil The Ih I of Ih I hi was WI by II on who I iIii 11 Unit I ha I thin lii Ihl I ii IVUN aits an 1111 effort lo to I ii In Iti l I the lit under tin Ihl I iii gui si 1 of or a n ii i III I lou Hk III null sa It It the lie I is was Willi tInt nut nuking St idi Iii j lo III I 0 Introduce Iii ii ec this I hi s IK fill a is the lilt I ii t ii ul ti 1 ili iii I nee 11 f a u u He 1 I Ia Mild that hilt they Ihl to o Kt It n a ment I I e by hy Adams lo lu I U Orchard ru If 1 C CIt li It should turn out that thin thil was a ti con tile the III state wan entitled lo to know a hit I duals had ii stud said t not 11 t under miller 1111 compulsion ot or sillY any kind I hl l ii Iii I H ii with had toads mude 11 a e confession ami then repudiated I III it Ii II 5 that It IlI under The rue desired simply to 10 show K ShOW by byth th tb that Ihal there wits was a It s num lO ONY VIm IlO W I AIA M S JUlI Wood ruled that tIle might Ill III 11 Il lit hi liow what IV 1 Adams ll It I i ild mi so Huhl Id ill n limit ii n hut but would not 1101 KO gO 11 1 Into lilt tin Ih I I is OIl Oll I n ii C III I mr uhl iii C rd ic ru that hul I 1 J would riot nol I Iii In iii Ina a 8 II hut hUI it sit I I lie hI it C I he itt malu n it 1 Cull Ct Iii C After ti I hIs conversation cli ii lid I ii you SOll 1111 ami ii i 11 1111 continue coOt I fl itS to In I II II 1 hitt tn cell ii lid did Im hi ii It with MM 0 utter after the thi will willi it ii re Ill ritual n kod MI Mf Mits 11 Yes ts sit sir he did Ihl Did you and II Adams l I a tos h I II vi I ii 1 con In II ii EMIl I loll with tIlt ii nh ui Hunt tOlli I li Ii ni ti 11 1 III C in I It the IIII I he I In i shortly at ty aft in your talk hll iii I Ic with i I I I s1 it III Yes es It sir 11 Was this r of ti the nile llImo con oon conI J I fossi Roni Into 1111 I it I I l I the Ih I Il four nur flU r of or uV u Ill continued I Mr lt II I Yo II sir and with l It th it you vou and 11 tOl ii it I II t I hi its h confession The 11 defense ill 10 ed tu 10 I ii ii 11 Si hl It hr vii till the I hi I it r id l of M i C this titis line 1 ills of oC o oCI I tit I m all hi h a court 1111 I Itch tied t Iti i sit tn Ifill ts I it ii iii t i I to 10 t n lle IIII I Its I hut hul unit 11 an 11 II III I II he hi Introduction I at roil lId ion of or the hl e Nil Mil IJ I rIle I II lei t I I I of at the lit t I t I Ifill In ii between 11 Adam 1 do 11 1111 III ni I ami a S JH II U f N i s o Orchard was al turned I urn til iier ii V In II fur the 11 lb a aI I I 1111 by Iy a nl inn 0 ic he s tilt ale of o 1 C bin I uN shill it in ill i II Jh i the h a mini wan W ns lS I lit 11 1 RI Ht RII t I is h Ill lii I It un C to lp show hoW itt t th I It 1 Iii wn not fold In III 1811 1 StI but was ti R simply 1 In to Orchard t d he lie hold had sold ihu 1111 Ih mine 1 titlE out In 1807 SUi I Sd you 01 Dave Contos that ym 11 had hll an nn Interest re t In Ole th mine who when 11 son II well out nut of It l the Coeur dAlene Y aI 11 No Ill lr I did not no Orchard nv nl J denit lit lie h had hadn n indr ado thu Ih sama to lit u II tago driver When I t was In Wallace h ItO 1005 1 O Ohr hr lie mill I ti 1 I met l Iii ami In ill a rl ta n said shil he lie Rive gli 1 me Tile I 01 0 flO as us ho had ss o owell well In ill the li flint nihil i wn losi Io tv lv iU u ulo tR tIM tIMI I lo 10 I 0 his hll with ii 1 11 lu lit l Ian kill g the t Its 4 lIt about tilt tile letters to 11 ll hIs wife t r mot In house liliuse or store In ill luly hll or 01 t oC or KiCio 1 1 lI 10 said Orchard Ilo I to Subi my II wife had hll been to 10 it huh him I T told him it I Ill to 10 II write I e to III I I nor her and ant ii tell lull her I I 1 had gent Kone to lo Mask Tills was prior to Aut 3 35 Have VI you wn eln Haywood since inc 1110 7 1 n IJ l on ono No Na o sir HI Yon 1111 Ii si it your Our ifo to deliver Joll Ivar I 1 r to If I the tho morn mole a ii year U ag agNo No 0 iti Jr t ii I ii I 1 dl 11 I ii tit know 0 II of cC tho Iho her until II some days ORO egi I n went IJ Into Iho tim conferences between 11 11 tnt Orchard Or tilt few Cew etc days Orchard liI said Hn Ihl let letters tiIS tn not shown to 10 hint him then or 01 dl tl Can you tell ill Io lit why h the letter lethal which you oll stud said yon 1111 told liny I wood loil tit to wilto In ill July Jul was not licit written until Nov it 0 17 I 7 shouted I 1 think I can All I dont clont think lifty wood Intended tn ta write writ at nt tile time little nit that my 1113 wife wrote Iol to him and he h did not reply until November answered Orchard Why h did clist 1 you tell h ind Pettibone that you had tile the theetter etter r to lo your wife ilfe to 10 Paddy haddy ind laid hud dated the tile letter from SaP San Ftc o oThe P The Tile reason K I Is said Orchard very that Illat my m wife unit had hl I told that If Ir site she knew t where whore I WitH wan Iho he would sooner See tieC ei rn In jaI then than lot know where I WItS was CUSTOM CUSTOr OF OJ TIO Changing to another subject Blob asked If It It Wits wax not nol and nl tIlls had not been een the custom of ol the lbs Western Fed Federation J or ot Miners to send s nil a n lawyer law er to Ii the he erton assistance of OC o their members liem bels lu Iii I trouble rouble I i iI I I know kint kl they lh have Ilone done so 80 You ct know dont you ou that ihal troubles trouble once from rain a I strike tho tue news nOI lay Jn It I to the Iho Western Fedora lon ot or Miners Z Object shouted Senator tile the tie newspapers are Ire tile the best hest evi evidence vl dence d 1 Cl The Tue worst worM drawled dra le 1 Clarence Dar Darlow Dardo Ilo do low my There hore was u it 1 pause sud stid suddenly denly said What I 1 ii thin tho name nam of ot your O daughter low 1101 living III In Canada 9 1 Orchards face tace tell fell fel and his hil Voice low Olive OUe lie IIA ht sold said almost In a whisper whimper flints all nl said Mil n ami the ilk tk wItness was ns remanded to 0 the til Ih lar larED lary r ED BOTI ON 0 THE STAND Kd Ed Boyce Byee fur for tUI many years rears president Western Federation ot or Miners IC sit if the was vas S the next witness Payee lloyce o ce testified lest et as aH to 10 the tIle manner r of cC organization or He lie le told lold lane how ow the t went vere en elected cl lIeu how hot the time secretary at nt nm vas lytis WIS not nol a ft I member of ot the executive hInl but hut when Haywood became see sec CC clary and treasurer under its as lS resident |