| Show OR HARU STANDS ORDEAL WELL ILL Counsel Failed to Make Him Con Contradict Himself But Showed Him in His True Light ONCE A RAILROAD DETECTIVE DET lii I tin Ut II for III JI I Il J mi 1111 HI I Various I ft Ue Ile UePa I Ae AeI Pa III III I I I 1 tru III S I lila Ida Junu llIn T j Counsel 1 for tr r lf 1 IX D 1 nUnc on till Hie tj If Or Ov Orchard chard at both Hin e ot uC o the 1111 trial tritt Unity t theIr t r t t ul on 1111 tile the with ItI the Ie In Ihu Vindicator and ending with till Jim he earlier hwn tho to the Ih lor t thu f i In l er To ri th the that traffic trank with 1111 thu the other Mile IIII In III the war IMI of or o olit labor lit und capital tn tu I In I u Colorado wait ws die 1 I creditable they tiey the succeeded III lu liiK 1111 tile the i r up U p the th e admission n II t ii t In It i direct ti I I ii that hut I lie h been cell lo 10 U his hI lIlls In Iii 1 Creep Cro by hy tipping ng off 11 a Il t traIn plot they lIll developed d t tin I Ii fact Ia t entered he the employ of I 1 IC D DC C who hUll luiU ot Ut the tIm run rail railway runnI way vay nI detective Orchard that with tilt Scott ic I t he III had met K J i 1 ig a do ii 1 e III in I employ of or the tile IIII 1 Iti own i 1 n t and thin l hll t I Scott had imUl pu hi his hili xi and 1111 na nIl him hi in lo I tL on tie Uio trip when t he hc had laid met mel lour tutu yUtI UP He I le said that tiati lie III had luul agreed to 10 report lo to Scots ett hut bill that thu t he was wun lying rig to tu him ii ii nc cr Intend I uI InS Ing I ng to 10 t o make makl to tu him Ii I tit and a lid lit never hId ilia make genuine to 10 hIm The alo III o tiled tu to holl that because he stood In with the IIII other othel side Or 01 Orchard chard was WaR never by IJ tho Iho mill tutu tin tia In Creek tinting during the Orchard Intimated that hat t Scott had lurid told him If t I the Lue Interfered 1 with him he lie to 10 sent tot for him lilun and that hint the never did Interfere with vILh him tutu or searah hili iu Orchard I that ho ItO went to IJ Scott first because he had not lint bean beun paid ald for his It us 1111 at lit U t the lie t Vindicator V mine mille ni I no and a he lit Will ii because U ho ItO was given hard work vork like the thc Vindicator Job while other men nien got guit ot the thu Ih Pimple I task of uC train Iraln wrecking by 1 i mil great and small verc vere added IL ded to Iu Orchards ils record today 10 Tim The Cripple Crook Creek with whom ho he committed bigamy 1 had three sons Orchard tIe tIeI I ore Are front from a messmate he lie stole tHole two IWo cases casos of or powder front torn the thuC Vin Vindicator hi mine lue 1 stole powder to make one tune of Vt the thc I he bombs hombs thrown Into the tho yin Vin coal I oal pile nIle The Iw defense endeavored In various arlous ways att to lu throw the shadow of 01 doubt and Improbability around the thu Vindi Vindicator calm cator story a d the alleged connection of W IV P I Ii Davis and William l wIll the anti thu circumstances under which Orchard he met Moyer and Haywood and was lIas paid for tor forthe forthe the commission C of ur a II crime and nual to Orchards story lit 01 that he lie was W S sent Kent hall hack III to I Creek with I tit unlimited U nil in I ted 11 cl and tj orders id firs to 10 commit any nn act of o violence tnt hi ho cared to They con fronted Orchard with J and nil Li lid Owney Own Barnes and paved the way WilY for lor forthe the contradiction by liy h them of or the story told toki by b Orchard Oll hard and iid fi times timeR dui lug Ing tho thi th day tin the way for contro his lilii testimony h on Oh material points Orchard stood tilt strain und test very well lyell and held het tenaciously to the tho h hue yesterday and the ilav III before Suddenly toward loard the tit close of oC the day the I In lit took look t up III ii tho the trip tn p I Imade made to southern Colorado with Moyer In the early part palt t of anti and showed showell that I Moyer loyer feared to go o south unguarded ed til 11 beci mine I oh rue o s thugs had beaten II up 1111 innocent men mell I ItCh and all a nil had ii t Iii for Orchard to aid III In protecting him 11 H 1 1 was Wa agreed that thal thuy should Iii I uit IIII cry cutoff en totT ii and sit lilt In lit the tho center of or the car cur so st S that If they we they could defend themselves Atty All In lit the witness made It very 1 clear that this had been bOell a per perfectly proposition free t Lee from any un taut fake Counsel oti use I up U p several timoR t I dur dul during ii ut ing iiii the tho day du and tiltil In the last hist passage at arms Prosecutor sola sold lieu Hint told n a falsehood when hu lie Intimated that was watt a I fixed wit witness ness lIess SESSION I 4 the Ih wild at tt ll the IIII afternoon sOI lolI on of tiC u court f Oil Urt i t Orchard iti wild that prior to tu L ii his hla it Itt marriage unit ruiNg In III I it Colorado he lived hIs ed at II t Johnny Nevilles house lunue at Ill Cripple t Croell lie I 1 k admitted taking some high grade ore oro from a II trunk and Lild It for fot 01 10 TIle The Johi Joh Thompson hud the ore orl After fItch reporting to h D 1 C Scott Scotta cohl ii a detective of or if the Florence Creek lIek railroad rut I a the th t Ii e attempt tent pi to wreck a i train said suld hu tie had seen the tile OI times Me lie denied that ho hu h was l it I nit lo I ci the t lie detective Or Orchard 0 chard haud iuliu nl said he lit hud haul been to 10 sue sel ec U D UC DC UC C Sterling St t rh ii g who Iw hut luul charge mit a re or ot tho e de tIe detective force of oC the Mule Mine Ine Owner HH tiN you ou Ml Scott Soll and Sterling that t hut I you mu wei wert e going to the tile ht heathi tiar t leia to LU tl gel Ul the Ihl luau lood T of ur the of If thil IIII oiB Ill 7 1 liMit HI 1 t helut l hll I 1 told coli I 1 was waR going tu to try tr r to 10 Ind Ii ad out t If lu lug about I y our lu tu Scott Who lio 1111 your In lii lien Den lienE vur Cl E I guI got III money you tell III I Scott l cott yon Oli were ri to out tutu about und and Yes Veil 11 I 1 old him him Hint hail I ha iii t t I he lit w i N 11 not lIot 11 b In I I U t nt lIl I t Oi I H v only our in ti December 1903 He lIe said he had laid tried to iv conceal the fact that he hf hot had been to 10 tosie o osee see sie St Scott and amI Sterling but told lold and anil Davis Dals of or the hue union tuitIon about aboul It whim they Got ot out OIl of jail Jull Orchard denied that he lif hUll hud given any Information concerning Moyer or and tutu said hf lie h was waR va lying to lo Scott when he promised to tn gel information for him Atty 1 tty Richardson again began to In Interrupt the tho replies H of ut u the witness wIttie to 10 some mime of or his luIN questions and tutU bloU out OUI It 11 protest train from the tho prosecution pro You iou lift the lid ltd without ex cx expecting what Whal Is beneath to conic come out taunted Senator Borah Bondi for lor the state Wh n I 1 lift the tho lid hut II I I want It II 1 to 10 to come out lson Thun Thull after M II i moment he ho added TUB nm LID AND THE ME MEI I know that Ihal this lid hUll hills been heen fixed up till for lou us and tl beneath th Is also up ur Atty All hawley was on Oil his feet In a Jiffy If you OU make a at statement like that he lie shouted to tu you Iu matte make a HIli thai ha absolutely 1 is i Proceed td gentlemen Called out Judge Wood Richardson did not reply relI to 3 h di r hilt but up lip the cross examination exit in I lat Orchard od that he lie went to Denver Dener In 1303 1903 on oti money supplied by IJ Detective Scott It was 1111 1 tile the list time lime he had met and Moyer loII lie He had hadnot hadnot not 1101 hear bear dor dOf ul u II to lo this time thune Haywood und anti Moyer told him hIm when hu he himself that they the thc hud hitch lieu h id idof of or Im hn I read lead an extract from trl Orchards testimony Jn of Th lh Ilie Interrupted him once to say ay lie la hu had something RIchard Null suii load again anti and nd Orchard Inserted IU one 1111 or UI two words which he hu said sahl the hal had left out Those words wore wIt ui under the th lid I 1 J tilt the attorney snarled at ll the witness I dont know anything about a II lid 11 I I 1 replied luLl Orchard 0 unperturbed u a tie I u Orchard wild 1111 hi he lie had never told lold Detectives Scott Sett and Starling any thing about the explosion In lii the III Vin hiu mine Richardson questioned the lime witness ls closely clo as Ill to to the Uw shaft ho he In III t a entering tort a the t he Vindicator VI ad Cur mini 01 1 till lie He Im ht II thought he went vent down No 11 J I I to III ii place limo Iho bomb bouni you say sa NO Iho tho Whiting shaft No Xo sir NIr NIrI II Has lias I as somo one told lold you OU since yes ell I hula i that Ih t ii i ln ie Is a II bulkhead 1 U I II which prevents entrance to time the mine mIlle by limo tha Whiting shaft 1 No 0 sir alt you seen Detective lePar since Inc ine I Yu Yes sir all sirAh Ah th h hn Iun called the nol How ling It JI ii g were wen you OU with WI Ii him himI lit tit 1 I saw stis him for 1110 01 or ten hm In lii Mr 11 i r 11 offIce toddy 1011 at noon Orchard 0 mu said lu hI tutu that I whim he Ii h a return returned 10 1 ii rim ed eel to 10 Crook Crek from Denver DenI ho lItO lItOn imported n lo to D 8 Scott ami tutu Ster HIr Sterling ling fin I I it g hilt but ho t did d tul not IlOt ii ot tell tel I them I about utti i ii t his hili Interview Iii with ivl t Ii Haywood I und and d At t this LoCi I and lay lIu 1 0 1 hall had ha ii toll toU toil 1 him ii I lit Orchard 0 ru said o I 1 to o UK get tot busy hils nt Il Cripple Crook Creot and a do tin iv lm h ho hl could cou that he lie so 10 0 too Ion fur iii for them Moyer lou gave III him 20 JO l fluid and I salil he hutS h cumulI could gut git gutmore more I ho hu wl U tl USo So l you 1111 I U wor Wc Vi Iu broke luk after art a tar I that H I I wan 1111 broke several I times I In hut but I I J Rill gui I mono every e lime I I I r asked for fur It II ItI I TWO tWi nO Orchard waN Willi next told 1011 to do Mn IIii of ut two Liva lw In pit pie Iii Creak h won 1101 OTI to tn bo Ia thrown Ii Itt I i tn tel 1111 I III Vindicator toi oal motul bins hili iI us ll ii S It II ii is 1111 Ill lii lit lie lol lii h till powder I from fromi Ill lit i man lilt I Charley He III I lo and o IM tho bombs Iti Itt Humes rim aa cabin ii Then Thon for a It second time Llama during tho tito day Orchard wax confronted with n it 1 witness for rOI the tilt l Humus WaR In 11 the WILO Lo told to lo up til Orchard looked 1001 01 nt lit him and incIte more nore without luL ui I raid the I I ic mi with Ii whom 1 made iii a tIme the Ih bombs lount unmaN II short holl henvy ct man luau with v Rim n a Iti igo mustache flu lI nellie gri it 11 ii 11 el ed and 1111 sut down Orchard said Molt i io 10 hud hilt told I het him to 10 II fake thew 11 ha Ihl ii I ci It U In lii cc I i tho I hi a ii ode i nt at the Interview with I Haywood I a ii d In I n D r Itu h KO go n a lien d ul mm It ul lo Jo lu Ihal t lit t he hI I o could cu 1 Id IIo I If lo mild Ill 11 he lie Jot gOt I i from flout loyer In lii GrIll Crip Cripple JIll ik Creel cel orchard mild Wilt in III December hl 1101 1 he hue Willi told hy luy anil Moyer 1 tr In I a turn I thing t hi In gui loose he could con I not RO 10 0 too loo to 10 ii suit stilt them tilt the th hl of eif C January ho he h h hn 1111 told to until some W I III of tit IC lite hI federation re mon mell under arrest arret In Cripple Creel Creek laid luid been tried 1111 So Ho tIn the th policy of uC tho C co lii tie le of uC two v WI w It asked n lcd II t was tt more immure than two lo woe re ro replied plied tIme the witness n I Orchard if It Holl lb I I Detective Scott html had not told him that the Ilma company lund Imd to tn stop tol u to train at a n certain curve III H and amid un aim at tot train to tIll tho AV tarn of or Minor lInor Orchard denied that Um h hw had ever heard hEIlI such a It lolY At t n it trial tm of train wrecker t Oi chard said ild he Ito heard ht one of or tho th testify that he tas ftH n tt of Ut tIlt the ind at atthe the lime lIttle limo a U or of tile the III Min Minors lIn ors lI ms union This Ihl mon maui was ivas Vf involved In tim thu 1 Ola lit Dl DI l Scott ever eter she give you y u ut passport tim h the military I I itu m linos I I No 0 sir aIr II lie 11 I Ia told mn inc If I ever elOI col Iol colIn cuL III In trouble te I t tm tho 1111 I hm Ii II ILIR to 10 I 0 let him 1 know 1110 j I I lid Did you ever tr have any mimmy nn trouble with the No 0 sir Did Dill Ih pIckel or sentries ever stop clef lOI you No 00 II Yon Yit wont where you ou You Yell 11 sir It IU you OU was never searched by the militia 1 No o lr 11 html But the time searching of or houses was va a very tr I 1 understood S ISO so o 1 PLOT 1 01 AGAINST SCABS returnIng to Cripple Creek In lii January liu ISO JOI Orchard said gave 1 hint several cans autos of ot dope or 01 Grecian fire enough to make four fotH our gallons HP lie was to throw It III In cars where shere scabs wore were riding and down mine shafts hurts Orchard said he lie burled the lope dope and never used It After hl hI his arrest onest In he lie told tol l Detective Detect lye about the tho and tu latter LHer ho lie heard hemd had dug clog it up lip Orchard would not admit that the till militia wai searching scotching each train at time the time Iliac he te took the thue dope into Inlo hub tho limO district You VOU luau had iio io fear of being searched Richardson suggested I t tried to keep 1 Op away from rom the tho sol aol soldiers diers as III much as lIS possible Orchard told of o Moyer sending to Cripple Creek Cree for Cor him soon SOOIl this tills Moyer 1011 wanted him hIm to 10 go so along ulong to 10 and to It Silverton where the rol Tol brIde miners who latch had been loen deported by b Gilt Bulkley Wells of the Colorado were vere e gathered Moyer told lold him that the tie mine owners thugs had threatened to 1 bent beat him up UI u If IC they caught him hIm outside Denver Orchard to 10 go along to help defend Moyer rOO In case ease or of attack Two guns were WIIO placed In tui their grips Moyer saying 1 the tile guns gunK would woul be h b good probe protection rotee tion In the time event ment ot or an aim attack Orchard said haul had itlo carried two pistols lit Moyer had the shotguns all nil ready when hen he lie reached Denver Nothing happened on Oil the trip to Ouray OUla and anut once there Moyer was busy husy with the thc minors miners Moyer eventually was arrested for or desecrating tIme the American flag having drawn dlIn pictures of the Hag dug and amid printed something on iii the tho stripes Orchard said he lie took the two sawed Hawed off shotguns hack to time the miners miner head heal headquarters quarters In III Denver they the re Ie remained until he got Rot them sonic some time Inter using one to kill Lyte Gregory Gregol with Richardson asked the tho witness if Ir h know as is a 0 matter of or net fact that thal Moyer still has possession of his gun und antI that It hud had never been b n fired Or 01 Orchard clairol chard said sal this might be bp so solie he said there were more than t two o of oC the guns gun gunal at itt headquarters It was vuis evident thumb that Orchards cross examination wits was wu not corn com completed when court adjourned until to lo tomorrow morrow morning at PIG To Tomorrow morrow being Saturday there will be he but Iamb one flume session oC or court COLORADO WIFE COMING CO n G Ci Crook Colo Cob June 7 Mrs Ida lila Toney Tone the woman whom hum Harry Orchard married In III Cripple Creek la ha laon 1 1 on oil lIar her way to Boise Boille to appear ns liS u a witness for the tIme defense According to Intimate friends ot or Mrs rs Toney Tono she will swear that at al the she married Orchard he ho claimed to lo be hi bea b ba a II |
