Deseret Evening News | 1907-04-03 | Page 7 | President Says That Harriman is Untruthful

Pr Says That Harriman is Untruthful His Statements Regarding L Fund to Carry Carr New York State Should be Character Characterized ter teri i by An Even Shorter and Mote Ugly Word Than d Magnate Comes Come Back Bick at Him Alton AIton B Parke Very Much Interested in n the C Controversy AinU nt floe I tb the 1 hi 1 lI h d this th tc hwO V IH ln by t I 0 oe New York rk In hi the part oC Je llO lit 11 hr 11 kiter the th s at the 01 Rose II eo ns JIl I a 3 oX ot to lie I u Uc t In ti I N St l Cot Cor h lit In 01 coHan at o IDO IOL lI the tI I nt l 11 ai I d lIter Ille aud Ih tight It hoult 1 1 by un en von 1011 word t I n hr Ir In If n I So the oi at 1001 Tile The prez denial dla w IIi Ili bie lt to IlI of o Nell V Th Ire re Oct S Int Oct 12 E W BC 3 The rhe Bt tor tl ll to Ic tb bei press 1113 I Ing ng After ACler the thee o cU to t r te that M n t not nt nade e tho thi cr him with lie as the ar In rr III hi th letter leller ot o now the deenS It proper the he h sent to mon lAst lait Oell cl 2 1 public tn In the letter r ereie h i te 10 a M Ir Harrl litrin nuil hr Ir wa re i t to th I lIt III which tEr Ir j said ild to lo laai Imy Iren Ien nil n U reason remson tot for hit his d ot of the tl felt to 10 thu tho Ind partly tile lIui that J Mr Ir to o I ella tor to o othe br nc Jil the to o to do lt It Jt it ap from the tho to lh that Mr r 1 gle tt t hr him tOI uI n a C for the c rhe president ay t also ul d to to 0 Mr tr De D Dev ev use thlu It Got by pleA JUR Interests Te 1113 aki 1111 ilo he Informed Mr tr te 10 did not I believe llIco jf 1 woula bi 11 lo 10 Dp hr nile kh e lit Ills a enIn that the the hi dol of ew rork wished th the uPP l i num her ber of them had written the place I be e to tr rr HyIe hr 11 WI hr 11 we n it nl l dId riot not wJ wish h to lo be as aa hIm TIu It IMI Un to o either eIber or M as allor und Imd Q left hl iii 10 II concerning tho com cent melCo ineice law laI U lion me end criticisms by b hr 1 e tiLe ho pr s course In III r ns cit ed In which lIlI ro to the FIRST IO Tue text toe cC flit e Letter to Mr Is l as a Oct Oat 1900 hv Iy Dear sherman Since J you Oll len mornIng i 1 ji Il hold o C the t 4 which j t rent erit tI n copy opy of at Go Coy dolra lIa letter 10 o me ot 01 Da 11 I 1901 At A I urn am willing ou letter Jetter to lo tr Mr UnITI man J f b JV by t Gu told IUD nio lie he 10 t 3 ou U on the last wok when yu OU went yent t tu t u k him lora tora n to the cui ruu m lie he with willi 11 In that HO ao loons tit J i at al the of f the party cr III it II d ly liy th the 1 p policies which 1 I Imil iiii h lie no It waa whether hearst or the D m or not 1101 lie a for his t d dice ice my to the railroads partly tho that after to ap Depew as nn to tol l Prance h 1 to ta do d It ond nii t I tood you to tc Bla say that he that I i mOte th this Is at t a 11 time Ime when ho bail COlitO doivo to Iti iea me In when I 1 sl hUn him to raise ralsa rr the tue rosI then lien on So Ed for or what Mr Ir I I I mo 1110 rl 31 3 tID l In hIs 1 t t MI Sh Fill RiU ro Iko the r r n MIl to t Wh 11 o hunt It Ie II J It wat well to lo eC Hear ha tt the J l J rou fn nya tho nl me hI he tol ot Oll thiat hi dId CUO hi 1 c tito llos popi copl W I l ho h could buy ud the I tir If OS In end In ii 0 burst or ba t temper hut but lt Jt In Inthe the opinion n i tn tnt which ho do de denounce jn Iii worl rhe second lotti ti ti Sherman simp I on n lo 10 the tho IN SAYS SYB HAmmI tU Anti Anil Lucli nt III l n Et tte ond It tics b oven l inor Cr II 1 ward Ia I i Mr tr to n tol dol doltar tar for tor the thO o oOn I I On tho Ike contrary QUI oUr C eni m as ll related to Q 11 io 0 tIght fight being macic Mr fo gOV I of Nel Yode Mr Im ian ImIn In in the f orr tt hE Thu tho nt it tuk on oil higgins e UI bis un an IJ t on n him Mt J and on hla hi friend Go Gay Odd IAna tuu II in was con cn In mo to t tell III hr to 10 till aIt Mr so I f fliS liS as ne he couI which I diLL ld Ho flo CE I noro Ioro thon urh flit to promise 1 lo Depow t l vIn 1110 tn in hi detail ho oOt why would Go GoV Odell bi big bb I I him i 1 not Ot b It be pO 1 for fOI me t I O t Mr and 0 11 n o 01 his lh men seating th the big or of Now York orl that made mac lh IV n a oX 01 lh m hail hll to io U tim plait be gIven n tC lo n de una thu that t os IU it ef c J i wise hot J to ui E doubted whether j 1 either Ither Mr Os or Olt Mr H to tl the 13 Afoon As ee I M Mr Mr tr VIV IJ a itI tb the tie o ILl Ite that he not wish tt It Itlie Lit lie JI i tr rr and be qui to willing W arit J I he 0 still Fr r h left me inc wider lufer the that he would 1 io Ij eatie lied with hr r Hyde hIde wits mitch nt It mY him so mot bUt that t r lid lIll hOt lIot think I b Q able LQ either ills antt Ill my now mt me ot Or th tsU of 1904 tar is IANs cI FER FERIn a In Cit his rI return front the Europe I era n SePt iO O ho he w wrote te teM mite M thit U IC I t 11 t able abic lie be W COI come to o see C me inc Itt at AnY an antime time mt either thea or OJ Il later ter On Sept 23 I answered his letter saying emit is for tor me to teu you about though Iere ere one or 1 two In 10 tny my letter of aC Dec which I would IlMo liked d to 1 with oU rutting putting It out OUI outOn On October Er t him himIn himI I In Jew 01 0 the river Iwer the ticket in NeW Noc York I like to have n row words with you Do oi think you cen jet et down hire withIn n t tow ay and take tak either lunch or ar dia eta The Th t I or refer oce nce to the bolt is lii reality hr Ir anti Mr ns Coy Oden A 1 1 lo the liles of th the New eN York Toxic p n ut t time will sho elton tho I It was a 11 very 10 bolt belt n hr Ir on tho Gov Odell had nod liD lie had In so some 11 0 hr lr man mall rouin In my being mable ili mans backing or of Od anti 1 cx cic trenie that he by b securing Higie fa a tt tI of In all Ule th Japers In the X York orl Sun Ott Oct t 12 Mr ii ruto roto me 1110 meI I 1 un AITI a tory ery part of time the trouble hero here and Intent to do so o It if y on oms my ciu be r sake the tho first ot C east week Neek to run rite down donti to ee OU Int thInk by conditions m hn hai 10 1 Limo II J W which I 1 iso full cull ht DIMIt MIt m m rAN I Oct 1 1 19 1904 1 try Ey Dear Mr tianA has come ome to me in J roundabout YOU do not riol thInk It wl vIse to La e come anti se eca m tn ii o closIng o the tho campaign but that YOU arc tru reluctant to 10 IU ite I III Mke you ou Now my dear sIr you and 1 1 ur aro nice men and au arC upon the anti the betler titan J I ilo ho It ir yoU think there Is tiny ut ot your to tue me trouble or U YOU theme Iro is II lR J 3 should hould be In or no matter In Il t Hh iivo aid Bla Of oe up lie 1110 for tor tue limo IJ being and thou Ihen a fet we ks hUc bolero r I I my Y t I shall shull you to tl Come to IA certain nt to with You ou will ac eec his JI I lter was o sri iii tiny ry 17 that J Mr Ir ti corl down own nd Bel ce me itla In my own or intended J to maim coy row ro of at any kind ot of hili help r from him Op 01 the contrary all 1 wits ont with In him was o know j r f ht bo be ot of hell lit III M the ho ue u Mt tt mull mun Jar for r F the 1 Would ho bo In n ha huts ben bc n Is fa I ci OY the HII that Iho t tr r iii lIot iio Ju itt late hIli mind r e it t collect any money unil that all on th the Whet JI Jia was tins concerned In wu his connectIon with lilY loiter to ie him WILS wIl L L ICI a the Iho hint I would like to lie Hue hIm r 1 tn 1 discuss ov matter hot 1101 the tho lila letter whIch is ot oe No Na J I DrOll Deti I lr r have boil iI iII it I t tali wills Ir r 1101 him Ii h iC J OU a J z Ir w his hili to lo tiLe lASt iati of It your l to mo I Oct H 4 rj tutu or of call course 10 I tilL tl net to lo ml meho l It a trip I it 1 II ho lec that thu hu liil t L Or Ir which 1 i had iti ll if r w 11 t he bu rei referred to iti tut t lii Iii IC 11 ittu 41 11 I ner tet oiti tutU of at the hO II III I II tren In th west tO the 1110 liP up tINI hll have WitH lIt 10 0 luu s IiO 11 I sei h Its pit lm stu I I iii 1111 J 1 mi r IJ bp it t 4 lilt ii h h part ort of the iD n could be t to lo nU inn I hono hoim 1 lic do cio ao I IllI It Il l ha o eo for alt itil thai no h to tIle Ule and In iii It II rn ll r r ll to In Hitch Fluch it I wit tt tI not qt bout n It 1 Jo U Its well veil tIt th o ei t tn n anil the ono cue OIL en we 0 II r I which II hi t t s heard tr from m This lottor to cn ll h which reads tiN laa L LN I N Nov 31 30 hr II LII LOCh II tells utu ml lcm c called mo 1110 loUt un on 1111 Ii mid J my I letter to 10 oU U or of Oct U In Iii which I 3 to uti ou r f 1 is isto 11 1110 to 10 ie j you to In pty my MI III as I 1 to lo a u wIth yea ou antI flud oiL Oll th t that hat I 1 r 1 sn H th thI the I t lh thai you titis and h d J I had Jett It Jut In irttie 10 1011 J i II lied lid in tW certain with nod hu 1111 pot not of If discussing mOot mat mattee tee with yen H Jt i H t oc to me mc t I hate been hlen iJo t d so go bitt IC yen OU W were JN down dawn lI here re both oth you roil 11 were Yero io o lii ot the V polItical that lIml J i If It all touch touched ell un mentaL As lit In 1 lu I tc 10 what I 1 had In my about the commerce corn com while I May ay r I beciL dell to irO go OUI Jt it with you i elso must Ell su m my mind Will was up UI Lain 1 tl with the of at Ih beef trust caused me melo lo 10 write the tha paragraphs In m I 1 with e tr care cei lh thu In In oC r the Inter omm re writing H ft I 1 then went Oler oer the writ ten and wi with orton tchi Is 18 of tilt Illy cabi cabinet cabinet net tit iliC e toen most r with road read matters of 01 course und ond with Hoot l nol Tuft nd Mood heady It t 1 iti 1 11 matter L had been Jill ILg tor Oi two and had I coma to tILe the conclusion that It If I un unwise wise nail for Car inn 1110 to leave tue ef rebates s where It hi 11 no now to 10 fell to II thu interstate tot merco commission n power ot 01 otan an 1311 1 hintS In J rates L me repeat that 1 I did riot not title question In mind wILen I 1 l you to coma omo down but J I should most gladly base talked It ever oyer with you OU if IC It hat to itie 1110 Lu lo do to BO hut but n nit it 11 matter of f when ihen ou lilt did conic down dOWIl to tile yeti nail ond J I siero ero both so engaged in the tue ew York political that wo we ot of little eLne and ami that the I have bavo taken takeI lies lias not been beull but titter thinking ever matter clatter nad lookIng at It II from Cram different tor Ci Ia least t two 1105 the most careful with 1111 Morton Taft hood M 1 J nox and ft Ot a II to 10 th the exact I 1 site 1 I dl not send end ou u 1 it copy opy because they mare gh ell no one a cop CON CONnot not oven vell the moo men above boYe it 11 hi 18 impossIble It If 1 I go out envies cOllies ot of any tny o of ray OIl moR a c to 10 prevent time Int belli known In itt asil the three prose 1 who now the tl II 1 III Ly riot to d disclose l e 10 n C wo rd rdo o of It before the thc time 01 Dee J ito he Jill inn the tho follow In totter on tile Site sante B NAT U I Dee Dec IDD Mr Thank you fos Coa Our fever of at Ilie 4 ll j 1 WIlS sias nu for Ol inc to 10 hn Juhl be inched roa In Li It you and I 1111 t have lIwe before w writing rl haur ur AJI J I JArn ate Arn of t th tile tituS en 1111 effectIve commission the Of M r rebates ned th prevent the ony of oe 1111 oat ouO an ou sit sa Push Morton Marton II mure mitre with tacit illch a an 11 of r IIii of at your 1111 r i 11 Ie 10 II lift 1 me nc In n this I fear thoro thero Iia been is 1 leek nok oe C During the pus tI meat of 01 the rou four r the lime found Jt it ver ry hard to hI 1 nap P I will tt Site tho I s Upon them tutu the tue 1 Uti as well ell RH been devoted it o n dl antl the arid fir Cf theIr se III its lIS tl ti the arid 11 bettor of them This of 01 helter huh insist t Uti io rut no Jt i 1111 hI important proper r tI lit ut It iii II t II at tilt country jt is bIle doubt lt Iho rW sin ii III lisa tho 1111 1111 to 10 IJ be ti bie ti ud 11 pi rOt for d ler and tacUI UtI tirs tit 1111 rilly I hiS hll I Will t to 10 thetis bit t to Hit HII Q Ui whole I bl beg t hilt ou will tn nr hot Jol sit alft L I 1111 to tl lt t Cd tr for or t 1 inv to It Ii mr It nie 1111 I wait lIUI to with Mr 11 iet ot of th matter left lett 1 t ns Cs till late latet t LIt draft or of thIs pet tI I Ion of 1 thc d In Oc c O Q tho I 1 Ju d I wn ways with 1111 11 nn nih Nl In the labor iI I ii h ot of tue big r Iii fill I well na CIS with tile Ihl of labor tabu of e SilO r cJ III II U lii III iI he I hint Is 10 h 1111 ii tract and 11 1 come with Mr Air tir MI ti nat oIlier raIlroad islet pa 19 i lULl seen with Mi 11 U hir Jf Keefe re Ir 1101 l rut tiia tHO I N tl JI r I IL like hIke moat r th iii hi bIg IS t toil tile Ille vcr ci roe gi rig t itt ni tt conre oi 01 sian I m control nier Ier bl bk VII the hI bi itt III a 0 H letter of r Ills til o 01 tug lg 1 ii 1 ti z for ILl l lh Cear 1 f Wl Y my osell tic m r II will be tILt mr cor lii Is In wIth what ir non 1101 as iU Inform n me e os nit to tn mY iii him t to mona or to cub lub for She pr latil 1 js fOr the P limiter r he it professed to b be In Inthe Intile tile the of nr oem 1 Guy Odeli hiatt that hs 11 I p w ho bo tie tm to tn J lit at ri n time when lie III W wie f OV l fur Iw tI I ti 11 after the Ibe iet lotte to tito J lr f and nil Dic 10 ho 10 WI wroL 11 pie thY lather lutze I 1 e r reida In III Oil 1111 FOR rnA CE I tM M Mr dr A Claris of Ie your veer her In t b be ter much It If lud It to Mr H 11 B Je I as II to III 81 re IS to him l lX X ills n Mo IO s would be of the tho of er fetI ork lOlli e b In the I ha f hI to 0 he be lists hos 1 hIm J I nn citi SurO UI the approval of oC r tad Dep ice tat till its I 1 Petit for lor the Ow r a Ill I 1 be lev lit hl be without 1111 morn morl uny be front New Tork lit its I Ith th tIle time t ly 1 I 1 cUr Of thIs hIs Illmo else eisa you II lo dc toa JIll Cm I r f you to MO le I t theIl lie he Ind to collie tJ 11 talk with willi ou about It hut j I there in ire I are N eloite to o you I ho feel just ts II I III ani t r that this would Jo be ail na hohl the lUI tt of tIle the 1 J upon title tills important appoint mert mertH H Im N OT JT J PEnSON te yin I was to the n Of 01 the th l New claret of till ItO of at the 1111 unit 1 t tue elI It pI pel la o Bt ont Mr to lo the tha thaP I P lie he sO MUCh FOIL FOlt m So mUch rill Mr raid me Fur mOl Ct LiO 10 the s mine i remarks IU LU U ou Of as you Inform me mc you U itha 1110 him Jt it ho he thought Jt it w itch JI to en 0 Sin lu nut the like In O I the party part Yost that lie he told lole you von liitt lie Ill not care in III the least because people crooks nail hi lu tile them II ha Cram n a state he COil moult 11 1 1 It Ii he coulot COIl Cois tutu that lie hI buy the mIssy This was said Ia hurt parI I iT III boastful cynicism and In U a burst of 01 bOil bl temper of Ills his oh ob to the interstate commerce commeree law nw anti to Ill nations us as pro president nut It n It c cynicIsm rm a which mak time man itan utter In ml On boastIng Dt at lIe III il a citizen itt I b bor or cit Moyer or It Is Ij inee wo we capable ot or tuch Gild mu capable of t all 01 that there Is strength f of the ilin corruption Is anti and the tho em who lu hi thu I iree ress or thic In or r out of at tI tIlice of lice clOse class against class rind to bitted Of 01 tue human S soul UI aro io rUll lire arc eC of oe tile republic t I WIlU IS em wise not when you OU told II sit lied sold to YOU An I say a It JOI kneel I hint nrc lJ welcome to show hint thIs letter It must be mole nubile unless b by some seine of at public pulley olle only after lily n has hilI bren yours vours Til Tho Jho lIon J C 5 Sherman St Jaina building New York Tue J letter leller to Mr Ir Is OH follows White House Oct Ocl ii 19 11 I iy hr 11 I 1 like lJ t an lI to my ms to yell of r the lie oIlier Mr Car Cor lelou nod tr Hits its Boon Cs th JI r J itanhi Itati heit tn lor t d to tl 11 tue till nl Im ot RESPONSE iII ew A E 8 ii H hate out It