Show ARGUMENT IN INTHE INTHE THE SMOOT CASE Senator Hopkins Makes Brilliant One in iii Behalf of the Utah Senator ON CONSTITUTIONAL GROUNDS A lI has tilt Ihl flight tl to of f of Is Its t the News New Wa D C lute heun waiting oel ever the senate today to get el UI an oP opportunity t to address the Henat un on the case hut but It Is probable that lie he will 1 hAVe a chance before time the adjourns to today a wi will thus thu open lt for isis his defense still intends to cOM close the argument 11 Iii to the ito report of time the und there wl lie be I IL of oC fUW speeches Senator Hopkins the 10 aCel after 2 une began thi thu argument on tilL tho constitutional tolls involved In t thu h Smoot case Tile ho gist of his lai at opening II is th that t tI I ii has urea held that ti n sUlu It itself lel self had thc tho solo right night tn ii Jule judge o of the tho ot It Itts senators Ind and to lo uphold hil his conten that states alone have that right This position Ito ho vas nR up imp upheld held 1 by the convention In spite of the oppoSite view advocated by tt Neither the Constitution nor time the Iu may he held give the th right to 10 the action of ute In deciding upon the Uon ot of properly elected senators The ho clause giving each house n a right to tojU jU juge e the or of I a member Ii me tenth Cers to age and lIe He from time tho l e and Alexander to show that tho t his blA construction Is right and declared that that CI con construction iaus nl beep been sustained by states court ns as well al as the supreme court of th the United States |