Show SOME tile All cincy gives ills I 1 1 arg ardan their appointment tit an exchange 6 sieg 6 that ou oil UK the ulli ol of slay jy ISS I 1 i t C I 1 s cailton Oll Ca llon ilion and addre c cd al tile seere secretary tary ol of the interior a cettei finlo glo ill liliu alic in ill view odthe 0 alic approaching As election whether certain wrt ain territorial 4 tie a I 1 I 1 1 I IQ lilly t I 1 ay iy I 1 lie elected bythe by aliu or by the governor the olli ecra slie aro are the ills superintendent of 0 schools auditor nt n publio accounts allol to locate university the lit in their letter lite plo piu and con colt unil final refer to the laws echea u cicil oil by tile govel Gov Linor nor to lo ills N aey of 0 tile rate case and by bv the it lu sustain t heirs ill iii deply they have le celled tile collow i us letter ii urn the attorney general getice al or tw r issa I 1 L Q y V lamar Ss ecret ni y of the interior silt 1 I it at the lie listati cn ut of I 1 the lie utah cuin cill the 11 II 11 1 L 31 willow ackim secretary of 0 life interior lit in a letter the icil n liuio iny opinion upon the following question whether earsin in utah Lt ili it alue nii of 0 ln ills liitt schools auditor ol of bublic accounts Tica surer full anil to luicile li icile baudil should be up lip pol pointed bulf ed by the gohei nor A ilia lite lugi nt ot of the icci le illative council or oi chosen by the teopil e at their genci ill election for convenience so go minli amith of 0 ll 11 alie ile question 1 as I 1 elittea to lo tile llie will 1 I sq bv bat feair bitely as ai the appoint or election ol of ollic eig appears to be controlled by a islon not applicable tho etherd upon 1011 of 0 the statute sti enacted by tin tilt it appears unit elliot tho the auditor and tire lire thereby requited to tobe be elected blenia lly lit at the general election by ilia qualified voters volora ot of the ilea I 1 atory see sec co colip ill laws ol of utah 1870 1876 1 p act aclei of fell rab 22 1873 clial I 1 11 1 lows laws ol of am 1 e ll 11 27 the 01 bulc law i however we bee sen see lion 7 ot of tile the act of congress of sept ept do 0 1830 map 51 dec I 1 laica ales that atile alic governor er beall humiliate and by and niah illi tile lie advice find consent of tile e council appoint nil all off ivers not herein c provi provided provid td tor for anil and as the ali ollices 8 jast il ale otherwise uther wise lor for a klinect condlee conil lct exists between W baill lilt H of the ten leg jeg asi iture above referred tu to anti and the hie or r finlo inlo law liaw the of 0 ule dav join acri atory takes elie place glicr 0 it a i tile lie fileda t i i af ait tile hie aoi 11 govern it t Is obligatory vit oil fail WIN ilia hie 1 I ferlito lial K S nat R ink vs vf bounty of il lot V L S 31 A any I 1 y let jf 1 it ile ihu allt nl lt alil Legi legislature Ip Milino lature iteus 11 c 1 civish antl at lie be hell hali void 1 erris vit v ill icy 2 Q Cong ilia may YN v wake male a vold vid wot net of u wall ibn teri it orail vald vill ij and it valid hl U S S I 1 supra but tor for the ibe at power isom a I 1 I 1 act on oil lu IIA piert linvin lenvi flail ill it effect be certainly gothing call chii lie be implied tit in favor of validity bt bf il A territorial statute alch ar un an provision ol of the elie org ceranic nnie law ot of the territory fr froni alio 11 mere fact that congress liis has not dis sp it it it follows thit that the statutes of utah in ill to so tarns faras they abo v tile lupei intend cut of olf ti let school auditor of ellb lie ile accounts and treasurer of 0 lite tei rl lory to tile be eleca being contrary to the provisions provision 0 alio llio organic 1111 lord ford mentioned lire A nullity flud and ill lint it those should bo be appointed lit in conformity for fulty to ill that A allar b by the supreme ii oart luvurt ot of that territory in ill re to moo by nn nil act ot of the legislature ul of alie territory for i nna na enquired I 1 equI red to lo lie 10 alc t ed by a joint vote ot if tile both rile court lidil held tile the net to bo be willi 1110 of the organic law abolia adver teil 10 and therefore void sec gee ali libonn etc CEO I 1 utah rep hep 81 81 lit in tu to tile these offie drs at me c by the te ari ilot it sti statute tute rc inbred tv tu bo be elected anu anut ully tally by the qualified N oteria sit at tho the general election Col callip lip iltis of 1670 1870 p 1 ily hy the lie yd section of tile the jet act ot ili cou gress of feb 21 1855 chap it cor lain lity ot of lanil wo wn rc redl it arved for or 0 glov 0 O be salt under tile du cation odthe 0 thu IC beg isla turo etc ilie ot tile provided for 16 the selection ol of this must by luZ it a board of cant io 10 roii lt tit 0 three licit incisi elected us s boic boid ii il itron such bond bolli lie I 1 lot of file allio illio it lit eliat it the ile milli ill le ril lattire iii uy y arille of nl ibid jet ift wits willi ahi till nil arr ele iiii 1110 ww lanil in of r uie laud fit loading the he anent ot of tile agency ly by v mull tecc I 1 tion aoi to bo be it wig wag at lib city antto to avi olye the duty of ill i oil al ivAll ci emed br it I 1 ishoi i lie hie t in en t of 0 tor for that pill il disc be by y such off lecis or of ta by the covet n or or o provide alc tlc e tot for carrying its will upon the subject into effect the lit in question file 1110 not to be as mathin tile the opera operation flon ot of the above mentioned provi provision gion of the organic law full aud their election in ili the manner prescribed liy by tile la Is proper I 1 ani q ir fr varv A 11 CARI akil aidi attorney Atlo rury general i |