Show butlers Butle erB rc stolen fee the late lion joseph Q lloyt for or ink merly e aly of boston noa loii when a lad attended a circus and hla his silver watch was stolen the supposed thief was waa ar rested and was defended by benja min P F butler who he did inot not take the watch and never wai at the circus during the civil war hoyt was m I 1 in trod produced to butler at a dinner at the astor house in now new yolk mad aad the tha latter remarked this la Is the first time I 1 have had the pleasure of meet ing 3 sou ou oh not nol said hoyt who then related the circus incident WM was that yiu lloyt hoyta asked but ler for and being answered in the at af formative firmat firma lve tive butler laughed and sald eald 1 I hat was vas an awful good watch hoyt that to is all I 1 got for defending the thief |