Show J I J d For Tle King icing IlIa in hi inI rM I S Scathing Tue TM of the Al Case Casa Will IVill Soon Go Ic 10 The 7 session In tIO tho CI I of O the morning bY the thu ar up P s V hn cOle case Frank Dt of c by byj 1 P He was U j 1 tte be defense efre h iD 1111 hlll to a address d I I re ret 4 bIJ yote t he W unable to to tort t t j rr lBs HIs If rt arni lie he great and of I n nr lon on th from hl iI and r life r the olgar olar bOw gW h i t rl of 10 or 12 years thO th lg Ll tu bt at UBe whiRleY tY and al alJ d l to until t nit all absinthe ot J ort nd of 19 rea tho th bed It upon hIs Ilea lY i the nt ot Of Oft mem and In 1 a the lIe u a t killed n a man le he j 11 ot Of nil alt U those ose facts vie that It In n fl 1 the thu boy wall salle aY that 1 the crime und and was 1 he be I for hl hI E arguments yesterday 10 i Blown the Senator with child of defendant ot of the theOf hO bl when tb t mother became of L 1 e and liquor anti antiL of cigarettes the use U II of his the use L pursued by ciui i until he Wa lie toM told liS rJ ot of various upon the young woman loved as a 0 sister and I bc I by thu of the y had brooded oer It and w ui bO b he his already I upon mIt 1 It Itt h brats brain until In a moment ot of te be took the tho life of oC the man tto no hd hal attempted the Insult to his He a the jury II 13 the sanctity Of f their own and deal with this boy accord DISTRICT ATTORNEY In the of his Senne iena tor or Brown the dis for jor assailing the charae t it r ot of CoL Kaighn and Miss Coates and lot tor intimating that their stories teet eze and for the of f do de I lie Ife Biso severely arraigned police force for attempting to wring I a from the bo boy rn In closing to 11 the Jury to pa e In the same posItion In which d defend ct uti m placed on the night of the at t td mault and then decide e what do o under such 1 It lie asked them to he true to the kund true to their h hurts In ren render er Jr HOFFMAN FOR Fon TIlE DEFENSE Huffman next ad hued the jury ot on behalf ot of the tie lie lieb b lie had ha a 11 detailed t tnt on the tho testimony introduced e trial but before ho he concluded t I adjourned until this morning rin the opening of court this morn tr r Hoffman resumed hits hIs I tt t I In n speaking pea k Ing of at the actions ot of I nt on the da day of the shooting I Ii nI that nil all the witnesses had e that he was under the r or D a drug anti that i tInt Into the hardware tor Mr r rITer r ITer th the e clerk who sold old him hini tho the fautt t bae known that he ha as In I other saw the bo boy r ih aati td his hIis wild look looka a to hunt up sonic excuse a Ulf 1 itching the boy rit ru The th declared that ies te on was also and made i 10 kr t the for convIcting BARnETTS TESTIMONY ONY 1 Hoff then from the c of Ir r testimony On O Ot t 1 hearing in III whIch wit I t th 1 he e con the ho boy d r when hen ho siw BW him nt at teh th that da II and he must 1 teen rr for or his actions J e fr or the state said man In j referring to the le leI tee I 57 7 1 of 11 3 tates sya 88 tl that I II her ler lert I r It If t I story ii 11 ta t tn r p D Dennis 1 how I r ear r t that wound Yo u upon tIann Is evidence If rou br be I In 1 a verdict ot of guilty Lt fA this with will open the Va 11 dI II t men to come lucre here herer I n e ei r 1 U Im ri n ed hIs argument II by i lines lieS of the poem t tA R 1 S A t tt t conr a 1 of Mr n se King ing spoke In behalf p e In III q sorry 14 1 t I this 1 R has haR not nol nota t 1 j n a h a air and h ta lit a II have hae h bean tn I Irk rk duty of f the 7 Is lQ r c n all t the 11 eat t brin out the facts In the theto i to tb or h Why not Mr Ir Ire ft e 0 r Dat n a Wh did hun not 1101 ca l Mr Mr lien lIan shau ouch amI Mr the rica ot of Mi 1 lIano who took his fi rom onu his hie Jerson ierson Is hi It ju whet when the district chops Jut tut lo Iwo VI or three hours houra In the life lite of this boy cud then than asks nAlla his export wit to say Hay or not ho ha was sano ane when ho committed the act POLICE 1110 deserves a little from rain 1111 ne for l 14 to extort a ot of santo sort from this br brt boy It t 19 l nut not ight It I is like the barbarous ot or ancient times II a per Jer JerU U all placed lii 11 torture to t a from roni him There are dif torture nut line I say that IIII I boy lIa b by the thu continual which bich lie ho j at the hands ot of the tho jhel hll I no f In this case as to the tho shooting the Is hi what waR wan the cause caus causo o of the Iha shooting Let Iet ua luke the proof In case easI We contend that the boy It I itt a 11 ph Ical and 1 psychological fact that these or of ours orten become so o that wo se are film tOI QUI our acts You cant say that the thebo thetO tO bo he acquired habits In his youth which ruined his mind was rl re for tor hIs acts and should be betaken taken out mind shot or 01 hanged for tal this offense The question Is not did the boy do right in III using tho those e deadly 11 drugs 1 lInt Hut dill did the use ot of the druGs affect huis mind If the boy ha lund In his youth re received D a blow upon the head hend which nt at his mIne mind ail him act and Ind tiara vivid hallucinations ami am then later intel uch an ct as the ono onn charged In this case you gen would not go 10 through the form formality or a ballot you ou would acquit hIm hImat himat at once We have hao by who I have hao known ami been with time boy nil his lite ll that his use ml of liquor nod drugs has hns ruined 1 his mind Tho evidence of hIs school teacher hits his boyhood friends time the women with whom he has live Ince the death ot of lila mother and who thought os ems much of hIm ns as they did oC o their own son on is that hl his mind has become 50 affected by his that lie he Is for his bin acts AN m NT I 1 nt at this time to t refer to the statement ot of the district attorney that Col was the of this levil wll Incarnate That as unfair It sas nn an injustice tice even to time the goad heart of tim muon that muade the remark hue he dill on an In Injustice j justice to himself lie he thuat If Cal CoI hunt hnIt I thence In this case hue hI could have twIst the thO statement of Mr tr so that there ther would have been no doubt as to 1111 it admIssibility all as n a dying mice dec nn and thus avoided time the lengthy ar arguments which were In by bythe time the attorneys a on that poInt paint line and made doubly doubty safe the statement whIch meant so sa to hi his boy boyAt boyAt At this point the court took n a recess until thIs afternoon JUDGE IrING m At tim tho openIng ot of court th title Is ate noon Judge I King ln resumed his ar u moot ment lie He said The evidence stanus h here rc undisputed that the father And counsel tried for tor n a month to get a clear statement from him nit nil to That It was ns fully a month I rore lie ht could give gho any such a tl In n view of alt that evidence which is IN Oll cannot say gentlemen that the tho boy was for his nets on that day The counsel brus AR saId that Mills was temporarily In lIe anti justifiable for killing O That Is n a iso where a agi gi own mun mum n a man ot of Intelligence who h bee ot of Idaho o days mutter ot of hs temporarilY Insane and killed his I If t 1111 man II under thoe was WaR insane then there are n a tUnes times a reasons WI this bl boy was insano when Ito he committed that act After hearing hearn nil all the evidence that h 1 lIe lit In this case e can OU out gentlemen on your our oaths say that this hll boy 0 responsible tom tor his acts Most certainly you ou can not ANOTHER ASPECTS Jet Iet us u look nt at another aspect nf at thIs case raFe The distrIct attorney would have havA ou b believe lIeve that there was 1113 no n assault n ir would discredit the of MIss Coates Why the testimony or of Mr Ir Traughber one ot of own wIt it ei goes to show that there thero was sas something wrong IrO f between rd I onti Miss 9 Coat Coits s JI t 1 r I rt rl I lr n tf her to find out what the trouble wits WIlS lie asked her In I If M II hlll had n her and hl lm gave him nt and nOlI that Is what he in inthe the Tribune the next morning That was enough nough evidence that something was vas ron tong STATEMENT Then take the statement of at Nt Mr after he was shot To three or sour persons he said that the hue ho boy not to blame huno and that the theman moat man who vat aR sinking Into his hIli grate would cover coer hula hlA own with shame to hl his assailant to shield n a aboy boy hoy from This much mUth must be nid to the credit of the Iho dead man that ide hili asserted Itself anti hue he spoke out time the truth so o that nn an mao Inno cent boy not ho bo Judge t ing concluded his hlA argument nt at 3 anti the court took a artress ot of 10 after whIch lIs Attorney EIchnor took the floor for tor his concluding argument |