Show opinion court complaint against demurrer demurrer defend arc arc ante given forty five answer jr otherwise plead plead fled nih upon dean arc same answer plaintiff complaint reason plaintiff sixth paragraph predecessor interest front defend predecessor interest 1892 permission lateral ditch upon stewart tract trace JUDGE JUDGE UPHOLDS DOCTRINE irrevocable LICENSE case jennie somerville administratrix hannah G somerville estate george decision affect way moab valley came demurrer complaint august term court judge week decision demurrer complaint forty five answer full text before court upon demurrer complaint being general special special complaint ambiguous cannot complaint upon plaintiff us foundation nile way right defendant argument counsel support demurrer almost special counsel cannot upon theory plaintiff right ditch whether prescriptive right irrevocable nature cf right upon thereby tat right permission once theory upon prescriptive right court opinion sufficient allege irrevocable end per counsel argument further took position posit incumbent upon plaintiff describe tract ditch plaintiff title specific tract land position tenable view fact ultimate relief order right ditch court deem description tract land ditch necessary kind ditch question being upon land defend hat reading complaint court defendant left Ps king mission opinion ali |