Show NOTHER REAT ID Y ATTACK ATTA FAILS fiNAl V T l M MrA ON rA PEACE With ith Senator Gores Gore's Proposal Voted Down First Reservation Is IsI I Up Before the Senate WASHINGTON Nov An 6 An immediate immediate imme- imme m diate vote on the ratification of the treaty of Versailles without reservations reservations reservations reserva reserva- was proposed in the senate late today by Senator Underwood Dem of Alabama after Republican Leader Lodge had challenged the tho administration tion to make mako such a move Senator Underwood's proposal followed followed followed fol fol- lowed discussion of parliamentary procedure procedure procedure pro pro- which was attended by great groat confusion Half a dozen senators frequently frequently fre fre- sought to speak at the same samo time and Vice President Marshall was kept busy banging his gavel for order Senator Hitchcock accepted the tho thoI challenge of Senator Lodge and mado made madea I a motion that the tho senate ratify the treaty without reservation He then demanded a Instead of proceeding to vote on Senator Hitchcock's motion for unreserved unreserved unreserved served ratification the senate revived discussion on another proposal by Senator Senator Sen Son ator Hitchcock to report the treaty immediately from the committee of the whole in order to consider resolutions of ratification WASHINGTON Nov 6 The G.-The The vy peace treaty amendment presented by Senator Gore core Dem Oklahoma to make an all advisory popular vote mandatory before beCore any declaration of war wal under the league of ot nations was rejected today by the senate The vote was 67 to 16 Republican Leader Lader Lodge and other leading lending Republicans Republicans ncI Re Re- publicans voting against the amend amend- I ment ON RESERVATIONS ION After Alter action on the Gore amendment amend amend- I ment Republican Leader Lodge called up the reservations framed by the foreign relations committee but a n. parliamentary parliamentary parliamentary par par- tangle delayed their immediate immediate im Im- mediate consideration Senator Borah Dorah Rep Idaho said he had two amendments to propose but was willing that they go over if It assured assured assured as as- there would be an opportunity to consider them later Senator Underwood Dem Alabama Alabama Ala Ala- bama made a point of or order against such an arrangement nt urging that all amendments must be disposed of or before before be be- fore tore reservations could be considered I Senator Borah then withdrew his objection sa saying he would rewrite his I amendments Into the form torm of or reserva reserva- I A long argument followed over the possible parliamentary situation should the reservations resI be adopted and ratification then defeated PRESIDENTS PRESIDENT'S VIEWS I President Wilsons Wilson's views on reservations reservations reservations reser reser- to the tho treaty of ot Versailles will willbe willbo I Ibo bo be given to Senator Hitchcock of Nebraska Ne Ne- Nebraska braska the administration leader at ata ata ata a White House conference within the next day or two Secretary I said today he was arranging with Rear Admiral Grayson Grason the presidents president's physician for tor Mr 11 Hitchcock's visit The Nebraska senator plans to lay laythe tho the entire treaty situation before the president and give gho him his opinion as to what reservations are likely to receive the support of or a majority In Inthe inthe the tho senate The president in turn will s say y what reservations atlon will be acceptable acceptable accept accept- able ablo to him Mr Wilson Ileon has repeatedly repeatedly repeat repeat- edly said that tio change in tho the treaty which would require its renegotiation would bo be acceptable I KNOX OFFERS PLAN When hen the treaty was taken up in inthe inthe I the senate today Senator Knox Hep Rep Pennsylvania introduced a blanket reservation to release relea the United States Stat from any obligation to be bound I by decisions decision or recommendations of the league of ot nation nations Senator Knox I Mid ld the purpose was to make this oa pace liege 2 I FINAL VOTE Continued d frown from page page 1 1 1 country a a consulting mem member er of the league The rhe reservation would g give gc c the United States the fullest and most moat comp compete te liberty of action in regard to league affairs with the tho sole right to determine its own relations and duties and course of action It also would claim an unconditional right of withdrawal and would make caste ratification ratification ratification tion of the treaty dependent on a affirmative affirmative affirm affirm- acceptance of the reservation bv by bythe b the other powers within sixty days |