| Show ARGUMENTS G MENTS IN CASE A Md Ml d Nov NOI 20 OAt At pp Fr n of or tilt up fl 1 for tor the defense BUS aug fie ge I J I that thu be he submitted with without out OW M Yo 10 ti thin the Judge cal cat objected James then op oi open en eu I tin tu 11 aHe for the Ills first of 0 or addressed ed Itself It elC to t tUt tin Ut II n t testimony produced by hy the th This he lIall HUB sl I copt as OR to 10 the fact tact that none nono of or that bad l ever seen teen such as nil astr HI tr ric In lit this case cilitO list lI t blow J 3 hut but all nil hUll hail s seen cn n Injuries from Inin ti against hard substances as 0 was WIS to 10 such uch UH as the deceased re rein rel retO l in tO the falls tolls Therefore the court holt hold hut the hall hail no II 1111 with the I ath athor or of I nth hi h hl iA w i l fur fiti a liS tile charge of or manslaughter ter tr 11 I i on Mr it U we ve will wP na n L the rase l there ther II m nf not been exactly right fn tom in my t ho lie Mid hald but th of IC if the tho the II I r tin IIII h academy authorities towards light ng g w ere vire re for mr Morl lorl lorlI t fh I hI 1 1 it 4 l n Idea I grant gre ut that thu tint ting IH IM hut hint theta may have t i II a IL t minor minot penalty If IT hit u I L I L lid nl lived ami the Iho accused is ill isn n 11 t 1 n r for Cor his hll ii In th To 1 tc t that Iw I u ti much bettor chance of ot livIng i iIi til 11 bid Tie fie been heen treated judicious I li h Fit t 1 by It his hili companions and then thell by b tin till surgeons ur to who whose e hands ho he fell tell JUri A Marix opened for COl the pr ph He lie I Ic mild II 11 I it i 1 involuntary III I and Involuntary f tn ill i Li thu the Utter hitter being the thet t I hi Ii tg K 1 In the present cusP case cu The rho court II it Ii I I to an all especially tine nile set sel of sn 4 the ni 01 u tit hilt there lire two to TI Th ire t o Humphrey lio liot t in n Ii too much when he camo clImo on ont t f ft t oar ad time and told a story that w tl by Ity m I I whom hom 1 I shall Imp Imi at a li 11 i All Q 11 of cit the who bad hiti lit in Ill thio question tp te that death deth h ha hat i ic r from list fist blows blow Opposed I t 10 uM I t a aS K the tite testimony of ot only ono one onon Iii 11 n 1 Dr Amen Dr Glaze laze r k In III of or the practise of ot off f NI i had been ileOn kept In court n 1 t 1 n put hut Olio the stand his hIli ten tee tenn te tin nfl n v Y should not nol be he given much 1 l I i 11 then called attention to 10 toc c in 10 iJ of tho the test teat I IH 0 H ni that the great greit weight wel ht 0 o I 1 k 11 the th low of the thc 11 1 coine oI ll Ill with the operation or I 11 o or tho o 0 lair i which had hud caused the death had when time the autopsy halt hal been mule la 19 1 days front from death It If mid the thi Judge judg advocate the tv iV ld doe lio that death uis WUI l ed eLl by dills Hots and tilt the clots carne came from a 0 aall fall all huh not list nit lilous I join In Iii the tho accused und and not IRk ask for fop n 0 convictIon on un the charge of ot But Hut have havi the falls been proved It H is on this point PhIt I r will Im Impeach peach the testimony of Midshipman Fitch Hetre the board of or InqUiry and andon on the tho stand l the first time Fitch saIl ild nothing about my uny tall fall but bul when the tho point 0 t hud risen arisen a Midshipman a Fitch h who had refereed the nave gave evi 01 evidence dence of or fulls during the tho light lI hl 1 I think his hits evidence should bo ho stricken out Is III at the naval MIal academy anti everyone knows known It They are ure conducted In secret s ret and this very tight light vas al secret A Ason per person son Is hI responsible for tOI all the tho th unlit I connected with a wrongful net act 1 For a tt set Jet or of young un gentlemen to pro propose pose pOlle a II I brutal beastly light fight lI ht IH Ic If n it line title thing to acknowledge or tir to 10 offer as us nn nit excuse A A M fist light tight not lint show real courage The best fist light lighter ht cr er be ho the meatiest meanest coward In battle battlo A fighter Is not a 1 hem fin evidence has that thai was not malicious though thou h hIs running hae have been specially I wards to nome 1 degree dc roe It ItIs ItIs Is 1 the tile custom I t believe bellee for tor or certain midshipmen to direct their attention to 10 certain lower dim tacit men The acts of Mr Branch along title this line welo nut not severe or unusual anti do not hot constitute tute tulo any nn mitigation In lit connection with tho the visit of or In III which discovered the stilt milt cane cute the thu Judge said there sas WilS sasno no 00 evidence to how any ally net act acton Oil on tho the part of ot At the tho conclusion of ot Judge thu tho court OUr adjourned until Z O OI p II I m ill when United States st Ally AUr tty John C Hose Itose will vIII close for tor the prose irose prosecution prosecution cution Tho ulie caio a o will then Own bo ho given to the tue court |
