Show ann rID IJ D II II 11 Q Q Q Q Q HARRY HARRY- r THA THAW t LOSES IN COURT COURTr I WHITES WHITE'S SLAYER TO BE SENT HACK BACK TOG TO G GOTHAM W WASHINGTON Doc Dec 21 21 Hany Harry K lh Thaw w lost his fight today Oday in tho the su supreme teme court of the United States ag beIng being be- be Ing lag extradited from the state stat of or N New w Hampshire to the state of New York In a a. brief dec decision lon by Justice Holmes which was the unanimous decision of or tho the court it was vas hold that the celebrated pr prisoner ner should be turned tamed over at once to tho the New York York authorities t to answer an an- to an indictment charging h con con- to esca escape c from froin u loin lion for tor tho the criminal inal insane Whether r his escape from fram the tho asylum while bis bb counsel c contended nt h ho was insane in- in sane tane constituted d a crime and other questions the court o tH cd with ith the comment that they could coul not enter into a habeas habeas' corpus pr proceeding and that they were proper questions for the state tate of New KeN York to decide Actually tho the celebrated Thaw ea case case case- the tho killing of Jf Stanford White Whito- White was was lj not before the tUe supreme court Merely question of returning Thaw Than Thaon on the thc conspiracy conspiracy con con- indictment was up for decision What other otner moves mO If an any wore open to Thaws Thaw's counsel to prevent ent his bis return to the tho state where ho he was tried I and had bad mado made many man futile efforts to be released those familiar r with the tho legal it procedure were nt at a n lo IO loss 3 to forecast To 10 o those thoo who n have c followed the case it it seemed scorned that the tho fi fight ht against returning to New York was lost fast and that nothing remained but for the t of Coos county Now Hamp Hampshire to turn Thaw o over pr to New York officers upon the extradition ex ct ea- ea tradition granted b bv br the time governor of New ew llama Hampshire shire but stayed by h- the decision do de of Justice Aldrich which was as today today to to- day dUj reversed re History of oC Struggle Straggle On Au August 17 Ii 17 1913 1813 Thaw escaped camped d from torn the In Insano n. f hospital 1 In to r Nen York where be had been confined after two trials for tho time murder of ot Stanford Whito Charged ed with a conspiracy to escape he ho waa finally arrested In Now ew Ilan Hampshire Ho Ito was Indicted In Nee Cow York on that charge and application for or his extradition was made mado to New ew Hamp Ham shire Extradition I was lS ordered il by the governor KOV- KOV ern or but on habeas corpus proceedings In the federal district court Judge o Al- Al held that Thaw should l be released Justice house Holms 1 announced II the tho courts court's unanimous decision today Ho Ito first overruled over ruled th the contention that It was not a crime for or a man maim confined In an no Insane asylum to walk out omit If Ir ho bo could and an that th therefore a a. conspiracy to do PO to W was 3 nota not nota nota a crime Vu We f do not regard It as open to debato tIet tIe de- bate bato t that the tho withdrawal b by connivance of n a man 1010 from an Insane IU asylum as lum to which ho he had boon been commuted committed as ns Thaw was did tend to obstruct the due administration of ot the cite law Jaw At least the New York courts may no so d decide clde Th Therefore the limo In Indictment Indictment In- In charges a a. crime If It there Is an any remote defect In tho the earlier proceedings b by which Thaw was brae committed which weare wo Wel are aro ara far from is b not tho time thoUm time Um slid and place for that question to 1 be e trl tried tiled Thaw Makes No Comment MANCHESTER N N. II IL Dec Dee 21 21 Harry Harry K Thaw received oo without comm comment ot to today today to- to day the tho announcement from Washington that the Iho supreme court had reversed ret J the decision of Cf the lire federal court In New Nw which refuted to e extradite him hint to toe New e York HN His HI secretary speaking for him after afler manifesting c said ld Mr lr Thaw has no comment to make Any statement regarding the courts court action action action ac ac- ac- ac tion will have o to come from rein hl his counsel Philander C Cr Knox In whom hom Mr Ir Thaw ha has lias every confidence Thaw received the nC news through a I. I press dispatch He tie has hns been stopping In this city cily far foi the past pat three months |