| Show ri SCENE 4 IN HUBBARD CASE r i Judge Powers Objects to lo Theatricals and Deputy Eldredge Resents Resents Insinuations Mrs Lawler L Weeps Bitterly Wm Writ Wr Cooper Jr Wi D I Powell L E LS ES S Lovoi IIO L J Judges Judge Joe Joa Jo Jl IL I Snarr P I Grant Coo Ge H 14 I la rI Time The Hubbard trial was WI re resumed um d In Judge Stewarts court room rom at Id 10 II this morning manning behind closed door dooms dor At Attire t tho tire close of ot yesterdays session lelon during dUr the examination of ot Detective Sheets Shet Prolocutor had attempted to Introduce testimony of happenings prior to time the date dale of at tho the Information against the Sum The defense vigorously objected o and ana the point was Wa argued at nt gloat length by I I counsel on omu both loth tides ldes Ido Finally FInaly about 11 1 this tiala morning moring the time court overruled d the c lion lon by the defense anti and thu the state scored Iro its first point pointOn pointOn On being recalled to 10 time the stand tand tane at 11 1 this title morning Detective Sheets testified that h he 11 visited room 11 m 2 and Realty block on 00 Easter 1 lter Sunday Judge Powers Power objected the time prosecutors question queston as us to how long lone he was In itt the rooms at al the time The objection wa was Wil overruled The Tho detective sold said that he lie hod had stood on the tho dresser in room 03 and looked Into 1110 2 2 the trait tran transom Born som SOI Judge Powers objected leI to his Oils stating what he lie could see nee S e He lie le was again overruled and took an exception The grounds runds were that the time date wan not late 11 lint on which the Information against t the time defendant stated that he was charged 1 with having committed rape Mr Ir then asked what that was hanging over oler the tie transom The Wil tion ton of o thai thu defense was 11 again II In overruled led ledr Mr r Sheet wild said that thui gauze wa was wa hang lug ing over ocr the time transom Judge Powers then said lie he entered l a genera general objection to an all 11 th tiu a claw class of testimony ns as lS being Immaterial Detective Sheets then stated that lie he could He see e the th beth bed wardrobe In hi 11 room lom RU Z 0 In the mirror He lie also aJ o saw uv Mr Hubbard In iii the room loom J lom r Star Spero Starry ry my 1 was Ivas with wih the tue detective on the lie oc occasion canton casion Answering Judge Powers D Detective Sheets said 11 Id he lie hind had cut rut a I hole holE In the lambrequin hanging over orr the time transom to so the time could coull command a view of ot the time Intel interIor lor of ot room boom 2 Charles A Sperry was r rolled railed by I the th Stats State He lie said ld he wan al as with wih Detective Sheets Shet at nt the Realty Hel block on Hauler Easter Ealter Sunday April He lie II went welt hack again on 01 Tuesday April Apri with Officer Gillespie They The looked through the transom In Into Into Into to hubbards room and could see about of ot the bcd td They were In Inthe Inthe Intile the tile building from Irom about 1 I to t 8 C In time the evening He lie Ie said raid he arrested orr the time defendant In the limo block on April Apri Mrs Sarah E Lawler the time landlady In n the time Realty block rooming house hou e was IA then Ihen called cald by b the State Siale She said sue she was wa born In New York and after arter being In Nevada antI nn l moving about ti a I good gOOI leal theal with her husband she Fhe he had 1111 come cometo cometo cometo to Salt Lake about three Jm years ears ago after obtaining n a divorce from her lUEband Mr II Hubbard had roomed ro n e at her house houe the th Realty neol block since 1 f 4 t April 19 1900 She siw Helen Knox on nn A AprIl rl In IW Mr room On Ihl lie ormer date Ar Saturday Y I tl she ag the hl I chil thud II iii the rOom a 3 ald 4 oci ek On the time following TUtI Tuesday about ta t I she he i Ihl Ji rODI mount 13 1 Itt at the time she Ih w saw WAi helen Hulen i J and was al on tint time ih through lF bureau look i I the transom Hub flub bard ri rd anti I ln Jub i Knox anI lelen were tero ero V 01 tilt thin the bed bod hd M Hi then therm n proceeded I ae to In describe the room what Site she he heard saw gaw r Helen taking crying place i that thai ha nM hurt her h r I A Curral current nt of f air blew bin open time the door ot of rm main where I wal was and na the child chilil I t alarmed at the noll noise amid ut 1 it cr cry Tv I J then Ih caine t tf time bureau 8 Rail went lown to time tho I 1 I I street f t t to see gee If Ir I could coull find Ind nn aim 11 oil 01 CerOn On Saturday the lime I making looking through I the t l Mrs Lawler Iwler saw Baw Helen 1 sitting nit on Hubbards hOr la Site Rho said laid I that she f saw time the defendant I go KO to towar towards urd the time withstand I I In r o Mrs Mra Lawler Mid Ild she he became Ulle acquainted d with Mm Mrs Irl Knox on April Auth Il She Sha denied that Mrs called al at lt the thc n Realty alty block on n AP April th Ihal I with wih Ella mla Jensen J Im n SOme She denied denial positively that she ho had ever evel s In seen n Ella Ela Jensen Jel n In lit her houie hou o al also o denied dented alt that there was wa any army lam over the time transom ns as 8 testified to by IJ Sheets Shet and ammil Sperry Later Inter she sh admitted that she eim ht was waR talking I r about room but that there ther was wag wa a 1 curtain on tOme the I he side o or time the tran I corn som sm In II i room rom fi next m to that of ot tho the defendant Witness 1 also In to Judge Powers Power question qU that I she phI was willing that the chIli child should chilI be he hI raped rp ll In order that she h might ob oh lain tain eten a 1 Counsels aim A 11 t I h be to 10 make maka mik witness wl ln l p Boh hr her aLth He ne got her to av that of at what alma sy fart Il u MW saw AI tok tak ing In place In Iii ream rm In tin time mirror anti nd part hart direct At Jart i the preliminary hearing wit ness fleas had said that all ni she he i had hal n was through the time reduction In mm th tm the mirror Powers l bv hv his questions rl aid I d severe lerl attitude r worked the witness Into a 1 nervous state ette tte anti and site ho homade r l made contradictions of her hr former testimony At noon non th he witness lne was aA breaking down and An w when the th recess was II taken till 2 ti When Wien Deputy Sheriff Sherlf nit preached the time to take tak the lie witness ss out or of court she rIme wa quietly weN ln tr j I dont tont want any nn theatrical in this thin case arise OAI shouted Judge Powers Power T I dont want any am on time the ml eI I lags Ings InRI of the Jury jur while they the still mill In Incourt Int Ino incourt court o Deputy t to take II le th time remark as al a n slur nt ft it anti and round on nn the judge and routed ried 1111 4 In iii return ms turn I dont donl w nt any Rn Insinuations lol and It looked for mr n a moment ns as asif f f If I the deputy n the tho lawyer lawer were vere werl go so to pet get mired up Ui uJ Meanwhile Mrs hs Lawler I I I I r who Is a n tall tail tal anti well tush dressed d woman of nf 45 years yeats was wa quietly sobbing l In the witness K stand After n 1 m moment or two In which she was as drying her Imer moist maoist cheeks Ii 1 Continued on Page rage Two 1 SENSATIONAL SCENE IN HUBBARD CASE CASES Continued from page paRe one Mrs Mra Ira Lawler accompanied the deputy out of or court and the tho scene was wal as over The Tho examination of Mrs lIra Lawler Lawer was continued this afternoon Senator Drown BroWn was In court but hUl whether or not riot he ho was wall present ent counsel for Mrs Lawler was ras wn a II state slate secret Tire The senator would not admit to thu tho News reporter that tha l ho he was Judge Towers continued his hili cro cross sox ex of Mrs lawler Ills method of was AS considerably milder In the afternoon thou than It was wan during tho the morning Mrs Irs positively denied that Mm ho hio lied had said I want to convict him Hubbard He lie has hall plenty of ot money and All I want rant to make him pay Mrs 1111 was still till on the tho stand when the News went to pros |
