Show All 11 L JUDGE COULD I GIVE ON EVIDENCE A decree handed down dmn this morning lJ by Judge John A. A Marshall In the ho United States district court brings to an end encl another of or the tha old time LImn smelter fumo cases The case Is th that t of S. S M. M Whitmore Whit Whit- moro more and Ralph Jenkins against t the United States Statts Smelting company and tho the Bingham Copper comp company Jn which was as flied filed In iii the federal court March 16 16 1901 1904 It was waR alleged that fumes fumes' from the United Unit Unit- ed crl States Mates Smelting company plant at al Murray l destroyed the plaintiffs plaintiff's crops crop The They asked for damages es for fOl tho the loss 1085 of several consecutive crops crop Judge Marshall l today handed down a I. I derision giving Whitmore from the United States Smelting company and 13 from the mining company compan Jonkins Jon Jen kins was granted from the smelt smelt- ng company and from rom tho the min mm- ln In ing company COmpall In tho tim decision Judge Marshall 1 said ho no believed tIne the damage had been greater Teater than the tha amount allowed but he could not allow more because of the tho lack of evidence In iii respect to the lie loss The fine long standing case of Charlotte l y against the tho Sliver Silver King Coalition tion Mines MIries corn company am In which title tithe to property in Par Park City lt Is Involved was argued this morn morning Ins and submitted |