Show TARiff ON IRON ORES DISCUSSED Senators Involved in Debate De bate as to Who Benefits by Its Removal SCHWAB'S EVIDENCE PUBLICLY DISPUTED Declared Magnate Has Valuable Valuable Val Val- Holdings in West Indian Fields WASHINGTON May 13 After Atter After a acaU call caU of oZ the senate had shown that sixty sixty- three s senators in tors present today Mr Burrow B in favor of a a. du duty y on fro fron r cr ore as a source of revenue for tho government 5 Tho present duty of ot 40 tO feat a ton tort which the committee pro pro- po to reduce to 25 cents cent yields he of or which m would uld b ore on the free f proposed by tho the house houle gur t Borrows JanoWs said that it was rea reason reason- on I. I O state ate that at the present time men ien were el employed receiving l a to 1 in m the theBon i of of ii iron n ore oro which b industry i was wall now flow proposed to open up tip Bon of tbt world ow read a de description of ox- ox p L iron ion ore deposits in Cuba which hO saia d A ed d to th the Pennsylvania This The body of ore on theeT tho the Cuba he said Mid was wee l tar lar rR er err erth r t o of LAce r eT th kit Iron ore de deposits lit of the Lake ot and all aU conditions were fere f. f tic jetS to placing that ore on the ket n st cheap cost i i i Trust l j t ii it the relation of this thie Pennsyl Pennsyl- United the f company to t 1 asked Mr t E. E EtI Steel on oP o of Nebraska i II not material replied Mr Wi t. t 4 It will appear later t eros s to me ale to toor be Uc very material Brown to a. or ox said he understood an ore could not riot be bo taken west e ene Alleghenies ne on account of the thc fr l ht tates i t. t row stated that from the lake I Ir the rate was a I to r w Ue from uba luba to the theral I Ime ral me w I of un from advance proof sheets 1 a nal report o of the geological cal Burrows said there are arc now the ho United States of high grade ore ore re iek Rn Minnesota and Vis Wis e- e were of grades that available and are arc now useful ful tons making makin which it i ill is esti- esti In addition to i tod rt that the Cuban tuban deposits of or hi high h he 4 ide S e eore ore or amounting to basis of the tbt facts eking of the 14 t Good Supply from South Dakota yes yes- r tod us that our iron irOD ore deposits ls lse Be e exhausted in thirty years year but c- c Bg to the statement tl of tho thu geo- geo eo u i y at the rate rato of t going on the iron ore of these 1 slates will last a little over need not eon con p that I think wo we oo hes about the exhaustion of pr dueta years rears hence e. Tl petitions from bodies of oft e t miners in iD Mu Michigan hl an and else else- a against the with with- j o duty on iron ore ort U Trust k that if it the senate should reject t of t the e committee c. on finance duty of 25 cents cent a ton on iron iron Jd lter later move to put that attha ar ar- t. t tha free list Mr RaynEr Kayner pro pro- to discuss the iron ore industry extracts extract from newspapers to et that if the dut duty on off iron ore be be i retained the act would rethe reto re re- to the benefit of the United Steel d corporation as the owner ore lands and would injure the nt jf steel companies as those ie must arast buy their iron ore from front fromn vL oration if they thy could not noty y it n free ree of duty n or er read from a statement of tive Payne in the house in 91 the action aeton of ot tho the ways and in placing iron iroD ore on ti jt list and remarked to the Reme liei lie lie- I i aide me of the chamber c n Mt Ir Payne iun m kate bre protecting Mr r. r Payne of the senate J id a 4 be II did tot ot ot believe the Cuban t would go JO west wet of the Allet Alle- Alle t it would be available for t I companies on the Atlantic Eastern Dela Dela- Maryland The eom companies T were l competitors of the Unit Unit- Steel el I corporation from which I iU its iron ore of Michigan quoted b n U stating before the means committee that rO ore on OD the lr free list would of the frt b he 1 S Schwab jt at t b belle believe H v a word hr hv- saV says Mr r. r Ras-ner Ras with energy i don't dont believe e ome some thiD things rj Mr Smith aea to be something about u M said Mr Rayner Raner that d' d the ti human mind and and the asand as as- iad and a oa of the soul ul for U trat true of importers importer a as well wll II inquired Mr r. r H s Fond of ot Liars te situation i in Washington here herer I Rt- Rt r replied Mr Ra Rayner Der i i is such I it t you yon 01 cannot get t the truth of any any- if I 1 am very el fond of liars liars- I I. I vo stu studied ed them by day and aDd night night bat at T r sever never in my my- life saw such lUch an aD aggregation ag fl of ot them as all are art assembled in t and the they they can cau lie with equal facility upon one side or the other of oftie tie eke same question Mr Smith Smite of Michigan replied that he spoke e not for the steel corporation bet bat for the he great body of men wh who owned the th iron ore of Michigan n and for the thousands of men who worked in Its those mines of his hia state later Laler Mr Mi Smith aid idL Mr ir Schwab owned more iron ore pr property y in Cobs Caba I than anybody el else and that conse conse- I free iron iroD ore would 1 give e him hima I a fine fiDe bonus on his pro property progeny rt there ther I Short speeches were made h by senatore senators sena sena- I tors tore defining their positions w with th ref reference ref ref- erenee to the proposed protection of 25 cents jents a ton on iron ore Mr Nel Nd- aud sol Rep favored the free entry of I that product Mr Daniel Dem Dam wanted ranted tea it to pay the duty of 6 cents cent Mr lr TUlman Tiliman Inquired dUI whether anything I was as ever eser t to N be done don about t the Illegal I J absorption of the e T n e Coal and Iron company b by the United State States Steel cor cor- Mr Hr Cul Culberson on that if llio attorney attorney nd ney K had not information to snow show the Illegal nature mature o of 01 that combination he could furnish h It to him Mm |