Show RENCE DARROW SA SAYS YS HAN HAYWOOD OR fREE HIM TH OR UTY MAND D fOR OR TH T Tp DEf cut Attorney for the fhe Miners Diners Sec Sec- f fir rV v- v Treasurer Pleads With Jury y Not on Verdict Says Hay Hay- mL d Can an Face Toes Fees Bravely nee irence tience Darrow Darro v of Chicago one of th the attorneys attorneys T battled so valiantly for the liberty of William D. D I gis ds making the second and l last st plea of the de- de He talked for two hours and Ja a half today add a a with th the jurors not to compromise on a ver- ver lEote to hang or free his client Iri ow said that Haywood d was either guilty of the thee e eim us crime of modern modem tines times or entirely innocent li ge against tl him w will talk at the session tonight and will cuDy cupy both sessions of court to tomorrow orrow H He will be d. d by Senator Borah who will end the arguments al dlly K p cution a and d' d pr prepare pare the case case for th the Instruct t tI the e jury v I JULY 24 CLARENCE 2 o EV CIUC CHICAGO GO FOR FOE TWO IND A HALF OF THE OF T THE HAY HAY- TRIAL TODAY PRO PEO- THE INNO INNOCENCE ENCE OF OP OPI INI I 1 AND THE IS CO CONVICTION up- up UNCORROBORATED EVI EVI- F HARRY ORCHARD HAWLEY LEADING WOE FOR THE STATE AND J WERE THE FIGURES WHOM MOST OF THE F THE THE MORNING CEN CEN- e ten weeks weeks' of Hawley jg and Darrow have most daily and there have exchange of angry words rig Hawleys Hawley's s 's argument the used Darrow vented his hi ac- ac rw nth There was no nn atthe atthe at- at the refinement of attack it ht vituperation and angry on n For two ho hours rs and a half haft pg ilg he chan changes es on Orchards Orchard's tre went rent nt and his future and on every word of Con l contempt empt that the Uie least pos pos- pos respect if respect for the court ut crowded to its limit atmosphere heavy lawyer held his audi audi- attention throughout the Wise He Ha pleads r with voice aad and for a moment he and fa ro before the box ad ad- Itch aeh of the jurymen in turn turnIs turns Is s pleading ing that an Idaho find a verdict against Q on if tile e testimony of Orchard pid was corroborated only eyed lw j eyed eyed horse and James Tames rf rW tow in closing the th argument tang said that if the jury of Should shoud hould hang Bill Bm H Haywood killing filling g hands will seize seize the liberty bv by the open grave graveS S on to- to victory Plea lea enfant dant in in this case and the jail below declared Mr I. I av been brought to trial in in f fa man who was killed in the most brutal way ever sent to death burmen on this jury voted for enberg nb rg One of you yon had busi- busi ons nth him while in the theother theother other of you he made his hiso o ears e I. I almost the family circle tired erro man and none of you zany tany community of interest defendants Under these cir cir- I Ican can but ask you to lay ch hf f the passion as you can cantiS us as if we were one of ofu u the fair and impartial would give ve if you had not deceased Ifor for more than a year have rids poisoned bY br lies in the pens but now that you have than two months heard the testimony you have vave been fed upon pois pois pois- Lay aside as much as you p poisonous stuff try to get free ree and be guided only by in this case knows viet vict on the exact evidence upon the strained forced forces W to get et a verdict from you rou taken by br force from wrought ought ou ht 1500 miles and andset set a a. a hostile jury to be le tried rk re ac Haywood yourselves ourselves men taken Tins firms and set down before sago ago to be tried for your yourn yourD n D you can in some way wayn in n does in this case I Inder rider ider these thele c circumstances to te e to act on the rotten testimony f given ven in this case to take takeaway takeaway away the life of a fellow citizen But But some of you oU will say perhaps that while there is not enough here to warrant sending a man to death there is is perhaps enough of evidence as to crimps crimes having b been n committed in is the Western countr country to vote to put Bill Ha Haywood in in to to compromise on a verdict for manslaughter or murder in inthe inthe inthe the second d degree ee You have that right g gentlemen of the the- jury Ivry but I want want to say that whatever whatever what what- ever else you are I do not believe beli e you are cowards And I want to say that whatever else lse Bill Haywood may be he is is not a coward I would not thank this jury if it returned a verdict of assault and battery and assessed a fine of 5 against this defendant This murder was cold-blooded cold deliberate deliberate de de- de- de liberate and cowardly in the extreme If this man sitting in rin his office in Denver 1500 miles away way employed an assassin to do this cowardly act then you ought to hang him by the te neck until until until un un- til he is dead For For Gods God's sake men do not compromise com corn promise If you yon believe the story that has been told against this man beyond all reasonable doubt then take him and hang him He has fought many a fight against the persecutors who are hounding him into this court He has fought them themon on the open battlefield and he is is not a coward I If he has to die he will die dieas dieas dieas as he be has lived with his face to the foe Guilty or Innocent Bill Bill is eith either innocent Haywood r or guilty If he be guilty I I have nothing to say But men men this case cas is a case of Orchard from be beginning ning to end There is nothing at all aU left in the evidence evidence evidence evi evi- dence without him i Mr Darrow here launched into a lengthy bitter vituperative denunciation denunciation tion o of Attorney James Tames H. H Hawley the leading counsel for the State He lie assailed assailed assailed as as- sailed him him nim as a hired man actuated by byno byno byno no other motive than to get the money of the State of Idaho that he might build another addition to his house he denounced him as bu bughouse house and said th that t he had been a friend of labor organizations as he proclaims proclaimed only when they got their cash to his office fi first L It is too bad the old man could not have ended his career before he took this case and told the fool things he has told this jury What was there in Mr Hawleys Hawley's ar argument ent but Orchard According to his theory everybody everybody- lies that that scoundrel may be believed Hawley has got or Orchard Or chard itch would be a better term Darrow dismissed Senator Borah Borab associate associate as as- counsel for the State with with WI h a afew afew afew few words I Z dont don't mean to insinuate he declared declared de that th t Senator Borah is is any S HAYWOOD Continued on page 8 more honest than thau Hawley but I do dob b believe lieve he is slicker George Washington Too Mr Darrow declared that Orchard had been so contradicted by witnesses that there was wa no truth left lef In his story Why he said If I George Washington Washing Washing- ton with all al his ills great reputation for tor variety variety va va- had hd come here as a witness winess and had been contradicted as ae Orchard has las been ben the Father of ot his Country would have gone out of this courtroom disgraced and accounted the greatest Ananias of the age But If i you rou men feel you can convict Bill Bi Haywood on Orchards Orchard's testimony why go ahead and do it i. i I have sat here herewith herewith herewith with you men for tor two or three months and I have tried tred to read you I I have lain awake at nights thinking of ot you There may be some hideous plan deep down in your our souls souls souls-I I cannot see them them but but somehow or another I have never felt fel there was any danger of ot your believing that that perjured monster But if I you do do believe beleve him if I I am so mistake as that if you must have the Ufe life of this man on such testimony as that why gentlemen of the jury jur we will wi furnish you the victim with wih a glad and heart Coward Sneaking Reviewing the c crimes confessed b by Orchard Orchard Orchard Or Or- chard Mr Darrow said that each one of them showed the man to be a sneaking craven coward who had never taken a chance that would endanger his miserable ble hide It I was logical to believe beleve he argued that Orchard now had turned to lying to save his neck He lie le said he had been been- promised no Immunity whatever but neither Coy Gov Gooding nor not Detective had taken take the stand to corroborate corroborate corroborate cor cor- him Is he to get anything has he gotten anything for delivering these three enemies enemies ene ene- mies of the Mine l Ine association into ito the lions lion's lons lon's den He lie looks fat tat and sleek and healthy and In no no danger danger- of ot sudden death If I he hadn't put the blame of ot his crimes on Moyer Haywood and Pettibone the grass would woud be growing over his grave these twelve months gone But he must be saved till ti Bill Bi Haywood Haywood Haywood Hay- Hay wood and Moyer oyer and have been sent to the gallows and their bodies eaten up lip by quick Ui lb lime e. e Then there h are O members e be of the Western W Federation I I of Miners Miners criminals yet to to be dealt deal with with- with to to save Orchard for tor So long as there is a neck to hang why should ong we kill kl Orchard Jack SImpkins is Is- yet to be caught yet t to to o e hanged and Orchard must not be done one away with wih till til Jack Is fud dealt aro aroI with I Darrow Darow next turned his attention to those thoe those sickly slobbering Idiots who talk taUt about Orchards Orchard's rel religion lon ard and reg regeneration nera- nera tion and declared that before Dean F j m his r religious lg s adviser v had persuaded per per- him to lay his sins 1 on Jesus lesus Father the detective had persuaded father him to lay Jay his crimes on Haywood Haywood Haywood Hay- Hay wood Moyer and Pettibone This Religion Dodge eIt lI It was was' a slick lck game of ot shifty H Hrry Harry arry this religion dodge and a part with his past life lre But you OU might have had bad more faith It in this man if he lie had not t confessed to McFarland d a i to save his rd lr life before he confessed to D Dean an Hinks to save his soul As to religion Mr Darrow said he did nt to know much about It He lie had endeavored to solve the th the infinite mystery mys mys- tery but he found he could only bow lila hIs h head In presence of It a and say I do not know wei For those eo who l o oa believed I d in a God who numbered the hairs of the head and noted the sparrows sparrow's sparow's fall fal the attorney declared de de- de dared be he had the most profound respect But gentlemen I have never asked for fOI forthe forthe the life of ot a a human being and never shall shan to the end of my days dars I do not ask for Orchards If I he stood convicted today and no one else would say a word for him my petition petton would be he there praying prying for his lila lire life Ife Because I do not believe beleve Iq In taking away the lire life of any t fellow low being It I is not for us to say ay that If we were born lioni if it I we were molded if we were surrounded surrounded surrounded sur sur- rounded as Orchard was we would not have done as he has But If I Orchard has haa religion men of ot this Jury I say to you OU that that l I 1 never want It Before he made his confession Harry Hary Orchard was bad enough but it it remal remained ed for tor religion and I am carefully c i I l t weighing my words d to make him t totally i depraved Before he e got religion n there was some spark of ot humanity some spark of ot manhood left lef In the creature but as his conversion there seems to be none What show of ot remorse of ot pity or re regret regret re- re gret did this man man make make as he appeared before you to tell his awful story stor Attacks Orchard Darrow declared that once before In his life Orchard had bad been converted had converted had become superintendent of ot a Sunday school school and and he could not say that the second dose would be any better beter than the first During Dung his years of ot cime crime Orchard had hadr protected ce the name of his s family farly from r Fi hedi he Infamy and n disgrace It wan waa he one spark of in his criminal breast Other criminals had shot through the trap door to dangle at the end of ot a rope but they kept kept locked within them the secret of ot their family name to protect those whom they the left behind It I remained for Orchard after aler his conversion to reveal to the world his name to send sed pack back to the Horsley family tamly in Ontario tories stories of his wild career so that people driving by bythe bythe bythe the graves of ot two old Quaker parents might point t to t them nd say There lie liethe liethe rd fl the father and 1 mother h of the fhe greatest t monster of modern a times The attorney also told of ot the disgrace which this act had brought upon the deserted deserted deserted de de- de- de wife and the daughter back In In Canada Canada The blowing up of the Independence lade Inde ide- ide depot was vas a sacrament compared compared com com- pared to the stabbing in ip the heart of that little year old year old daughter with the knowledge of her fathers father's shame Orchard Darrow claimed had been told b by a miserable Pinkerton detective that if he told his real name nae his story w would uld have greater weight with the Jury and would help to tie the rope ab abOut ut the neck of ot Bill Bi Haywood |