Show IT ii SS HitS HAS ED IN N THE HAYWOOD TRIA iNSE RESTS I A SS TODAY Its Is s Are Made on Instructions to in Oren the Jury and Ind ence Drama That Has Held orld's Stage Is Ne Near r End nd mss ats s in all probability will begin in inthe the the Hay- Hay Sorrow morrow morrow and it is a possibility that the fate Defendant defendant will rest with the jury before the I ind had the mountains of Idaho Saturday l a verdict t is expected by next Tues Tuesday y case 3 minor r d delays ays come COlne l up p. p 1 lP attorn attorneys ys at Boise are arc making arguments ley y think should be stricken from the record I jading a n before Judge Fremont t V Wood fo for in- in Ithe he jury Anse inse did not put a witness on the stand in sure sur- sur e steel L-ested at the beginning of today's s 's se session sion of JULY ULY 18 la THE EVI- EVI EVI fj ANALYSIS AND GIN TOMORROW THE NEXT SEVEN EJOF WILLIAM D. D REST WITH THE THE THETHIS i iI THIS MORNING B r TO CLARENCE I IN BEHALF OF OP THAT THE THEdE dE DEPORTATION 7 CREEK DURING PERIOD AND THE RATHE PINKERTON ND HIRED GUN BE IBE ALLOWED TO RY Y MR DARROW COLORADO SITU SITU- no owners and the anning a fake wreck Cripple Creek rail rail- up the Independence riot not and dis and hurled stint at the detect detect- rf fa appeal Show a conspiracy rn Federation of Mito Mi Mi- ill repay to Barrows Barrow's noon an n the Haywood case pY r. r after court ourt opened without calling a sin sin- sur Judge hat the opening e jo o the jury iury would 1 morning by Icy ley J O u ht into court courtIng courtn Ing n ng given over to the tho to be given iven io havo the tho lif Ufa lifa of the hands bands On this sub sub- heard tho views view of who were requested ions ions as to the mater mater- r p hn taco Ingo Q showing deport o ent of s' s and citizens of wan the first to speech was preceded ement cement on the part of tithe the State would not notT g T out ut of that at part of 1 which dealt tOYO Adams and Pet Pet- into northern I lid nd of some claim L attention to this thia lYland and and indicated that a Y it had been conway con con- Wa way with the elend m ow that at testimony when declared Mr II Darrow and we and we do not think I will ri right ht any anyse se by it We will not liken eken out put object pt-object object to the court with fry n-i n reference to Wod W od ai t do that replied I Ii el while I do not at athe atthe p the he court for the th the State in this o be a disposition ny ny- in some general conspiracy by y whom i the Coeur d dAlene Alene I Darrow called the thee I ce o e more to the fact I y wood Y y at that tima With ith the general or or- Western estern Federation member of a local hundreds of I many of the disorders disorder ni mant nt of detectives that most or in the case and it would elate them and their methods from the issue Taking up Orchards Orchard's crimes as confessed by bv him Darrow said the defendant at bar was compelled in m refutation of a charge of having laving murdered d Frank to meet all sorts and ana conditions con con- d Lof allegations allegations The State was allowed through Orchard Or Or- chard to bring in hr something ig abo about t ai an n. n an alleged g d att attempt to wreck a train and L IL of course this this' defendant ms held vas held tip Las 33 the guilty part party Was ryas V s it immaterial fog fot us t to show ih that t the att attempt was was made by detectives S in in th the employ of the tho railway company ny and the Mine dine Owners' Owners association q T f I think not 1 it i-it incompetent nt for us ris to show slow that the meri who perpetrated the crime crIme Conti Continued on pa page e 6 HAYWOOD TRIAL Contin Continued cd from pa page e 1 i. merely wanted to create an imp ssi impression n or 01 appearance of a train wreck so 80 as asto asto asto to trump up another char charge e a against th tn Western Federation of Miners l As to the Bradley claimed by Orchard DarroW said it was entirely competent t to produce testimony that the explosion was was was' c caused ull d by gas as It was also the proper course he said to show that the Vindicator mine incident mi might ht have been an accident rather than the result of design Accuses Detectives Mr Darrow spent some sonic time in discussing dis dis- dis cussing and citing authorities as to the materiality of the evidence eviden e sh snowing showing wing threats on the part of Orchard against Gov He Ho declared that if there was any question as to the relevancy relevancy relevancy rele rele- vancy of any of ot the testimony in the case the doubt should be resolved in favor of of the defendant Mr Darrow charged the Independence ence depot explosion directly to K C. C Sterling the detective of the Mine Mines Owners Owners' Association Three undisputed witnesses he declared had told of s seeing see see- e. e in lug ing Orchard sneak into Sterling's s 's room at night on at least fifteen occa occa- sons The explosion n was a apart part of the conspiracy con eon the attorney asserted of the themen themen themen men who were en engaged a ed in the che laudable laudable laud laud- able occupation of driving out everyman every everyman everyman man who had ever shown any sympathy sympathy thy the Western Federation of M Miners n rs the men who defied Sheri Sheril s and courts and set themselves up as the only competent judges Sterlin Sterling sat in the courtroom for a week and was not called said Mr Danrow Darrow Darrow Dar Dan row and this he took as an admission of the testimony of three witnesses who saw flaw him so frequently in consultation with Orchard King AU All of p Perjurers At A t an any rate b he he- added cr these these witnesses have nave have not ot been arr arrested for perjury on the w word rd of the most perJured per- per lured villain who ever ca came Caine ne into a courtroom Harry courtroom Harry Orchard Arguing as to the competency of f th the testimony testimony- given iven as to conditions and deportations in Colorado Mr Darrow held that the defense should be allowed equal lati latitude ude with the State tate t A man defending his life life he dx dx- claimed should have even a wider latitude than is given to those who are arese se seeking king to send senda a m man n to his death We claim the crimes charged against H Haywood Haywood Hay Hay- y wood Moyer and Pettibone were c cOrn com committed m. m by others and we must be allowed allowed al al- lowed to show evidence conditions and circumstances which tend to bear us out All An that the mine owners did did the the of men the defiance of law the forbidding of merchants to sell food and supplies to the families of the men driven out of the district district district-aU all that they did in furtherance of their criminal conspiracy to destroy the W Western stern Federation Fed of Miners is competent testimony mony runny and it should be left to the jury to determine its value As to the Pinkerton detectives who were placed in the various local unions Mr Darrow said the said the jury should be allowed al al- al lowed o-ced to take their acts into tion Calls Them Vermin They should not be De charged up to the union these men who incited to acts acts of violence and the union should not be held wholly responsible for them They y were on the payroll of the Pink Pink- ertons these miserable a agents who Vho ho homade made incendiary speeches Are we going go go- ing lug to convict Bill Haywood laywood for responsibility re reo for these vermin who have even invaded this courthouse and tried to get g-et upon the witness st stand nd as our witnesses witnesses' t S The jury should have all the facts that this case has developed We objected ob oh j to the State going to Colorado to convict these men of a a. crime in in Ida ho We didn't want to go o into all these details detail but the State was allowed to place plate before the jury every jot and tittle every isol isolated ted circumstance ace every bit o of testimony that could in any way tend to corroborate any statement state stat ment meat of Harry HaTTY Orchard Are they to be allowed to show ever every fact which might these defendants with any an- responsibility and we wo t tO be denied the right to present contradictory facts in or order er that the jury may determine for itself who was ua-j guilty and who was re responsible p T I Let et the fhe twelve men weigh the evidence We i I shall rest content When Mr Darrow concluded a recess was taken until p. p m. m when Senator Senator Senator Sen Sen- ator Borah will renly for the State Senator Borah Borab began his address in reply to Mr Mn Darrow at 40 1 p. p m. m He lIe said that counsel for forthe the defense defense in his bis opening address to to the jur jury claimed that a conspiracy conspiracy- existed between the Pinkerton detectives the Mine Owners Mine Owners Owners' association and the Citizens' Citizens Alliance I to drive the Western Federation of Minera Miners Miners Mi Mi- ners nera out of Colorado and that many of the crimes charged to the Western Federation Federation Fed Fed- ed oration of Miners were in fact committed commit commit- ted tedas as incidents incident of the conspiracy conspiracy- to get rid of the union miners But when we come to s sift t the matter mat ter out continued Senator Borah What do we find That the conspiracy acy had nothing Ito to do with the Vindicator Vindi I cator eaton explosion where Beck and McCormick McCormick McCormick Mc- Mc Cormick were were killed That was an ac ac- ac The conspiracy had nothing to todo todo do with the attempt on Bradley That I was was a gas explosion The conspiracy I had nothing to do with the death of i That was the personal revenge ev of Harry Orchard The conspiracy con eon had nothing to no do with the death of Gregory That Wa was the result of personal difficulties Th The conspiracy conspiracy con con- had nothing to do with the attempts at tempts on Justice Gobbert and G Goy Gov v. v Peabody They were the results of political political po po- po II fe feeling ling j |