Show tHA I W AGAIN I I 1 1 I NI ii BACK TO 0 GLOOMY MA IlEA WAN im Prison Walls VaIls Shut Out the Freedom Vainly llie Sought Sough t. t I C GLARED ARED VICTIM OF DELUSIONAL INSANITY Gained Is That Justice Directs Setter t Treatment I WHITE PLAINS N. N Y Aug oj The of New York won v vi i complete Pleto victory over Harry 1 1 Thaw aw today when Justice 1 N. N Mills decided that tho thol l layer r of Stanford White was or till nane and rent Fent him back to oj- oj h he for fol the criminal in in- ane at 5 c tte S me o of many contentious made madeia Ila iSe ia during ti U f three weeks of his his- tit ring wu sustained He lie Is Is 1 r off oft than before ought ug t th suit because Jus- Jus in his d d. d i ion and n suggests and suggests am on ts practically to ort or- or t Thaw HI t 1 be ba rohe re- re he s iU-s s i he enjoyed during rat month months of nr if hi his hIM St stay there thera 1111 Ills 1115 l i allowed all aU I. I rl and with every when she ahe he calls call to see ace him w if to III remain rumain In t the jail at least II tJ l ja t torn tomorrow n wn n ilI his ts attorney ya will bo ho a ance to make mak any formal mo- mo before Justlee Mills at his chambers un X N. V. V pr took the decision coolly nl tat n f ul III was nua a denial of of the the tho opinion that he the lamp earn delusions that Mm to shoot formal omal language language- I u Mills Mills' deci- deci d the Ill nt of habeas corpus which Tha Thaw w applied for fOl his Ilbert liberty remanded him t to the custody of the Jan Dr Dr lir Robert K Lamb super super- l nt r Mal Ma f awan state hospital one that thai Tha Thaw I l I now Insane ourt onti gives first tance to his and childhood history HI Ills deter deter- the pi pi has not yet ret Tea redis Is based bailed principally on the Amos Bak r. r. r assistant superb superb- It tf r asylum All 11 such flues 8 says Justice Mills l are arc officers with Ith conceivable motives tto do their dut duty ourt says it w wits was s more convinced e of the alienists alienist called e than b b. by that of ot the prison prison- Regarding Dr Britton D. D Vi says lIas experienced d great difficulty In rec- rec present opinion with his pie pie- attitude In connection with the and to my mind did not IJ ly In so 50 doln doing W made a bad had Impression judge Cudge by his hili actions both on and ande e I stand Th The Th opinion calls 11 uIa ular ar attention to Thaws Thaw's facial ap- ap especially icet during the last after- after tithe t the testimony when for tor twenty es Gathe e spoke poke In hI justification of ot his belief as al to Whites White's conduct woman paragraph in Justice Mills Mills' alls devoted de to Mrs Mary Mory Copley Uhe e prisoners prisoner H mother The court MI thaw haw Not Properly Tr Treated fi this regard legard to Dr Baker urt Is ls b by no moans means satisfied with atm nt which Thaw has received it t swan awan sine e hU bibs return there thero i in act Mt lii his unsuccessful ati at- at i n C the courts then to obtain his hiso o one could help being greatly J the manifestly unfeigned oc he mother when as n a witness r ed that treatment tf how nl return to tile Institution n. n h lie hC his t former ImN comfortably fur- fur oom compelled nightly to undress ward iward In th the jn of fifty or unquestioned luna lunatics Ihs to pas pass between rows of ot cots II h k IO-k k in them to In hi his room with d S Its I sole ole article b of ot furniture and andI andIn andre I re In Ks ton ten hours from th this narrative doubt doubt- ce mum be lIP made lilith for tor tho eftI ef- ef tI- tI ht mothers mother's feelings It must flOat bo be tot tod Thaw Is he not fbi III In the hospital ci to muen undergo punishment 17 I Th The 11 authority 1 In the tho t mats mat mat- s Its i-Its Its vor verdict t df declared n d Thaw Inny inCo In- In Co ny crime In lii th the matter of the tho d lid ind that lilac er verdict must joust be reI re- re din I b bV b all oH public 1 he hc must be bo regarded a ns nil 9 ate o person pen afflicted with men men- one lent nt there thele not 10 to bo be punished punI tIme e. e but solely to tr b be b. cared cored 9 cd pt guarded guard I so that he lie heure jure Jur ure all i or ot himself but hut buti buth h i the distill l hope hop that he ii bo ho cured however er great I I bet bat hope really ma may be bt vors VOrs for Wealth I ft Il l. l doubtless that tha t care re should V 5 by the he authorities that Thaw Tha n red because of ot the lie wealth Health and r position of his family It Is equally lOW 1105 ver pr that care can bo be exercised not not treated inv on Oil those ts Tit It ma may well h be hi that this tills court ourt of Its plenary chancery gas all as the thc a a by ly order to tofic fic don us as to the treat- treat Spy ny nr Inn Uc Ii In such sn an n nV V hot nHI mav be hp I venture e to 0 till the there that I t. t returned I to I theli II custo custody tho the p Q which h he h. was 03 y In jit hIli first three months months' Ie e Stored to him It If such lIuch a n. pro- pro 11 not found to be clearly V th due and nd further Is s and tinI most mOt estimable le leI I iJu Q at St all times Umes treated with tn the Her sorrowful con con- commands the profound sympathy minded person 1 Ing out of or i for the tue 5 feelIngs continues Justice p d tf he n is Il a witness to toL L 1 wll 11 her pica foi toi h lj son Hon and In Ino Ig to to o give co certain Incompetent te tes- tes embraced criticism M hf Air Mr l it ii m my duty to say that I tI seem sem to m ole ni to be hI mis- mis although doubt doubt- ue In the tho very cr complete re rex record ord me mel meI I find no of any heart- heart or ilOr zeal upon his part If Continued on page pago a 10 THAW Continued from page ho he made the remark Thaw that he has said lien f never bo be released from Matte v confident It was made mads a s a-s th time not of a hope but of a convict cons would not recover recover- recover Dangerous to Public Pence Peace After a detailed r lw of the the tho final conclusion of J- J that the release of Hr firm KT would bo be dangerous to she lie pi Pu and safety and there fo c o an ami milled |