Show HEYBURN Of o IDAHO TALKS lEAD RA His Discourse Interrupted for Time by Quarrel Between Between Be Be- tween Senators WASHINGTON May 10 A A tilt between between between be be- tween Senators Aldrich and was the opening feature In the sonata senate today That body had no so sooner been en called to order than the senator from Indiana took the floor He spoke r e of the address of Senator Carter last Saturday Saturday Saturday Sat Sat- in which the Mont Montana na senator tor referred to the abundance of Information information tion to the pending tariff bill available to senators I teL think tho senate understands this speech sa said ll Mr l but in order that the understand it I will wiH ask the clerk to read an ox- ox tract from the con congressional re record I The Tho extract read was from a speech by Senator McCumber in which epin- epin pm- pm Continued on page 4 4 I HEYBURN REYBURN Continued from page pae 1 L plaint was made that no information was available l for senators showing tho the comparative cost of articles in the tariff schedules in our country and ad d abroad and in which it was suggested that a bureau to provide pro such information infer mation should be bo created Mr Beveridge then sent to tho the desk another extract from a statement by Mr Aldrich to bo be read b by the clerk derk the chairman of the committee on finance nanco being quoted as saying Is Sarcastic I T have no knowledge whatever whatever whatever-of of anything that transpired upon tho the ways and means committee etc Mr Aldrich said his statement had related only to the hearings on oran orange e mineral under consideration when he spoke and did aid not refer reler to the tho hearings hearings hear hear- in ings s as a whole because he ho had bad Iea read much of the report of those hearin hearings 4 I I have hav given iven thirty years to the consideration of these matters said Mr Aldrich Adrich nod and e and while I may not have the ability of the senator from Indiana Jn- Jn InI I diana yet such as I have havo I have brou brought ht to this question and if the senator will give a fraction of the time to the tho consideration consideration con con- of these matters that I have 1 given e l he will serve lila his constituency and the country better than by proclaiming proclaiming pro pro- claiming to everybody the tho lack of in in- formation Heyburn on Lead Ores Mr having ha the floor declined de de- de- de dined to permit any further farther tion He Ito spoke at length in in discussing 1 the lead schedule explaining minin mining methods and the tho system of treating I lea lead leadore ad I ore in or order ler er to demonstrate tho the necessity necessity sity far fr a a. differential duty on pig or orand ore and other products of lea lead leaa ore ore All the industries of Idaho said Mr Ms Heyburn encircle the lead mines and dis disaster to the mines would result in general business stagnation lIe He claimed that without the protection to pig lead provided by the amendment of tim the Committee on finance tho the lead industry industry in in- could not continue Smelting in Mexico he hI said cost Mst but one half as much as as' here and minin mining about two- two thirds third Dispute I As a compromise between tho the contention con eon t of Senators Senator who have contended contended con con- tended against giving any differential for pi pig lead pad and those thosa who have Ju- Ju in Fisted on five eights of a cent a pound as proposed ld by the committee on finance Senator Cummings r offered an amendment fixing the tho duty of three three- e eighths i of a cent a pound in addition to the tho duty of ono one and one one half half cents a a. pound on tho the lead in in lead ore Statements by Cummin Gumming regarding the tho freight rates on lead leadore ore ore- from Irons western west west- em ern states to New York were disputed by Aldrich Borah Sutherland and Smoot Mr rr Smoot was as particularly emphatic in stating that the rate was about 2 25 a ton and not 6 or 7 1 as claimed by Mr lr Cummins The Iowa senator declared however that if there was any railroad charging charging chart ing a rate of 22 a t ton n on lead oro ore from Salt Lake to New York congress should turn a aside ide for a few mom moments from the consideration of tho the tariff and deal vi vigorously with ith an any such uch railway niJ Borah Butts In In To the opinion of Mr Borah Borab no form of l legislation l would hurt the lead and smelter trusts It was idle he contended contended con con- tended for any anyone one to say lIay th there re were no such trusts So thoroughly in in- trenched were the they he said fI that they easily could avoid oid the provisions of the bill by transferring their bases of op operations |