| Show ANOTHER JUROR FOR BENBROOK TRIAL Edward S Milford Accepted and Sworn this his Afternoon Attorneys on Both Sid Sides s sore More ore Rigid in iii Their The State Now Nois lias but One Peremptory Challenge Unable to Make Cause Calise Against James W Pails Fails to Make Cause Against are Challenged Rogers md and County Attorney ney lie Putnam a Spirited Controversy Over the Alleged of George Raleigh ns as a Private Detective In the Jurors for Cause Calise and Another is The Takes a I Recess Until This livening Evening I The Tho seventh da ot of the Benbrook murder trial opened this morning when the struggle for n a Jur jury was renewed Only two tso men were needed to complete the panel but the usual wn wa experienced In finding inca qualified In every respect to sit on the case The ot of at time the morning hud had dwindled to u a handful of people Inside time bar were ero the u usual ual groups beIng cur Bur rounded b by Ms his relativeS and The group back of the Ule attorneys for forthe fOrthe the State Will was augmented b by the pr prence pres presence ence ot of Mrs S I Clawson anti and MIss MIlS Morris both ot of the dt came Into court with their brother Vie Vic Victor tor br Morris A little later S I Clawson and J R i hansen joined them TH NEW NE The venue for tor fourteen Jurors issued on Saturday brouGht eleven eleen men amen Into the box Of these F W Quinn man manager ager ot of the telephone ox change chonge Chas F Stillman n constable at atI I East Crek Creek and Ernest G C Rognon claimed under the statute and were wert excused G 0 GR R B Potter pleaded 1 Ill health and was I allowed to go The sheriff reported that W J Strickler ot of Ingham Bingham had been sered served hut but he 1 Was Ime some dIstance away amid nd could not get et here until to tonight nl night ht n It M Jones vas L In I and Mr In San Francic FrancIsco Thil This reduced the number In to I II A White Jog N Hicks Ed Mu Muford I for ford Henr Henry A Baker Doker Paul II E J W tire Uro arid and Wi Win C Boyd Boy It te be l t lb fk u lother nl Ina inasmuch much n as the number present ha had beep been red reduced uco A NEW Judge lile lilies ordered II a venire fur for ln ten more Jurors issued returnable at 2 p II mand in amid the followIng were drawn C E a Offenbach John Houston Jesse JesseE E Badger M O 0 Chas ChaR I L Ho ROOd James Jamell I E Payne f E M I Je Ie Prohn Einer Elmer 11 Hill Thomas Green J C 0 McPherson JUDGE POWERS 15 A WIT Before proceeding Judge 1011 Powers said he understood that exceptIon had ben been taken to Bore some remarks of oC his while ex cx a juror Mr Ir Downs formerly of Michigan on Saturday Nothing had b been n further from hil his intention than If t Ile give offense and he wished to make thI explanation together the that he would not attempt criticism again IAD hAD AN OPINION Joseph Joeeph N 1 lUcks ot of 43 out east Ninth South had rd read of the ease and formed a fixed I as to the Run guilt or In of tie tile lie He WI was chii ehul and excused leDge W UN former sanitary In pl passed 1 ii successful examine II He ha had known Rims RUIL Morris and n It y V Morris father ot of the deceased but dId not know urton C Morris IA Y A TILT Do you ou knol know George 1 aked asked Mr I r Rogers ft I do replie replied the JU juror rr Do yOU u know George Raleigh cn con continued Mr HOler Rogers deliberately who ts Is employed by some ore one as a detective for time tho prosecutIon In this cue case I 1 make the statement that he Is 1 so em employed The manner In which Mr Rogers eld saId th thIs IndIcated that I it WI was intended I as I a challenge and s so I It Ire Proved Do you 1 believe thA that statement elm lily l because Mr tr Hoer Rogers makes 17 It In inquired Mr Ir Putnam den It 7 retorted Mr Ir Do you ou deny flog nog er en Yes Ye I deny I it was Nr r an answer werThen Then said Id Mr Ir wih with some ore warmth 11 I say again that Halel Raleigh h Is employed by the 11 tic a detective In iii this cN care nu and we pr pro It Let Iet Mr vote liOn to prove RaleIgh be worn sworn This Thie discussion said the court I Inot Ic not The proper statement said wit ot of time the defense tr trims ft it Is tre true retorted Mr tr Rogers r Quiet quietly and we o ens It t by r himself Let Lel Senator Drown hJ wn t be sworn Thmia hl dl discussion wt e said the Court I It Is al all Ira proper The examination of Juror jurors was reo me cursed and Mr Ure wa was passed ls f tar r cau cause cauThe The challenge sIth lh the defense Judge Judg 1011 h his el vent peremptory and excused Mr tr Urn Uro exl In examining A n a I salesman leman at Bros who ha rC formed d a p pretty t strong opinion Drs Mr Putnam uke asked Cold Could you 0 pUt pilL that opinion cide Of at the aM curl course Is dee entitled to a tar and impartial jur and the State Siale wants nothing else jur We object to that on the ground that the question Include includes an argument for forthe time the deren defense Mi aki Judge JUdg Powers The coUrt ruled thit I the question Itself WI woo proper although It Included something In I it Counsel should re frain fro from ot of that nature Mr announced that his hiso o opinion would t require consIderable evl avi to remove remon and was excused Paul C howell the color colored man who formerly served on the cl city poll police e torce force had heald ot of the tim cue Ie read ad ot of It but had bad not formed an any fixed opinion rr regard to It that would affect his although lie he hind had some seine lon ion He could put ut aSide aalde the opinion and amid It would hat have no effect at all on ills his mind as ae a juror le lIe had scruples scruple against the death dath penalty and would not find a verdict ot of gUity guilty where the punishment was R death To Judge Iwers time tho Juror said mid that hi hIs scruples he would follow the law and evidence and nd return n a verdict of guilty If convinced beyond beronda a rM reasonable doubt doubt Whee here WM was gambling house In W we object to that question IU as 1 as asserting something not proven and throwing an Into the ease cue In adnee tha that counsel to be ashamed hamo ot of The insinuation said Sinator Senator Drown is 11 one advanced by the do de rom feni You have announced al eli along that the defendant I is A gambler drawn The Question was as wih with fr J did y u lern learn the he ks oe owned the he Sheep Shep J 1 know they owned It It I al aI alWays Ways thought a man named own owned d I it you OU ever hear ot f the Den Bea brooks No I cant say ay that I ever did be before before fore this affair They never neer were In any ony Icer fleer trouble while I WIS Was I a police ot of Drown objected to the juror n the round ground that his name appeared on oil the original jur jury lil list as wih with an s 8 This was as dIsallowed TIlE THC STATES ThIRTEENTh PElt FEU E Time The State thereupon exercised Its thirteenth peremptory challenge and excused Mr Ir howell Wm C Dod Boyd a freman fireman on the Ore Oreon Orega ga on Short Line resIding nt at GU Wet West Send Second South had not formed forme any opinion as to the merits merita or of the lse and believed he could give rhe the defendant a fair and impartial trial z Ed 1 Milord a laborer unmarrIed and residing at 23 1 H Street did not know Any ot of the parties to the cue case mind and had n no opinion as to 10 the guilt or ot of the le lie was op GP Ils hosed tu to gambling In an any terra form what whatever ever er but would not let It prejudice him against the defendant J so that be b could not give ghe him a 11 fain and anil impartial trial Mr Ir n brought out the tact that list dir lloyd was as a client of Jud Judge o Powers lowers but WI was not permitted to uk ask why hy the tho juror did not claim his Cn a as a 1111 railway fireman ITS CIAL ENG Milton and D Boyd were finally passed for Cor cuse cause and the defene IC sc copied both Mr Ir Putnam for tor the tho State challenged Mr tr Boyd Dord and he was CS cx excused Ir Milton 11 was worn sworn to tr try the case but one more juror uror to be ob ti tamed IS HIS OPINION SETTLED henry A ot of 18 Grape street treet was U examIned b by Mr Rogers in the at af teron and stated that he had Ind and settled tte opinion a as to defendant a guIlt li or innocence And wa was excused UNTIL TillS This e the jurors on tile the ye e nine and Judge called attention to ih the fact tbt that W J S ot of otIn han who had be been s served would ht In be be here this evening He did not crl cure cureto b to go ahead with lh a new Venire until he be J h had I a chance to examine Mr Ir Senator frown Drown In the rig ot of the defense to thIs rule and Judge lilies d that R a recess s would b be betaken taken until T when tie the jurors lii In th the second Int venue would b be examined as al alto asto to th thur lr statutory qU qualIficatIons |
