Deseret Evening News | 1900-03-15 | Page 5 | Judge Rebukes a Jury

A JUl The They Let Iet Or Off I Ph Mar Without Chicago to the th Chronicle frOn from Dallas Texa Texas a sae The Tho State Slate court ourt ol of criminal appeals IOa today the ot of tn ten years ears against John P CarlIsle for It hillIng tit t Irot Prof WI Sil 1 lam ham In til the Central Chris Chril tan than church o ot Pal Dallas on the night ot of Jul July 9 I liver was U cipal of the nAla Icho school Ca Car Carlisle lisle Hal had been a as janitor le lie shot hot Prof to 0 death during church services without warning ad adIn and andin In th time presence I of a larr t ties On the trial he insanity I U his Judge Judie Brooks 0 of the court ot of eri I nl nai toa today b Ui tIme the written oln opia Ion of the cur court time sentence denounced II In se revere tP gina the crime ot of Carlisle and rebuked the trial ju jury for tor torIs Is its leniency concludIng Time The cur court Is II nt at a Io toss to understand hO hw the jur jury rhe reached th time dIl The h dence amply supports murder In the frt first delre degree an and the highest t penalty which I s death