Show JI o e TIII U m > 01 The poeyt Innlxti ihil It Is I In the prlnl thll tho ug mn lancy llBhtly lurm 1 ihoimhtn of love but ptrlenccd I n in or buman naturo ngre lInt nil on nro nUke to 10vor II I uto nnd mn ria 1 > olre 0 I ngardcd n rtlj benrlng Ul un tho m r ship and the roro or IntI Un I It rt cllon Just n I hy n Drookly eourt an th h maltn The Clevelandf I mmarle the ot h n tl linK rUling tc which thi i 1 r Now York published fe the oe nnd states th l UIra i rnct nn < i con cluslontt itn I thot nnhl the huy Ih tMnt ut n gl nc It 11 ht 11 ynung mltn hort glvn t hi cholen 11 hnndoTT II I nImnt ring Ono day he II Ig hr uool on Us rtUto dlcred that the diamond Iud n rernoved Ilnd ro placed bysi I I d 110 or couro C 1 brokt n off Then 1 I u r lor taU 110 dl 1IIond n n1 thl vpimn man put In i ilalm for the ring tt fa llHlni his I rioperty and not Ihnt of the Bh 1 < Hir lawyer Insisted lhat therni lui 1 un git en outright to the girl snd lhat It became her propertyPJ aJlutoy Ills Hwyer clalmct1thn an engagement ring Is I glvn on cCdlll only nnd that the pioperty In I II I i not gone allogether rram the 0 I > lr Thci w < Ivuc and It brought tip ror d 11 qutlan that ho given on n to many puntf men unit mald n It la considered A point 01 honor whn nn onggemont I bnkn atr that IlU Irent of nlu and especially the engagement ring shall lo I at ono returned Hut thiri ro 00100 pon who do not look ery closely at the folnt of honor and reo Batd only the question ot legal tltl < Cases are not Infrequent where the custodlnnlt Is I doubtful whcthir It wlluld bo proler to oy < > l nn enengnwt Iln ho ruopd to give It up and the oilglnal owner has felt nn unccilalnty about the right to nclalm It lJ law The decision I of the r Wi lire > Un judge Is therefore of value a 11 lre nt He listened cnrefull to the ngumnt on clthr sloe Itnd go them < lu con Ide ration Iror 1oldln lhn h nnlloune < < t tbt n ngiigemenl ring Is I not n Bid but 1001 > 1 tho takn or n contrt IInd ot nlus to tho girl solel > as the sign I and ev Idnee or the contrnct Whn tho conlracl was broken the purpoi ot tbrlng wno nt nn n1 nnd tho glrls title fa It was lost The chart ort or-t elt was thelefore illimlned nd the ring declared the property of tho man |