| Show AN EXCnING lEETING I Fight Over the Mayors Nominations for library Li-brary Trustees I CLASS DISTINCTION ALLEGED AND DENIED f I I Claim 01 01017 1InI Itelmrmulver i rcxxos 011 thisTroxibled Wt l 51IIlne 1 I Jnt night Council meeting will I have to BO down us one of the most Milling In the history of the present 1 Administration Neaily the whole of the evenings session was taken up with 1 a discussion of the majority and I mlnollty reports or tire committee on niunlilpnl I lawn with respect to the Majors nominees for library trusted nnd the mutter of Assistant City IleA I Ile-A nlci Ilclser who was asked to cither vanle the councUmn NAITO hd Im p red IN BIT the tally sheet of the 42nd 1 district retnrct or suffer decapitation lh Mayors appointees vi are firm fly 1 confirmed and the Jolser episode after I 1 Councilman Mulvcy had prevailed his fellow members to Ile I calm upon dh dcl har i 0sul off us though nothing had hap t pec TIII PROCEEDINGS I I The Mayor A nominations for II tTury trustees referred to the com i nlltetf on municipal laws last San cm S-an Intin Major GIcndlnninB nppolnllng Coo t V I1 per a member of the hoard to cas fill the vacancy caused by the resignation t resig-nation of Gen II Scott The com t Application went or and com UI inter In the two reports of the committee 11 mittee The mujTlty I report was teaed by Dale Dlehl and Lo rrohon and read an rollu sIn s-In the matter or the communlca lion from the Ma > or naming a board of I nine director I for the free public library 3 our commlthe ou law rocon friend that the parties named be A ontlri val Ihe name of George D of IHier 1 Ixlns I substlliticd I for that of fisorge M Scott withdrawn We have hcillaled lor < before lepoillng upon A hese nomination In the hope that time changes might be effected took to-ok Ihe lIt more nccellnble but I fueling that Ihe llmo Is I al hand when the lioaid slxitild bo organized we J hole dOCI tied to waive our Objections 7e have no personal objection tn nny f of those named but we believe the uA11r1Z I oboard she Rid lime ben mad 1I10ro inrrsenlullv e by lecognlzlng nil class t co or cllln Wo call attnllon 10 J bleal11 Ze i the fad that here Is I only one i Dome crat two members f the Mormon Cie i tO lIl ocl I rent of the Community 1 I of the worllng element upon a 1tle 12 erd J I The mlnoilty report signed by Ilaj I V ord nnd Cnlllter > ws suunllled ntd read a 3 101100 Vie agree Ax till the majority that the t a arpolntre are riot representative let all classes or thin I city but realize that this Is I but following the Hies followed ly 1 > the ad fill Illot ratlbrx from the be o ginning In discriminating glut one I class of the people of this city We refer re-fer to tire personnel or the Tire and Pa lice board and board of public works to verify this assertion We think that the good and welfutc of the library demands j de-mands the rejection of the appulnlecs > Personally ut have no objection tot r 11 nkObI the appointees but think the policy lursued lnlho past should be cun I denined We therefore recommend that the Appointees bo not C I nJ1 Iscomb moved that tho majority le port be adopted Allen moved to amend by subKllliillng minority for majority Meara and Melv oy demanded de-manded of Culllster that he explain nhat he meant by discriminations rc ferr d to In the minority report Calllsler replied by saying tint he thought It was plain enough to those who had eyes And wanted to see I incan to say he continued that the I Mormon have nr bon rcogllizool or elven proper representation by this administration Take for Instance the J And fire board And Ionia tile loard of public Works Twont to see all classes represented The people Ito I-to e3en hae eon Igooro1 nil along I the line Yon mlvht an m oil hanor out it I I m1goNo Mormon need oWl for jour net show that ou have no time I for them and I am getting tired of I this diticriml AIR t lon OJtcara enquired how I many Tresby 1 Ifrlans and Ilnpllsls weie on the board Continuing he said he was surprliid to hear his friend Canister raise that point Such n question should never I hsXe > been been raised Awl If the mem MU I adopted the minority report they vimilil 1Ie in regret It Dlhl hoped that the majority report would be ndocti Mulvey said 11 was the first time that I this question of Mormon and Gentile had been ral ed In the Council nnd ho very much regretted It lie character I IM It as nn outrage to those not of I Mr Canisters faith anti defied any Po to show him where lie fall ever Icrlmlnnted In favor of Jew Conflict l or Mormon Ho 111 not know what the religious faith of the Majors up Mntes were He believed them good fnln who would do their duty and therefore hoped they would lie l con nrmI Dale The mnjorlti 1 of the commlllen TO Hot favorably I regard the appointMents appoint-Ments and 100111 I nm not parllcular Impressed I nm not troubled about their r I rolbrIon l beliefs fI Is their I po Ill filth 1 that worrlis me most There Are mlv 1 two Democrats named ml vj held the Majors appointments j ft till the hop tint the names could 1 1 I n bod No promArlot no Trulde In I the majority il Sr to make the re I I tr tonight There has been no bits I tile f > lings tovvnrds the library 1 noi MAr that the oil nil may go ahead I 11411 to for vonflimatiAn freVord Aid ho wn more eon I I f rn to > f h n nellllc cf the bonM than the religious complexion ot Us loml rs He thought the Democrat o iRni to have been given more repre Bpnlrtton OMtsrn Mvqt dlfrerence would It of ake to ta Illirnrj If the board was MI d or all DmocrolS one lIflul1 11nns l I III wnrdTllatFl what I went like I o kAw Vht 1 I Why aint they all Dolan It Msnmb I sold he was glad Catllntcr h11 I token for he had given I ln forecnst of ill Incoming administration I The J mmltt e named b > the Major com Io k1 I Prime nf the best citizens of halt Lake etJ tt And tint vvni nil I be cared for Jllt Je i e Prohhon won Just dldnt the thing think I ills llo hadnt com thought or tile religious fnllh ot the Intinhers Dkhl Paid he had studied the library It IJ Jon fer unwnds 1 of twenty scars bith here and else when nellglon and i lltles should novel le allowed to en > Portals of n public ol library j He i hod and old stand aluO religious 1 1141ifications It ntleied not lo him h t a roan R rxs religion I Avao th y ere ShA = noI true and J n L Ile Wils the representative or h people of till Fifth waril I but lit hhl 1 ease he stood up for the whole of 0peoPIP living 1 in Salt Le CRY o Jnt cut i leara nalved to btrike out thc reference to polBbs and religion In the if or r I lor t I Idea V1 Vrtelt 0 tied Count Ilman SrrSf I or nd proceeded 1 to fo I hoCralar lth I A Illsseltation I Of byV 1 d that t board named X ilrS by t I A A far Pon i on e Pro by tartan I T one C Ir o I toO r e Urin r V rL Alto nn I no I afterA n a Uplscopnllan fs I I andO t I i ree Mormons and-O Meara Inleri I tlngilow do u 50 know Did 1syou I Aatthent romng dur of the churches you he namlT the NewellI ant for did ua mj d I ofrril V Continuing Cant my rcoldont Newell ARM thnt the Majcr could not ru been faller With 1 Spect tIlM tolr1he element of thEf City It m he chon Ill that thought In Ill I mind DaleI ITo surprised at the wealth of religious Information PossPosed by our presklen N wcll I have vilwayi posessed tit me higher qualities Th have been d r niant since 1 mingled with thc members of till O Council The report was 000pta nol the 01 Iclntmnt conllrmed bj J n vote of 11 TIT I Allen Canister llayward and c ilnal llnlstl nlIt I for ney otlng In tho negative Lloyd voted 1 In the alllrmatlve but explained that he did so because heed he-ed to nee the library started He oIld not think however that the re 1Ilou Iollllcal still l business elements or the city Wei e IMporly lprntcl The personnel 01 the board in I as rol lows lloyd Park corgc D Ijper M C BTAT U Webber Itov A L Hudson Hud-son imma McCornlct i Mrs Ttachel Miller Mrs J M Uait nnd Mrs D U llempstea I siULVijy TO Tim nrscuc 6 goThe committee appointed to Investigate Investi-gate the charge made by Deputy lie corder Ilelscr r par led as follows Your special committee appointed to eoniult with the deputy recorder as to his charge made that some member of t ills council had Adopted R tlllly on th sheet cf District No 42 opj islte nome of ndgar Hone beg leave 10 ro port as follows Your committee called upon the del uly reolr thin day And ubmlllc l tho following questions to him What reaon hnve yo uon which tn base jour statement that Homo member of tin council made a tally on the tally sheet of District No 42 which Is I said to have Increased Idgur Howes vote fro m2 5 to 150 The deputy recorder requested the opportunity to make his lepl b In writIng 1 writ-Ing whleh was granted and Is attached hereto Unit made part or this report In the Aig P merit of your committee Ills reply Is I a quibble an evasion and A mltolmont or fact In some portions por-tions or It The statement of the deputy dep-uty recorder as made openly and notoriously not-oriously and his amended statement US hown 10 the record In I a direct charge that he ha I 11 reasons to belleve that a me mmher or thl ClIn1I hn com mllle1 n rlony II hn rerucd to give you I ommille Ihe reoon of elldnc he has for making ouch a statement a n1 tills grave charge Is I left to be at tile door or cath mmh of thin bod y Who ere present al the canvass W e therefore recommend that un fell the oIput recorder ImmlIatIY utter the reading of this report clearlY and oXIlIclllY lIMraw the mhole or ills tatemnt and readers oIu alol gles 10 big bodlc that Iep h talen to at one remow him rlOm I olco ImmoIlally after the readIng or th e munnittees 11orl and tile reply or Mr Itclsc as lul1l1hed In last nights Nw ho was given the priIlege of making it statement Mr ncler arose and said that tile report Was out or order OMara suggested thai lie conIIne himself to OXIll1ll1lo what h I meant whn he ml1 < 1e th 1 a charge and not to a criticism or the commlll Continuing Ir nIr 001111 mant protection but In Iw or the gaff rule Adopted b Ihl Council n1 tile eITOIt or evatain councilmen Iolnllll nt Dale to hut mo off 1 DtleI oIont propose the deputy reCorder re-Corder hall talk 10 file In IVAN manner Call1otrYou ont hut him off after ho Iran ben Invited 10 taM 031caraIte oboll be made to rOs poet the Council President Newell told Mr Itelserthat he must not abuse the members but online himself to tho statement he was asked to make otherwise he must tike his seat errohon moved to adopt the rcrort Ftevvart and OMcnla wanted to hear the deputy recorder first Mr miser liven went on to Bay that lie had l no desire to erillelc the Te An bers of the Council but he did not proto pose pro-to be told what he should say or how he should say It Continuing ho said 01111Th statement I nm nuo1 or making 1 mad 10 my superior olllcr You might its well take a mn a wlC still make hr divulge the secrets between be-tween hr And hr husband an to rce mo to explain Nhat I snkl to the city recorder II you want my head you con have It I will not retract MulvejDld jou say that the ole for Mr Howe was Increased by some member of this council llelser 1 told It to the recorder MulveWo It true Ilelscr H was at least I have rea eon lu believe It was and made the statement In confidence to the recorder re-corder lIcorolor rmry then Asked the privilege of saying n few wards unol spoke as follows I It nppllrs to me something Is I belng done Iu put the recorder In 0 hole When it deputy 14 on emploo In my allies Ito In I responsible 10 me and 1 am responsible for him rr anything Is I being be-Ing don or Said to ct n reflection on me It is I Ills duty to tell me wht lie knolls or ban 11180n to bet eve lie made the statement to me In Coon Inc find lie man has 0 right to ole mnol on phlJ1ollon or him lie 11118 lie bnsln to ansier In a way that may incriminate lllmrelf or tile recorders corder olllce t can say that I myself imve suspicions that that nark was made on that sheet and could give reasons whj Mr Htewart and mjself counted that sheet when It was first Opened l And 1e both found l5 for ilone rr I made a mistake so did Mr I 9temart I Ant surprised that a mark tills been made In the tally ht but I cannot say Alux lId II I Am Ipom 0110 for the acts anti utterances or m deputy and I ant YOU to rout tire I blame where It belongs I am willing and able 10 bear II DaleIt seems that there I a on attempt at-tempt to put mc III the position Eli prosecutor In tills ClUi I hoe no feelings I wont to say that I did 1 not threaten Mr Itellier AR to the late meot or the committee for one J dont propose to have nn emplo chrg m till felonY I Ion I rare what thin Coun1I doe Ile should III 1 com plled 10 disclose nr If he refuses step = = = = = I a houlo1 be taken to remove him from olllce BtewartI dont think try member hlo flAx rhanged the tally I mould not wr that there was only 13 votes last wk yoI HomneYUut you believe It oIont you Stewart I believe It but counted It somewhat hUrt 111 and might have possibly been mistaken I think thc Insinuation of the deputj 111 recorder an unwise one 11a shall I eland by my original imposition to vote for his removal Ir lie does not I nom t lie counclhoall or retract JyLC oyd Had that nIr was nol legal II comII1 I to cxllaln nnd that If the council acted with undue haMe it might regret It If the mailer got Into I the court and too Reiser might be called before the grand jilriff be had grounds to believe the mark was I made he could slate them under oath at the pioper time Mulvey Give him a chance to explain ex-plain I from what I hear he made the remark oft hand not Intending nn IIcllon on the CounlI lie Counell C141 young nnol you houl1 not htoll to condemn him There are lime hen e 11 loe our leads This 1s a limo when ire should Ile chnrllabl a nfei Lying Helrnr calmly E onololcrln I will state that I concluded with reason And logic that tile mark could not have been made outside tile Gounell and tile rcordl and his deputies I am Rare that an extra mark wa put on the I ehect A member or the Council told me or It before I told thc recorder Callisler was approached bj nn outololr on1 tI1 thnt on extra mark had been put there I told Ihe deputy to lntch It anol In his xltemnt Out for the defense of his omcc he told tho recorder anti wo overheard Is River vVe I III have vou on trial the arst Along you know Who WILlI tho outoldr ColllstrJ decline to State Hukl aid I tli I < puty recorder ought to 100 j Applauded for his lovallj to the city And him superior officer Iaot night proceeding be chnrtcr Bled Tin partaking of tin Spanish Inqul silion lie was mlxrl up In It but WAS now Parry for It As for people man peeling him he I as lJllnl to rue them floor neyThe deputy recorder did right In warning hi S employer I felt lot night that tile Council was composed com-posed of nutorrt An endeavor lee made to cruch tho young man clean lie wn probably unwise In maUn hi statement 1I0orI1t seems to me that Irh getting a mile thc worst or tills Thin morning the newopnlcr men waited upon me to find out vvhal I knew About It I wa woke up If I am Ibo i man every A lody ought to know It Iulvey then moved Ulllt the report be tabled but After some discussion It was dockled to rcommlt Thus the matter ended 0 IISCIJIIANIJOUS The Pioneer Electric Power company petitioned that tile Council authorize It to transfer its franchise to the Union Light anti Power company to the end that the latter my manage 01 control the business Imnorrred with the same lights and privileges and the same obligations and duties that the llonrer Company now tins under thc rranchle Tire petition contemplates the tronlr to the new company or tire lighting contract eif the city It was uferred to the committee oa municipal laws md tratirvenients Th I tie r1 or politic work Fubmlll I the hlol and contract jf D 11 Parry far the construction or a sewer along First street between D md 1 J streets anti recommended that It be nppioved The bid S619 IU wa apparently 1151 In ex ess of tire money thai would be I ole rived from the abutting property owns own-s and Dale moved that the contractIle contract-Ile not approved It appears that a protest was filed by many or tile property prop-erty owners but not within the required re-quired time Tile commllnlcallon from tire board was finally rrrred to the setter committee The election commlllee reported on the request of the sehool board for a copy of the ofilclal registry list that Inasmuch as the recorder Alan the con toollon or the lIt It would not he proper for them to be taken from his office but It rocommendI that the recorder be authorized to famish the bard a copy or the lIt And employ such extra help i as wan nocemsnry In transcribing then He should charge tile Ward the actual expense or mahlng thc list nnd the bun must furnish all blinks The report was adopted The committee on Cemeteries and public grounds reporting on the petition peti-tion of Sill Simon Anti others asking for the piece or cemetery land owned by the Catholic church and 10 Ioe deeded lo the city rcoommond1 thai the petition pe-tition bo granted and that the recorder ho Instructed to draw a deed to the pleco of land land that tho deed be drawn so as to hold l the city harmless In COM any oImge may result from removing holle Th report was adopted and tire city attorney wa Instructed In-structed to draw the deed Chairman C I Halnes of the board of public works requested lIulhorll to emptily Allen 1lnlllo full an official stenographer anti clerk or tire board tit a Salary of 310 per month salary to Commence September I 15 1E07 at which lime tile office or majors clerk was abolished The authority was granted The superintendent of waterworks reported the dlcovery or another case or electrolysis In th Ixlnh main on Sixth Went htcen North Temple and oulh Temple streets Th frailty or tile pipe was entirely destroyed and the Iran Could be cut with n knife Tile report wa IIIcol Prank B Stephens And about twenty Ight other property holders In the astern unit northeastern part nr the city requested the establishment of a fire station In tile northeastern part or the city upon the grounds owmd bj the city and already ileslgnald for that purpose inferred to fire and police committee rt A Sorensen Asked for the refund of n wator tax Amounting 10 21180 nfrrcol to comlOllloo on wntcrwork The Salvation Army by r Itaun Fupt asked life Council to npploprl alt 150 per month during Ill wInter rr the lOalntnlonco or the salvation home on Iranlelln anue Hoorreol In commltttec on IInnno James Thomas call1 attention to the condition or street var erolng on Second and third South and Fifth Vest streets and asked the Crnncll not to forget them Ilefered to committee com-mittee on slreels 1ranils Heulh asked the Council to rlmbur him for tire damage Jone to his cart nnd harness by reason ot a broken tlume on Iourlh South and Iw = T 4 = lo street Th mount I Asked for Is It Hrrr1 to CIO I Inittee j oil claim I The vnim Springs Itare 1 WO Slitting I but II I was 11 tli and the no Jnrlty want cl to go home so the location ment ocr for another meek |
