| Show A UTAH CASK DECIDED Salt Lake Coal Combine Wins In Court of Appsals VICTORY GAINED ON A TECHNICAL POINT co Against Moore Sharp anf Carpenter onThc sl u In Fit F-it tilt Trusts I Bt Louis rob HThe U S government govern-ment lost three antitrust cases today In the U S court of appeal The original suits were brought by U S Attorney J A Judd of Utah against r I Moore D J Sharp and E U Carpenter A technicality In reference ref-erence to Jurisdiction In the change from a territory to a state was the cause of the courts action r I Morn Is I the agent of the Union Pacific In Salt Lake county and manAges man-Ages the company coal business Sharp and Carpenter are large opera fare and belong the Salt Lake exchange ex-change I was claimed by tho government gov-ernment that an agreement existed whereby the prices of coal were BO manipulated as to shut oft competitIon competi-tIon and to deer the P ° sres3 of trade Indictments wire found and tho cases tried in the territorial court The men wire found guilty of seeking to establish a monopoly and were each lined 200 nnd Ofq Some of tre proceedings went over to the circuit I court that was formed vvv Utal I was admitted I to the Union whr a ucoBlul npeal was mado upon u technical legal iwint Judge I Illner de livered the opinion of the Hner |
