Show WITNESSES WERE AGAINST DREYFUS Still tho Defendant Created a Better Bet-ter Impression HIS COUNSWi SCgillJDA HIT r II IJrltirlhi Adnillleil lie lllird Ibe Intrigue < > r 1alyile < lam ami llcurylo fthlild llfrliair I ilenne Aug llTtw tjjhd week of 1TIt Hi Mcond Ill by Mt > marllal fIt Capt f-It lire fill awjtaJn of rIle r-Ile on the clutrg At tlfunn I 1wn without Incident a 11 lila morning There wa a large I attendant at the lyre I a thn opening of tfee court In view of Ihe pOMlM IMppMranrr of Maltre Labor leading I MOfcael I for the Ion Hut thnugli h It progrtwlng u aallrarlorlly aa i > oa 1 lila pliy alclana deemed 1 bt fnfhim to remain re-main qulei When I beMme known lhat Hie dlellngulehed lawyer would not pAitlupHie In the pmMilMa a large I number of dlaapppalnta9 a na quilted quil-ted I the court room leavln penetdlble gapa along tho bencliea The rourt Bellied down to bu lne aviulrkly and by oclock five wltnw had apivare1 al Ihe bar If Ihla rail fe conllnueil t It la ronaldered the u will get through with Ihe nlnrig Wltluaea iHfnre 1 Ihe beginning of B ieinbr and It la I expected Hie verdhX vHII tw dellv tred 1 by Itept 7 Oena Hovel di Hol4 r and lllllot werr preaelil and Col flctuarl look a plate 1 a ouple of nm behind Hi m The tolonel aat atom until M 1 Her tullua ih examining iMKiatrati who itldeiu wu MI ratomSI to IJntua entered and eat Iweldf IiexllaMt warm ly aliaklng him h > Hi hn l All th nllnoeea lolaf I were hoallle In Dnyfu but a nS of the itl I ilrni w rreh but tnoally a reltera lion of old alatemenle tpr andlelire followed Ihi lp iltlon with comnaro tlvly Intl intni n raferMue nJ M 1 ilribelln to the relation 1 o Dreyfua with demlraondalnni PRHflag Ihe moat apNtliliiK ixirtlon of lh mornlnga rOll > A ruMued titter went round th iourt room whn M 1 Urlbelln even prfced to kaow th exact amount Dnfua apent Uion hla varloua M Ortbplln gave hi tj llmony with an honei dcminnor and nrparrnl ln mlty Ixit he did not atrlk one u tie Ing iwnlcularly Intelligent Nothing Injil abvearaneawoukJJMlllrudlct Ihe oualeMwn o tRE Irlnea1aMa that he wa MaJ Iauth a tool In th inachtna Horn of th general ataft agalnal Col Plcquart who llltne1 lo M 1 Irllielln with an air 1 of ronlrmpliioue Imo tlenoe ln M o Demange rounael fo Ihe defenae waa more ucrewful than uual In crneaetamlnlng him and l > lbly ill M 1lhln ounol I a dltlnct hit when he got M tlrlbelli tn ndmll that he lnlxe1 the Intrigue of Paly de Clam n Henry tn ahleld Ualerhaiy 1 and when M Irlhelln waa finally dlepnaed of hla loIn had auffered badly DIHIYKUH DNTHU8 Dreyfua created a letter linpreeelon today He entered Ihe court room with a more conlldanl beating and replied to the wltne > In I a calm voice nllh out any thealrlial Heeture and hla re marka ir > put an luilJI lhat ho up wareil lo maki an Imprveelon 1 on the iulin all of whom arc relwrled lo be bitterly opN > d to him Th aeaelon wound up with n arene n ai count of llu txlraonllnary conduct of lol Jouaul prraldnl of th court I = who permuted I hlmaelf lo make an unwarrantable un-warrantable dlplay of iwrllallly M llerlullua I had been confronted with the laat wltneaa Capt Junck and I len h ln nh = lloni Iia1 defendtd Ihe latter when Col lltquart nke1 to lie IlIotd to refute aome < 4 Juncka remark Col Jouaut made a geatuic of Impnllenc and hauled Whl Kln A lhu1 01 1lnlt 01 hlnln oo Inm h uII I uh I y f ufoln JuI on1 Mn < r = moII1 huk dmlnhlr 10 hll lurno1 r1 nn1 Joun1 h UIIn < iiliiutfn later I followlnir la I the PMdenco In detail IIJN PA1I1IK TI TIIJ Cl < n ralire formir rhlr of n urcau of Hi Ken 1 IIT WM Ih lrl II 1101 II Ih1 hi 0011 ly I n Ih nrltlnc of the bordereau with Iho writ lint of arlou > ollliera In hla bureau Including In-cluding tho willing of a probationer I who had been III the bureau alnrv 1 thu ptv loua ye ir and w ho had not favorably favor-ably lmpreed hla n mnidea Thla tirolNillonvr Iirtyfu who wan warded untruiHorlhy and Innln tvre In hla pretenlona waa nwordlnR III Ih ItneM dtuully dlllked Wrlnl rmudo oM ulrlur antly erxleavoring c by nil a 1 O of 1 I 1m Ih aecnla 1 of Ih I pln f IlIln 1110 r 11 ym nd In hi onI 10 u In forinalionneiile < M hla dul < olllclal ilullo wltn < aluo Mid I placed It in l > rj > fuj p I r to I dlKloa llo aiKumMiti rcforcrtl ti in the banlvroau Wllneea cOld i lmllc lly l Ire > fu had uld on Ihla Milijeit When MaJ llerlln Ihonid line Iho bor > ileronu th latter waa truck wllh Ihu wlh nmnblann of tlw mllgraphy Hr y fn waa the only lkr nho ma > la niT In hi huru nnd iT inl1 11 > nhm thchlefif 011 al f othar deiwrtmonla conllrmeil wit n I 1If Un Irhr In Iulon h M 1 n 10117 n In I that tlie prlaomr uaa Iho author of > v bordereau nunvrtm IIIIPIIIIH After M 1 I 11111111 had polnlnl out the deureiuni y In rabrea > utmenl > and thorn he nave In mill Uol Jouaul lnvlte1 Iryfua In I r Ily The prlMlin aald On 1abr quite correctly da acrlliml the work on which he WUH en mmed 1 wlirn a prnhalloner eatvolally omiihalilng thai In ha to keep III domtcr relating 10 Hie ioncentrntlor onnlrllon if fhu ccntn i on Ihi caatern I ayatirr IwmM up Thin aa not a llclliu mil Ik rho 1Ionr 11 a mo o In 1111I I I 11 1 hi fon r mc1 I 1m Ih JUI l il I n Awl farmer dnpity chlpf of thn fourth bu u r ai Id h > t fr brc ba bon 1dm a phoUErapIt a an MIUU nolc I in which th writer In I lohloc r aiMiident etldintly KM i > ami that he had ionn ill documinta to communicate The on told Ialire hal the ilorillnnl toned ahowcd the writer could on I I nn artillery ofMcer liclonglni lo Iral alar who l < artlcliated In the lj 1 I I I ipondcd with tin ni illllma and to heir I great urprlx 1 ii Mrlklng memblance waa a parent in I the wrltlnga of lireyflia and lh uioiixmoua letter Ullneaa furthtr di lnrtd ihnl only a probationer cuuld I < the Information mentlonnl In Hi bordereau I waa lo only he i HUK of the rvaemldanre of the hand riling that uaplclimt werr dlrxled al liryfo I but f iaune i he waa In I a poalllon lo be aiqualnled wllh tin documenu enumerated M IWrnange wlahod to know why Col llAbarllle Mid that In U I that In or Jer to diacovcr lh author of the IKM I dereau he thought II nrcraaary to In reallgat th > ofncera who pejtlcllialed In that the year e p dltlona < o Ihi general alaff Vltneca replle1 that he waa Induced to do co b Ik eipraarton In the bor dereau 1 a rung lo the manruvrc for ho conatdered tm I million vf Ih r ou II w I I n Iully nl Counaol polnliil out that a great 1nl of arirumcnt waa founded on the en prcimlon I 0 going to the inttneuv na n HncM aald I 1 ehould nut b I forgotten for-gotten that In lot I the t ralon wa < underalood to apply to thu exiwdltlon of the headquarK r > ataff In reply I 11 the u > ual U elUm Itrey fua aald lie had novtr hidd any eonvrr Ballon wllh Col Handherr the lain chief n the intelligence department who aa o Mine a < ei lnicd with him that hun h-un addreeceil him by another naiw llroaler Inlenxt In the proceeding waa manlf > ated when the name of the nrit wllneia o announcedformer chief of the detective dlpnltmcnl CiHhefort who waa preaenl when llro > fu underwent the nictation teat In Hu 1aty de Clama otttci u 1 ouciiKn > irr CAILKU M 1 Cocbcrort deUarod he knew abao lulvly training of the IJreyfua caae h1 < lon Mercler ummonel him lo confer wllh him on the eubject of the bor dereau trlI aueplcfona In I regard lo Drayfua lien Mercler Cutbcfort continued con-tinued aaked hla advice aa lo the pro ceeduiw whkh ought I be followeil i and Introduceil 1 hlni lo Du Paly de Clam ubeequently afur M llertlllona re iwrt I lh arrvat of Ureyfua waa decided decid-ed upon Ai Ibe wllneea proceeded to deecrtlw the arnet and the fainoua rcene of lha dictation teat a ing 1 thai from the ll t remark dropped by llu Paly de Clam the prlaonw dlaplaynd evident uneaalneaa T tlmi thief u delec llvea pbiclmc hla I hand I on lh prleon era ehouldrr aald Cupt Dreyfua In UI row of Ihe nnl war I 1 uu o At the lime of the examination of o llrejfua wllneea gained Iho Impreeelon that hti might lie guilty and 1 reporl nl 1 Mkrn the mlnllter of war aeknt Ilia opinion During Ihl I formal examination Cothvforl added Dreyfue proleated hi Innocence very lolently 1 and declared b did not 1v 1 know what the > wanted or of what he waa accuaed Mlliree afterward af-terward acaled up the pa te de Claui etaed I at l > reyfu realdance Replying lo the rourt rochefOrt old Iha alnce 1 hla oran on Ih acor h had nothing to do wllh the Dre > f affair which wa III the handi nf the military uulholltle H had nol then aevn Hie riling of the bordereau olli wlae bla lmprealoll Inlglll hate been modified Dunne the couree of hla reply w 1 neaa mentioned Kelitiluiiy but lila mark wo Inaudible After Ihe remalKa of M l mai Col Jouaut Invited 1 I Dreyfua lo epeali Tlie prleoner rvplled h So 1 will reply when de Clam I M 1 aillllHIIN IllINCIIAl AltCIl IVIHT M 1 UrIWIIn the principal archil II II Ihe headquarlera ataff wua the nex wltneoa He ullll1 wllb r t bllll and expnieaed the opinion Uut when Drefua waa aneui I waa enacting a rolii by ayetematkally den lug all the i bargee olall1 hil etell Ibe Aioet obtloua and I I Ir am ihlnga and In detlarlw hlmaelf Ignorant of mallire whlih ahould have been known lo etvry olHter o Ihe general gen-eral > larf tl Wllnn ull be wna cognlaant of Drayfua relation with looa I women III I aupport of Ihla aaerllon he men UII rlu Honed all alleged inlunlary Blaleniin made by ilalhlcu 110lu brother uf Ihe prisoner In Hie wllnena prtnr I that he hail l > ueli obliged to pull 111 brolhr fom Ih Iuld r a u ot Ihl 10 1ln I the Choml my Ulbll rIlInlol < I Ih U ry uf h enkl 1 IIr cuu r Ih rlv1 of the liord t An1 uf th 1 of 1100 duI1 un < 01 0110 ImunUY y nl A I d Col JouUIhn 0 u Ivo 1 h d nI M nTh bordereau arrived alone I al-one In Ihe morning rVplvmtwr Ism Aflir nxamlnliig It Me did 1 not heeltali I to attribute It lo an oincer of the head I iiuarlera > taf Col Jouauel When a I iitinlttiJ la Col HaiidherrT M lrllwlln I hy Ihe very flret day The w Itm = a added Aa the bordereou nrrUol throiuh ordinary cliannela or what al any rate waa reirardrd a auch no doubt wua vntortalned aa to lla au Ilienllclty ItupDIng lo further iu lln M Irlbolln poellKely uaeorliil that 1jtrr limy ne > er came lo tho Int Illg noe dIn liarliiifnt d-In regard to I lli dktallon l t Ihe wltneaa recatlid Dro > fua repl > to I llu Paly da Clam when the kilter > olntd out that liln hamla w < ro link Ing mly ny tinge r 01 < 0 lIInl 0 tho 0utI re nil lo I M Irllielln un Illng the Uee Col Pliilliu mI IIf Ihe otcret aerlce I fund and the ln admitted the truth of Plcquarta 1 dn that mirtelllamti of tiaterhaiy coat but Illlle Quolond aa lo the alleged Indlarro uon or Col Pliquart In allowing 1llr Ublola the wllnew mild that Him he aaw U I Ublola in I Pliquorfa olllce lithe I li-the autumn of MM whll Hit acn 1 doaalvr nf the carrier Ion waa lying on Ilcquarla table llu had not I > removed fmm llu c > iuelo The n rloiea he exclalmi l Were opin I but ho llIIlltd Ihullhl 1 liTIWI 1tI INT Wh rl tho llberuleur dwiument llrllwll I milled h allll wondere1 how I Into HMerhaay hand ami 1111 nol underetund why liaterhusy waa Iul r reeled when he brouaht Ihe dj to Hie mlnlelry of uar Pol I Jounul the other Judge an1 1 Demange rloeely quialloneil w ln n nrloiia puinta and r > iil > ini w II Imparlid nmu information i tI I In petit biitu AnI I Ih ilr umln 1 nIr nhuli Ih F r t di n a conmiunlrr d tu PI iinrl II plylnj to M Dim in M O Orlbln ndmll q hwln = mi I I lu I c m n1 1 < lu u IIf rhu Th adll 10 < at 01 nlon I wu ty ordor at CoLIlniy Will < > added he drlbellnl put on rpritatlr and mnt lo the Hue de 1 Doul 11 hun I Rrtirhnay a letter in I whlh ih laii I wi in I rrnty Ye or Xo It a alao 1 Col Henry who ordered wttiwaa l Benny I llm I < 0 I o Ih 1m 0 llu indrr c falae l anl Vllneoa thought It would have been uch almiderto hne aumrnoned Katr tin lo thn mlnltr > of itar nun ally o Iu l bout I publicly 1 111 > l I Vi aligi utHKeil Ihll the de i t II lu n nrlatlon of Xathleu Dnyfu n ll hal v 1 wh Ih nnl Inl lh F I u wn muring coiul rim A ulie1 hW himaelf lln ha not contempt J wnl 1 I Illn 11 Ih n I 11 knon ma oN I am Intl I merhnly PAIHK IIHAntlH AND IPNCTACMM M 1 Ih mange Why then glue 1 waa a iUellon of aat Ing him war falae hmrdi and blue i lu le 1 marled lo M lireliellnYou had r aak Paly de Clam when he lo In lUughtm Do not Imagine It omuaed me t lien wd laughter Hcplylng to fuithcr queatlon M qUNIn J tlrlhdln dented that he had vr ouetttil a letter add In Plrquarl 1ur Counacl then wantnl to know why Ihe lellir algnel Hperanui waa not aetlt lo lMuart alme all hla Inter were npineil at mlnllry of war > l flrlbellnAa I never opened a lei lo ddreM 1 to l I l Ptcquart I do not know why Col Plciiuarl akid permreelon to quegllnn wllneaa When I left ihe mlnlalr of war aid II quart I uked J flrtbrlln In I forward my leltcra to Ihe aildr h knew Rlnce I the letter I algned Up ranaa u r tl r lln If he did not rerrivelnairtuUona I from hi ihif in liuercepl II lt M DribIlnNo I never received auch an ordir Plciiuart afler prolllng again Ihe manner In whlih hla iorreapond = r me wu tamiiere1 wllh mreaee ear prlae Iliat the queallon of lh > employ menl of Mere aervlce nt ehould oe tonatanlly mined up wllh the tHwyfua caae with which he added ll ha noth ing whatever tu do He aim 1 denied he had glten M lblol th lighteal In formation regarding the an let dieler 1 and mid Ihe I only do umenl of Ihe do aler retealed and lhal l not by him I aelf the cntle canaille d document which had been uinieil by the i > nrmlra of reyfua There waa alao li I llberaleur Klthy dicurnnl wh whh u1 h II 11 Ih m1 holul blakm1 n Ih mmnl COU I tITII rMIUIWH Col I Muih followed II trateraed the groun1 covered by hla evldeme 1 lie fore I tiro criminal dlvldon I of Hie niurt or taaaallon in regard to the tlrcum lancea under whlih Henry iomiilillu > tuled the bordereau He uld that when ihe bordereau reached Hie tntalllgenoe dipartmettl Henry wu abaidulely IB only omcer who knew Ihe agent who furnlaheit It and waa Ihe iniy otHeer known lo Ihe agent Henry ho lilalned liad ap > olnlmenla with Ihe firelgn py In queatlon only 1 a I or I odxK at night at the tartoua place Mo I waa Unpoaalble for Henry lo hand the paliera I lecelved to eu Handherr Hi aame evening Therefore he look them home and brought them hatk lo Hie omie In Ihe morning Very often tlieae appotutmnla were kept on Hal urday and MaJ J Ijiuth belleted Ihe IMcket contalnU Ihe iKirdereau wu handed to Henry naiurdar Heirtem Heplemberfl btr 13 and Waa taken to lht > oine on morning Mid Lauih I may hate Iten Meplember I or another date lliough 1 cannot matter muih I arrtted at the olflce and waa alioul to I enler the norni In which I uaually work when Col i who wa walking In Ihe corrlder called li > f ami look me Inlo bla roiHn fa pi Mather arrlve1 Imilllaniouly W e had aturrely 1 tere1 when Col l Henry I ahowe1 Ihe liackel I recelveil and exhibiting aome pletee he had pat d 1 togelher aald I la I frightful Jual aee wlial 1 I liatc I found In Ihla packet We walked to a wlndiw ami III three began lo read the tilnl of a lulatr which wu mine thr than Ihe border au We dlacueoed who IUII W I Hi niillior I IU hl h1 M Irlbln II r < r < I Ih tho Ni Im Ih w oly ho 1011 KnI hrr half or ihreiuarlera of i Iu later when he arrtted N < < l dlxuealng the petit Meu I MaJ Iwiulh aald 1 reachnl 0 l > lcquart a clof l In I packet early In Manh In Mentally III wltii menllone1 the mlailon lo I Nancy IHI which ll > mry went n aald that while he waa 1 rnl hU wife came lo the Intelligence dcpartinittil to aek for hla whervalmula na ahe knew nolhlne f hla iltierluri II wna the name with all officer of lluliitiniiH aald liulli our fora I k whe U w 0 whn onl un and II waa through Ihi ilepartinenl Hull Iho correeiiunded wllh ua That t I In I the fourth bureau aa allged by Coi Pli quart and Iho oKlt I li < gllKinl and lar aa hi baa aa wind 1 Ultneaa mulnlalned Ihla olao dlapoonl of PUquarl > aeaMtlon that I I Henry waa i In Ihi 1 habit of woiklng at home In Ihe primmr of n ranle Aa a mailer of fact 1 he adl l Ihe ollltera wore vry rearvcd Iwforo I their famllh Continuing Continu-ing wllmal inxei eil lo apeak of 1loquaN order to deatroy all ivl deno of the ltll bleu hating been lorn and lo delinnlne I hi olllc of orl gin by umUUf a illo ak Till HlV CUUIIK Tin p 1 Cuer aald lulh enter en-ter I nil i rrlallnna wllh the mlnlalry of wui wllh Hi ovow l puriHiae of n MtiBlim hlmaelf m hla nn tiininl Ha refill I lo aii pi payment Uonl hla fan l i 11 It Cuem waa evidently tin imnt protaialeur whi bad tnen nl In u 11 nOr bl 10 in l unyiblng f tin alliihleat value of him I wu aid aald liiulh that bullied him to pretent him tmnt piaklng I nlh Ihe pereon who inede the alaununl lo come lure and repent 1 II The triuh la I we bullied him not lo prevnt hi 1 leaking but bnvauae he Iud to uy anything whlih wad not known nnd that tneana the aanw tblng SluJ Ijuiih extremely long deimel lion wu llauned to In profound alienee He pronlid 1 at Pbqualfa allcgallona ngulnl him In the coura of I hi Ta terlir Inquiry when Ploquatt lo aetileil Uulh aa the Illatlgalor and per Mry hapa alo Ihe writer of the I 11Iy for ryi dwlare aald loiulh thnl If b liiplrlnu or writing II I had a linn In any way wluitetar In tin imimi ilion i-lion I of lh Henry forg > r > I aluuld I have avowed It the day i Henry 0111 iiilul auhlde I am not 111 now ufrald nf Ihe laior nor th rope of I i Mi rrlerPltiiuart nor > 1 of a broken glaaa omelette Al lIcowlno rl 11 nl 01 JIIU Iul 110 In 1 luIn Irtr wh kl 0 I n 110 n I h II I Ir Ih li I h n I I n n 1 h t I 01 n hor r n h I wi I In I M I 1 I I Ih I 1 f N n I r 11 J III I I h nlo 4 rm VIr |