| Show EACAHS STORY CONTRADICTED Two Beer Witnesses Mako No Bones Regarding Subject SEC ALOEU IS IMPLICATED rrrelrr of trr Atconllnc 10 tt11 none Alkeil I K > II lo lllf 110 rrUtnleit fleer w Trial WnihlnRlon Starch IIAII but two wltnnnea beforo Iho army Inquiry court today were memben of Iho medical itafl who wrro on erlco In Cuba during dur-ing the Hi > anlih war Tho other duo wllneinc wets Mr Oeose 11 lidding and Hen J lint Rypher who had been InlernIM In ra curing contract for UIII > lnir beef on tin hoof and t1 thv block for the army In Cuba They iMtlncd that dim Kaean had told them that Iho secretary of war had a krd him to glue Iho refrigerator beef a that while Mr flypher colt that lien liugan had created Iho ImprvMlon Vfon him that ho preferred 1 beef on Iho block lo refrigerator beef Their lull many throughout wa contradictory to ten IJagan tntlmony Mr lldldnn Mid 1 that ConEmiman llanley wa piKcnl at Mtcral of hie conference with dm lUiKun A majority of the army nurceon fl pm > ed the opinion that the canne < l bent woe unetllt dory 1e fool I for the troop but nme of them thought nu more harmful than other meat In the Cuban climate DID NOT IlllUmt MEAT The forenoon reunion of the army taut l Inquiry Loan opened with a num lr of ofllcer of the mefjciil 1 corp of t1f army prr ent who had teen l um moned Iol Charles It Irmnlear chlff medical lcI ln 1x clo rot the arts who wa Ihe chief lurgoon In 1 tho nrll during lira Hpiinlli war and who wa itllli lien Mile In Iorlo him was the tint wit new celled lu teitlfy Ho old Hull while In Cuba im till way to Tor In Illco he I had been able In Kite no attention lo the fond upply of the troop but while In Iorlo then lio had looked Into the question of rood l tact dentally The then heard no complaint of Impnrlnnco except a p In the charae ler of the cuoklnir llla nltentlon had not loon brought to nny com plaint concerning either the canned or refrigerator lor l He had eaten some IIr the I canned tonal beef and did not relish II It WAI not tdeawuit to the sight l he all and U woe mawklnh lo fli ladle without uMhnnl ouch a call ant teller 1 In reply lu a IUllon no In what effect the toe nC 1101 tousle CI Would hate 1In Iho hMllh IIC the trtupa 11r UrnlaC call Iho rrl nr It would In I lInlior III the at IIC all rann1 l mal IC mast null rreparel wllh rnndlrnnl lad vecelahlea n1 not u1 too much It might he u > e 1 without detriment If polled It would i produce ilcknera or probably If noel leidlly the > il Iern would not accept II It would It uxid dally and without eondlmenlii or vegetable Mil oil then the-n which at Unt would 1 revolt Knliiit it lie had found that In tho hat climate of Porln Illcn meat lid net keep long when opened Ho had not taken the fiml iiuettlon into account In Conner lion wild the health ut the Inmpfl al trllititlne the ilckncpi solely to the cllinulfWAB WAS WIIONOIY LAIHMI rot II I1 Pone chirr nurgfin of l tho rifth army rotpt In Ihn Banllagn cam troll tenllllFd comrrnlna the tcoh l iut > ply nf the onnipilin The Inrl tiroa I ho found pad and the citmeil 1 s egelnbhel generelly so The runnel turf wrongly lab led rnt > l bout he dll not peik or In urh high term We accepted II A n part or the ration not ate It u e wall n we rn1A 1 but II uaa uniailirartory In nppearama and entirety talking In I savor II wo also Itlnay and touch and In some canes It ire decomposed caumnu the can containing I It tu smell I I aim nntlced that It deteriorated rafjldly after bt Ing Hponed to the air rho great trouble eeenle4 10 lee I the Ik or rI1I1I for rooktt the hoof II wa not 10 bad In the form C pleas or hash a when paten o It wa ores miry It thnuld l be used by the whiter In hn without cnukltiK I or preparation I prepara-tion In any way Taken In that war It wee a very uniatl > rctnry diet It 1 looked like beet from which beef Im I hue been made 1Iu shock int pine Hut the nutritive qunlitles of the beet hero enttacted lolllnc old my IKT nnal opinion I thai at food It wits a low order of nutrltUe value VIIHV THVINfJ 10011 It 1 was a try trjlng fond un lex eaten with lltepee hut III Tin dept feature of It1 he nd II l lot wa In the label not In Ihs ran lie huh teen unable In leer any > ieilal dlieaxr In lip foci u > nt l In Cuba but ht Ihnughl the UO of the canned beef would tend In weaken men and canoe dlieaie Ilxm I the whole ht would not ndtlie the uo or beef for food In the tropic and ho thnu0hl the Ion ration would hive I teltor Th rdlarlo beet 1r 1apf rrn nuume1 good The lIonl h1 been rnmpelled to tilt oR p oltpl port but ir g toot otter thle w os done the rural uteri I roked It sr1a vary 1lnlobl and nu 1I111u Most ot 1he rAnnd beer atoll at HnnUoao torn me label or llnj VII eon Iarkln ornon Aiaj i igariie In command nf tho rccnc ho > plttl nt Hllxjney > iatp < l that the cannel lout lind be > n furnl lnd nt bile table at the hotpllal and lo the luillenti t I wa not cneclall > fond of II ht raid but Asa oubollllli It twill Ih place I nf fresh l > eef Whin we cniild conk It with vegetable It wa fur more pnlataldt than olhruIn The patient In the hoifll inxd 1 lip cnnneil meat rcRulnrty and them was mi eieclal coimilalnt clout It I There I was coriderahle I Alrrhen howevrr and I presume mueli of Ihl waa due In Ihe Uic or thr and other meat The ration contained more meat than It ihould nine contained for food In Hit climate MIAT sum TIIIM ni Copt Aihton II lll chief mrgeon of the rough ildrr brlgado In the Man llngn campaign the flm wltnei nt the annon section 1lIn1 10 leing made dick nn three different nrculnn by ratine canned mail beef tot nn onIon o on-Ion ectcral oilier who partook of the meat with him aim became very III Himn after the tiperlence he had found n hlrc 1 or bacon lying by the roudlde I Thl ll he had taken up cleaned and conked t an 31 I had kc found It very palatable Till meat had not routed any I neon enlence The beef had nccniloned tomlllng The lUmeon of the Tenth cavalry had reported rlmllar etn neon among the mtn of that ntrlinrnl a e a result of eating the canned lout other had eaten U wlthnut apparent III effect The hoot wan rough string taieleiw and devoid of nutrition and I Oltll 1 Ur Heyt thought II mo had rallied illenir Al Ibis point Ihi llhe nf ilrnrnn un ocr rtamlnallon tranbroken In upon by Hi Introduction r Mr Jeorge IJ Hid ding of Han Antbnlo Texa who had put In a Md 1 to supply the foot for Cuba on the hoof In reply 1 Ion request fn > m Maj Lee Mr I Ulddlnr detailed the partlciiani of > nriu Interviews will nro Hagnn corcornlni Iho letting or the contract for Zplnlj HI llmt cnnierntlnh had related In the etxtifleatlolls I for bide Al Whirl air II lilnit hid caliph nlUtitlon to the fact that they Wrte tagdc ln ln l a 1101 then raid 1 thai the mxlncatloin Were ncccriailly tanue no ht could not at I Dial time glee Any iptclflc Informailm lien Iugan had at that limn sold 110 Vrerercme would he I rcrrlgerator hr It hi had any connlnr In III hut ho did not think Ihs nfrkemlor beef could bo made available In the Cuban U I had tree In Cahn haul Ihl lime myielf tall the sellncea uqd I agreed with him that It Woll 100 IIn IHimible to keep the refrigerator beer In that climate without refrigerator Mr lidding then told of Ile tlilt In Iho commliMryircneral on the lit or July rh I n the latter toll ilir IMt I Ilia I eeerctnry uf war hid rent for him the night t rore nnd l had laid that awlmr lo the different In price they had tulle Sic the refrljenttor Wef a trill and that ho would hiss lo do Ihl WHAT KAtlAN rtAll I then naked len rngnn If hi hid car confident In the proportion and he rrpll < l tint he had Wry little but that the refrigerator nl ensue cm prepire In else bond lo kep hn tact good enllwo Imum after IcaMng the re frlrrrnlon Its aim t ted that they had a ircenrlng proeeii by which they were able to loop 1 the beet In comllllnn but ho poll that ft then wan dlnatl fnctlon after the contract went Into ef tI he tumid upset It nl Rite the Tn alllmn n chnnee Mr 1I11lIna then i proiird to I mob n plnnp111on 10 keep hli 00lblnnllon ot cattlemen together for the punlose nf taking cnnlmet 1 In the cmerirenr Indicated I In-dicated and thl lit did Hi produced a copy J of Ihl document lie had rep neon led he salt 1 the comllnallon wn fully capable of cnrrylnir Ihe contract Into effect Mr lid Itnr raid 1 In reply lo t quei Hun by MaJ lec that len liignn 1 hat I tnld 1 him that when he wao nn oillcer In Iho Held he Milan drove hi beef With him on root and that ht Ian thought thin tht proper way to lupply beef for the anny AIXHMlH WWII A LAW Heiientlnit 1 hl 1 Inlertlew 1 with Metre tar Alter nen Kngan had ill 1 aa cor ling lu Mr lidding Well Hit secretary rent for me let night and loll me thai there wa no much difference differ-ence In price thai ahuuId cite the I refrigerator beef a trial DM he order you lo do that r I arkel Nn Ile replleli but hi wlih coals III an nnler l1n lnnn I then relunlet hi srant oC rnnnAonee nll1 felTrnVed that If the bnr did not prove ntliractory ho would annul the contrail con-trail for he would not let the rnldler 1Jiil rIn With reference In len liigun P refer rnce In I a preiervatltc process Mr lid ding ald the general had toll 1 him that Holft tt Co who had made Ihe InweM 111 nn refrigerated 1 beet hid a ittxTi which would enahl l them In keep the beef for > etcntvtno hour af Ire Icing Inke from 1 e refrlgerntcr Ilto nil belles Ill I nknl lIn ttgnn 011 Dlr IIIAllnet Tn rnhtrh h tpllh 1cr Rot In lellveIve Rot 10 glue It n blot Mr I Olddlni Mid hle relation had been plrnrant with len Juan that ht bad lIon Into tle Renernl office fre 1uonll hrOOIlO he felt hi had a rlnht to da 1 rn tr I h > > added len rnBin nfirrnl to mo when he ald he had for tddden some one adinlMlnn lo hli oincr Iho Mniemcnt tta untrue IIDDINUH HTOIIY COKPlUilKD hell J tall Ilypher atlueney tor Ih Teas cattlemen r6l1nrm what Mr Itlddln4 hat Bald Ile Poll IIlnt while he h1 not netted tent MOan WiIh Mr ltldinge lie had Peen hint frequently n1 talker tlllly Will him IIn the sub Jt III the Inleresl or the Tea tnon nn hope 5011 I llh witness 100 velyd Ilm OIIrloli 10 mo Ihnt ho die tlnrtlp and 1unitlveIY t reftrre h boot nn or J l 1 i Iho Meek to rcrrlfertnr Io ot and 1 en r 711rnrI Iuw1ir P001100 tr ono of them In come here Un Hypher call that he had tint Ii cotercil a tendency In change his Inlll1 on Ihu part of len Ia nun toon after Ihe bid were olKtird + lie dld1 lu I I tno them onl1 1110 Inllne lh1 Iho torrllfrnlo hurt mo loll volunlreml In give n IMm1 for the IoorI1I11II nC their neat Cor soven101101 hour aUft Ieving lhtotlerlor I okra hlon IC M oUalll 111101I11 III do inlP non no refilled I ion t dellet u lunle they put up cold rlnrnco plant Oontlnulnx Ion H pher unlit that mniihlne wu raid liy len ligan m Ihui JuncliiroronccriilnR a iirerertnU prcceee but lint hI Rave II very 111110 ntlinllnn Some dts Int r Jn Hy pher salt lien Hunan Informed mi Hnl owlnn In Iho treat dlfferetico In prla > 1m trnuld have lo glte the refrlg cellar tort l a trial Trial tin Ihe word u lucil The wltnr sold In rrply In a goes linn put liy MnJ lj llmticn IMeun ImO Mil l omrthlnr about political lireimure 111 the renew for the new n liy for innVlnir 1110 trial and l that he had wall mlhlnlt about his confer rice with I Iho secretory or war is In Jnl what he had laid nn thl latter IK Int wllneM could not r meml > er but ho fiought Mr I Ulddlng had noted u cprrtetly MnJ Iiilllln V Harver whn woe chief rurRrnn nf thn Tint dltlrlnn of the Only at Cnnllntt and Dint S H 1 Ap 101 I who wan In rvmmand of one nf the rllljlvn I hnipllnli tilh leilme1 but neliher had Plven etteclol nltentlon In the beef uned Mn AWI l Mid he hind never heard a cowl word for the cannel Let I sin tend contft nut RAn rranrltra March IITh coolest of the truil rttu < In I the will nf llm late William Dmnphy Initltuted by his daughter llm I flood 1 U I mailnic nn end The dcrcn ed millionaire left till entire mime In laid until Ihe deaOi of nil htt children Mr tlool I l want1 her ihare I and ciimmenceit Pull Julte Trnutt of 1110 superior Blurt hoe offered the te Pendent In ale nn nniwcr lo her do nIur rwltdnten I i1ups Trl trbtupe I nl In the etaten of Jame fl Pair and the emate of Walk rely he led 1IAr1 1111111 nod Mr Plrnd I expect n fattirahle drclilon I In her0011 I The Durni elat conilit of nearly two hundred thouinml acre of lind I In Netada mach real 1 date in this city and realty In other part of California Th alone Is I nipponed In IH I worth In Iho iiolthborhoud of UOOOCog |
