Show LIUXAUI JUIMIUN VliUV judge J 1 M Washburn luthelhll adulphla American resents the silver coinage question In a way that le I not ollen considered by the ooplc lie holds that between the free coinage of silver and Its limited coinage tbu halo election Battled nothing and could not settle It lIla argument preieuti Iho view In a clear logical nmnnor list only Ibo United Stoles Supreme court cn oeut II In the pirsout eltu allan eat ho InilsU that thu way to proceed la for some cltlziu to demand of Ibo Weer of thu mint to coin Into money ut the precent ratio ul IS to 1 any elI ver uch citizen ma > poseett and bIllie 1 tHUtr of tko mint rctusca lo accede lo Ibo demand to apply to Die federal court for a writ of mandate which Judge ushburn saya must be granted In conformity with the Con stllutloH uf lIme United Batvs Of cuur > u Ihli pruposltlou Involves the validity i f the law of 1ST by llIch Congress reluiud to cm > sliver In uu unlimited munuer and this u vrhereJuli0 Waauburn Btys lu quet lion can ti dtclJed lie claime nuu mla n drool showlu lu support of lola I I claim that It lie queillou of Hit validity ol the law ol 1873 wore to bf tested In the Huprimo count ou tho loiut I of Us limitation or silver coinage coin-age that law would buduoUred void Ita cyst TIe nuobtlon 118 to tho coinage gold and ohio ct n1UI8 oulv 01 bo brought to tore Ohio uouee000 court to bo sail toe ovor at 0 hOoeeooeouaIoudotol doulocu ro how he conrt wlI dl I rldo floe 500000 lo will I 0 wise 10 bno oueb d tolun o 10oct11 t dmoalhy aetblo ho o0ue0000o will 110 Ibo oxche dolt dluon of tier country and bite ho I country tbo gold ntto i aliverl000aooy iu tndcd by Ibo ousillullon In dUcutilu tbo pronaltlan of the Invilidlly of Ibo law or 1S73 should It 1 lie brought before tho Huprcme Court ho lakia llm positIon that the OJ al tulloo comllloll ia Congro to culn mooch that at the dale of the Contll miloa lbs money ot Ibo coun rl was elI I foreign coins of Iold t and rh oar and the country wsa bank I upl that there Is no doubt 0 Ihu Intention of the Conslllutlou that Cot krcM should coin nil time gold and silver tho country could obtain and that tool coins aru tender In pay mont of 1 dbl Accordingly ho say a law refusing lo coin diver ur limitIng limit-Ing Us colnags 1 vlolatlve at the Cull Btltull any Uw of Coo gseer sayIng tnut till or KOJ or silver shall not be coIned or caylng that olthur gold or olIver coIn of tho United States hill noll be tenJer In paynie tof debts Is vlolallve 01 the Co alltutlon lionet lop holds thuetlf a 11 oars wale 10 be tro 11111 tin HUN tie coon would have I u allrrna bUlla declare that wltbcu condition orsuadow ofduuh HIM act of I ebruary 12187 I lefusluh coln co In 0103 mouth 510tt 10 silver Is n vlolntloii cf Ito Constitution lIe iayi It li lot boar hole for Iho Kupromo court nol ID hold thai lIon Constitution bllgn LOMKICS lo tain all Iho lIoht 1 and allvur Hi i mincn of Ibo county will leo duot lilt J pliln that Ibo CunntUmlon obllgo tongroco 10 colli dIver Will Ibot court any Ibo loot 0101100 1011 1I0t 10 obHto Cou0roM IheLonMlltililon duo not limit tho nmotinl of alher Congo dull 1 coin lVhiI that court tny Ihat ton IroCI003r000goitoCooshlollomaeonu to IlInlllh iiino ml of allver It will eulo The COII itllutlou makoi both I Iohl nod IIHr cob In ton lor In po aymout t dobls lhli tint coast dccldo Uml toni ross may dcHtro the lender c1 olIver ooll1lIn1 1 retain aloe Kinder of gold I coins Will that court drcldo lint Oo iRrosi may dlt crlmltiato aloof 1 allow gold 11 bo 1 come 1 lo no ulIllIII ovieol tool ohhvor Dilly 10 a limited oxtcnl lien rlnclpTo m Biich H ikction wonl1 1 allow Congress lu abollih Ibo 8uloremo court Theeettuse Judge Wabburn Iblokl Ibo njillatlon about unlimited coinage of divan la a waste 01 ilijtl m upplleJ 10 actloo by Ibo voto 11 lIvor men want unlimited coinage they have ilia remedy Hut Is I open 10 all cltlzei s when Injured bye law of Congress In violation ot the Constitution that Is to Invoke a decision of Ibo Bu ttme court declaring Ibo law to bo unconstitutional unconsti-tutional This woulJ settle Ibo tune lout of t limitation of coinage As to Ibo standardor unit of money or ratio ho takes the stand that tbe Conilltutlon docs not fix that It I loft to Congreta lo make lbs uoltto regulate tbe value of tbo money It mutt coin Ilecce Ibo amandard5 Ibo nnllr thou ratio 10 loll ntlroly to Cocgre nod Is a polllioal IUloo 10 bu voted 00 by Ibo people n inactIon 01 policy ood political collomy In no rpot JudIcIal Wab lion IIr1 rethlrd ua Ibo Joadge roys could be doo Iulkly and oaollr inlayer In-layer 01 tho lIver mans Coagnesa would ba compelld to ollbr change the aehio or to let Ii go 01 Ibo pressiol Iloodord 016 to I but III ellher event home wOIIM be Iho free and unllmlld eoloog at gold nod silver at Ibo mlnoot Ihlo reunIFy |