Show DISSENTING OPINION1 I joM Eitlcu > > Dw Rat Agree With the Oibtr JBdB sIX s-IX TIII CAM I or III1DI is 10MI I I CnlHiHi It lli llnmellMfdleT f Cvi 1 be toner l rrurl Joel then I U I AnirniKlIne More Jnlfe Harlch > today delivered a tilt jetting opinion In the Huifr > ro eouil In the me ot Allied U llrlm tool rurMvrwr rMpomlmti agalnit riiooiai W nfappellint On JunuSmt the itii Miyol Ihe Huprrme eourl dli mlweJ the appeal but JuJge llailoh dew nil aire wilt them urlllirf dow be ogre with their application of tuft of law 10 curb cltcnnwlaucei M ore shown by the rtcord The action WM originally brought the Third dllllct court before the chief Juilleecf the then Territory of Vial under HfHen 2W7 Compiled bees ol I Utah toe which rovf lee Hull Any pettonttlia dtlvel a herd of buttw I mule attef ottlle iliiip goitt or twine ever t utile highway white tuth highway cootliuctod I ou a lull tide elicit Ie liable fill all damage dam-age done by audi anlmalt In destroying the bank ur tolling rwli Into ot upon suet highway The I Miunlalnt ehargeJ llnl upon a corUIn day the defendant drove i > band uf ibwpovinuch it highway and that the cheep thereon dimaged lite highway i high-way lollieeitnlotjlu deiltoylug I I Hit banki thereof sad ty rolling I rocks I Intotbe road There wio no allegation allega-tion of negligence m lo the driving of Ibo ihtep 01 uiool Iho highway The defendant dummed to the complaint ou Iho fround tint It did out state fuel eufflcleul commute a cane of aetloo The court iiiilaluid the demurrer de-murrer entered Judgment lu favor ol the defondot sOd dlmiied tliu case wuereuien the plilnlill appealed la the Territorial HUDICUIB I court Afterward the cause WM again btouihl up In tin dlilncl oturl where o till I ti I Jury having been u rely waived ly Ibo repectlvatai lie Ibo cause wai ttle i tefote the court illllliK nllbout a Jury Juilic turnt was Ibin tultrtd o aluit ttin ar fenUkDl rot a cirtiln luui and ootli sOil Ibo piticul sppssh l vrn front that JuJstufnt Tlie milorlly ol the Hupteme court hold 005 the decisIon otto T rtltor lilduprcmorourl not bironm tile Iw l ol the rear nJ li ovucluilTa whrlbrr rIght I or wroDtt Itcainltlim non rol fo lion to the lulu of loonier ehjlulfnuitti I Judk honda nyi ° ° Hire Ibo juUiiuibl awul i Itom wneu tired I M tbn iiiull ot a urw liltl vehicle WM ordered by the al pp IIlo l court end lint a I the result ol 110 tie Ulrtcllani I i ft r from snaIl court Jin tbtr > foruii > ttoli from the vpluloa ol Ibo majority la dllujliilDK Otis ippul |