Show I OE1OB81EN 1f 1 f SIS Muli of Theories gI Utcctic Work I IS SIO IIIE ELECTION CASES I Wii Soii AMI a Stem MMt 1 Hi IB tl UDJOD Road I I 1I1LLOlIIOX itUIf1II i lLLtbtD I hid II uUod Nub ss r i sk SIs ft TrIrh II brI001U 101 11 ThIlnl1 LO I lb hnur In Judge 1 t lie Third IIIlrlel BlltI1 durns II Inv jhi i 101 InOruII prcilnel elell n ThltJ nwnltln i I wi lfl Ullllullull of Jue rf CLI Wd l l sliCe very remark 0 ihSil tilpM hlWfn the wllne iland tlbth ODd lIfrD t cet I Ila 111 nMteiiloiel lobvo ple11 l Al 1 ut Notrinlir hellD l A com leftIlill Ito interesting proceed 1 Wlll fOh und hIw 45 IQ II fe ii rsjl oIod a M Miioul J ThouiM IhllUb nl 0 1 1 II waioulhettand w Wile f oI I ly O H hardy then the-n cu uuJ8 of ILI nPollan ° t iliatliat 1 Ibe count made at < j Ill i wu coiru It5 and Ibat Ibo tally I nUinUa I < III tumbir ot volei dilitJ I lei 11 < 1171V101111 cod liorge lestio4ll1w < < J Itepubllcau udgo Ittel lcoiliidlUnl tbe atdlenienl i lId that wlfellow 1111 I lit ifols tuttkea the lilly tbut In lulJobn llioiyrlmllh Hoalto niCi ti to tin cotricluwa of lid Juho4IbtltluIOL ILL Eoilb wbo WM candidate title ItnLkitIL ° cn tlokil f < ir delegate I1 It C nutuou liont the Tblrd indict ass root examined Mr fc > Jibuti be vuilHict during the ttzl 1 if ill Ui Isle cut lu the TulrJ IIKiLil I tiling remained at Ui 111 l lt flue until Ihu tuoru I i Mlnlaf Iho election He vanfol Ui nuut very cloiily and 1 j t niaifiiuiini ol II which lo I e v 0 1 f Ii rtculhHllon iboweJ III Oh I Iii I Ibtra Wire Gael hI0 ilillI hienieretlo sod hhIll sIrlII4 loarran I titus and 37 scratched i 4 so tail ill icmlcuvd Xoiuc i l iui U I At tie three pollt John 7 Pit name WAS scratched ut un or two ballou and Mr ri on tiir la ihn hal ot Mr i i mr i uuici Witness taw 111 IU > tiuiau up auJ tlgued > u Jiiitu with lilt owu uivmor I itttt n Alit il thai hi 01 ill I lilo hi4 j too tally ibreti ali al-i it gin ruiuito 1 Mr Burnt I UM I 11 i1u Well cornel He Hli I Ir 110 WIle 5tatlit dunhIll dun-hIll j I I uut 1 mo i iiumitootl t li I iii ill IP nnuJudgulownri bsl i tIff ol lUu aiiout UKbt 111 i ill I a i i hit belwenn 1 Ibe ii rlinji III h imny uUUruw liLt Sell 1101115 wui not ireteut t t Its r unl llm WIles ex 1 Hit I be did nil Include Ibo hi 4 of lbs iialloli ai part ol flue AFullin who el1 ma clerk u k J ii I 1 tain wuut upon Ihu 11 I 1 Hi ittlej 1 Hut be WM with I this tUI bOb or 1111 No1 t ill In 111111 10wtO lull With iit Kn t cud who lUcIa look k iWC7If d rroboraled llio loller OIl Ubli muring both vltltt 1 CLII hIs otw ho alhOl bb iliilUI hi lieer waa called fir lhitluti 17 of eIMlIUhli had IILUd Jiiej u any infjrmitl 11 bet Ills Al I 1411 I bob aeon U > luuaiMktd by 1 Allorney i ItrIt lbS Atu I slid he did not 1 jUJom noui ol tbem or 1 10 t I I II Mr Jill spls Ib1 t bIlL i changed In lImes w Vai1 WM lrl al any thnie i II1 nn lo lulirtre I Wllh II tbe 1 I 11 Iii icikre WIll Hum i 111 Ill 111 nowol I I any cIte i I 1 bite 101 convertallon 1 I I 111115 7xu Were cIOtuJ WII tie Jmlula Uor ny hIVe bd siLl a can It dIg Ibat tCIUI7 hat 111 Irell I II < I101 I 15111 it II oIk of 1 eloallau iood I 111111 5131 nYlblng 10 M illtttg Illolbil Asked Judgo Yu ° J h lob a convinttlon wIth lllllbo aai7 1 II tit 41 HlUllh WM Wiln IllS > mitiVr I 10Slil IhiAl It would bo av t yftr ft Icf 7th ou Flr 1 1 b S3 bow ii could Lo 1 rett > J JL IAOJlblvg 11 0100111 bIIDl It I tt I II OU MI to sayf 103 11 it lIrr nuui Imitation an It 3 11101b1 1 wit 0att 1 11 I 1 7 lii tbls cost hid I I WIoh agu ailbe 1 loot oh ho aIsles 1 of tbli billlllnr rnme one sell 11 me that llitre mould Lot be more talk Ibau VM miomiary < 111 I Mr Klch make lujtiURgei lInt onTYet sIr Did Mr Illch risk you tluoe tlrtil time lor 11 l i silo > lo Loop to yourielf wIlsit be IbId sold No Irnol ainw liVid lie cyst lie niaynt II II lime nt the oinver tatloii linT sjiikeu if ulihlil you not iay lo It 1 ° Morris hut Itliu had laid i bit he wanltd It change bouts with llaraei No sIr ill11 you nol lay In Moroni llllei lo that lUch had ohaujod noSe No Air JuJgeluwcn objected lo thlimethod 01 I iueitlolilng aud Judge Miner n PIledI em imuewhel aurprlaed at lilt antneri of tin wttnew from fie nforiaillon I roned tiefore he west on Ibo Hand Uellien cited ISIS mlra of juiHlloni to all ol which the wltneta gave negallve roplUit Have you any knowledge thaI the box of roll Nu 1 WM opened at 1 Jtlobi houte I JM not Jtleh tell you It win opened at hll bouitT Kateyuu any lnformallii M 10 whether lIlIeS were ojienid and ballot chaugeu Y Judge 1owen who btsl iilitently bJ04IleII tu Shoes ijtitatloni apparently Licaiiie wrathful when JuJge Miner aiked the wilnmi Do > uu mean lo I wear that you were n 11 h twrnt Wild lie ho ics Wale bltliNi Y anil declared bat tuoh tumjlonlng belonged only olnferlur cool Judge Miner then urood Ihe will vei over to thedittuie Attorney Wllllaiui toll Mr Folland oilate fully wlul Jlloll rail to him NOd the Whets rnioudtdt What I caught from hlioouvetiallcn wee Ibat II I WM not necraiary lu Ill aofthlug nore Ibou know I wAs lu a hurry it tin time William J Newman Uimoortlle uJ t > M poll No 3 leillileil 50 to Ibo wrreolnrM ut the returua if that poll J II livid a Dimocrattu ludge M pull I Iso 8 cotro otkleil Mr Isiwnuh Ill shIed that be gave tbi j broken key of one ol the bolts met at hIs poll t ii II WHIoau tin hMdiuarlere of Ilia Democratic Central committee ivl Mloant liillMl Hi had tforwarda coked Hloan lor Itlutlln Inlter olalmid to have lorgotlen thai he had been given Iho key and could nol find It The key could nol bo uud to npiu thi > luck but It WooD aerve M a pait rn lor vil I i making I a duplloite I He delivered tbe box to tIme Caiuiniwloa on November 7lb a lid II woo alter lIst that bo gave the key lu Mom John T Caloe wai present at Ibn commlllee lnajijuatlm when Ibe WhIne 110 tIle key to Hloan Court then ailJoutueJ tIll Ibli moru log 7UUAlB rHOCIlUtMUJ The Out Wlheos called by 1 Ihu pill tloneri ° allurutyi Ibli ruurblug WAS Ueorgn Liiubourue Ho tald ho WAS outtldo poll 2 Ihltd ireclucl all election elec-tion ilay lIed lace bout It tIle OiUik lu lueuvoulng Wltinei was iekscl to ileucolle the plan idol tol In counting nod did 10 1 be ballon wire tallied ai uuunctd Ho saw tome boxei lu I the relriibuieut lent between I cud 4 I oclock on Ins following mornlur n mlu iiamiil Katr being In ChArge of mm Whin the Judge I got through Will the ballot for Coutlllullonal can dilute all the ballot coals put back 110 time bOlt los h OHrlen mil tellfled that he knew a man uaintd Jonph Urimuan He left Halt I Lake however Iwo or 1 kW llll lilts week ego I Wllneei 1 met Iron nan In lull ally about Novooiber lllh huh and neoomrauivd hint ai fur M Utorge lllalij bust up Ibe Canyon road On tlm way III 0 liCIt itiinauiald he wanted to tee 1uui LewIsIl whole Inlenil ho had bun working elected lo iliecnioeif noun ly I ihiritl over Harvey HaiUy und lIlt ba could get JDJ or POlIO J for iliilllug the box lu tIme decoud pn clue Judge ranitiobJeotoJ lo thIs lull llluuy 15 U had rnltrtuoe only lo tbo eloLllon cf ihtim med 10 lIme HwlllI proclnoti but Ibo court overruled tulf ul leotlulboobeolloo Wllneu titled that they mrl lllalr and It W Hlofcil tubiuiueully un Ibe oauyon I rOll ami wltueit j heard Urtn I lian Mk Hluuu lo try and gol Ilbu boys ol r Ihu Dials UommlMloii room where Iho ballot bout wuro kept for him cjloau saId ho would > ie him on Ilia following day about 11 oclock and fix It up for him Wai anything uU about the providing pro-viding of lldUi asked Atloruty HUM HUMUrcuuau Urcuuau sell lib haJ tho tlokcti nil ruiUy prluled foiilivrlll Iii chewer ta Allarniy 1 U VII MMIII wllueei laid lull bII eiied boilt 131 on Uund y aftoruoun No vembirUth Urenuiti had loll wll niw before ILl that LIUIHU and lev vial uioru good IrliU llepublloani wanted to cleat Tout Lowli ai iherltl Laughter Mr Wllliamt What Lauuau wu U 11 or Molllu Well 1 iloui Unow bo liatl btun talking Mattln ii WM hors any protulio to give 3oh any ot tIme money Well I watnl lu II It I wanted lo dull em I wouldnt go with Drill lIn lull Ibol job Laughter I Vltuii lurlher til J that Hloan Out culls LIlt of lIe buuu lu the Canyon road and lllalrcauiouptolhont later Uivutan had told Bloaii that he wDul1 I to sum Ueorge Itlairnbout gal ting Into tho Utah ComtnlMlou room white Ibo bullot boxea win but I hu illdot thou iay what he wnnliul to yundlhat It wu when lllalr wai will them that Sloan sold ho would wo Urinuiti on tliu morrow anil lllalr remarked re-marked full all right Allorney William then riddled Ollrlon with iiuuttlonc at ta hIs iiul blitory Ha tittue hvrt > hu Hid knead of tho llanrleld ilileollvii uaU Sloe dull etloon anil followed virl out otbtr oocupMloin idor la vomlug lo Hilt Lake be WAS a Chicago delecllvr with 1liiLorloti Ail uiuui 1lukortou Uliohauu youVWell Well lie saIl I oiuldnt draw any mote lfllO I iUll Laughter Vim me nujir Inuiutniunt tor fouury In tbli cuutt nW arent you Viti What are you doIng now for a llv 11111 Wull I ila a llltlo dulecllve work i alltclln all ua n pick acid tuovel 11 I lilt laJ I uif 1411 cool What dJ 311 Luow ubaut lieu IrIsh Itepuolloauii pulling iMiliunoy tu lull the ballot t x11 I Only what Urouuau till me Uo told mi thai Mstlln Linoaa Wi at the ueadofll He Ml iso LmnaM Where le Ureuuail now Hack Kail Whire II prnumo fan U I In New York I could llnd him I gum 111 wauled 17 t Are you oMlitlnj In muoaallug Ml whbooltt No sIr 1 am Hat Whopaidyoufir what work you dlJ nl the election Nol a Kill 1ne ttttnrarkl didnt even piy nu for what luu for them Laughter Mr WlllikmtUugraleful fillowtl Mono lursrbler In nniwer lo oilier ijue lloo OHtlen mid hi Informed Harvey Jiardta Irleiidi of Uronuani mUrpHae probably about hall nn hour after Ureuuau lint rpoke to blm on lbs UbJfOl How much dM you cob Harvey Hardyi frlendi lo give you for the In lormillou I 1 hey never gave mi a dollar illsW much lid you 1k7i Nit a cunt What WM your motive going up there lo Canyon dUal with Ureouan and having Slot talk wIll him about till mutter and bail going sad lulling It to then other parllM I will tell yon what mr motive wai I bellwed lust Harvey Hardy WM elected fairly anil Iiiarely and I didul believe It 1 wai right uf the Lanuana or any other pirtlee ta go nail try 11 defeat hIs eleotluu You and your vjnnleuoi were at Will Iuhlr No It WAS A uialttr otfalraee uud quireuna uu are utlolr for falruen and iuaritiea arent you Will I havent dune anything very wrung that 1 kuoivof Hu nol Charlie Crane the nhalr man ol the Itepublican ujrumiiter agreed lo I pay you for o milng ben He lii srusl lto noililng Jlavent yon aaked him for par continued Mr Wllllaini I liNo air I have not anaweml Ollrlen tiler tome prevarication The WIIUIM mmllte1 pmeiilly Hut he had roelved foil Irom a Mr Mi Mahon but nv did not Ask him white It cilno fruui or wham II woe Ulil MoMaliou aay when It came from frIllI 1 knew where It came from prumpily reipondtU lie wiinew from the lUinblloau oommlltie li WM for working on thli oaie and giving tome Information 1 tubmltled my report to McMabon and be sub milted It toll II llepublloau I oommlllii I liSVllAtUlduudS I Detective work I Itiviillgated every theory lubniluej to toe Laughter Wero you Investigating a theory when you went with Uiauuiu up the Canyon dull lnl U wai since tlut lime 1 wai I emplojcd 1 WMtitalUeda Cliltit DM you atoettiln that any Lalltt 1 bones I had Ulrli Hulled lii did Who ttullol I them Lolt han II 1 If you know 1 dout KUOW who tutted them What ballot box woo iluHid 1 Iull I In Iho Tblrd precinct WIcu aol where 1 ooullll loll V hero wan IttulIJ I never taw It Huffed Who gvs jon rln Information nf tl llo WAll s ho Information I fouuJ WM Ihlf 1 learned that Mr K K lllcb on tliu Bill day of Noveuiter nj proached Hank lUrueiln II lie rear pan of Hoiilti talooti cud lulu him hi WM requiiKdlotee him and find 0111 It llnrnue would allow him to handle llm box toilufl 11 os at to elect Who heard II 7 Interrupted Mr Willlami li I heard II but I wit not prewnt at tin ojiiveiMlionl iugblrr 1 gut lbs Information fioiu Wui lyke I > who hoard ions ft It I the wilniua saIl 111 uuiwer la vnolbor I llUeltlllU Whohiard Mr Illch hOnk thAI tlaieniuiii Ive beard It i tevtral tlniii Afler buliig borg plowed foneveral minute Ollritn tald ho had heard It wai one 1erry llatweu who overheard that oouvorialluu DyVm lold him to bul bo couldnt where IJykii obtained till Informitlou liu didnt Mk hlui Wlut did Mr lliruei lay In reply lo Illchi rropotlllou Will lbs way t cot It It that IlaruiM ailil ho WAS not H man ol that kind and would not tugige In soy tuoli I utlnoet sutdiwlieIe Web Ibo boxei ttuaeil then At tbo Uttli CommIssIon Lulld Ing 5 IJy whom II I wain Iliorc 1lylng Ilia wltiiFH wllh Uurimw Ilium In IbIs tllrecllon Attorney Wll II eli llomi managed to get Ollrlon ellgbtly tauilid up Whin ho evoulual ly I emerged bun I Ibo ruvulal lag bu nuiwcrid donl renumber re-number wbolbor I wai Informed who did It or not Alter another itiugglo 13 I remember ha nldh rt oelviil thunamti nevornl i riont Who were tboj and Mr WIlt horns IntlMrd upon an nuiwer It heard thai Hank llarneo ttutloj Ibm nniwtred Jor and I htirJ Hut L L Illch tlulUd Hum at lilt IIOUK bill I donl remember who told me tIll Time wllurn admitted that ho had rent loll ul llnio chtilnr rumors IJtwty ItliliarJt clerk to I nrtltorlal Hecrutary Itlolurdii whoio tnitia ron r-on Ibu am Moor of llio Uleu Commli tlon building muttering Attorney HUM rioll ho did net know the tills Urenuan Homo llnio alter Uu ului lloii II wai about nildnlgbl ha taw U I J Oordou 01 O deu at Ibu Commlulin building Uordon tuld he hail oome Ihete lu lako homo Mr lllalr ouo if the cltiki ot Ihu Uini CummiMlon and went urtulri lo find him He had bvaM loll gills up SlAbS Hieii > wlnle working hli oilier III all bolll 01 1 lImo nlgbl No I 11101 lIon Wit ulitl lu crow cx lulIl1o Jonih Lllny wool la nnawtt to Judge Miner lutllfleil Unit bo Woo oliu uf ibu hul 1OD nl loll J Third precinct at Iho In Novnubir eltolloii Muitn lined and Nowman being Ibo other JudgM All Iho Vtu warD ourrtclly ojuntid and tallied J T mipbiaian ITII r 3111ulI and Mwdslew olhir iiualont and thin Jo J SkIes took the ttaiid Ho wai nil U 1 Ill n I iVInlrd I I lhftliIprvclnei n > n Cbiiliutaoi law Ilu I Iwtbrudlra tiirJ lInl1 JOEY 0 BRIEN lusts on and WM prawnl when Ih unrtllullonel vote Ills UOUD til VlinM obecked Mal vole M It w C ouunttd at pjl 1 and tie Judas return WM quit ooriiol 1 net well SOI ballot bal-lot OMI far John Henry Hmlin and Su3 tot Ue + rSe K 1 oery At poll S be d1vo took altos nioek ol lbes eon in nod befall Judges oorreotly reported Ibo yt Ins J II HJlIIII slot Ire got nad iuery2 Wm L llykei gave rlmllar hell I monyuti > au > lu5asl u uut by Ilte IUIKM Wltuen aw Hauk Harm salt Mr K K Utah telkiuic Mgoibit oearHeconil Houlh elreil a few tills Her the eleolloi lie baard Mr Hraa > ey reimtbiui anout No boa butlueu ana 4iiueiilly l > rae told kla Inoonrljeuaiur the envra llun liml WilneM unl pleflolllr heard tht oil inn wets iwlag mad to luduo Dime to lull Ire ballot boll beiHimuel UtbMulialdha MW wont cur ballot boa in HID reittehineul lout utlbul bird precluot t leiwen I rod r oolook on tue morning stet tb eltotmu Wllnitu remirnl It wae 010 ulc pleni lo bare t leut Tte anus ware Inchiu I ul ttornmil Kill he hnlii bran Mlon Ibere John J Hoi a Iblrd I preclnot I IIJ r voter WM at x ana 8 on l < tti 15 day 11w In lit ttsotum fib rOIl1 lId nioHjr wltb rue I IIIIUI tv tunr lultI 1 II Ionbo rainic r if the Halt I < ake TVioMiM MIU he knew no euoli ireou re Juupli urJouu irennan V nru Idll VVllue ha I u bruiber mailed Marlin 1 JuJg 1ewen In ahJIt IIM heon Unflrl to In tuUetmiuu heal lh Irlih Itepubllmn ol tbli allylad Ih uuin of the l < unaiii were mm nosed 1alnok and 1 Merlin uat ellbtr rIme a fund ur wnu wllnnif l1 ralefftut cur the purpxe ul yiuK n mm nenifd lrnuau fur lultiiiii the I Kllol but ol Ih Hiojlul lraalrt In I favor ol lo HIM bawl l for shorn aid aiiaiDtl lleivvy Hardy Ii Ihr soy truth In It Toll It I not auiweted lit Ij > nnan moil euiiinMlmlly And you hvu saw beard ot If r y mi bijuo llxbl ° N lion iutwni he equally > IIIV leply Attorney llllerN kEy olaltne H t Hut tliv taUuieui 5w roaJput in Judge Pow cr riitu ouuunl aikeil aikeilUj Uj you know Ibe putallon ot Jo OHrleu in iin oouiiuunlty tit trutti aud veraoH 1 Will re 1 think Hint I It well re Ublbbeil W bet Is I t good or bad Oh bad U0WdIJ CummulonT K W Talloek IiheU by Atton y Ella stored 1 Ibal at thus Ilm III writ i uf prouiblllen wet eer ved t be oouimlieloiwre ha J gone into the ballot box of full 8 mud had lIbr uiid or wore about lo open that ol poll a Th rwull ebnwetl a dlflereiicr ol rollout IM votei hotwe i Ibe tlly tbeete and III btlloie Unu In Ills box making a chauu uf IU at b0 votie gKliiz tht llpmuoraU 49 or nit mai and III Hiiutllo oe that taucli lees I hat would ullcf all ILe iJeiiucrallo candidate Ho eanr the brnkun kty In tan lock 11 oux No 1 When lhr subject ol gulag luto ibo Loire wi Ihl lroaoned be bllved winilh log 5u aid 1 abjut Tinucln hut Im did not rtmemtor wnat II wanuggialed that oouleeKlial or wervuuvut to bu 1 lniltut unJ matt mat-t mefore It woo advliable I Ilm Com nllulou to KO Into ha ballot bouoot the Tnlrd jirnlucl Uo did rut re mtmuer whether or not any grounds were etatvd at lust lime tor lkiuit till 101 Ijter bon II Wl Call I that Iliu IrtllUi had leen lniiro < rly oouuleu and thai Ilio tally heel did nut how the oorreit nuinur of volee 10 which 1110 otudldatM lids vu tlllfUDj Dj you know Inked Atlornvy tllr buw bore boUt wr kopt In tin lime twlwcvu their recepiljn by III CommUloii and tub luoeptlou of tbtio uleotlon cuutelt A e 1 uuuvrdud It they were Jepoelled In the room aoroN the ball irom the working room ol the Join mlMloii > loom which had but ono door and 1 which woo always kop locked NVltuee refeired Ibo lotus generally and not a to soy puitlculir preclui1 Julia a number of billot hug ui alro lu Ib Coniml iloui working roam Uonimiwlour Hlienmn aUo loillfltd a < lo Ibo luiuul by rue Uummlieloii and urn other mtlter imiineluJ w Itli IhHunJeltaklUK Thl mierooou Cnnlrmun Iolcher wai twilled br Atlorney llllr > Ho WM inMlluDd tin the eukfect of the brukcn key In the luck of liui Conttllii tlan box from poll 1 and UU that lIbl lJ Cuwtolnldn JII when the Coaiinldlon oem t > nuho IbereoouaKnn Nuvehibtr 14 III iiiuro xa obevrvod lo Ito toiuoihluK lime pert of a key In lh loot Omnuiulnur Hlienuan had Intlinitel mat extra cum ehuuld ba I taliun us there woo rumororuiinl I ouiicerniuic allegoj It renularlllt Ill thofleolhiui Ash it what InJucul I the Couimla clot logo Into the ballot bug whose a5wtd III tii0fep 15 tls oil the taus of Ibu relurni WllneM war inlnrro galud 1 IH to tho place lot kitplug 1n gballot toile I liter their rtoel t ut tltr Coininmio i building 110 1 lift a member of Ibo nin vaulng buarJ WM re u11oJ b 1 > Allor nay JllltM and wa on tho laud when the Mwa rejiorl clonul |