| Show TH TO BL ME I fire Commissioners On the leiiiJ Case VERY GOOD ADVICE GlVEN Fiiorltlsn Will Not Be Allowed In the Department KElIMUt miIHMIIIimi > lN TIUN I or Toko ttstie I H UK llnnitiof Ibid r lUililn I The are and pollc comrnliiloneri bavi alter citrtul oonilderutlon end ritliw flhlihed Hi complUltoo ot their report lo Mayor JlMklu 01 the belling In lb caie of Chief Divine until u nol oouijleted The wOIII we Chairman tale bout this afternoon Jinolngi ImmedUtely ptntnl a COPT of the finding to the Mayor they sos ai followit UiUCLUXTIlrsllOAIltlOV1 fOMOe AOl plug OomJlSlIONlaIK HALT LAKK CITY Utah July itb 1603 Ta the HonoraUe Mayor of BIt Luke City Utah BlnThe iloird of 1olloe and Fir Utniniliiluneri cud tu be proved U mon James Divine chief ol Ibo IIru Cepjrlmeut of Halt Luke Cllj a OJP 01 Ibe chirgnure erred by IJHuiii van and oIlier > and n hearing wai had benson lasting live lull diyi and end lu July lid 169J Of thu charge preferreJ Its followIng I follow-Ing were nrlcken cult Under Iho tint ipoclllcallons then obirge rrgirdlug I Ibo huldlnir I uf iccret dl fIO ULf osomloge wills loader of Ike Itepubllciu fully audio hiaouaolog toitticul totlor upon the elliot and I In unending Ihe lie put llcu ttlwcuoat Murray Coder the tint i 1IIIclllun Ibcro wooden woo-den ulckoll out the charg that orsturn do out 110 Iuolly 10 Ibo ullnt cbltf or his rapulni but are Irauimltted llitoiuh third paulo Un lor Ibo ocond ipecllkatlon tlioro woo utrichru out tilt ilitcelhiit 1 Iho clue ilI hut 1 iwoUnletiu I Ullbtoil I at nlcht which hove lui re on ibo outillo uf Ibo aleamir at J > o J hoops and under third paragraph A I with reference tolls number or hour off etch week wore klrlcken out The ta rnnindyof tbe cbaruw were ronildernl m detail kill all of the evidence obtain solo wi coutl lend Cuirtel 1 Hpeolflcallon A Allot ctrelully weighing the tivlaence we ire of the opinion lhal Ibu following conclutloni are warranted cod wl I lib up rub charge lu III ordeil ellnJ lhat HIP elilif hue imokoJ upnn the apparalui floor al line when be would hi imoklnc III III ollloe cud would be called out upou Ibu floor la look after come matter hole II pegs fit referred lo In this clurge li I n tub undo by Ibo chief lot ills government of tlio choirs soil into sod while itrlctly ipuatlug 1 Ibo Chief lerlinpi I li iiotiiunniblo tt till Ilb J lull blosaeit l tlUK I I oiiu ratil ty liln 1 lot thcuTTcrnniclitot the tlllctrs soil lain uiurr him yet the oplulou of the commission It I tint I lug M the Inn die itobiUllid from uioklui upon till fl or that Ibo chin itaouldobirtfa the 51105 lulu us litliiR much unto con oucUo to food order und Ultolp Int l Change 1 HpcclUaatlou I wilt ttttrrnce lo taklax lull lu pollllta ton eroilno p tOnoloo There wai no ovldonco tint the chit tad boo a diletata lo any politic cOllnolloo Dr that he had liken any tulllo pail In any polltlcaloanToalloD lot Ibo vTliloucu UliKn Hut III thief WMU attondanoouon > ollllo 01 l m utlni < nt Ilaiu and woo shout upon tho lloor of the liouo tMklo5 with UIUicut InillTliluili and api > i tutly Uklni oooilileiablo InKtcil In tb > I racmdluic I Italia l apitari Ilia uW Hie chief lea moral I et of the oiroutlf ccramlttrnof the lltpubllcan League Clot oh Utah Unitary b CO 11110 II die of tile njlnloi Hut while tbli acllvlly 10 Hillllct may nol litTiikcon rattle I to an cutout 10 t lotitlero wlili the lllcluDcy 11 the floe Or ttm nl yet tho ohio It vlglatln Ibo iplili I net the IdIot ol tho law l and we shall II the future IB Slit upon hli rtfralulDg fiotualttnJ > nce atoll politico cjUTentloix ind Hull rriUMl him to resign bh Icillloiinimembir of tho eiriutlv estuuilltof of the lUiubllcan Jo lIe flubs of Utah In our opinion the Chief ibould not l dye Ihe cloy for tile utMie of attindluic political COIITUI tlODi and hli mtmketiblp of tbvti loutUe commltlee of the Hipubllca LtijUB club mutt iiori Mlly rcqulr M him a paiilclpatlou In ally IOIHIC I bleh the pll 01 tha law I at lent Of 111I Jhirge Ic 1 Hpeolllcallon 2 wtlk Iei < uceto enteiltiK III unltotm ally linen white plrlluoiH mull or Intoi llllIuuu mal CltlDg llUOII kto sold Tile eiUeuaiiitliolcieg that upon the lain the public exhibition I givois hty m hat r IbOA Ibu cblet f uulrtud Ibu OoiurJ Ilooa wlih Chlct Illuford of Ogdou All tbe leillmony on the matter of bl MlK In I uullorm ln wai that he I woo 10 I Uilfomi all lay IhU ohtfo WM al lhs UnlnnlnKOI Ibuhearluiradniltlo r vy IU olilef r but oilssoiaiou woe alter ward withdrawn and the proincullu Pill Ipon Iholr 100 hVu think I the otldrnii I nbows Ilia f cblef aid I enter the Oxford Mloon 00 his day doled I I ill I uulfurui and WIllie 101 toll 17 hub l o U5 under Wistful the rbllro is i brought Is I a tu0 nmj by I ie chlel I for tho contrnraeiit of Ib imctn and taeu uuour him we are o i lhuophoi10 thin niln theuitool tub II > I H ° 6J KOitruInu lbs uio ol tobao eu lueclilul ought In the littered 01 f tOt Uliolpllue I < refrain from onion K0 loouexceil I lu hiss I lotloOloafiCu 0 iihliiiutlei l Uliolo I au oocailou whu I alt buuer tnior or member of lisa JOB Olallniolit would to lohILI1 lton ILliu 1 HpolHcallou i i charg I log I thf chief will filllUK In return hiss kluUiot Ike omcers oDd I alan A number of wen tiitlflid that the dun had ailed 10 retudi limit soul los when Ihrjthoi lit he niunt ace inin lull on tile other hind tile Ioshieso iy ol Ihu coin ous that he hId lover nowlnuly I ftlltd 10 rriilltl I Uilfniil I lust If be hd toiled lo Oa si I moot have 11 whn ha WI rIlgoged III rrriatloii with sonic one ci 1 Aol bad failed to see the laluli of r the ubordlnnle except upon ouo or Iw I i ccMlotii when Ibe chief itat ho toiled lo return the talulu III UMCI I win the lUbjtdlDain tluiliK haj reriouily foiled solute tile oblol D ucDiumliilou are ol I the opinion h1 the IUuro 01 Ibe chief lo lalnle outlet such oleuml cI Is I YenJ ichHiiiblt ihoui the tubordlnate oi I all lo laluln hue chief he onKhl to be called 10 ONo and If hli latentloni Were lo wll ullj thaw illirti icl 10 the chief the I illenhrt should be irimpliy IJ bi r fined or reporuil to tie commlnlJD but ou uulIIJ11 ooelluu n rluln 0 nniwir the talule of inch uu ulleuder bed uie he hid on a former onIon not ihown proot retpeot to Ibe chief li In Ihe opinion of List com mlmoii nol Ihu way lo unlih I mem bet ol the force and we ate of toe opinion lhal it ulule by a lubordlnale lu Hichl tmould alwayi ba rrluriuJ by him uo matter what Iho relitloui are between hue child and such lubor gloat linage 1 BtiiClflcallon I lli whit reference li huldltu I I Ibo Heart oluck The cjtilmllilun Hilda thli charge lo be wholly uuiuitaluol and Illlly riidonei all Hut lui boon duo hy use chic with relirercu to Ihe buds that have siam Into till lundf Ills luilruotlaui WOO tu hold such fund In Iie huh until Ibe baaid hould decldo la what ut0o Itiey should I be ap hail hue boar hid diad under coniMer atlan Ibo viUUIiliauiit of I relief fund but BI yet uo ditirmlnillou hai seen reached In regard la I Toe eldeuce rru > rd 10111 Hiitri check bowl lhat Mr Hull btoiifhl Ihe chick lo the olllci of tbo utile the ohl1 aol secfeiaoV Ilu retent and that nolhlnewaiiald by him at tise lime In I regard to I what dlipoilllou ihould be undo ol lie money liiereolfliiKil Ibo check wai reported ported by ttaei cblxf to tbe li I and and ulna a depciltid lu Ihe bank lu ho I limo ul Iho obl1 etiRlneir with other loonIeS drrleest 1 Iroui KlH la Ills do irlmtul I and muuiy dId Item llcei lIuTh chlel acounti of moneyi re colted fram Ihtie lautiei ate es hiatuc lily lo hue boar Charge 2 1 ieclflc l on A lure good lo luHllcUtcj at llrrr VetJ lUll erldenru W151 Utuu upou Ibli paint aud alter hearlUK all of Ibu ofllec Ibo hoard are of stia 0 Inluu Hut all II Ihe llrri mentioned In tbu ipeclllcitloc were elllclcully Inudlid soil Hal nu mole water Woe uied linn good luJic local at the lime uf Ihe hire would ulctatc III eeirt after a tire tony how much water should have leei uied than to know durliiK hIss J rogri i of Ibe Dm how much li lie eonry 00 p I tout the fIne Uootjrcttf afire depatlmtnt li I lo put out a Iliaaiipuidlly aipjulule I khd ireTeul tIe iprendlug ID iloluc tbl nioti xattr nuy louiellmei to used Iban a critical examination of Ibo remliei I after the lire li I oter show to bato len luciiiary The uie of dale mutt reel lirK ly upon tIle Ulirttloi ol the lukoruluale cQIceti ala mm and the board ate of the i pinion Iba lu all of the bOric rosilult000d t t lu Ihu ipvclltoalloni both Ihe chiluefa and Ibo men did excellent work Ubirin 2 Hcolllcition 1 > hint at t the Waltner Ulothlni lire JHOI fee ot hoie wnru laId out and that lu cat of another call Ihe chief could huh lisie ponde4 wIlls tbe kiss Ihu board ate of the opinion that Ibo chief ihould use care lu kee log hI I lonlble Dine boa toned Which could le I liken to uuotber alarm hut lu Ihe olio Initaucid the lire wai ad jololiR Ihu Cullcn liottl and Ihe nl drnce shows thai there wai iinoke In I the Culleu hotel baieinenl and It woe aol kluoWIt at Ills beginning of Ihe fltr whither II wu lu the hotel or not and III vIew I of tho faot that Ibo ill IlbUI t roll wai a large 1 building Illlel will gocsle l the commliilon are of Ibe oplu lUll lot the chief wai warrantid III I 11101 out all of the hoie lhat woe laId out at trie tire Churuo 2 Bpiclflcatlon Lwlt tile fell Ce lo hating iteiiu r < out 01 eovifls The evidence ihowa that the Uauiur at Home No I hai been 10 I lurvlco ever ilnuo tile lack el wale priiiuro In tuoiprlni and that I han ha-n T t teen cuitonury to have Ike 510010005 III active lervlce with a nor mil water prenure but are alwayi bold lu ruidluin for a i ooud rail Ib dlOO III No 2 konee lice hisnet bun In aftIva onlea Iocu loud belo Cblel Uevlnei appointment by Ihe Mayor 111 I kept In readlncn for ft itoond cal riieapiaratuiat No 2 houio coo iliti 01 hose wijon boo test 1 sod steamer 1 li I lni ttttlrely neoenar that Ihe hoia wijon and reel 1 bo lakeu at once to u fire I they moat uecu tartly beuiedbifore the iteamer and In a majority of Icitincea ttau iteunie li I noTer und at all In addition 10 Ibl there aro at No J no place for lImbs fr Ibe iteamer Here are ilalli for five lionet 01 which one li I ton this aalatauh ohlo buggy twoliorieeforlhe hoie wagon soil ono or Iwo Itunso tot Ibu h usarnil 1 according to whelbir I one or Iwo hone reel li I lu lerTlce II will ther lute bo iron Hut I li I Itupciilble 10 t hove s Iluml 01 Hiatltu 2 lu active lorvlci and liavn It teipuud upon a bosh oil Kpeclllcatlon SIhiiI undur Ihe earn obirge lu 10K ard tu laklnic away IOU feetot hoe from Home No J thus evidence show Ibal when tbo Iwoboriehctereel wu uivd ther were 2000 feel 01 lime at Houie No 2 In tuillut the iteamur lu I > LHV lerTlco It became ueceiiary to pill I Ike one uotio reel at No 2t reducing lbs aiuouul of lio > e to 1780 101 Thli wai the but t tbu Chief could do with tho apparatui and honoi lur nlhtd LhatKu live Hpiclflcatlnn iiJSl 10 I regard la not liuvlnn nulll onl fore upon Aerial ladder truck Ibo evidence ibani that It Ukt from one thlri to one half of the I o lIre roo of lolli hOI to roperl mm aerial ladder tttlcU whiohI loom llvo me at a tire The chkf iLfdi oullo a fire ovilh tho aerial laddor truck two and torn lImos Ihlue men udrlvir I tilliraia and loninlluiei u nun oa Ihe nut wll h thu driver All of Olin other uiemle or the dtl attinent 11 ie oudlni It a oil are aiiUrifxl toappiratii whloli will t1 t there flrit and which will In all uuiau probability lu herd but lute I rtcotil ul tbe Uepatlmeul ilnon Ibo 1 < IOhl 01 the 11 Iflok ehuWs hluh lily iiuin ram bccatlaui bull been > uiul at at The loitd ale tlronic Iy I of Ihf o Inluii that the kulniiUKUt of the lueu la tIle > pp taiu > by tbo enter 1 judlcluui and 100100 i I cir laluly acorns lo the board that tool uJitmeul would dlctaie that In view uf the limited uumter of men III the derailment Ihote wo have ilioull be I R lIen tl a Htrat ijulckly a l IOaiiile sail upo Ihe lIalu > hull U I limit lot In servIce and we recommend Ihual lisle iliiK > illou ol Ihe men be uiitluued ouulnuol Ciiaruo 2 Hepeclflcallon 1 In regard to latoMInK up lire apamtui atd mint tins cart will twentyloot item on and twelve lout laJdir and faIlure Iu Well fire haute No Z mare lull once a month The evldinie ill iw > cod the board Iready knew that the apparatui Hut we have Iliac been repaired The bra lice endeavoral lo ad mlulnter the ifliln of the de > arlmeul se ecanomlcally I poeilble aul not bake rciulilllon for new apiaratui where old would leudir tlllclent ervlce The hoie wagon at No 2 houie li I nol ai good WIKUU a < II ibould bi but 1 bai always rendered illlcleut erviceatflrei and while the board would very muoh like to purohaio a new Is ice waxou yet In view I of the necenliy for economy In the oil sIre of Ibe city w hive thoofihsl bat the old wi oa coull be uiii with safely lit ometliue langir NVllli regir I lo lbs hoio wagon with weuty foul eziesusion twelve fool had Uef tile board 1Iooa Iu Olin nlaeuc UID Ih ulol and alu tuollod Ihe ppIII rslertoth Is I sod ito of Ihu 111100 111 his lulsleoo do nut rlll Ike w1111lulellllly top bonl 10 Implr lbs lulIo or nonihst I do giruui in reiplu llni lo dlittlcti In thli city 10 which I Is lmur > itlotble lu enod the aerial touch It li rude uty la have lid diri Upon the bun trajan with which ocond and thirl tory wIndows uf dvellluiri tan hue relcbeJ rho nlalc III rgurd to Ills ftc 1c1 with which Ike chief yhsIha loul No 2 we IhI Ollllul be 111 not go lot Iwo or lure leech sod onllm Wee Iiiete uvery li hue bOla 101 los ollnlol Ihal lOts obl e Is MIuIloJ Cluange O rlo lnalou iieI I I changod bl reusno of lark of 1laR 111 on the 101 ot f CII lJvioe 1lu1 ware no My 011 sOd tlh 193 only IWo 11 II charge 01 Nu 2 l ° sue llocas lt Illul hour Il I sbOlctiy 10lllado hy lbs chIef cod I only 10 mn wore hell 10111 hUII 00 Ilsoce dope Iho oOer lu clalg 01 Ike bouo h rUIIIIu Ihero ilse IIUIUY woe Ihll Ike captain propound Iho Ibeaul 01 roal heun Is soy event I Wol reli teisutu lots lu II oilef haying gbargoo010e hOU Whether cplalo or allIII ollul lu How all but two men lo beabienla the name lime Hfirfllfloatlon iCi charge Cble Uevlue with belUE surly and inapp ill luukhly sod dictatorial tbireb breedIng a feellug of dlioanteut sod IUd imouR the roT ro-T evidence upon thIs point wa CJnlllctlnif and wo Afoot Iheoplnlo Ibal Ibe ubirge wai 1101 luilalued tipeolllcitlou D clutue1 chatg the gOld with faliute to harmomie toe men sod allegti that the chief and I litant chief have uot teen ou speak InK teimi for month excett whe putillo duty hai undo Ibo uochahsgo 01 wordi abiolulely uectuii rle ovldsote ihowa lot when Ike chief came Into Ihe diparluiuil thpr Was 5 lack 01 111011 11100K Iho 01e01 Ihtttbeiuwire 10 iccIous cud Ibat II I articular I Ublel Uouavan and Uapul Bulllvauweru bitter entinlei and hd tome altercation utter Ibo chief nui Into thideparlmeut that lu attempt UDI la reconille Ibvie Iwo olUcir Cut tain Dauuvan Uoli oil ueua I tome celiiuio of the conduct ot theie nun lo I words each other and Ibat for a Urn lbs relalloni between the chief sod I Biilitant onlef wire itrilaut that Ian iprlug lists iitrauiemintwai remored Chaue 4 1 with rolernuuo to ftvorll hi 01 IndIvIduals We ktu of Ihie 01 lulon that thli chatfce WOe not mi Ulred Change The tint ipeclflcallo chauei that Ud McCarthy acted us uurie girl lor Mn Uevlne and tha he used nulerlal bilongluic la Bal Like City In miklui B wardrobe und cOast of draweri for Mr Devlne family flu ObI thai MrMiOarlhy ached at uurie girl woe nut luitilned byev t dine Tiio evidence ihowi tint a wardrob sod a cheat 01 draweu lor sac In the Ui irtment wears Wade by Mr McUar thy but that the arllclei made ore fix J turns und properly ol the cily SVIieu the former council chimbi was IUfol ovar 10 Ihu fins 111001 by the City Council the board Intruded ed tbe chief ta mike the necimry cbaugci wllh kt llllla expeni la Hie oily ai pgnlble and ta employ the membeiiuf tbe force lu making lisa change whenever poulble 10 lo du There Wine uo cloiot In buss deart ascot niilliuiil lo Ibe chief and out nt old material on hand the department carpenter at odd whenever r he woe tool needed In tlss olher work of tlse di urtmenl made a obetl of draw eri and a wardrobe which are tbe roperly I of Iho city at above ilaled and Ibo uommltiloneti aro of the o Inlou tint Ihli action wu tiro1ier olh IbJ g Charge 8 Hmlrallon II1 I ai lo discharge of MM MoUlnnli and employment em-ployment of llobluton we ole of Ihe OII lulau li luot luilalnnd Charge f Hpeclllcatloni C and ID lu regard to member ot the di I ailment uolUK rlvale work for the filial and falling to bo able la respond to hue alarmi lu couieitioucv 1 he evidence ibowi thai when leI le-I upurlmenti were being filled UI wIndow were waibtd and floor icrubbod by mt > mleri of Iii dcpaol mol lhat Ihli wat work which would < havu been a oharieupuu Ihe oily sod hIss evidence ihuwi that Mr 1atil woo hull 112 60 fur lurvicet ho reudered but we aruol Ihuoplulon lhal the charge that lie wai moved Irani one houSe lo lUjUlllOll uolhur Its toiite iuonc < i thereof li uo llio evidence iliown Ihut t 00 lone 00 cation I miuubiir ol Ihu depirlmeul while wurkllii at Ibo filling up 01 tbo chief rom dId iiul ktt down In 0 VOt ttHUIQ OH Jag bite 1 BOrH TO BLAME Iottlnuttl ran fuye One lime logo wllh loIs t > iiralut lut was laken Is Iho file In tbo chlela buggy ChareeO lit rexanl locouJuit un LtcuiuiCR oufllcrr and a eeutlmiD we are 01 bloc opinion liuniuilalned I lliHu lino evidence U mow tbat mIst dual hid acted ulber than lu a tn lou y minner towarJa Itiiur > u emeu 01 lisa illy and Han Fran ilii I bill on HID jullary iiveinl In turam moll tuttined tbat lImes bad aiweyiilieii I xirnutd every tourUty l y hadaiktuf r 11 retatd In t oifcitton C mitt llK a Ivller lu Mn Ol 5 OliO bloc evidacrotholvitbit Ibu letter to Mt OLoonu uu wiltinn by liieiccretary cf Ibo dlpartiueni lamn was read lu iivltlturn abd III I tbe ulnlon ol tbi ccnimliilin It wIll liintleiuanly sad pruir Bpecineilloii Ulu regtrJ In liy luit ta tel Welch la wer to harem luotiuiptleucy MO urool tbe opinion Ii not aunalbrd Ihorota III dr 7 wIth rfrooe 10 uilnjc ciiy proi oily for houtebold pur pone ana in iiiiug boor Judgment In I iiirbnliiK luppliea lor Ibudeparlmenl we nllIIIU 01uIIIId The only mppin > uod by tbe chief wiiaaliurulihrd by tbe oily ion the heatliiK ol hli ajar menu In corn lUll wllh Iboiecf Iheiueu Tueio vti no IJeuoe that any do Iota wa 0nluold ton Ih ohlel aol Lh oesIdr b ban lread1 beell mentioned In rcxBrd 10 i tn m 1tK 1000r bay Iha vidiuo > il oil that utica liiy w a ollmil ion dlsa II o Ii was nol ui lolheiiniuin I It utivitber n oliu or a rtdtttli c main tonal tbe tier Cbarce No hi wllh luftreLie lo favotltlini lu ton nomOtIo nt the meu wraieotllieoplulon II I net luilalned Hit Loud alternlvliig cirelul con lldirMlon I to nil of Ibe stdemoc stir tf Ibe cplulou lilt nulthtr ildu In thn romrovrrry Ii I wholly vtllhinl tltnie wo era 01 the opinion however thn no tTlteicewar 1 pruiucid and that Its luch itkir ul illill exIilK ai would wonant Ih aatosiIo ho n cr unioval < f III chief I lirir trim Uillminy to the elliot list Ilitru 1 ol l > au liiiialnri I In the ilefiitment lu regaid lu reruoT alt mid bear inonj the luvu that they were iclni lo lie I lmovou bloc cjiiiraliilon dimre llmmemberiul llh lieiaruneut hi ucdmland tbat Ibe JIo J board I icrdct y Iroparllal I aud will I allow r u faTorlllini lu the adralulilri II9II of the depirlmonl and lint LO iniimbrut lbs Oipnrlment hIred tear leoicvil If 1w dot hit 1I1j an the otherlitnd wu desIre tliu derarlmrnl 10 nuuerilaud thai no luiutwrdlnailou or altrmpli l to create dliiei lion lu tbe 1 lultuielil will Imnil rated I I IUN V JiiNN 3 ih YI 1 K A lMIt TllAMC It MlinlkXD ommllleo loird ol 1 mice and Fire I Caoiuiliilmi |
