Show J iii f lANE SHUT OUT Tbe i Snpremi Court Refuses to lltar Him In Argument CCIUHU 01 HIS rillHOUS TALU lu lIme llrtllon usalie I lies a Vigorous Irotnt Ihcreon In 1Orlihhy I tess not al nmoolli lalllnc 10 the Hupootne Uonrlrovmtlilt morning One huhgh warn Imo nnexecledly and untied Attorney John M Zone aod hi Illlla boat to shoe Tbo JilJuen wore lIstenIng to Irgil jumculiln tug election cater At homey Iarley L Wllllamt bad fin babied Otis clmaluhluc reinaiki just beforo lulgll noon liaTliiK urged all bo loul biy rould on the halt of the Utah oiniDliHou at appellant and then I was that Attorney John M Ztnc c f I mniel fur the reffondenti meltpboil ally CoIled I hit sh rove ire aratory to launching cut lli hu nat not fur niitiy ineonui UpOD bit heel Mrino n > d saId soms thIng en I > Hun f deroK lory to theIr lOUort who IheoiMwaibtloraJiid Jarlch In the lower court and Ibry mold not Forgot I now J was upon iltlbat Ibis irltf dlilojue wai spun Ubunirl bad got only I far at IUD wordiMay It please the court when hu win Itterruplitl by ChIef Juttlcu Merit woo 1111 lleioro you iroceed Mr 7inv I wlili hi aIsle thai blue court ban I Inloi mallon that Ibo following ttntement wai made by you readlni frum aloe neWspaper of Jaouiry llhhmhl 11 Mliey desIre lo get tbii cue Inti Ihiu Hu leino court freed front Hie toni I uf odium wblcli bat lien oait UIHIU It by thete frauui aoa forijerlit upon lit t elurur lau lice to may tbat I tbu > UK lioel up I lu thIs manner there It I Ittla doubt what Iba Hupieme couri oonttltuied at Itti would UoHtwul Ills IUHOD t Utl ail iiiuited by tbe court teen IIUUIH Ills ililel utllcr lo esk wlialber you made lint itttemeul Attorney Ku dellberalelyAt hits time md allbl hOI 1 muu di dine lo aniwcr your quvilion Judge J Merrill Then you uied not iroceed Atlurney ZonoIlak an exception and 1 would I like to shale my axceptluil upon the rotund Judgo Merrill Take your teat Attorney Ziue Don your bouor dc tionWe chIne tu allow ma to take my xovp We decline to hear you at all Von may itato your exception In willing solo fIle It will tba clerk rIIC o Mr Nuns needed uo further admoni fInn to lull down Ha returned ttbs tent but a moment later walked out of tIme courtroom and lab Olk Dunbuti chIli took Ui a IOU and paper and daihed oIl the followIng txcepllonr which he oil lime 101100 101 In fllloc wllU wil Uluk Jlaobeln accordance Wills tIle courla tuiEgeillool CUr UIIllonl In the 8ulremo Court of Ulab Territory Ter-ritory J U 1JiiO reipoudeul V J II Lttober at al appellant Man dumiit caiej pioulbltlou cute l Tbe court liavmc upon Ilia opculntf of tlio aritunient 01 John M Kane attorney for J VlJKt reipoudeut aiked Iba tld JohuM ZIII whether or not a curtain arllii nillllid la the Hill Lake dally Jrtiuiw was authorized HI blruieir auu hOe saId Joliu M Zoo bavluK declined to aniwer tlio said ijueitlun and Iba ojull uavlog r 11 bused to permit lbs laid Jobu M Ziue to ttatn llli exception but Having peruilttoJ him ncollOD exception ex-ception In writing liu comet now and aIID cc nor sod ohecls and rX tepu lu 110 slid rullui and action of lIme count for tile rrai IUK I nat the tald 1 court hat no rIght to iWo the mid Mane tu untwer Ohio kail ijueillun I it me reaiou that hit nniwit tnerulo miKlit tend loexjiote blui to a prooeedlliceither tit ooulompt or fjr the luiiKnlllon cf u i anally and there fore tbu mid I Julia M Xiue It proteotej by willclllij tiinflitutlouai irlocl pIes and by Iba adjudlctlloniaf mona from auiworlni tbu scud I < iut < lluii S flial ibis pioieut uccatlon It I neither lIme prof ir lime nor lime pioper I lice for auy pr leudiu baled upon Ihn alleged arlklr 3 Tlmt tba mi m John M Zinc by nrnlikemeut Utwieu ilia ocuuiel lur lbs r iiilent wan iteiunud aOI1I pre puio t locke the vuuuliiK argumtul lu favor ot bile reiiondent gum hits action ol tIe ojutt lacot lha rptpouu oUt al a dlsolvaotse all hat a tend tory lo reludlca hit rlgbt 4 loull onjl chill of hImself lie 5511 I John Hiue ileiina tu Irmuleat noalioc holly but firmly aiulmt the ac tloi uf ton molt for Iba I riaion blot It baa n lenduLcy tolLtifjro wall WilI lie ndependeiic 01 HID mar to Ia i Ibu I lur luiubjnrvlinie tu tliu oouit audlu delroy I tie j t ojullduoe u j lltlKHiilt In reijflii up > n a fmlum aJvouoy of heir I rid I II In coons cf law JOHN M I ZM > Ulu Ior hoe teimuitdeitl i lInIng Ibo litlance cf tho caa Ion lie otloiidlui ultoruey aol with Inn oolloaxuw and while tuklug no ha I t 10 tie talk ho made blmielt ionn n unfjl by occatlonally proniptluc aud olledui iUiReitlouilu an undertone |