Show TIIIEDESDEFENSt I I 1 Opinsd Tbs Horalni Upon tin Close t f Ihe 1ocattoa 1 0101 E3117h 1 bIt Till WIIM SSL3 r Ilif Affiiiil hltr dId UllifM Trulirr 1 n < Ihleile 1 a Mold llrKliiml I i auilllld IIU Whir liciok I TIea tllhn irueeeutlon In the j riilele ruurdr tilal olMd at 1 10M lIla i 1 nurnliiir I nndoouuiel for the defeui i 51 I itartd In their 0 oresha by ctlllnK II II i II J wllnetee There erai aila a full lleudanc of ipeoUUiri during thu j I forenoon nnd hue Koiieral Interent In f Im praorvjloai ooallniiH tinabalvl j Tho aejuxd oucuplol hU aoeuilnn I I lout ImmidUtely lnblnl hH attorney i Me n Cherry A Cnirry and ex I hlbltetl all hie M unconcern Ha I Idem attentively 1 Ihe letllmony of II varloui Wlboaoenldlih o i < iloually J Indulge lu afilut iinlli and trIpe to Mumie an air ol ludlllf reoc Alter the NIWB belort iloiid i yelerdi allirnuen Henry W Weller via called by the proteeullon Ho I luslIllet hot he arilvud at TIlliJtN I taloun curly on thu uiornlnic followlui 1 Ibo murdir Thleilo wee In he I laloon aud laid mmei e of a b had killed Ile wife Ho also elated that two men hailhouht lotun whliky 1 Irani Him the prevloui nlfhl out h I believed tbry killed her Tultd < vn i1 viclleJ and sold All I lute left now limy cblhdes At I Juncture Judgo ltowa > ilatnl f llialoieor hli wltueiiei was ibtenl txit that h I would rut hli caiu by way II If Jobs Cherry was ready to pruceid I with luoueleuie Jujge Cherry auiwend that he woo rt II OII not F bored tu I roceed al that time 7 u oaurt Miiurn d till ID a m lot ay I Wnen court ouuveued Hill muinlui the pruiecutlon called bIte Kva llnric a bweuv who reildei near the Ur uiima riurlter al Murry and a hew 11111 lies walk from rhledue iiloon rilie leitllled Iliniuith Interpreter HUele huh mo kuew Mr Thlod by llIhl now her ou the eveulDK be huge the lr Kedy rttie came to wIt DIMI loU abjul 7 clock alone and had beeu cryln 10 01010i hued m iu about five uiinulee nyluic sue wai mulHgkoIhshItW1VSWer51nt00110 111 Iol tula < I in bal utUvl KO I r uohll d d Ih 1tlr b wllneill ovideuc b irlokuoui i 7 he uroutid Ibl I wulrrelvaTilauJ lujii > lilal rue oMeollou wa uver ruled John AnJenoo of Murray next J Inlind I eniwer lo Judge howe that kn reilded about U yanii fruui riiledee nloou Uu thu uluhl telore Ino murdir alter ie had gus la bed lie heard icieami CjmlnK iruin Iho ent sIde I uf tho Kluuu Iney web not very loud an I wllueii could not en y whether they Wore thoie ot a won uc wuuiau wolUIr Cherry Jr wllneii auiwered that hn weultubwl about Iou oclock Ou hit way hoinv ihurily before IhU hohaJ lieu Mr Tuled iilllUK la lbl of Ill eOloOn Huw do > ou know thu tcriami oiinulrom Ihiedeiialuun fliey cainulroui tOot illlccbolo I nilihl hove 1u uluo one reiou lug ou tho ui > Ubly roaii uilght 11 loKur all I can tel W K llllpj ll r 01 Ihe county Jill dialed liS IIolr < L eiu uuulliied there be tclllla time He wai rUbt tuoiUed ro were hIe UDy pow 1011 ilid Ihe wllue 1111 VrIKOI OIBNl TIlls old Ihe cue for Ihu proitcu tlon aud tIe defeuiu Illou upeued 111 llJub > calling A V Mlll r civil engineer of Ihli illy Whorl leallllej to piuoirlni I Iho p I aua of Tuledo laloou aud Ihn lurrouudlug 111 I wi aud aria the rauiu belug attched tu Ihu wall ot lIme courtroom bhlud lie wlliieaiataud Al tluo reiiiieit bl ouuael explained luo vail u < uliUucft tic Itjuer Keyieruf Murray wai tbu rbd next linen llullveaubout liJo yarui wc > t ol TuleoV iloon aud laid ho ha 1 HIIOWII Ibo Thledei alvut llvejfun Wilueia had worked around lor filled beginning about a yvar ago looking oflr 110 1101 5 allI allodln to Ih aloun during hli abtence While working theiu hs nln hIs meala at Thledei aDo ilept ul home riUlo what you obiervi l whllu you wore working 1r 110 the conduct ul Ihlede cod hIs wife toward oaou other I They got along ilrttratu ao far u I could tee 1 law uu ditllcillty between them1 utvuraaw him drIb lila wIts 111 aol oruw her wIll I hlck eye lld l > u ever tee Mr Tllludr ahow any oledhut act ul klu Jueia toward hit Wllt Wuat woe lhalt Abuut a yuir a to I took Mri Thledu to town ouo day and hu klued her got d byo beloru wv boll Jo ceo out and kiiaedher CouDiel was ahjul to Intirrogalo the Wlll lode 05 lolhvgneral lurnlthlug ot the 1hlede houtv but bite Howat ollecleJ JuJgu Cherry laid be wauted Ic how lhat Illlede had provide hla wile wllh a coiy hOI and had hilt ueglded her at lie I roitcullou had tou < hl tubow The iiuuallou wai allowed out wIt ueiaananured ilhtllod iood furniture In Ibo bout I boutWhul wai the clmiaottr and quo lily III thu food whlln you weiu thir 7 ofll I WM good and there I plenty taloou How olten dMyou piiilhe I Tilled rjiveral llmut a week Al any Hum when lining r while you worked here did you ever ICViiidmtif on t > < iyt t i n HbnUIIt Mont pace 11 I 1 II If UKS I Itsn ne Mri filled wllli blob era black reel eyt T Wllueii answered no Ou oar oc aston tin law Mil Tilled ill down MhlnJ tin Ur Mr ruled wai DI thr til dlit whether your OrlDlun bUD we b-UD er the Influence uf liquor at that 11m I luppoi Ibe wa Btie lookej tome to-me MluuiMD site was Uiunk Did you me her al any other line when you thomhi ih was uudtrtb lolliieija ul I quaiT Yi alter in tl Lj you know anything about Mr Tlileila olni ID harmony wulle you Wer there Yes Ine hIImlr went tbre lOtfrlller ai I UluJellliioJ WilD lurlhi r ilJ that herd bit brother rtlurued home about 103J on the II100bi before I be imrnla ui Ue lricjy Thy tasted riii tltt saloon Titer wit a light In tin house iud also lu Hit saloon JrovnuuilneJ WDMI itld he woe twenty ytrt of > K and let roliool l annul four years ago rllaca Ihen hitch h-itch bsuo > Winking around but hd bin tile tin lut moo lb Yu line been htnilnt around Tnlelej saloon r good nil of yew them Hie lit Inlclr days liaruul you utrl 1 Judge > liana I Vi at Ir WiialUolniJ1 I lleliiluiclhi fellows who ar running run-ning It n iw Wlliieii iM however lieulJulgcl uiuoil fur what In had i 1 I d UUP Titled always 1 treated hr nicely you my 10 In aiyou knew Vw altar What did you il > when Ion raw Mil fiileJ tall down behind the cuu nil T 1 looted its soup door went but through Ih weitdior iiiul II win liuine aul sit hfMlieie What pact 01 the day was Iblil lulliniBrnlBC Was filled away that day Yes III Bill likr I billet How lour wm let Lelor Mr Titled a we kill + It 1110 y have hn a month ur two Wer you working for Tbleda that Jat TNo air luau what brought you tb io lheu7 IhorI 1 wai going by Cud Just flopped there linlll a fact that you liar been ipeuUluu nearly very eruluf 10 lUleOullllooll 1 during the pill Ibne VjanT queried Ju lit I lineal Very sir JiuliteJ tin wllnui wllli torn shout I I ul reluctance Mriln Ilnou licit went u m the mUil Hall a mtoualt and 1s t > fled at Handy abiul uUvyeiti Toe dtleiiJaul he said li till itbeMii lw Wlloeii wirrlel till aloha about Ito year ago alit line then hal loan uii lullmlo harm with Tltedae pity Duilliii that elm lie bail VKiliU tlm liuuiu ales ur twice e iiunlh uiuilly on a Sunday lie uOet saw IIW I wrong between riiltvln and till wl > i ayer law him I rink tier ubr did l bearer uUtuu MeFhlbue wllli a black ar What tan ot 1 a boos war aiicJ i Judea l Chatty 0 to thus lurulib lugI It wan a nice oomforlibli homea netolaobomehortulcauouy aid ti Whitlese Who did you JI see MIa ThiN lltit On Hi lilstil ol Aplll SOIIi rids woo lb UUlit Attar tu thus burl Wit us and utbxi dray over tu Mur my In a Lug to see tbeliiduilrlil klinr who WMI eucauipeJ there What time lu the etruln i wn that About 8 oclock Whit was the apptilaiu of the Il tlouof ti rDDI and hits wllu un tint occnlOL They were fnendly I I Wr Mil mileiryi < rod from crylukt liuuot tell tint WllntM further aaiwerril H veral Ituudltd miuibtri ol the Induililtl luiy wtn > mo > ui il near the tmilier Were any ol hue men ruublux around den Th iU > illou was 01Joold to by the IMtiuilobwhirtuiuiu Cherry UII latued why he bad akid hI He I IU fib wanted la ahuw tbt with Ihu lire body ot men waiiUtrlnv around It was iloUlil > Hut hue deceaicil woman wai mjrJtrul hy IOIUDUII out 11 1 the bunter II utjecitd to hew > cboke4 OH by the irmiutlJU lu tel w W AfLr comb 1lk Judge llulch laid 1 1 counrrl iiiltht seek lu now whitbrr any them matvJ In thin dliecllan < > t the nloou and eaunelhrhed till 111 ttrrtiialbry arroniaKly DiJ you tin saod 1 lee any one 1 goluir In the dlnctlou ol Tuiislvi plan I lee err I law several RO lu that dlttOlluL In all ililectluu JuJne Howal Aur of them at 1 Tniiuei laioni whsujou went uvet lure lureNu Ihrrr were none i LuufN Iiriioii wife I of Hi irTlou > olio liallfleil that FhleU It tier Irolliif Hhe hail tieu lu Ihlirountry nbuut lour sad a bait year > Her rela l tloui wllb fliUilv and lilt wll bad lien always friendly a d ihe < l > lteii llinu thiew or rout tlruti taili uioutli rnievlvind till wllu also 1 ys1ad wit near Tell tea Jury what you obierred at o die tleiliueul ol the defendant toward to-ward hit wl I eaatd Judge Cherry All the tube 1 law them limy net frelloif liaip tpn tbei I taw no trouble wllli Iliriu WilD i bad I ealeu inill at ThlidVi place rnd the was always 1 a 101 labs IhIIod plrnly 01 II rle house Was well lunililied Tilled jcl tUluiil together wbll hula wile was III 1 Uormany 10 ea to bar I Hie hume lied up I oOOlIrlbl uefute her ir turn Mil Tilled had ihowii wlluna tieienli oljuwilry luuudlui a golf valet Whiten ihu raid tier husband bid liltm her Him bad itvu Mil lbl aw I a rth watch Wllueii next lulllled ai lo Ibe roll of bemelf and buibaml lo Tlilnlrt house on the nUhl brim the murder tTerylblun Hat then Irleiuly At any Unix during your acquaintance acquaint-ance with Mri bled dill cu erer aae her will a brulrej foe a bleak eye nr anything ul I that ItliidT < r iY liaw br one wllb a blue1 eye bat wai throe or lour moulh btfore Do you know how ill received UT > dh told m alto had fallen duwu Jamb Illoom of Murray salt lie I resided about tau mlniiltV walk from Tuledet laloou I and 1 luaU I Unowii Mr r and Mil Ihied soma lU yrare WilD hd worked hoc tile 0efeudunq Ile 11111I about u year ago What did you dot Mk d Judge Cherry Ob I did tTerylhlng wolked In tbn it ruD mf IB beer and Woe with thBlioriei Lauiihler Ibil saw Mil riiinleeteryday while he wai workloc there and uver ob erred any cuts et bruliei upon hat foes fftceDo you know whether she ever drank 11101 8n rank beer and whisky Did you uTir lie Mr ThlinJe wheo the woe aflicled by 11 1 i lot Yr lea winter IBIOI lul Hhe abed me to late a drink I let I rem up ibletem upand ihe not a Ilille bit drunk Lualiler diank ibcr ibdraukt < tio Ixu bter Wllneii wi l at toe anon about 10 oclock uu lue nUht ptlor 10 the mum hug at tue outlet Wai them anything unplearaht iben between fneje and till wlUT quell bed J uda Cherry No ilr Jog e Howat liked How many Kla ntlniyoii dlluk on IIIB occailnu you lifo meulleiival I bad annul four lnweleJ ells nei how miny hlhI1 U ib bad mele Via i that Ihe only time you bat teen her under the iLflueuCB ol llqu 17 Ye alree Court then adlournol for the usual UOOII Coo Upon oiutl rrixeraiilliiK Dili after null lourelta Illjoni of M liny wai tailed by the ueleiiir Hue reildri strut h1 a mile from Thlrdef and aid she lot nw Mri Thltde at Iha akxm IKJUI 0 oclock on n o uigui U tore Ihe tnuratr Atoms clot lb lielulOOll IIn I Into IB 1 cam tu wllneeaa hue ahd teoalueu abele llklun about line home Ibe was nouu wean at Intl How did she act lbe whole alter laT uooldu cried once t 111 when she went away iho wii In a good I humor Wllueii bail eaten with Mr and Mil Tilled at their table and heron w any trouble between then there UM you ewer > ee any wouudi ur bniiniou lien f rYe r-Ye > I hur our i hfr eye wt blue that was the only llnu Witne an > wi > dei Judge 1I0wIWIIn iltyouia lier with 11111 lion ere Wlliieiiniia nearly a year before she 1 wa > killed Wai Uu crying when ale como to I your boiii + V Mr Minnie Hmltb ot Handy lull gel Ibe lilted li 1l Her Irothrr Hhe had known Iba daceuet Mil InleJr lout ere 11 join and I lull 1 taw her 11011 Apr IJiu Llwfu eeteii and aught tolock In IhBavvuliig WilD aiooruianled bar buiband and olbei on thin lire Iron Handy Mr end ilr Thud Wale ineudly 1 at bat llmr llmrJtiw did Mil Thledu teens Ibo dhv apitated lo be lu a good humor Whops taw the dead lady of Mri Tilled next iiuruliiK II It lay upon 111 I bllliaitl tall filled I we luau Ihereunier aired 110 and bli Wile tilled wltutiii lnui tomilltr o bd wltuoit olleu ate uiiali at IliloJi lilx e In all your Tlillilherr who Mr and Mrrlhled caste t IIlbr itrve you coot beard them e ugiiKd lu a ijuirirUr dliuti7 Wlluti eau ha lad not ne lur had ahe 1 lien Mn fbled with a bltlllod or dlillgured lice Kiln Uilu a eloou hOI er ot Iii cly Mid I tin had known the fl Jre for upwiidi ol ill year and wa uu Intimate lermi WilD them II believed he bad Borer leeu Ml IblrdB with hlUh1I laory ad Ir at wllueaa olxerfillon fine IB aud Ire Wile Wet always on funnily arm Chart Hlmrp a farmer web llvei four lilies outhwet of Murray Mid he wolkld for liilede about two yeai ago IVItWU had eaieu will Mr auJ Mri Tilled al Ihelr lalilr and at no limn had he I tan any umleaiuluri between Ilieni ntr red MrIliluJe with a bruleJ or dli6turi fate tihoilly alter 3 bMuck Nvrl 1 of lilt urea ouniln ol lelliu rather lei tail iudiu < li > d that they tu tight fro i lluwed lo lake a hurl walk in 11 reh air 1 at a change 1Ilh club rid haled room Ie court al o0te ace let tu the tlquest and abrlel ten V t-en fulljwixl 1 |