Show ANS AN'S ALIBI SHA TIERED BY ST STATE ATE i AILWAY MIN MEN SAY sY I fi i f HE DID DD NOT LEAVE fiL iL oK THE TH CRIME 1 k 1 iI in Rebutted Rebuttal Springs D m e ing Rg Surprise on Defense Both Site Rest find end Arguments Begin 3 r Case to Tomorrow j By 1 1 Gordon Snow now f Tottering like a shaky structure in a terrific storm re e a defense of Joe Sullivan alleged slayer of Policeman rles arles S. S Ford is slowly going to pieces Every main PP ort upon which he and his attorneys have relied to toive tova ive va him from the hangman's noose is weakened and unies un- un ies some hitherto unknown strength is brought out in the te the defense will it is believed be a mass ofas of ns as when the case goes to the jury It Statement after statement made by the defense has hast m. m t n declared false by the prosecution Witness after withas wit- wit ess es ss has been brought into court by the states state's attorney lac laced ced d upon the stand and by sworn testimony sought to rov the falsity of Sullivans Sullivan's statements and the assertions asser asser- airs ip of his witnesses Y erday Sullivan on on the stand set up an all alibi To To- y 9 Harry Logan and William Harrison Hanison who were in g e of the train which Sullivan said he bO boarded at cods bod's Cross declared such a thing to be impossible as asle ast astrain le train n was going through Woods Wood's at thirty miles t hour Thus was Sullivans Sullivan's alibi disproved 1 1 s This afternoon final arguments were begun in the thee I e e. e These will probably not be completed before Satur- Satur ay y y noon The case will probably be in the hands of the before the sun g goes oes down do tomorrow l aza nn Wa was placed on the stand t nd almost F last hul moment of the states state's rc rebut rebut- ut ind end testified that ou on the morning of i Tiber kr 14 ld the time the murder was wass s witted he hc left len Salt Lake Lako in charge o e r. r freight ht train of nino Dino tors t f sas ya wi ai a a. a J. J rn ra when the train left ht lards ards after ha having vin been keen chef bed b ly by the tho police to see if Sulli- Sulli tras cas aboard a i aid it that the train E slowed cd down own in North North halt fealt Lake yards to take the Il r hana and from that time on ran ranra the tbD ra talc lc of thirty miles an m hour bour or re e it reached Farmington larmin ton He lie tv ties that Sullivan Clu caught ht the train 13 down in the north var yards J- J JHo Ho Ire Hoat I st that the train passed through h Cro at which he point an a caught it at ata a rate of a more moru thins t mil mites an hour bour In O Ogden a- a t ah h he saw Sullivan t as he 9 train t at 7 30 i in n the morning ees stand this morning II a a Wore swore that t at the defendant dant it the courtroom yd W. was the man who his bis train trai after altor daylight ali ht mornia i Good of Decem December L r 11 J 1 0 07 Look at Sullivan I 11 1 took Iok j tJ r notice of r I him laim be bc 0 It ft Salt Lake of the murler before rC and had harl Watched the lIt my train in the Salt Lake Lako garde ho said A After o tram a h brou brought ht ter the t trot he back from Portland I II I Bounty jail to see if ele C my sir Sur- correct t. t I th the recd reco e minute tc I I can Lim thIS thin damaging i the K lip j of a testimony came cam d is In the ease case ase e Joe r Ulan man wholly di disinter disinter- d' d I earner 1 his h Sullivan the thc aco re ac- o wall head It and d looked look td at ut atto h to if the can anlo nio io like liko a thun- thun 1 it J K attorneys s M wit wit- who r 1 I th that aI ilea ES rested unprepared to m leet cot it I tole ts tib j lJ at I 1 o o'clock und nail thu tho an at C 2 M 0 o'clock clock i this after after- I cross I Itral straight examination t Lo Logan n told fold details stor 3 not varying in inOa Oa It Was wag th the ny y to o first ilay aD come from oi wire who ay y a. a was wa 1 ay i o 1 in n the told I ease ate gan his hie m story th tho obi Crowd crowel ante leand d forward ot of the the a d testimony striking he had Il lot d a tonsil l ther e t Ira in I o tellia i 1111 pl Plainly the rho room t the th tho o si- si story tr Toe tae chair and Sullivan shot ho c l ec 1 iha By nf assume raisin raising f eyes t to o Bt a smi it o of f tray as rt rin effort or i pate bory St tl which his he has s trial b elun Clung began an b ail I it been dig dis taJ hay t. t plain t lh he that tt th tLe e Flory tor the tho accuse would fe ry men sitting hav c tr r fl near ear him 1 in n I li l ot a all as smile mho 0 of f t 51 silence I dUrIng g t Tested rested on n th o gs 1 euting tf U tOlle d d' itself 1 s th the e and aud bean fran Kan eu a u L on oa Iago hago 7 7 if i 1 SULLIVAN AN l Continued from Page 1 tr erp j examination but was unable h the testimony henry Heon n a brakeman i the t tame train corroborated the tel tev I UJ of Mr Logan Ilog-an Harrison deI dewed de de- dc- dc wed red ca that Lo Logan au notified the tho O Ogden don jf p t of the tho matter but tho they failed fails to any jar nr action t t 1113 this morning momin the thc defense ef r ltd cd its tuo ns 31 and l the states state's rebuttal BD o D Deputy Sheriff Axel Steele said it t ie ht saw 12 Sullivan and Owens enter I JuNIt saloon at ten min minutes to 1 12 tie lh the Right i ht of December 13 thereby proving ro ng n Sullivans Sullivan's tOT story that he be to left t I J Ja Jubilee a Ilce saloon before 11 0 clock o'clock criff Emery was 1118 called RO and denied tOT story told by br Richard Deming on witness stand t that ho hoto d to allow alloT Sullivan lIli to escape p I then shoot him bim down Sheriff Emaid Em Em- said aid th that t D miD had informed him Sullivan was nearly through the theof I of i the cell and Ind that they had bet bet- I him hin or he would be he ou out t by byr r d. d t He lip told the sheriff that he hc hefu fu bl 1 contrive to have o the saws on his biR hisT T person so O that Sullivan would not Dot t that bo be Deming had told on on r i ut Joe c Sharps Sharp's to tob testimony coni con con- contat e. e i tat o of Sher Sheriff tr Emery it hen tn n I L Loan pin 1 wa war called be be said eaid he be firm n D officer about 4 0 o'clock cock on the raiD of the murder as he be was TAB on ay 11 V to his bis train t At t a rate of inc or r thirty ln miles lt'S an hour he be K ca pit It Impo Possible impossible s bl for an any y on one to a train Tan I y afternoon was entirely I. I tl up by the prosecution tiou in m a mere merci erosa cruS examination of Joe Sullivan an three boors bours the Ule alle n murderer o oas of f t aD Ford stood told the bitter in DS as and l I n District AtIT At At- IT Loan y r the district row In quick shat attorney teh tt the defendant off hi his s guard fuard ab ally was P pr re Hared He wel weighed Uy every ery word ord that came from irom r He e knew that on what he the ho y to 10 answer to the questions prostitution depended fate c and eh 1 he was careful Knowing 1 o th the d district or r o fi strict a torn made attempt to ey ey- ey goad oa the be os man bu tern on to losh los ls h h n P er that he be ml ht lay bare i th e oe Oc some Sullivan p raf part l of lie his nature ou on the ao Dot t the witness Joe he fit e tars in the spend spend- If rot to p ith ml bin be m ar cle at ho be hos OC r la 5 cumB ers frith tb a s t 11 ent ad eye smile resting on his IIi his ii e a bet b- b his hue on tt et any cue tlC 18 att attorneys so as End tit e they ej might bl live 1 hint be ery the I t tery a put Ht to him and nd 55 i tame Itne t coolness Diss stand at ij 0 o'clock clock with h the e aarne s showing bonin on his face faco O nth 1 contempt h hD shown in bi his e a bad iad ad bEfore entered it six sir t doM of f the le afternoon a as session tl teats Ounce that it let Ht t to had three the be at J lase upon th tho ate o raid I ft early would me VI probably t Ua f r Uti s On the stand ii in |