| Show MRS iRs WALI ER SAID SH SHE LOVED WITNESS ASSERTS Mrs his Donohue Donoe T Testifies es That Defend nf's I Wife Declared Dedred She Not forsake Form for sake Boj OV r for Her Own nd's H i Mrs Frederick C. C Walker Valker confessed her love lo for Dr Earl S. S Beers and refused to leave him hun to further the happiness hap hap- of her husband according to a witness hi in Ogden this morning I love Dr Beers and do not propose to sacrifice my IllY happiness for Walker she is reported to have said She refused to go to her room with ith Mr lr Walker Valker at the thet t time that she and he discussed the attention of Beers to her in the thc Lenox hotel in in in inthis this city according to the wit wit- Hess ness Her lIeI husband husland pleaded with her liei for the sake of her good name and their child to end her hei mad ilIad infatuation for Beers Counsel for the defendant tried repeatedly to have witnesses testify that Mrs ills Walker Valker and aud Beers had bad stopped at it a t the Healy house bouse the thc Colonial house honse and at the at-the the Hermitage Hermi tage tag in Ogden under tinder assumed names n les lie succeeded in getting be fore the jury what the clef cusp expects t to prove I br by r each ss I II to Th The Tel Telegram I CUDEN DEO DEC 12 MRS MARY DONOHUE PROPRIETOR OF THE LENOX ENOX HOTEL IN SALT LAKE CITY WAS THE TIm STAR WITNESS FOR THE TIlE DEFENSE IN T Tw THE w BEERS WALKER ALKE BEERS MURDER TRIAL THIS TIllS MORNING MRS UE DONOHUE TESTIFiED TESTIFIED AT LENGTH AS TO TO A A CONVERSATION WHICH WInCH SHE SAID MR AND MRS 1 WALKER ALKER V HAD IN HER HEll HOTEL A FEW YEW DAYS BEFORE THE FIGHT IN THIS CITY WITNESS WITNESS WIT WIT- NESS SAID THAT THE CONVERSATION CONVERSA CONVERSATION TION STARTED IN THE HALL AFTER AF Ar TER TEE MRS V WALKER ALKER HAD RETURNED RETURNED RE RE- TURNED FROM A TRIP TO OGDEN Walker Valker had upbraided her for hay hav having haying in ing gone goime to O Ogden J to see pee Beers Beefs The couple lo were talking loudly Mrs Donohue naked asked them to go info into he her room so bO o that they th would ollia not annoy anno the thc theother theother other guests After thc they entered her room and anil in the tho presence Ince of tho the witness wit wit- Ul ness hess Walker Valker r pleaded with his wife for forth forthe th tIme the sake ake of her good name and Inti their ir child not to have anything more to do du with Beers Ben I He lIe Hc told her s said jd the witness that Beers would only use her as 11 a plaything and that thai when he hc tired o of her herh h he would her off He Ho NI her that ho he would do anything to make mak her happy if would t only keep awa aWRY away from Beers Mrs Walker r Refused Mr tre testified that after Walker hail had talked with his bis wife wiCe for some pome tint time h ht asked asked- her to go JO to their room with him but that fhe she refused refuse cd t Walker r left tho the hot lintel hotel l that he was going to t rind nd Bob Nicol irol und nod see ee er if he could not pr prevail wail upon Mrs W Walker to J give Beers up After Walker had left Ih the room Mrs Irs Donahue had a talk with Mrs Walker in which she urged her to have havo nothing more to do with Beers as it would only lead lea to unhappiness I I I lovo love Dr Beers and antI I am not going to ruin my happiness s for tor Walker the tho I witness declared Mrs 1 Walker said to her Mr Mrs lr Donohue said caid that t she still till pleaded d with Mrs rt Walker to tit have havo nothing noth jog ing more to do with Beers Deers for or the sake of her chill child Sent to Los Angelo Angeles A da day dav or h two Iwo o later Walker told wit wit- I flees neta tb that t Mrs Iri Walker Valker and nd their daughter daugh ter tot were going to Los AD Angeles ele for a visit i Time The morning ming after they the left loft Walker Valker T went Tnt nt to Mr t Donohue and and asked h her r to write to his hill wife as one cue woman oman to another on and to urge upon berto her ber herto herto to h have nc nothing more mote to tf do lo 1 with ith Beers Witness wrote the thc letter as 18 requested Mrs ns Donohue made mado an aD excellent witness witness wit wit- ness for the defense dense ani nail and despite a ari ri rigid d cross examination at It th the hands of District Attorn Attorney on her te ti wn not nat shaken Mrs Beatrice t r Nagle t o- o of Salt Silt Lake Lako City was tho next witness called Mrs rr Nagle sui said suid that she had met the tho Walkers talkers sail anti Beers h while le she sho was slopping slop stO- uin ping at the time Lenox rooming house in Salt hako Jako Cit City SundaY Sep September cm r 0 9 she tame came to OJ Ogden Og- Og den en at the request re of Mrs ITJI Walker who ho had hall telephoned for her Sho She met DIrt Mrs Walker arid and Dr Beers at the Union de pot At this point counsel for the state objected on tho the ground that it was was was' not Dot proper proper testimony Objection Object Is Sustained Attorney Hutchinson explained that he br expected t to tn show by b- the thc witness that after aHer the meeting f at time the Union depot in this hii city Beers Bers Mr Mrs Walker mind and the tho witness wont went t to tho the hotel where they the had dinner and l later hater ter the three i wl tnt u nt t to tho time in O Ogden canyon can can- yon Jon where Boors Beers and Mrs r Walker spent the tho ni night ht to together in room P. P Th court sustained the objection for the thc tiu time c bein being Pare Parley Drainer clerk at tt the H Healy aly hotel beta L Lester ster clerk at tm tho European J hotel W. W W. W W Wilson l on proprietor tor of or th the th H Hermitage Arthur Mug Ulis- clerk Jerk at th the It Hermitage it 3 JC were wro called illet in itt tIle the order named District Attorney At At- torney torne Halverson objected to the I of f n each ench h in turn 1 I Mr r. Hutchinson Huthinson explained that b he C exI ex- ex I ported td to prove b bv by that B Beers Beer r 1 and amid Mrs W Walker stopped l at the ll aly aly hotel under uDder assumed names bv h CranS- CranS con that the thc pair stopped Mopped at the tite European Euro Europ p penn an hotel under assumed t names and by hv Wilson and I that Beers eer and anti Mrs Walker spent th tb the night together together to to- gether at the Hermitage September D. D rile Tho court announced that he would ouM I sustain the objections of the state for forthe forthe forthe the present at least The other witnesses s 's called all this morning morn in ing were cre Os Oscar ar Cox secretary of the Y V. M. M C. C A A. A at Salt SaIt Lake City and amI JamM 0 C. Leary both hoth of whom hom testified to tho good tood character r of Walker Attorney Hutchinson informed lime Hie court that he lie expects expect to bo Lo through with his si side sido o of the tho case casc b by Satur Saturday I after noon Hutchinson's Statement What That the tho defense expected to pro prove was dramatically told to the jury jur yesterday yes es afternoon b bv by W. W R. R HutcHinson ch chief cf counsel for tor Walker Durin During tho the recital the 11 eye myee 00 of th tho defendant ant fr frequently ftc fre welled with t tears Mr lr Hutchinson Hutch inson said that the tho defense would show the lime good o d character of th the cl defendant de rIA- of rif his care for or hi lii 3 aged ld mother and o of lJ his s love loc for his wife and child Tb They would show hoW of his I struggle le with poverty pO Iud and of his having ha risen b by hard work vork from a bumble humble position to toon toone ono one of responsibility Continuing Mr r. r Hutchinson said that time the defense would show of If tho meeting o of the tho Walker and aud B Beers ers families ia io in Salt Lake City and nd of or the influence Dr Beers exercised i over Mrs Walker r of her iD ba having followed Beers to O Ogden en enand and amid of their Ini in having gone to tho the Hermitage Hermitage Hermi t tage Jre in Ogden canyon and spending a night ht there thero and aDd of their having spent a a. night to together in the tho Colonial rooming rooming- house in this city dh under tinder assumed names Wo We will pro c prove said laid Mr Ir Hutchinson Hutchin Hutchin- son Ion that that Walker pleaded with his wife wile and with Beers to quit Itch each others other's com company pan and that the they y both promised do to O so Continuing he aid that they would show that Walker tent sent his hill wife to Los Angeles leA in in order that she sho mi might ht b bawn bo be awn awas' front from the thC influence wll winch which ch she claimed IIi Bce Beers exercised over o her bel and that later hater Walker learned that Beers was wall about to follow her to the coast cit city Mr Ir Hutchinson referred rp to the tho letters alleged to have havo been written en by Mrs s. u. u Walker to Beers and o of her answers an nn ers also also to a n sixteen page letter which Walker wrote to Mrs Walker Walk r nf af t tor ter r she had hid gone one to Los Ios Angeles and in which bleh ho he promised to do everything c in iii hum hill newer Hower to make her if sh sho W would ulf only forget Beers beer rn E Iven then n declared the attorney attorney Walker was loth to believe e that hs hh wife hud hind done anything very cry wrong and did dill not really realo- know until Beers con eon il it to him hini in iii the room where tho the fight Ight ht took pla place e. e J Mayor Bransford Testified At the conclusion of Mr lr Hutchin Hutchin- 1 sok's on's ons address the defense called Mayor John S. S Bransford Brailsford of Salt Lake City A. A V. V J. J Da Davis lavis la president preside of tho the Salt Lake Laka City council oun l Don Porter proprietor of the he Kenvon Fred I Wood hotel clerk clrk Fisher Fiber Harris Harri- secretary of the tIme Salt Lake Lake- Commercial club W W. G Gi ruttIe rut fut tIe tic lef real estate dealer o of Salt Satt Lako City A. A II H. Crabbe a clothier of S Salt lt Lake LakA City and John of O Ogden dell who to tu the good character of ot the defendant |
