| Show THE ARGUMENTSa I Review 01 the Evldenw In the Fen I stermakerTrit3a SuIte 111111 tuMnMs nv touvsn Judfg touern and Mr and Mn tiiuwri Atloriiy lIon i i Closing tOll Attorney J 1 A Wllllatnt on the part nl tOte plalntil and Attorney Ogden 11 lln on tbe part I of tile defiijM having had their iiy to the Jury ynlerday aitrrnoouou the dial nf tbo IoD ter IookrJnDa3jtji hurlsult Judse 1oweri this rooming begun lois tentlon of the orguunut lit Ibo defcndantf tu Ibo courm of hu I remarks the Judge hit the Fenelerniiker family pretty hard and launte1 the lloitlhhlbo at loiupjB with tlulr liHhlllly to bring one single person upou the wltnmi stand who had Ibo temerity to swsar that Iho reputation of the Kenilcr makers ai I wholewai good It seemed 10 t > e a curious family toy lu III component com-ponent bustle inlUjCouniel the old Indy appenrliig to havn Main I mania for Oak lug In IllUo waifs and itrayi At one lluieahu had in many ai four 01 them together at the llox lld < rraoohand lu Iheau silo loud stated OIls WOe more partial luau la her own ablldrro Judgu Towers sneered at Ihl piece of allegml hypoorliy load deceitwhich be said was backed up by n like attertliu uy her huiband llsferenoe was raado lullieHiUeeralioui bold0irlastureilhy Cuar Die em In Nionolas Nickltl y I being rlilrmtd Ibat a parallel I I DIM of croloity was hrru rmuu What can tie urn awful asked uounwl than tOo building up I ol hoe mind ul a little girl lo that polit thai she heillaled uot lotmllniKly 11 1 laid n faliebood le C UM 1 wauled t > urI toiuiu I do lout kuuwwh To eve aud heir little Onrolluo Hiieu I upon the wit I ones ititud yesterday Wa a plclurr lonnua ely 1 wluom given In oouu Ilu tory could Judge for thrmselvei whelber ahl > load leoelved time In at uieut and training which ihuulJ lo Hiveuio 11 little huinele1 and friend ieM girl floe lestlmuuy in and uf Ilielf was unioi iot t tu wipe out the talus I the plumIll Peusteiiuaker at once and luunummiiy jryuli ourhite I and honett lUfii tu ally upon their oath that tiu muit gn tiomu with a verdict ol uu CHUMutaotlotl booed UMelled tbat hu would la willing rest Ohio delnud nuts OHM ufou Ibal Oblldj ItJlliUI y ° lour I legllluialo ur llleglllmau Carrlo was an Incubua 10 jlauiou llugaJtl She was nl his own thesis uud blood uud yet to ecu hluieir end help the plalulill he went Uwn Ibo wltiie l land coiili > log fill own w rungdolug aud hearllmuess neeklb 10 call discredit forever upon me intellect intel-lect of Ills child Site wai indeed nu orphan with her boor nnllur b nealli Ibe loll In Denmalk with 01 II Wlb her father virtually disowning rturnng her In lo Ibo bands ut people whom hu dId nut know and carelessly care-lessly furgetltng their addrrii thiuklnx sj lIttle of her that tor II vu years lie did nut reo her nnd Hie kujwlng bloc trestmenl she had received re-ceived Irom him relerrlng tu him lu all her 111 oIly 55 Mr ll gatell C UUtel spoke of Ihe KVldencu ul idsuin lllnou who bu eald lor more than A jinittriul I a cviuury had been well kuown lu this community and declared him tubeau ulsolulely truth lul who could have lullU no lutereslln wooing n fahm siaiuiuenluf thli oaio lo Mr Inuuan Wa < II likely lhalu girl or ouSt tender yean would have started uul ou such journey uf eight babe or lau mlloi ulour Ibruugh Ibn lagebruib t > sleep out In Ibe desert under the slats In the Iroity wunther lilllcw there bad been somelhlUE the miller In facl ihe horielf had ndtultteU that wheulsUu left hoc Fenslurmakerhuuiihold lile oil that April day that she had no Intention ot returning 1 wai evident that Ibo girl bad been coached Into tbe lale of uculsls that shu had now tola upon the HllueMsUnd M her coulradlolory ilatementa leaved and the Judge In shied that Wllou OlIn t mid her original story to Murjoclt Inn eheepbcrder Uiltan sud ohiosrs silo rgklh truth He aiktd tuoJury whether Ibo story cf 11U irtatmtul uf this child did not touch their hcarla no meunud wbetber they did nut bellovethat hIts Tri U1 less JuilltleU In taying that this was ° a Iuuullku ucll to a cbllI 10 turn her out uf door In SOOt H minner lu wan doe whither she wuilu Tun evidence of Carrie I little cuiuuanloni at the rulmeis was adlerled to they biaviag ewurn that Ihey hadseeu Mr Fobster I maker beat lose loverely uu varIous ooculoui Judge 1oweri spoke of Carrie D an bled for pity not lor reproach I sOld he trusted that the OrpbaiKJlluuie would riot end anymore any-more oiilldr to Ihe Fonitermaker much and that ouu of thin mulls of lllli ease would be an Investigation of the boirulug out system 01 walft He doted by askIng for a verdict for hOe defendants Attorney John MXinefallowed tills afternoon Couniel spoke uf Caroline Humoua peuobaut for running way from home ai the evidence bu said clearly proved and claimed that Ale Fenstoruiaker wai not Ibo ilondllku lertou that Ibe defemo had tried to make out There was no testimony to ibuw thai she ever drove the child away sod told her not 10 rituru nut Carrie herself on Ibo wltuuHslaud host loomed thai abe did so TIst the Femtermakors liuJ treated her kludly was evidenced hI the fol other own confisied desire t return lu them Would the jury lay that the plimitlllwas u parly to such a scheme as lo turn tbli ciilld adtlft cod send her out upon thu desert I > ctarvu Ueiilh bloc wltnui tu dool1 wil Huplocka nllegod varulihed ilory ul Carries con veriallou with him woe ridiculed and ut what couritol diumvd to bo many equally feeblu links lu iho cbalu 011 lei olllho side 01 thou ilefeuiu imiouy ou ltulo weru pointed out Mr Ztne was speaking when thou KIowa rupurl cloied 0 |
