| Show I OPPOSITE VIEWS I I 1X Agatl i Replies to ProLsor rial s RenirkaDli SUlemaaU Til IT QUWTION OP I OCATI01 II bat Hunt tartUl Unlw At I t4ut hi a Illllf Slaw U Ilm Adtlc N tn film Out AoStor enret > AW I rof Paul continue to make rtmark ohio lalement fonuded upon peculiar f ti I and figure Sine hll but erlet of Kb tatlt prenliom new Arlall1 n ihe old Ihemei I It require little tlttnllon He enumerates Ihe following 01 all Ih stud ei taught the University and I n t in the Agricultural College hnj hh I literature third yetr1 three year of I I I > K ORY > quaternloui geology prob n llv a misprint for IhU II I might In the liege Latin three 1 year tholild be I x Greek five > ein French two jc or i Germ two year n1 alto as lIhahle I advanced trig mometry nnd 1 rvcy ng and Integral calculus Then he I ki for any educator In Utah tu MY or hli own ttgnaluio whether If I I r ms apparalu etcbeing furnished i t wlI cost more tlrail fioooi to ttach I t e m Ira branch II applied for for i I i c not two yean Certainly lim might cover the rlci required for thht addition v IIk though IhU depend upon the hutment I to woik already enltllnttnd I tl writer would be pleated to agree u 10 II is ronclutloii II Ihe rcta un which i hd I are correctly given Unfor I I irl 1 UICM alleged fact are utterly IIlIIdoAble I VI lance nt the University program I I 1 in itions during tile pretenl term I litilhe tallowing that thoutdhave I I nimludedm the list given abotc I loSixin and hngliili llology ivlmt advanced chemlttry llilril r 11 urie Prencli third year Ger III n third year advanced American htul I > hlitorical seminary liulory of i ulirailonih prcent lUbject KiujlUh trialure I louilli > n1 liblory and ll phy ol malheniallc projectile I n i nrj inodtrn synthetic geometry t ntrnl I jy an I pehographjf advanced t ursr f s chology advanced courte I1 rlMi t lomt oihtn as it It I dllhcull lo I k i It nil Ilm college citilogue Ihe ot Ioty I nl work In any tubjtct so much nlttnilon Is I given to hli it mcntmenlyto thow Iw unrellabll > hul t even IItt were true It would tie Ix ttcrly valutlets to ihow the i tit of I iivertlly work not now I M li I it the c liege Alliloftui I lUtfhl tells veiy Ulllr about Ihe xr h I an I tlnracler of a ichool unlett lulormallon about Ihe r i miwmed b > > ml too wl Ith the aul jcct are punued a Illi 1 qii ilny uf the work Your mini on It I Invited tu the follow I lts I pnrlial toni > arltoii ol undeniraduaie 1I1I1cUlty and college work olrered a npariton HI ublth ealeiit of tubjtclt > 1ItI dur prom neuce in itinutry the College oflert two > e ra unl the University three In te lug Iho College one ttrm and the llu LiivciBliy I live In mlntralony tie lollcgu three houra tier week lor one Rw d Utnl an II I iw i hoiirt I for R > ecund term nnd I the Dnlienliy four liour ier wnk fl J i i fur one term and Ihtee hour lor acc a-cc n I nl I Ihlrd term In botany the Colli KC two hour for one term and hvt I r it tecond and Ihe Unlveriily three I ouii li r r one tirni and two noun fir hue mint Ueiit terms In mathematics hi Dniveiilty prm I Idi nlnelcen counea vi lln I tepirnlory I and the College < ut ittfiurh na many while the hhm 1 in nnd Sophomore mathematics f tin L II e k ° eniiUMMiring courwt cor r 01 I u M3 Ii I to Ihe University pie i intory ullh t entire inallicmalici ol i he 1I Kr cull t I couuo go not iulle to lir th I n vcrsity prep iralory iiml it moil U calltd lu time Uhel I 1 ec 1111 belt if anywhere Ihe L II m til IIIIuhl 11 r iv de as much or nion 11t0n the Unitirtttv an I In every one It Wlieci ultcnllon u turned to Unguage Imrnturr hlitory eti one flndt it m ht be eniieried u itlll grealvr db p my The Uncrity ofleri In Bug I Uh Oernui and Fruich about 11 Ice ul inn h u the Colleiie btildu Utm and UeeL which tlio Colleire I don not oiler t ill in i hlnlory the Oniveraity I offer lully mice a I much or mure luatKridiMM work it i advertlawl In I nth li ttltullont > o that on the face of It hUIIOII I arc cICIIn Dili point but th marked del ciency of the College un ler dOuale work u ul mute lu no calletl I t uraduato wuik lo be largely an > t out ol i rctlfcui dtficlendta It i notirolMtle hovtuter tint rovlilon t r pott raduntu uotk nin unU to much at yet 11 either Inttitullon 1 lie lionlleituii tuyt ID lie l mne or Ihc811 Ukswrllm I r c u lupl ui n 01 nine IcnlU ol ilw k lonclxllme niiluilau I le conluundt thcte t o prO > otltlona thit 1 nine Icntht o I ho college work It dUll nt Ilw UiiivcrMiy nnd th it nine t nil of the Lnlvertlt work It done at 110 e ColliKe Ilie flnl though robably i nu ht exnnnernliil It I nearly true hle the htcondlt I lion here near true h ut bun oho n above M r I Imperfect liatol work to Ic J 1 d to the College In onkrlu provide lor Ih e Uii vtrtlty the gcntlenun akt lIow much huul1 It cott lo lupply tdchu fur the oregolni tranche Inn t lolttithapreteni ficully uf twenty ic then Aglnncuat Ihlt ficnltylist vtillauitt in niMKcrlnK Ihit i ielloii Al out one third aro u gneil tu aotvlng iloiintlic econinn dairy ti and anlnuil I 1 anilry and me like tuhjactt In wi l kh iheWrvlcet I f I however I valuatle fr the Lolkiuo noul I not bo I In the liKhlett degree illabln to uititt in diutinx ht Unlvrmty work W e al > obwive n rouuor ol ih3ica 1II1 i hl rI ju k ology and nuneraloiy tulleili in Hlich I the UnivuiUy rcqulret the rvlcn i of between two ami mree I > er > 11 i alto 1 n profctaor of lnili > li mid m dim UrgiMiici witjicli th it rrq lire i f ally threi Intilt itlon In 10 tmur ty OWIIIII i lo the Rruatir n oum ol I wurk conttu led In Ilium Ioulh I hu been p Bullied 10 l tl ow ih ot the College I > ut ol hlfih ti ojl i m < I Ir the mmt IIarlln Un iollit1 u icn an 1 ol dlttilct tcl ool ir de m is I i npnratory I and that tl the talk I about i i inumimedtodollelnijeiMiy II i lIh lit olin nl n trill ill ddhonlll tul i 5 a tt > iar H Ih mllh I 11 itun I iiion 101 c Unlv r tiy waj In 11 similar cundl lion when Prof Paul w c incct J I with 1001 I see n t k II N nI I r tc l I li I i i 10 I t KI ne Ia In llil l r HI n III CI I I tl vomit IK h i i h n oqlo 0 r male li Ie t I nl hhle Intlln I Ititc but wiu f riwl by ih cenil m nt I for erroneoui the reputation compumn of hit a < alte necnilty conclti tlont I The College prt hibly doe at well al U ran with taking d rcld Mhool p pl ntoltf Fmhman clatt To graduate tpem In tour nrt lit courte mutt necetMtlly be limited an I upeffitUl I Any remdr lor thIS mnt begin at UK botiom The gentleman ask to have tome educator In Utah my over hl own igna lure whether II will cost more than Jio onto carry the Unlvenliv al Ui > n Well we can form li him sometl < ng a good aa he atk lor The n imtw of J htholi IIOACO pet year to carry the Unlvcn ly al Unx in inclusive of the nnrnul and IIAoooiicluilve of the irmal wi < ob lalned from I le acling pretldent of the unlvenity than whom a man mIlt e widely and Uvofably knowrt lor liir coruervatlve and Impartial Judimiit ikwt nnl cahl In the T rrlt iry n r u inert any nne belter outline 11 > Kio l u i relabln tilmstr I uke Ilia hbtriv nt KlvlriK ihit to my Infurmam htciu the Inloruietion wo obtain Who u tny nferenca to t ncney or to thu uio 11 I e ma le uf MI nor doea the Inior luui h anyrnpontibllliy lur leta rl Irof Paul can uiio from the tame tource Ihegmtknunaayi that the I nlver slty eipentet for the remaminn I part of f Iho preteni tclHMl year were provid I yrC f r wH by the latt lugiilalure He I mini lurmedi approptlml m wa made for two > eroiily which e > p red Jan j lit Il19t The chairman of Hit lioir I of relent II probably belter authority Inan Trol r L Paul on Ihit point lie 111 10 Tiny l i r on lo wy Iht an tlBcknl ae mU n1 11 < h nt Kh l will c t boul io too fell a cmiwIicMimiy o imoam ih II u but ih pnon h y lo lr = r done Itii I ye If al UM Unlnnlly apart horn UM high icbuol work lui I COM any such smuunu Tne ilAtemeni that an efficient normal ichool will COM any amount the lenlt lure lIr git ell 1 rDI toundlng I but In tens It I a puerility The generally or parsimony ol Ihe legUlaluri hat nothing = ro tl inoru 11 do with the coal of normal ichool than w ih the price ul thoet a 1 r lnt1nr J chool of a certain kind an I grade like anything el ustt exactly wnst It require re-quire to t roJuie lIlhc quality of that rtlc Tho list part of the quotation is I elthrr a lophlnry or ariset from a Hinder Handing of what A normal tchool mutt doI lt I Id not practicable to run > tte irmal tchml without high nhojl work Ihe pupils I mutt lie wt if taught In Ihe lUbject nutltr before they ci i obtain ob-tain the theory a id practice lu method ol teaching U mm the earllett normtl I rhooll were opened In the Ruler late il I wit thought I y om that II olb vould tulhce i lo rcicive pupil I lor a j r proluulonal training and turn them out at iralntd tiacben but the dooll Oil oon forced lo at Atidon Ihli Idea and eiitbl > h full couiiet of Instruction ending witna year ol lira 1 let oiul w irk A few applicants were quillncd to ttart with ihe merely professional work but thu Kieal uuu were utterly unprepared and liny rew obligtd to close or to take their applicant a > they louu I them and Impart the needed In tituclloo If this 11110 In the otdtr cooimunl tie tan oiiylhlng bttler be expected In UtahAn Utah-An efficient territorial normal and trwnlngiciuol illnqnlr faculty ol at lean from eight lo un pertoiu hrst class Icaihe II and will oat about tta DUO per year 11111 I U not merely un etli naii but It I ibo actual con of iuth uhaolsin other peril of Ihe country where Mlane ear I coil of living are generally let than In Utah Tnlt cum no of Jjouoo I r year wh th colnci led wiui lilt writer own observation ind knowledge wii oh ta l d from I hi ictlng president and the hlId1 I thu IIUIIIIIII department in Ibe lulverill r t y 00 authorities I Now the gr und it pi p in I ft r ajnln II W r I resenting I i r Ihe 11 ille 11 in f consider allon 10 burui llIch l he it Invited dlt irovo or lo harmonlu win his 75 o tavlni in tin coming iw i yemi I > immediaii anlal union at Logan leav n the n mill at bait I tki t1 The Un tetiity It undent hu1 I to I Iw able to tarry lit present c t irge with out iirovil x lor lmmdlite luttlitr dcvelopmtnl for ooo i lor Ibe two following Jan in lta suppote 11 u moved lo Logan at Ibe cloe ul I Ihe proMral ichool l year leaving tho norrntl and l school for Iho deal at S ll Uke or tlMwhere niij what will Ihe Turllory in out ol 90003 by thlt optralloo It uillcoit about Jjjooo for the til monllualbalt I Lake lor the rent inmg fourteen whoul I month uril will cott ftoi per month for Iho deaf nmlc fionofor the nornul at bait Uke and 1 16uu 1 lori IhellnK my 11 Iu n or 6ieoo I ir i l the three an J I Hi i um with < > 5 ooo lub tracltd from joo leavea ti 400 lu the lavhiL ThegeuilemmMyii He llbtn louWod or lcltel mt t thu itiown lot uf many f t h If I oln i frwii ho J II 0003 liymloani lug n No my dtar ir that would be followIng follow-Ing > our intlliodol luing flgunt ou arc welcome to a monopoly ol r that butt neu neuNow for vnrltty let in consider the uvo Mtini IlIlho 1 1 light cl hit own gureX tint t of f y r month for the rr J1 J = nivertli I ul I U n lor fourteen noathH and il to i loi l it i oniml al Salt 1 ake lla I with f s I too th for Ihe leai luliMiu I iu kte I the learnt ball lakomal t i lih I lroni > o avtttJJit itindof f75 > ooa In order to I ivt ihegentlenun f no notalblegrou 1 ol Ijecilou I toinyli I ufe I m 011111110 t 11000 10 llnlifl the and tlllmnte far 1110 meient 1011001 u r on efrl UJ 1 i wlh J hi l 7 hguio fisou fort t llY ° K tKe nortnAl LI t uoao for the I fC Ol Iha UnVvmi H 1 Ihete deducltd w I IRlll1 01 IIOUI fygptJO 175000 NA wIIIIIII bla Clil I r I d I I u II btrtfor lh rel 1 ol tht L l ilvertty at logantheae I lucted from < flO x > h 111 ul 15000 II Ive WZ 5uoo l h 1I1IIIOVO will be nil 10 II polnl than to ffirerctit or blu ter boat Ih AIIeC III he uIlto e II oll o II tha IIIIOlllenlh11 by unlllld with Ih UIV y al ah I o II tlw M > v rnmt nt Man 111 0 h It I t Where elu wuhl I UK lo Unan but to Ih l luUI 1111 JIIIII grant Romw th It httl ir h I CulltlO < I indUmvi rally ore IIl1l1ell I > I I ogan I n salt Lake Si t < lc ri r 111 N tlo I Ilnc 1 IIii vaybody I uHu i I I I I IIIIlIIall 11I ude lu patriotic Ullt abjui UIII w 1 rnlll I I I t i < 0 d 1 II < or 111 > lither oil is s n Ion of In i r i it IIIUI11 iitoiiiillrssanditenieleM The I lenll < mon laY IrIt wAt dodo or n o hoI fro h tltl 1160 > > tfe In r ul on la I igan In prafcrvace o p rr u IS ooo lo hst Ilw wheit ol II nan t Thiili mere immp ipetch thunde nd niUreprrMnuiion In the fits plate if It were true 1 the legtalaiora i it appropriate thi f 56 ooo to bellied a Salt Lake al entily ni al Logan and il Ibe whole ol It can be don In Logan for 0ooo rum the Territory then U am as well be done lor that fum at Hall Lakt In ihe ncond place the proposition in il fru n 75 ooo to < ioo or oah l JJf no i cat be wed i without ticrtfice ol efficiency d ir ug the com ng two yean by union al cither place ri utterly Iunde s AS ban bo n shown Tho ceooo r ol I Silt Ike I City Is not I lulllble for fie Col egr it Ihe suburb hut Ihll locution i quite as suitable fin the Cntlexnns tlo u nneni I ran I lor the Unlv it ly therefore lionnrt are euyonihlspm I II Im nutate union al either pta Is I ntcrssiry unit tin gentleman hn il It the Unlvert u Interests 10 be tecon Ury to lho > of tin College fgr Tnewrliir miy juatly j olijnI to btlng rejireaentcd us the 111011x11111111 a Ivocate of Hall ol Ukt writer Ll rich one look not far hlmlf an I tMen 11 h own potit on Tb writer advocati s whIten wh-Iten to him the truth without Incite men from anyone or arrangement with anyone m ived ta II timplv v n desire ta txpoie tho error of the I K m advo cat KICK have been s > uxht rom Ihe most reliable ourcen an I pretented at clearly M It I po Mhle for Ihe writer to do to If Ihec commend Ihemielvci to tho tense nt undid reader more than llioie of Pro 1iul they uill IMVC greater weight otherwise other-wise not The gentleman tay Sane of the tgurei I g > hiw toe an r kwwwl by lb0 Mil Lske m I rscrut by lunk tomtit of Ike futi lar it ntrlvet hs1 IIIIlIulI I l al Ibe > fry betianlni ul inn agiu lIun The absolute faliltv of hi figure liai been hon repeatedly JII It thown In Ihe protent lllr SUCh talk a thli qu union teems to be mtra lilusicr to cone al I defeat when tine is I unwilling to surrender and ocknowleuiie in error Some writer for uni 11 mide rather exaggerated etln te > of ilm i i mr but tlio In heit waabetween JLp unandtai OUM j early fir complete ui on and Itt Included a i allowance of Irom Jioooo lu Isuo I led Iotc and i 10 wis figured on t t uct of each Insliiuiion when furlhtr developed not i n cxiitntrt In prscnt cut dill int i I rof Paul I I has the unique distinction of lI inuring out Jtluooo > saving on eipnw lor Ibo next two year I he gentleman pleading penonal dliinteraMcdne la lecure greatur con alderalian lor hi words anu hv Impll cation a well at d rectly assigning per IPj tonal intareit to oppouenli tu Ivutn the Influence ol their replle Ihii Live oc cation far reference lo hit motives lie allow all Ihe t > mploms ol I thai xetlous imrUtaninlp which Heka lo obscure and L rl Ir belittle lactt llul oppjie It cause and to onaggeratu w lalever ulds It U lit Y the Kentleinin t motives hsvo been It of no conieiiuente and probably a conjee = I lur tbould not h we been e preste I rhiia Ivocate dot not favor Immediate Im-mediate union at either place at Irf I I M Incorrectly tiatet Hut if Imme dnti union mull be mile It can at well be madi at Sill I ike the bitter plait m al l izsn and tho combined r f = milllullons can be conducted at cheaply at ball Uke at at Ligan Tho writer a authority far ttatlng that lurtlal union at logn will wvo nothing of I consequence It I uncontrolled fact ant I figure than which there li I no higher authority in the unlvcnu The educational rltnn of 1ogin u an Ideal college town the board and morality ar umenti etc all eem tome to-me lo arbe from that Inltlnci of nun which ln > icla to try to jiutlfy whatever he detires and llhout thb would never havu betn icrlouily urgetl or van heard 11 as ground lor Ibo removal of the University to 111 IAII II the IUtOil i of location of the Hale Untveniiy uirt being coutldcred de nl 0 nd tilncii alone were colored I uui ilinill i town on the edge of 1 I Itury and r p iiulaUuii would Ie I not be III the rate nt ill It would probably lie between Sill tko and 1 rovo 1 o turn up 11 h s been shown In thlt or preceiliiu pi II by uncontroverled Item that the rup nitiou on which the cl ilm far Immedi Ua union al Logan til most eutirilv rent el1I1I1 from tltaoo tu loo uoo can be laved during the next two ytan without tacr flee of efficiency liy removal ol ihe Unlvtralty lo lx > i n la eiitlruly lilse or a KroM ex ggeratlon I that the propotod iaithl i itiuuu at 1 ogan will merely tubttltule I one duplication for another and IdVO I nothing alto that Immediate complete union at cither place InvnUel by ubui donlng properly a lancial wcrihce too great tu be justified by the Immediate gain ami that if un un II I dctlrabl It can I HI effected with robably no low if time U I tlveil lo make iratigem nt lor It rum I theto conslderatloni It ras re > nblt in Inlor that it I wltor to make the boil potsibla pruvltlnn enuit ably for ihe luo Inttllulion a they are at pieunl and n ° little tlow about union on one ille X lluaJ A i Ion ri nnd tmlgranti leatlercd > etllemeiit In all dlreetlout fioiu tbe inalhtroilaiilMoii the AlUutlu emit loaaawereRiaileauiliunluttlntdlotlicm t v taxing nil the uUltene ivtldlng In II o tuwiulilpf vouullM on4 ttalM tbrough wbtcli lluy piwwJ Wbuu u uullo rua I woi a touch uud llitrjiiiirirvdi luonJIiigintriiorUliinryi lldltyol r 0 J n dll U tho Ltit tuuillliuii uf rep4lr 1 a loui any vu i unnu ilo Ital > oa lur nlUiHi uud thu roaa wut baudml i ver tiy II o I lotuuuuuiiAuy bolvwtiul ll gradsr brldxiil Ut limiur tlouid mildralnirtiu wluul wiy ma vlivri ItultUeJ uhrii a eaih Ituvi l roa li iiu orvtunult > i lull fur ittnli mile liAVelm UJKJII II fbu Hit ublio to J bevnue ttluiliilkt en U4ltl UoauM it IU llunn wbtr tbu toll wa cnlholu I Ihuro WITS Iul l armuj wilt plhiN iut acroMilutuaiJ whlu tiruoj upm u loi aiiloliljr nuilon lu thu lluvdu I Ih Al lie uiutl pay or 01 Itivflrtt Urniku lu America WAI uhart r U lu 17M by thu 1 IniaueluliiA ud 1 tiiOMlm lur ilka t niiMtiy II I ioiiujtuoiKl itil7UIuuU I > oou oum pleiiJ rivreli na more liuoit nt i > oono rulo iiibret Uforu t u Amvrluau le toilnj limn llu be > l ni tbtU ol 01111 I i J muimlnmu me ublio r a in UnrtH Mat vanie m Uaro MM i I |
