Show THE DEFENSE OPENS ° Gtoml Ctrlir and Ills HID Now Tike Their Tarn AT lOIUlS milSl NATION Motion to Dlichirge Or > ln of I Ilcftuilinti Umrnltd Ily tko Court When the Now report of Ibo Carter otnl contempt oa e closed yt erday afternoon Drtuly Martini 1owler ol Irovo WI under Iho UN of rovoo amlnallou Tim eucrefdlng II mony went to bow tool uutl if the defendant engaged In the dlilutb ance that threEs were uioJ and clubi braldlihoj sholl when tlia itcpulliH appeared on the wear Nearly Mil tin iwviilyiuvin nun now charged were Jeallflid m having Iron preienl The crowd was excited aol tOm ma i declared tell they would not uLncht to a TODAY lyqrim Wlmi onuil oonvnueii 01 10 oolotk Dili morning Iho I tiraMcullon cilled Hberllt llrowu of Utih oouuty who mid lia had a oouviriatlon with Ueutral Caller on Ilia tlreet J ri Urd y nllli reference la Ilia lit InK of lha trilu nl lohl Junctlou Cartel bell declaied t him tint ho kuew Leforthaud ul the nothing Ltouhull 1In loiteal the train and lutlbtr that lie had previouily eounnled I hit men tint Id I retort to auy act of that kind lie HOI aim 1 about la ny louielblng m 10 thatltlMniof Leui having numehow arrarge l tar tIlls train 10 Ukeihearniy OD but they if it Interrupted In the conversation mil ll wn broken nil before tltlir bed fliilthed Wltueii Identified 1 irom am nig Hie defendant Ircgory Ktta Nowell Mcllae eool nay Os bnlul been llro and he inciumidall the olberiwiro there l fio Incroiiesimluallon Ihetherin said I Caller told til in he ws not at l < ebl at the lima of this taking of Ihe train and dId not know anything about It I till next uiornlne Iiefore leaving leav-ing Litbl on Friday night he had directed hl nun to uy In camp aud bad laced guards around lucre Cal might have ial 11 ho weut to American Fork on the Friday nlKlit but certainly itatrd that Ilia null beard of tllo train iteallug wes ou Uilurdiy morning 1010 Tin proiecutlon hero restedat me urriioK orcii Attorney lloulxtbin laid that ai all Ibo IIuda with the dccl blot 01 Caller had been In cutlody oouflued lutbeicnlloullary alum lu time of their atreit oil H > turd > y alletncou their oouniil bid no porlunlty ol talking wllli Hum lu order lu prepare tIcs denl Ho therefore asked Ir minion ol Ibo court t > consult wild Ibtm all In private tom a fit moment Iwtoru proceedlug ta udduco urMeucc Judxa Mirrltt Cerlaloly Tliruuixin Mcuri llouiz Warnir and Colonel Allan Mlllir wllli Jon rral Camber and lh other twenty ilx defeadanli leinlred 10 tIc IIII JUlY room and returned alter au abuuue ol twenty mliiutei Attorney Warner loimtdlitily mod tuu court to dlsohargo Ueniral C rEd r-Ed Moor Chns Hurl William AuJrow Mlcbatl Hulllfnu and Jut Cauidy on thc urounJ that thor was uUoluttly DO leillmoiiy whatever lo connect them with any act cooplaln vIolin Mr Youngs allldaTll Cuilu cob 1 Ilktwlie luofeu that Ibu defendanu Charles Mllcbell T UlldJeu I Kaugbtaud eVA Ijwry be rekaieil for II beau ro that they bud not been lulllcliutly Ideutlflad Judge Minhall uu the Iart of the iroieculloo In < HIC the inotlou lltll drill wIll the Otfendnul drier and commented upou the publlu sIde t wool ol his lnlenlloi M mown by the imwipai ret 0111 lu their eTlJeuie I lo ride wllb lili men by icuie meant or olber out of the Territory Larier ho I laid had formed an oricaulzttluii of them rUD WM elected IbtlroummauU er sad piraded In adT noo of them ulitreTfr they went lie Was 11 Ikelr rto > Kiilied leader aud commanderi puke 1 Ibm In tubllc anuouucad their laia aDd what they Intended In-tended to IIoto rIde ptace 1 ally I Ihvy could but lo rlda In any erenl Ha deuouncej tha rallioad uuiiiiaulri sod aliened that all iba forces of lIds court aud of Iliu United Mules cold not rr < riot them KOloi toy train ICtrry more nieutoflhli kind remarked counul wm promt ted by knot uud bole but Carter did not belong IJ thu uilir caiegory and wan 0101 going I lu voluu Hilly plica r blmiclf wbera uvldeura could b ashy oblaluod aualuit him Naturally euough he wm atimit wbun Iba train was itolon at lthl Our widen aver It ConIc lo any ACLu1 l llill tiocsu men whll Wer osouotlve lu Inciting others niually kept coiiTeulent by I In Iho rear Ai lo the ri malnlng ilefeudauti tbera were cclliln of them who bail not Leon IdollnII a havIng taken bait In ole actual iteallUK of Iba train Hill there could be I lltlla doubt tlint Ihoy all rode upon II to 1ruTo and lIce riding OIl that train wnluit an much u braaili ol thu order of the court ui lIce uctual I In lerrrenca wllli or handlinic of lIon lima louuvel I referrnlalioniu lenytb lu CIIIU ads 01 tbo luun ou the ccca Ion ol the train itMl and urged that all had lUOjtcteJ Ibauiielvel lo punlih mcnt Attorney tan Colt ipoke of Ueucnl Carter ai lice plaucur thou CbIO tIle IIlloetol of llui men and soil the quetllon hnra was whulhtr wben he Ima not them right ti tIe 10011 whom tlcoy oonimllltd au overt aol briiuia ba hrnllaled uillmr from pruueuoo or r I of uerra 10 LO lurlber wall them be was uow to EO uupuuUhrd tiuntel dwell U > on Iho preparutluni wuKb had boss mado for blvakliiK up Ibo oamii ol moll I bulwteu Ijubl r aol IroToluorJer tint tbvy miKhl I gut upon tIde I caIne route I sod ridiculed ridi-culed the Idea I that Cooler wai Ignorant 01 Ibal tociedlUK Thwc wen In taking tha trim tuily curled out tide Tory thing tint bo bad dlrerlvd them to do lu tin lutillo ipeeohua Iban for soOlo rcison but knowu to blinielf bo mon < away to Amorlctn Pork tu not out of iba nay for Iba llrno balug wbllo lice itial Was toeIng ef 1 fected 11 reaponr tvjoln sad colll lake eeo0010ol ol the AllY at tPOVoI oul l diy Judicial clnrgM on tie eub 10 eif I IncitIng to riot and oonndriey woe butch d Irnm and Mr Vitu Colt luililel I that Cooler Oluet Im held re 1Iolbl n Ike organiatr sad lIdl lu IbliiuilUr Hehailneit d > lauiieU tad icbrnied tu bata a certain ol lot acroui Ililied wai be Ilieii lo woipa while tho other men were UiiUhid iluiply btcauia ha uUlld IUI WM not lmooeltt al Mm last nionieui WIn the Heal took plM > Wai lut Curler oun of Ibo ileuiaiit which oou lltulad OhIo wbolo Uduiirlil army for Ibaaoooinpllihiuaul ut au Illegal 1 HirpoicT Why iboulj tIde brad aol I bold f tbli olfeiidlUR go free am I Ihow who aclal uuutr hit ordvu br sent lo thu < ullriillar > 1 Attorney I ItniK I In nplri Mid J that lliMomen could I loot toe Held lu contempt con-tempt bar taking mo train unlm I could bhouho IhI at tIle Vary lima lle on took place they knew thu profirty ol Ilia rallruad wai In the hand of rictlrera I apiwlntej by thu court OUI Judga clamrlltlIo l you ay they bull nay iert nul notice of that irivrlii I i 1 01 A turaiy llouti They inuit tcuve kiKWlaigeiof that iso Julgn I Maintl uuwnel 1 that tba courie would be utterly twweileia to protect iroiwriy t II lb > rn wac 10 hoes i f icrvlca by p rioual untie lu atery cMte Attorney I Ilouli cited I aulhoiltln ai d till r liulited that Ul IerJii 1 oouli 1 ba Iltl rMwiulbla I for violating an Injunction 1 hr knew ndulng of Ha rxuleuce beforehand and moll wa < tbecaiobfir Counial paid there las not a iclulllla of avldeuce to hoI that Ihe delrndanli M rare llurnr Andrew > Hiillltau and Caaiady wero cvnueclaj with the urniy at all or even that Ibey were In Irorii lul Haturday and In tho da > ulauU HUMUM of a knuwledita of the uvurli lujuucllou tba ohAI < 1 of OoI > ICY to violate the me moil fall tj the ground Tha fact that Caller announced that the army lutinuad lo Ion Ilia Territory audio ride out of II lou Old tint algol fy a threat sold could not ba cuuitruixl Into luUtmmatory lauguige 101 ul Hut Allorury Von I Colt called attention 1 I at-tention to tba ulreuuutince that Carter Car-ter lu bli I ipeach cballenitad tIde whola totes of U H maribtli and Aul I ollca In the Territory to deler Ibnu lu theIr abduct Even on tba day beora tIcs tmahn was 100an Carter ayuouncad al 1 Atuerlcau 1ork that II tha army could notgo In dlllrr then they would KO tugelhtr aIM muieover rIde II tlia proircdllou had cot rro en sly studiO act agaluit Ibo live tleftndanu U fore handed It wai ihown they wm around auglua and formed part tf the boy ol men who larforinad those overt aclp Couuwl loll that before Ibo angina was iloleli Uugluecr lllaka called upun the toes lu Unlit nod Marurdtbrnitr Ibelr 1Aluod Ibul wrongful IDle frrencv Sir Van Colt alt I inaiked tInt eviu alter they wire 1111 aiwsreo f tba properly being In I the banui of recetvera they did not detlil In their unlawful AOt Tba entumint lailed until 1210 wben Judge Merrill laid Ibo motion lor lIds rule sssofcellala of tbe defan lanli would La overrultd am 1 they bad any Hvldeuca to adduce lauding lo urga Iboni of this charge of contempt they would now ta beard I being clool upon 1 3 an aJ journmeolwai taken UIIS p I in TCSTIMOMV doll TUU ULIKNIL When court returned at 2 oclock leitlmuny ou benAI nl tIcs defendant WM IntMluord Pence Illlla delay was occitl ued however owing lo Iba ab ivnca ol one of Iba atlorneyi tie IdercI Carter wn lIce llrit wit new llallld ba had relldrd lu Hail Lake e clara the fall of 199D and wai by trade a carpauher Ha wai aniutlnted with tome of the defend ami Ha arrived allebl a wok ago tomorrow aud had command while Itiura 011 1 rjbably POd men On Friday night Ian about 10 oclock I ba lilt I the men lu camp at Ileuint Urovr wanton want-on hluieelf lo Amnllcaa Pork and < Hayed the night al a bcardlni hone Mail of the men were In bed sal before IravlUK Ibo cmup be cave itlcrl orderitolhem In lbs I rerenca of two law I otllieri to out ou a double guard that ol h and allow nIght not any luau oulildo the lluei alter ulna oclock 1rlor lo till on Ibo fhuriday nIght oma Iweuty or thirty men bad dreerled the lank wbllo ha WIn spook bog ut Ijehl and tIdal wai bit reaiou forgiving Ibli loitrucllou Witiiv 1 tba lioardlng houn between b unu V oclonk 1 moriilut too laYIng teen any of the uriny slIm departing from Ilraianl Clrote That I wu the Hrit lima ba beard of cIa trouble on tbe rallroaJ sod Will Uood lell wai his lulorminl Ito h1I uo knowl ln whil > vrrol Ibelr goIng to trovoj hey tiailno oouiuliaii him 00 lIce Iou u in I ally way lie dId Idol aJvUe bole men al AlI tlaie ta lake a train I 11 < nose I ha I alweyi beau to Iba country aLd Ibe until wttaiwirii It f1 under oalb mil to touch I any mans proiwrly WltntH blnnelf always > wora lu Ibe men Judge Merrill You bn no lower I 01 3 uiMlf lo adiuluUter au oalh Attorney Houn ll la I a nutlr of honor loot 01 law A copy ul the lull of Ibo ergaolit blob wan 1110 put lu WiiuaH continuing nald hli declara lloui 10 tba army hut alwayi bteu lu I lIe direction of oaco uud order Ho conntolad them alwa > < 10 bo law MihiluK Attarney Houlz Uldjou idvlss ably of your limn 10 take a train from bold Junction at any Unit WllueM auiwervd poiiltlvely NoIr > No-Ir I did 100111 Ha sIded that bo women t 1rovo on Hilurday morn 1001 ou bearIng lOSt bll mu bad been arrritoJ there Wituaw then arrrtJ woe Ih1 or ruled lob obei If and had not been lu comuivud iince lu cro ifijinlD tloii by Judge Mir ibi > llCitliir aild I be tool i reached and alao practliaJ lawjuit J u lltllo June i a number of moll in lIce oimp ho nah na-h iniurnivd bad not j el ° taken lIce 051110 lIce movamenli of tb army we alwayi directed uy hlmielf OhIo Icea did lob bear of iba lakiiiK uf Ibi angina nt HinKlumJunutioii early lu iliijj until altor Iba oiuurrtucv lln hid beard hI eoun lulklug nnioug tbemielvii about liking a tram kill I mado no uirllcular liuprrMlou upon him bocmito ho didnt think IIIJ would do llui ba bad always declaimed de-claimed agaluit incti a lulug Al shoot wIll Iu mob m Hulili tbe raia tujuy I tbouxli at 815 when tho Now importer left tba pIUPO for thIs did not am favorable |