| OCR Text |
Show Ml 9f II!!. 11.11 PS lltt.liICA.Ii.Xr. MS IX TiiKJleralil of Bunds)-, BeritcmUr In iK! ""' "rosed ono of His moit Hornt Wii yM, Instances of plaglsrlira on record. Tlio X -jMu gentleman whose eltcepllw conduct JJ WE was exhibited ! Hie ltsr. Dr. Illll. WX uH dellveritl,onltie!litof lastMarcli, IBJf jjflf In llio Halt Lake Theatre, on the occn K jB'l lon of the aniilter-nry of thiJV. M. C. HI W A. of this city, an address which was K M notable for III excellence. At Ihs MjD Sfi conclusion of Its delivery tha inanu. UBI IK rrrlrl was handed to reporter of tho K iff H" Lal"' 7Vt'.unc, In nhlchjournil B IMP, It in published In full. Nearly the an. Xj whole of llio address was laxim from Uy HE hook containing "Icrlures unit ml- iK S dresses delivered bjr tho Iter, Thomaa MR ' K Ouard, I). D." B ; The cCrct of the delivery of Hill B H urlolnt material by Dr. Ilia and lta H ' Hj publication In a newspaper was to Hf B laca him hefore the community m a HB Hi brilliant and lulilltoluat pulpit orator, 9B Hi which ho really Is not. A J arson who H ' Ah enojs that distinction cannot main- iflBI DrJ lain It by the Ule of other men'a bralna, itHJl BBS a recount of that nature Indicating 3 Hf; that he hlmielf dors not pOMrs them. '3? Mil Tho TViounc, while admltllUR that a fltt flH newipapor with atich facta before It ai H IBi '"'"' '" I10"""'0" of tho JlcraM, waa H iJHil luatlfled In making the txrciurr, but Hm 9H It alio atlciuim tu make an explana. jflj tlon la ixlialfof I)r. IIIO. Theaub. fMl ill atanroof tlieapoloiiy Is that the Iter, 1JuBmJ Kentlrmau was flvon auch brief notice PJHnB that he would be eirctrtl to deliver jHflJl the aldrrts that he did not have tlroo liarftRB1 to prepare one; that he Informed the iBrilrHh audience that he would have to draw HliHaaf; la'ielr from tho Idem ot othorr; that fUjSjPJi alter the lulllcatlon of the borrowed BRmBI addreu In tho 7ilun aa original, tho HbuMM Doctor called the clergfrnon tosother HBIm and explained tho matter to them. VkE Wrt Unfortunately there doea net aprar SuarWU to be anyone who llateued to tho a J. Kb! Wfj dnrt who luard Dr. Hill explain that jpHfe HJ lie had drawn largely from other pio- 9JRHI P'"'' Ideal. If he had made tho iBBJ HJ alatemcnt oven that would not US MjH be a lufllclent excute for Mich ffl WH whoteaale plargrarlimai wai rprtrat. Iffifli edby him on the occasion. It appears Dy HJ alio that he did not explain the matter MIL IB tn hla fellow clcritymen immediately W 4llir the publication In the Tribune, HB 111 The addrera waa delivered In Marcht HAWHT and he made no mention ol Iheiub. 3ect to hli brethren until the rretent , ..-u msuth. The caute ot lilt finally UU- (Rffi Sff Itiu; till Ittji was on account of ex o JHllIri ruru lulnu Imminent, ho IiuvIur Iii JK B Informed Ibat the article whli.lia. KJi H irid In the Jfcraldot laitHunday, nHMHj had been tlTered for ruhllcatlon. Hut yKHttff evtn If he had couthlcd In hit trolticr HjwWH clurnymen, what had that to do with WkHB the deception of the lople at Urge by InlMf thu publication of lit, (luard'a lecture naUtanMi D1 tne 1 rduct of the I ralna of Dr. MmBW IITT Tho publlo were allowid le HHHH1 Lellevu that the addnaa wai original BJBJMEj mid to tlumber In vain belief nfij In the Doctor' Intillectual brll- BBVjS 1 llaocy. The excute that he did not BS39 ! have lufllclent lime to preparu an BKm li iddrrm ot hla own urmi remarkable PBBw be waa notified tho day luforo iftllv. M'HI J try wairnjulred. Ho neina to hau HSciO ""' Il"1lr cf t,me t "opy, In writ- PHVaHJ InKi 'from Mr. Uuard. PBKHJ " III icanntug the inatttr which Dr. HHHJ J1; Illir took from Mr. Ouard, ono iiotablii BiEU future ronotcteil with III ue by thu HBfi I' lornirrbciM itrwng evlderiuuf . 9fH J rllJ lulent, W refir to tlliiht HBJHI erbulaltiratlunint the buKlunlnK and flHKffij . endliiK of paragraph, Thl maul Bfl ' ulatlon ahowi an tTldent urco to HnEjS ', avoid glvluK credit tu tliu tou no front HJHHJ ,ij whlqh the iiuutiitiuaa were made, Tlili n 9 joint appllea alio to thinltort maile by HBtuN ,1 the plaglarlit to maku Dr. (luard'i BJ ifj language nnd Idem ronfurm to tte HflMDj iS ticulon ujii whloli tluy wiro uied Hjnj ifl ty Dr. Ilin. HBW In It Uoltar lqourIi lhatDr. UllThii ,1 tun ireltlng to I "lid up n rofi. BKjfll lJ iloual uud limlleolml reputation on pHHjj 'I cthir oplu'i bmlni. The i,iciu to aDjM I which he ha been lutjnttd la not HJH9 i "1 lurprltlnj. Men lit thlu;a recape nHpjnJ thiui Uiut iro luj l) which flfffHH j I their mllhru run be undrntoud. HPHlB 'I i his gintltinno, evidently for the ur jflWffi tote of poling n a patriot, In oue HJBli ' ot a serin of ant!-"Mornwn" iiuetlucs, BhHhU I liupruvlfed to itufftho mtmbers of WJw v'l l''u " A I'm on their ) to incaiup. HI merit at riJn Frucclno, ttalid, In a HJhJhH ! cecti,tliot ho placid the cross under IpHH R Hits national flag. However, wo Hvi I U I robably would not have trruti-d at all IWflBrBilr u "1l" "'" "1D'tc' c' ll'' terilblo Mflf Si ' I expciutetowhioh hels now luhjectud, jXJiV '' had Ituot been fjr llio lllmiy esp lina 'udyu n nDDdolnattiniitIng hi covir up ll 1 loo fUsiantplaglarliimof vhUhUohaj Jr - clearly Ixen KUllly. If nothing of that kind had been attempted, and a frank acknowledgment been made, charily would hare ttepred In and luggwtrd that the lubjeot be allowed to illda post, to far aa we wero concerned. |
